I knew you'd linger like a tattoo kiss | part 18
Warnings: slight angst, mentions of body dysmorphia, mentions of an eating disorder, mentions of weight loss, mentions of cheating, mentions of pregnancy (don't worry, it's nothing), depression and anxiety
Pairings: Steve Harrington x fem!cheerleader!reader, Eddie Munson x fem!cheerleader!reader
Summary: A conversation with a girl that you had been trying to avoid, leaves you more confused than ever -- it might just be the cause of a storm in your heart.
Word count: 6k
A/N: BIG BIG BIG SHOUTOUT TO THE LITTLE DEVIL ON MY SHOULDER AKA @hellfire--cult thank you so much for helping me, with this chapter especially! I was struggling with the dialogue at the end of this chapter and you were such a big help so thank you -- you're talented, amazing, show-stopping, perfect, thank you for helping me with the dialogues (and so many other ideas) mwah! You guys better follow her and give her stories the love they deserve
series masterlist
-
The gym is filled with girls dressed in their cheer uniforms, the color green is starting to give you a headache, just like the sound of giggles and hushed whispers as the girls next to you talk about the latest gossip. Another supposed breakup.
This time it’s Tommy and Carol again.
Just three weeks back, you heard rumors about Steve and Nancy’s apparent breakup, which turned out to be just a rumor, considering you’ve seen them together – maybe less than before but they are still around each other, laughing and smiling just like before.
Clearly, they are still together.
But teenagers love to make up rumors – especially about people like you and Steve. Despite both yours and his fall down the social ladder, you are still the hot topics of the school.
They love to make up rumors about your relationship or past relationship with Steve and your friendship with Eddie – or as they still like to call him, the freak.
Apparently you and Eddie had been seen making out in his van.
Apparently you and Eddie have been in a secret relationship since august, last year.
Apparently you cheated on the king with the freak.
Apparently the satan worshiper had cursed your relationship with the king – so he could have you.
Apparently you are pregnant with Eddie’s baby and living in his trailer.
Apparently you and Eddie are in love and secretly married – at least, you understand that rumor. The matching rings on both yours and his ring finger may have been the cause of it.
The pregnancy rumor made you physically sick – it made you stand in front of the mirror, checking for signs that you had gained weight. You did not, it still made you feel nauseous and you had to cancel your dinner ‘date’ with your friends.
A sigh falls from your lips when you hear Teresa talking about her future in college – Princeton to be exact. Of course the cute brunette has it all, beauty and brains. The straight A student isn’t only one of the smartest students in Hawkins High, she is also one of the prettiest – cat eyes, a small nose and big lips, she is thin but her boobs are, well, they are huge.
You wonder why you were ever crowned as the queen when girls like her exist. When girls like Heather and Chrissy exist.
You wonder why Steve ever even looked your way.
You look down at yourself, your uniform is perfectly ironed, your skin is soft and glowing after scrubbing and lathering it in moisturizer earlier this morning. You reach for the mirror in your bag, wanting to check on your makeup, one more time before the photoshooting. Your hair looks good, your make up looks good and yet, you still don’t like the way you look.
“Well, don’t you look beautiful.”
The frown on your face disappears when you hear his voice. Looking over your shoulder, you see Eddie leaning against the doorframe. He is eying you with a smile on his face. He ignores all the nasty looks from the other cheerleaders before they continue getting ready for the little photo session with Jonathan – who is getting just as many nasty looks as Eddie does.
You put the little mirror down and walk over to him, smoothing down your skirt as you take in the sight of him. He was forced to leave his leather jacket at home and he had already been whining about it since the early morning hours. Clad in his favorite jeans and a metallica shirt, you can’t help but miss the leather on his skin – it’s his staple piece but, it’s the end of May, much to Eddie’s dismay it’s too warm to walk around with vests and jackets.
You like seeing his tattoos though and his hair in ponytail or a bun when it does get a little too warm.
“Hi,” you say, giving him a sweet smile as you halt in front of him.
He smiles down at you, tapping your nose, “hey sweetheart.”
“Wanna join the photo session?” You joke, gesturing to the girls who are still getting ready as Jonathan is setting up his tripod and his camera.
“Yeah,” Eddie says, “give me a uniform and I’m in.”
Giggling, you shake your head, “your butt would look cute in a cheer skirt.”
“Oh, not as cute as yours,” he winks, grinning at you when you look away with a blush on your cheeks.
“Are you enjoying the last day as the cheer captain?”
“You have no idea how much I wanna get rid of that title,” you laugh, “I’m ready to give that position up to Chrissy.”
You haven’t been loving cheerleading as much as you used to. Things changed, especially this year.
“I’m ready to get the hell out of here.”
“You and me both, sweetheart.”
“You know, I always thought that I’d go to college after high school,” you say as you look around the room, “but now, I’m just lost. I wouldn’t even know what to major in if I did go to college a-and I don’t even know what college I’d go to – and why am I even stressing about it, it’s too late for that now–”
Eddie places his hands on your shoulders, “I thought we settled on not stressing about our future anymore.”
“Yeah but–”
“No buts,” Eddie chuckles, “you’re taking a gap year, you still got your job at the record store and I’ll work at the garage, we’ll save up some money this summer and then–”
“And then we’ll go on that road trip.”
“Exactly,” he smiles, “we’ve been planning it for weeks now, don’t let college ruin that.”
Your shoulders slump and you sigh, “I just, I hear all of them talking about college,” you pause, gesturing to the girls behind you, “a-and it makes me think that maybe it was a mistake not to apply to any.”
His eyes soften at the worry in your eyes, he shakes his head.
“I don’t think it’s a mistake.”
“It’s not?”
“No, you got all the time in the world to join all these boring people in the normal world,” he chuckles, pulling you closer, “let’s live in our own world for a little longer,” he smiles, tucking a loose strand of hair behind your ear before he fixes the bow in your ponytail.
“Our dreams will be crushed the moment we step into the real world, let’s not let that happen so soon.”
You eye his face and curl of his lips as he stares at you.
“Our own world,” you smile, nodding, “I think I like that more anyways.”
“Yeah?” He grins.
“Yeah.”
“Good.”
“Good,” you repeat after him, making him chuckle.
He tilts his head with a smile on his face, “did you do your make up differently?”
“Uh yeah, I did pink eye shadow today,�� you chuckle, “I’m surprised you noticed it, guys usually don’t pay attention to these things.”
“I’m offended that you think I’m one of those guys,” he jokes, placing his hand on his chest, “I notice everything about you, sweetheart.”
He notices every slight change. A different hairstyle, new clothes, the new color of your lipstick, the slightest change in your behavior, your eating habits, your struggles. He notices it all.
“You look gorgeous.”
“Thanks,” you smile but the look in your eyes isn’t genuine and it makes him frown.
“Not as gorgeous as Teresa.”
“Who the fuck is Teresa,” he mumbles in confusion.
You point to the cheerleader and Eddie follows your gaze. You watch him closely as he looks at the pretty cheerleader.
Does he think she’s gorgeous? Does he think she looks better than you? Does he think she looks sexy in her tight uniform? Does he think her boobs look good?
The reaction you expected never comes, he scrunches his face up and a look of distaste crosses his features.
“That bitch threw gum in my hair.”
A laugh tumbles from your lips, you cup your hand over your mouth when the others turn to look at you.
“That’s not funny, y/n!” Eddie frowns, though his eyes are filled with amusement, “Wayne had to cut a chunk of my hair because I couldn’t get it out.”
“Your poor hair!” You pout, reaching out to touch his curls.
Both you and Eddie are unaware of the new set of eyes watching the two of you.
Steve just left the coach’s office, passing by the gym when he heard your laughter, he couldn’t help but peek inside the open gym.
His eyes fall on you, right away.
It’s been a while since you had talked, though you had been more present in his life since the night before your birthday, you were still far from actually being back in his life. The only interactions the two of you have are the ones in the hallway or in classes, greeting one another and saying goodbye. That’s all but he wishes he would see more of you.
Things haven’t been easy in the past few weeks, he barely passed the exams, sleepless nights haunt him and his days usually consist of reading and trying to better his cooking skills – he has nothing else to do. He has no one to talk to, no one to hang out with, no one to be with, not even his parents.
He had never been more miserable than he is right now.
There you are, pressing yourself against Eddie as you play with his hair, looking happier than ever.
Eddie, who wraps his arm around your waist and looks down at you like you are the most precious thing in this world.
Steve’s eyes are filled with nothing but sadness. He doesn’t even have the power to feel jealous anymore.
“Hey Steve!”
Shit.
All eyes are now on him, including yours and Eddie’s.
Steve tears his eyes away from you and turns to look at Jonathan who is walking towards him with his camera. By the look in his eyes, Steve can tell that he wants to do anything but talk to him.
“Uh – it’s good that you’re here,” Jonathan mumbles, holding the camera up, “Principle Higgins asked for a picture of you and y/n.”
Steve’s brows furrow and confusion takes over his face, “me and y/n?” He asks, “why?”
Jonathan shrugs, refraining from rolling his eyes, “cause you’re the captain of the basketball team and she’s cheer captain.”
“Oh.”
Jonathan looks away from Steve, glancing in your direction, waving you over.
You look just as confused as Steve does but you make your way over to them nonetheless.
“Hi,” you mumble to Steve before your eyes find Jonathan who stands between you two, awkwardly.
“Hey,” Steve smiles at you.
“Principle Higgins wants a picture of you two together,” Jonathan explains to you, “cause you’re both Captains.”
You raise your brows, “uh okay,” you snort, “what does the cheer captain have to do with–”
“Don’t ask me, y/n,” Jonathan chuckles as he motions for you both to follow him, “I’m just as confused.”
“That’s weird,” you mumble, glancing at Steve who’s awfully quiet.
“Let’s do it in front of the banners,” Jonathan looks over his shoulder, giving you a small smile but avoiding Steve’s eyes – you notice it.
Does he feel guilty about kissing his girlfriend? You saw them together yesterday, Nancy and Jonathan. They didn’t even bother to hide their affection. They kissed in the parking lot in front of everyone to see. All they got were a few weird looks, no one seemed to pay much attention to them – no one except for you. You stood frozen in place, a mix of confusion and anger rushing through you.
Despite the things that Steve had done to you, he still didn’t deserve that.
You didn’t know whether you should tell him or not, by the sullen look in his eyes, you can tell that he already knows.
“Alright, just uh–” Jonathan waves his hand at you and Steve, looking around awkwardly, “scoot a little closer.”
You don’t have to look around the gym to see all the eyes on you, you can feel them and you can hear the hushed whispers.
Steve ignores them but he can’t help but take a look at Eddie who is still standing in the same spot as before. He watches you.
You step closer to Steve, when he lifts his arm up for you. You place your hand on his back and he places his hand on your waist. Steve looks away from Eddie when the latter looks down.
Jonathan looks through his camera, squinting his eyes as he motions with his hand, “a little closer, y/n.”
Steve feels your body closer against his, your hand slides down to his waist, your touch fills him with a warmth that he hasn’t felt in a long time, it makes his heart beat a little faster, it fills him with life.
If a simple touch of your hand can make him feel such things, he wonders what a kiss from you would cause.
For a moment, he forgets about his surroundings and what he is supposed to be doing. The sound of chatter, whispers and giggles fly by him. His attention is on you and he basks in the feeling of being so close to you, of feeling your touch, of being able to look at you – not from afar but from such a close distance.
After a few snaps, Jonathan pulls back to look at the pictures he just took, he furrows his brows and glances up at the two of you.
“What’s wrong?” You ask, not pulling away from Steve just yet, “do I look okay?”
Jonathan huffs with a soft chuckle, “yeah, you look good but uh, Steve? You’re supposed to look into the camera,” he says awkwardly.
Your breath hitches in your throat when you look up to see him staring at you – now with a blush on his cheeks. Oh. He wasn’t looking into the camera because he was too busy looking at you.
He closes his eyes, furrowing his brows, “right.”
You can’t help but smile to yourself – a flustered Steve is not something you will ever get used to.
“Alright,” Jonathan mumbles after snapping a few more pictures, “I got it now.”
He looks up from his camera, giving Steve a tight lipped smile, “thanks Steve, you can go now,” he says before he steps away himself.
You feel the hesitation in his touch before he lets go of you, stepping away slowly.
“Alright uh, I’m gonna,” he mumbles, scratching the back of his neck as he points to the entrance.
“Yeah,” you whisper but you hesitate as well and you find yourself looking into his eyes again.
The sadness has taken over.
You know that he knows about Nancy and Jonathan.
Why is he still with her?
Why is he still with her after everything he said to you?
Why is he still with her when she is seeing someone else?
He gives you a halfhearted smile before he turns away but you stop him, reaching for his hand before he can take the first step away from you. You grip it tightly, unaware of the feeling in his heart that you had caused with yet another simple touch.
He looks down at your hand only to notice another, new ring adorning your hand. A skull ring on your ring finger – he doesn’t know why such a small item can cause him so much despair. He doesn’t have to ask to know where or who you had gotten it from.
“Are you okay?”
The softness in your voice matches the one in your eyes, it makes him want to cry.
How could he ever be okay without you in his life?
Now that he had finally dropped the act and let go of a fake love, he had nothing to hold onto anymore.
He lost his best friend, he lost the love of his life, he lost the one. All because he was an insecure coward.
The past few weeks have shown him how much he had truly ruined, how alone he really is without you in his life.
He needed to lose you to realize that you are all he ever wanted.
He doesn’t need a bunch of friends who don’t even care about him nor does he need girls chasing after him or the popularity that he no longer has or even wants.
You, he only wants you.
But he won’t fight for someone who he doesn’t deserve to have.
You look at him with worry in your eyes as you wait for him to answer your question.
No. No, he is not okay.
He has never felt more lost in his life than he does at this moment.
The emptiness in his chest is eating at him and he doesn’t know how to keep going when every day feels like hell.
Every night he stares at the bottles of expensive whiskey in his dad’s office, contemplating whether or not he should just drink until he no longer feels anything. Deep down he knows that the whiskey would just make everything so much worse.
Maybe it would lead him back to you, maybe it would lead him to the phone on his nightstand, maybe he would make the mistake of calling or even seeing you only to beg for another chance – which would only end in heartbreak.
You won’t take him back.
Steve will forever hate himself for losing you.
“Yeah,” he says, forcing a smile on his face, “I’m okay.”
And for a moment, it isn’t a lie. For a moment, he does feel okay when he still feels your hand in his, when he sees the worry and the softness in your beautiful eyes and the necklace around your neck, the locket that he gave you. You are wearing it. And that alone is enough for his heart to flutter and for the emptiness in his chest to disappear – even if only temporary.
He avoids your eyes and that proves to you that he isn’t okay but just like he never pressured you, you don’t do it either.
“A-Are you going to college?” You ask, not wanting him to go so soon.
Your question surprises him, it’s been a long time since you had initiated a conversation.
“No,” he says, shaking his head. “It doesn’t seem really appealing to me.”
“But you wanted to go to college, Steve.”
He runs his fingers through his hair, tilting his head with a small chuckle.
“That uh, that was our dream. I only wanted to go to college with you.”
His hand is still in yours, his sad eyes are still gazing into yours.
“You wanted to go to college with me?” Your eyes widen when he nods, “for me?”
“Yeah,” he breathes, “I couldn’t stand the thought of being away from you so,” he trails off as he watches the way sadness crosses your features.
Your heart jumps at his words.
“That’s uh, that’s funny,” you laugh, “cause I couldn’t stand the thought of being away from you so I always told you that I had this huge college dream when I never even knew what I actually wanted.”
Steve’s brows furrow and his eyes fill with confusion but also with amusement.
“Really?” He chuckles.
“Yeah.”
His eyes crinkle and his smile widens.
“Wow. We would’ve gone to college together not knowing that it’s something neither of us wanted,” he says, “unless it’s something that you want now?”
“Oh no,” you mumble, “I-I’m not going to college. For now, I’m stuck at the record store which is actually being moved to Starcourt soon.”
His eyes light up.
“Oh, the record store is being moved?”
“Yeah!”
“I guess we’ll keep seeing each other then.”
While the thought leaves him with excitement, it must leave you with annoyance – at least that’s what he thinks.
The look on your face is puzzled.
“I got a job at the ice cream parlor,” he clears his throat, “Scoops Ahoy.”
Suddenly, he feels embarrassed and his cheeks heat up. You used to date a king, a popular guy, the captain of the basketball team with his apparent bright athlete future.
And now he is just Steve Harrington who barely got his diploma, who threw his athlete future down the drain to work at an ice cream parlor. How humiliating.
Your jaw drops and your eyes widen, “no way! Scoops Ahoy?”
“Yeah..”
“Oh my god!” You giggle excitedly. “I’ll be your regular.”
Steve can’t help but laugh at your enthusiasm.
“You did love your ice cream.”
“Yeah, I still do.”
You are still smiling at him and he can’t help but smile back at you. This almost feels like a dream – standing here with your hand still in his, laughing and smiling with you like the past no longer matters.
“Y/n!” Chrissy calls for you.
You tear your eyes away from his and glance over his shoulder.
Chrissy motions for you to join her and the other cheerleaders – who are all trying to hide the fact that they were just staring at you and Steve.
“Come on!” She says as she glares at Steve’s back.
“Yeah, I’m coming.”
Steve’s face falls, though his smile still lingers when you look back at him. You remove your hand from his.
“So uh, I guess I’ll see you around?”
He nods, “yeah,” he mumbles.
You step away from him but this time, he stops you. With a hand on your wrist and your name falling from his lips, he makes you halt in your tracks.
You look back at him with raised brows.
His soft eyes make your heart race, his touch makes you feel warm.
“You look beautiful.”
“Thank you,” you whisper.
He knows you don’t believe it, you never did, no matter how many times he told you these words, you never believed them.
“The locket looks good on you,” he smiles.
You place your other hand on your chest, touching the locket, “thanks, I love it.”
Chrissy rolls her eyes, watching the interaction between you and Steve. Annoyed at the affection and the smiles you are giving him, she forces herself to look away.
Steve always finds a way to sneak his way back into your life. He doesn’t deserve you, not after everything that happened.
She knows that you might never stop loving him but she hopes that your love for him won’t stop you from letting another one in. She narrows her eyes, glancing at the metalhead who is still standing by the door, watching you with an intense look on his face, one that can only be described as jealousy.
It’s the same look you always wore when you saw Steve with other girls.
She sighs, shaking her head.
Chrissy might not be a close friend of Eddie’s but she knows that his feelings for you are nowhere near platonic and she knows that what you are feeling might be deeper than that too, though you are still oblivious, too focused on your feelings for your ex boyfriend.
She hopes that you will let go of them someday.
-
The first big summer storm hits the town of Hawkins on a Friday afternoon. The rain is falling down harshly from the sky, the wind is howling through the trees, the bright lighting lights up the darkened sky every few seconds as the thunder crashes loudly.
The streets are empty as the water flushes down the road.
Of course you had to come to the library today.
You should’ve come here tomorrow, you should’ve stayed home.
You tried to leave the library when the storm just started but the librarian, an elderly woman named Margaret, refused to let you leave. She forced a book into your hand and told you to take a seat by the window.
She didn’t even let you put up a fight. She offered you a cup of coffee and told you to wait out the storm.
It’s been an hour but the storm is still raging and you are becoming restless. You hate being stuck in public places.
You take the book that she gave you and leave the table, giving her a tight lipped smile as you pass by the counter.
“Don’t worry, I’m not trying to sneak out,” you whisper to her when she gives you a pointed look.
“You better not, young lady,” she says with a mean voice but her eyes are kind.
You chuckle at her, flashing her a smile before you disappear into the aisle where the shelves are filled with nothing but dramatic romances and sad love stories – your favorites.
The smell of paper and coffee, the sound of rain and thunder fills you with a nostalgic feeling. You love these types of afternoons, sitting down with a book you love, listening to the rain paddling down the windows after you light up your favorite candle and drinking a hot cup of coffee – too bad you did not stay at home, you could have done just that.
As you walk down the aisle and you trace the books, trying to find one that calls for you, you don’t find a story that you would love to read, instead, you find the girl that has been the cause of a lot of pain in your life.
You halt in your tracks when you find her sitting in the little nook by the window. A large book resting on her lap.
You don’t know why you freeze, why you don’t just walk away, why you keep standing there like a fool as you stare at the girl that stole your boyfriend – ex boyfriend.
She glances up from her book when she feels your eyes on her.
For a moment, she freezes too and stares back at you.
What are you doing? Just walk away. The angel on your shoulder whispers, trying to save you from the awkwardness of this situation.
No. Confront her. Tell her what you saw.
You were never one to let the devil win. You were always a good, obedient girl. Always listening to the things the good ones whispered to you. Always doing what you were supposed to do. Always being kind and sweet to everyone around you. Always doing the right thing.
Maybe that is where you went wrong, by doing the apparent right things.
But you never did what you wanted to do.
So you let the devil for once – or maybe the devil is actually the angel and the angel that has been whispering all these discouraging words to you, is actually the devil in disguise, waiting for you to fail, changing your mind about the things that you want.
“Can I help you?” Nancy asks slowly.
You notice that her hair is shorter than it used to be, a few of her curls fall from the clip that is holding her hair together.
“No,” you shake your head.
She furrows her brows when you make your way over to her.
“But there’s something that I wanted to talk to you about.”
“You wanted to talk to me?” She asks, pointing between the two of you.
Surprised that you want to talk to her now.
You nod.
Nancy can’t help but feel nervous. Despite her dislike for you, she is aware of her wrongs. You have every right to be angry at her – if you are angry at her.
“I saw you with Jonathan.”
She tilts her head, eyes straying from you. She looks confused.
“What?”
You cross your arms over your chest, the bracelet around your wrist slides down a little.
“I saw you kissing him.”
“So?”
“So?”
Now you feel the anger rushing through you.
Does she not feel ashamed?
You scoff, shaking your head in disbelief.
“I should be the last person to care about this but I still care about him,” you start as you stare into her confused eyes, “what are you doing is disgusting.”
Nancy begins to understand a little but a part of her still leaves her with a big question mark.
“I shouldn’t be defending him but I know that he is a good person, despite everything,” you murmur the last part with an eye roll, “and I know that he is good to you.”
Nancy straightens her back, she pushes the book off of her lap and holds her hands up, “okay, uh I’m a little confused.”
“Oh, you’re confused?” You mumble, trying to keep your voice down, “you’re confused about the fact that you are cheating – openly?”
Technically, you are not wrong. She did cheat but not anymore.
“I’m not cheating,” she mumbles, “we’re not together anymore.”
Silence fills the space between the two of you. The only sound you both hear is the thunder and the rain outside before you speak up after a long pause.
“What?” You ask and Nancy realizes that you don’t know.
How do you not know about the break up?
How do you not know that he left her?
She stands up and crosses her arms over her chest, mimicking your pose.
“Steve broke up with me.”
You are stunned. These news are something you did not expect.
“A few weeks ago, actually,” she explains, “when he came back from you.”
Oh.
He broke up with her, the night before your birthday, after seeing you.
“I’m not cheating on Steve. Jonathan and I, we’re together.”
So, the rumors were true, after all.
They broke up – he broke up with her.
“Oh.”
Nancy looks you up and down. There you stand, wide eyed, confused and definitely unaware of the break up that happened so long ago.
“You didn’t… know?”
You shake your head and you lean your body against the shelf behind you.
“No, I-I didn’t know.”
You had almost forgotten about the raging storm when a bolt of lightning strikes through the sky and the lights in the library flicker for a few seconds.
You draw in a long sharp breath and look down.
Why didn’t he tell you? You wonder.
Nancy asks herself the same thing. Why did Steve not tell you about the break up? Why didn’t he call you the way he called her after he broke up with you?
The two of you stand in front of each other, shocked.
And as Nancy takes a closer look at you, as she sees the slight frown, the look in your eyes, the tension in your shoulders, the hand over your heart. She knows. She knows that there is still something.
You are still processing the news, she can tell by the way your eyes flicker back and forth as though you are trying to piece something together.
“Wait so.. you heard the rumors and you didn’t… think they were true?”
Your hair falls in front of your face when you lift your head, you don’t bother to push it away.
“I– well, I…I saw you two together a lot, so, it was hard to believe the rumors.. you know?”
Nancy nods in understanding.
“I get it… Then, the rumors with Eddie are not true?”
For a moment, you think about her question before you turn your head to look at her with a frown.
“The one I’m pregnant? The one where he sacrificed a lamb to get my undying love and devotion? The one where I cheated on Steve? Which one of them all?”
Nancy’s eyes widen.
She can’t help but snort at all those rumors. Shaking her head with an amused smile, she looks down with furrowed brows, “trust me, even I know Munson looks scary but probably is a fan of Garfield or something,” she chuckles.
A smile tugs at your lips.
“He does have Garfield pajamas.”
She looks at you with a stunned expression before you both burst into giggles.
Nancy shakes her head again as the smile fades away.
“And no, not the pregnant one either.. Jesus,” she sighs. Her eyes find your body again, she looks you up and down with a look that you cannot read.
Suddenly, you feel self conscious again. You feel the urge to wrap your arms around your waist, wanting to hide your body.
But her words aren’t ones that you expected.
“If you’re pregnant with a body like that, is the baby like smushed to the very back?”
Your breath gets caught in your throat. Your eyes widen at her words and you restrain yourself from gasping or holding your hand in front of your mouth or your stomach.
Nancy had spent so much time feeling jealous of you, of what you had – because at one point, she thought that you had everything. Beauty, popularity, friends and a guy who was hopelessly in love with you. You had it all and when she got a taste of what you had, she wanted it. She wanted him. She painted a false picture of you in her head, to make herself feel better about stealing from you.
Though, the false picture in her head didn’t stay for long, it started crumbling the moment she walked into the girls bathroom to hear you crying. She knew it was you, the backpack that laid on the ground had a pin of The Cure on the front, one that only you had.
After that, she began to pay attention to you.
She saw the way you looked at Steve, weeks, months after he left you.
She saw the sadness, the heartbreak, the pain in your eyes and the love that never left.
She saw the way you looked at the other girls and the way you looked at yourself. The way you stayed in the locker room, a little longer than the other girls.
The way you looked at her and compared yourself to her.
All because of him.
“Y-You look amazing is what I’m trying to say,” Nancy says nervously.
A flush creeps up to your face as you gape at her.
To hear it from Steve or even Eddie is one thing, to hear it from a girl who bashed on you, who belittled you is a whole other thing. It feels.. good.
“T-Thank you..”
Nancy clears her throat, suddenly feeling embarrassed. Desperately wanting to kill the awkward tension, she goes back to your previous question.
“No… The one where you and Eddie are dating.”
It takes you a moment to realize what she means. Your mouth falls open and recognition dawns your face.
“No, it’s not true either. None of them are,” you brows knit together, “wait, why did you think it was true?”
There’s amusement in her features as she takes in the sight of your confused face. She shrugs, “you’re always clinging to one another, and you guys literally kiss on the cheek! Like, who does that to a friend? And– you sit on his lap! It’s hard not to think you two have something going on!”
You press your hands together, laughing awkwardly, “uh, well, that’s how best friends interact,” you say these words with a twinge of pain in your chest but you don’t understand it, the reasoning behind the pain is unclear to you.
“Trust me, that’s not how best friends interact with each other – or look at each other,” she adds quietly.
“L-Like what?”
She stares at you in amusement, albeit a little bewildered.
“You’re a little oblivious, aren’t you?”
“Oblivious to what?”
She looks away from you with a small smile, glancing out the window, she pretends to be surprised, “oh, it looks like the storm finally stopped!” She points out.
The storm had indeed stopped, though the one inside of you, has just begun.
Nancy reaches for the book on the nook. She grabs her bag and turns back to you, “I gotta go home. Jonathan and my mom must be worried.”
You follow her with your eyes, staring at her desperately.
She looks over her shoulder after passing by you, “one piece of advice? Pay attention.”
And with that, Nancy Wheeler leaves you standing in the empty aisle.
“What?”
next chapter
-
@mysticmunson @taintedcigs @wroteclassicaly @corrodedseraphine @corrodedcorpses @succubusmunson @xxhellfirebunnyxx @trashmouth-richie @take-everything-you-can @sherrylyn628 @nemesis729 @somethingvicked @chrissymjstan
856 notes
·
View notes