Hindu Persecution: External and Internal Dynamics
Religious intolerance is a pervasive issue worldwide, manifesting in many forms and affecting various communities. When it comes to discussing religious intolerance, it often appears that Hindu persecution is overlooked or strategically subtracted from the conversation. Several factors contribute to this phenomenon, which can be explored through historical contexts, media narratives, and geopolitical considerations.
Historical Context and Colonial Legacy
The history of India, particularly during British colonial rule, plays a significant role in shaping contemporary perceptions. The British employed a divide-and-rule strategy, fostering divisions between Hindus and Muslims to maintain control. This legacy persists in the form of communal tensions, and discussions around religious intolerance are often framed in the context of Hindu-Muslim relations. As a result, the persecution of Hindus can sometimes be overshadowed by the broader narrative of the Hindu-Muslim conflict.
Media Narratives and Representation
Media coverage significantly influences public perception of religious intolerance. Western media, in particular, has been criticized for its selective reporting. Instances of Hindu persecution, especially in neighboring countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh, receive limited coverage compared to other religious conflicts. This selective reporting can create a skewed understanding of religious intolerance, where the suffering of Hindus is not given equal prominence.
For example, the plight of the Kashmiri Pandits, who were forced to flee their homes due to militant violence in the late 1980s and early 1990s, is often underreported. Similarly, attacks on Hindu temples and communities in Bangladesh and Pakistan rarely make international headlines. This media bias contributes to the perception that Hindu persecution is less significant or widespread than it is.
Geopolitical Considerations
Geopolitical dynamics also play a role in the selective discussion of religious intolerance. Countries with significant geopolitical influence often shape global narratives. India, despite being a major player on the global stage, does not always assert its influence in highlighting the persecution of Hindus. Additionally, countries where Hindus face persecution may not prioritize this issue due to their own internal dynamics and international relations.
Case Studies and Examples
1. Bangladesh
Hindu minorities in Bangladesh have faced numerous instances of violence and discrimination. Reports of temple desecrations, forced conversions, and assaults on Hindu communities are common, yet these incidents rarely receive extensive international coverage. The international community’s focus often remains on broader political issues, sidelining the plight of the Hindu minority.
2. Pakistan
The situation for Hindus in Pakistan is equally dire, with reports of forced conversions, abductions, and targeted violence. The case of Rinkle Kumari, a young Hindu girl who forcibly converted to Islam and married off, garnered some attention but was quickly overshadowed by other geopolitical events. The consistent underreporting of such incidents highlights a systemic bias.
3. Kashmiri Pandits
The exodus of Kashmiri Pandits from the Kashmir Valley is a stark example of Hindu persecution within India. Despite being a significant event, it has not received the same level of attention or acknowledgment as other instances of religious conflict. The narrative often centers around broader political and territorial disputes, neglecting the human rights violations faced by the Pandit community.
4. Afghanistan
Hindu and Sikh Minorities: In Afghanistan, Hindu and Sikh communities have faced severe persecution over the years. Their population has dwindled significantly due to violence, discrimination, and forced conversions. The 2020 attack on a Sikh temple in Kabul by ISIS, which resulted in numerous deaths, is an example of the threats these communities face, yet it received limited international media coverage.
5. Malaysia
Demolition of Hindu Temples: In Malaysia, the government has demolished several Hindu temples, claiming they were built illegally. These actions have sparked protests among the Hindu community, who see them as part of a broader pattern of religious discrimination. Despite the significance of these events, they rarely make it into mainstream international news.
6. Sri Lanka
Tamil Hindus: The Sri Lankan civil war saw significant persecution of Tamil Hindus, who were caught in the crossfire between the Sinhalese-majority government and Tamil separatists. Reports of massacres, disappearances, and systemic discrimination against Tamils, many of whom are Hindus, have been documented but often overshadowed by broader political narratives.
7. Bangladesh (Additional Example)
2013 Violence: In 2013, following the sentencing of an Islamist leader to death for war crimes, there were widespread attacks on Hindu communities in Bangladesh. Homes were torched, temples were vandalized, and numerous Hindus were injured or killed. This wave of violence was part of a larger pattern of targeting religious minorities in times of political unrest.
8. Pakistan (Additional Example)
Forced Conversions in Sindh: In the Sindh province of Pakistan, there are frequent reports of young Hindu girls being abducted, forcibly converted to Islam, and married off to Muslim men. Organizations like the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan have highlighted these issues, but they rarely garner sustained international attention.
9. Indonesia
Bali Bombings: While the 2002 and 2005 Bali bombings primarily targeted tourists, the Hindu-majority island of Bali suffered significant trauma. The bombings were carried out by Islamist militants and highlighted the vulnerability of Hindu communities in predominantly Muslim countries.
10. Fiji
Coup and Discrimination: In Fiji, the Hindu Indo-Fijian community has faced discrimination and violence, particularly during the coups of 1987 and 2000. These political upheavals led to the marginalization of Indo-Fijians, many of whom are Hindus, resulting in emigration and economic hardship.
11. Myanmar
Rohingya Conflict Impact on Hindus: While the Rohingya crisis is often portrayed as a Muslim-Buddhist conflict, the Hindu minority in Rakhine State has also suffered. In 2017, Hindu villages were attacked by Rohingya militants, leading to massacres and forced displacement of Hindu families. This aspect of the conflict has received limited attention compared to the broader plight of the Rohingya Muslims.
12. Bangladesh (Further Example)
2016 Nasirnagar Attack: In October 2016, Hindu temples and homes were attacked in Nasirnagar, Bangladesh, following a Facebook post allegedly insulting Islam. The attacks left many Hindus injured and displaced, highlighting the precarious situation of religious minorities in the region.
Hindu communities in Western countries generally enjoy a higher degree of religious freedom compared to many other regions, they are not completely immune to intolerance and discrimination. Here are some examples where Hindus have faced challenges in Western countries:
13. United States
Hate Crimes and Vandalism:
Hindu temples in the United States have been targets of vandalism and hate crimes. For instance, in 2015, several Hindu temples in Washington state were defaced with racist graffiti. In another incident, a Hindu temple in Kentucky was set on fire in what was deemed a hate crime. These acts of vandalism often go underreported in mainstream media.
Bullying in Schools:
Hindu children in American schools have reported being bullied for their religious beliefs. They face mockery for wearing traditional attire, celebrating Hindu festivals, or following vegetarian diets. This type of religious bullying can have a significant impact on their mental health and sense of belonging.
Workplace Discrimination:
Hindu professionals sometimes encounter workplace discrimination, where their religious practices or dietary restrictions are not respected. For example, there have been cases where employees were not provided accommodations for religious holidays or were subjected to insensitive remarks about their cultural practices.
14. United Kingdom
Temple Attacks and Community Tensions:
The United Kingdom has seen several incidents of vandalism and attacks on Hindu temples. In 2019, during protests over the Kashmir issue, a Hindu temple in London was defaced. Additionally, tensions between different religious communities occasionally result in targeted harassment of Hindus.
Stereotyping and Media Representation:
Hindus in the UK often face stereotyping and negative portrayal in the media. This can perpetuate misconceptions and biases against the Hindu community, contributing to social exclusion and discrimination.
15. Canada
Cultural Insensitivity and Racism:
While Canada is known for its multiculturalism, Hindu Canadians have faced cultural insensitivity and racism. For example, there have been incidents where Hindu religious symbols like the swastika, which in Hinduism is a symbol of peace and good fortune, are misunderstood and equated with hate symbols, leading to backlash against the Hindu community.
Temple Vandalism:
Similar to the US and UK, Hindu temples in Canada have also been targeted. In 2020, a Hindu temple in Brampton was vandalized with anti-Hindu graffiti, sparking outrage and highlighting the need for greater awareness and protection of religious sites.
16. Australia
Racism and Assaults:
In Australia, Hindus have reported incidents of racism and physical assaults. In one case, an Indian-origin Hindu student was attacked and had his turban removed by attackers, an act deeply disrespectful in his culture. Such incidents underscore the racial and religious intolerance faced by Hindus.
Cultural Misunderstanding:
Hindus in Australia often face cultural misunderstandings and lack of awareness about their religious practices. This can lead to social exclusion and difficulties in integrating into broader society.
17. Europe
Discrimination and Social Exclusion:
In various European countries, Hindu immigrants, particularly from South Asia, have faced social exclusion and discrimination. For example, in Germany and France, Hindu communities have reported difficulties in practicing their religion freely due to bureaucratic hurdles and societal biases.
Misrepresentation in Media:
European media often lacks a nuanced representation of Hinduism, leading to stereotypes and misconceptions. This can perpetuate biases and contribute to the marginalization of Hindu communities
Targeting of Upper Castes by other sections: An Emerging Concern
While the historical context of caste-based discrimination in India often highlights the persecution of Dalits and other lower-caste communities, there is a growing discourse around the perceived targeting of upper castes by some sections of the Dalit community. This complex and multifaceted dynamic involves social, political, and economic factors.
Political Assertion and Backlash
Political Mobilization:
Over the past few decades, all communities have become more politically mobilized. Leaders like Kanshi Ram and Mayawati have galvanized Dalit political power, particularly in states like Uttar Pradesh. This political assertion has sometimes led to tensions, as policies favoring Dalits, such as reservations in education and employment, are perceived as disadvantaging the rest of the communities of India.
Affirmative Action Policies:
India’s affirmative action policies, designed to uplift historically marginalized communities, include reservations for Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), and Other Backward Classes (OBC). Some upper-caste individuals feel that these policies unfairly limit their opportunities, leading to resentment and allegations of reverse discrimination. [Landmark judgement Indra Sawhney & Others v. Union of India]
Social and Cultural Conflicts
Social Backlash:
As Dalits gain more visibility and assert their rights, instances of social backlash against upper-caste individuals have been reported. These can include social boycotts, public shaming, and accusations aimed at upper-caste individuals, sometimes irrespective of their personal actions or beliefs.
Cultural Conflicts:
In some areas, Dalit assertion has led to cultural conflicts. For example, there have been instances where Dalit groups have sought to reclaim public spaces or rituals traditionally dominated by upper castes, leading to confrontations and sometimes violence.
Economic and Educational Competition
Economic Tensions:
As Dalits gain better access to education and economic opportunities, competition between castes for limited resources and jobs has intensified. Upper-caste individuals sometimes feel marginalized in this competitive environment, believing that merit is being overlooked in favor of caste-based reservations.
Educational Institutions:
In educational institutions, there have been reports of tensions between Dalit and upper-caste students. Allegations of caste-based favoritism and discrimination have been made by both sides, contributing to a charged and sometimes hostile atmosphere.
Instances of Targeting
Violent Incidents:
There have been sporadic reports of violence against upper-caste individuals by Dalit groups. These incidents, while not widespread, highlight the potential for inter-caste violence as social dynamics shift. For example, retaliatory attacks and social boycotts have occurred in response to perceived injustices or historical grievances.
Legal and Social Accusations:
Upper-caste individuals have sometimes faced legal and social accusations from Dalit activists, which they claim are unfounded or exaggerated. This has created a sense of victimization among some upper-caste communities, who feel they are being unfairly targeted due to their caste identity.
The issue of caste dynamics in India is highly complex, with deep historical roots and evolving contemporary manifestations. While the narrative of Dalit oppression is well-documented, it is essential to acknowledge that caste tensions can sometimes lead to upper-caste individuals feeling targeted or marginalized. This emerging discourse requires a balanced and nuanced approach, recognizing the legitimate grievances of all parties involved.
How can India move towards a more equitable and harmonious society if the concerns of both Dalit and upper-caste communities are not addressed with fairness and mutual respect?
References:
Here are some resources and links that you can refer to explore further:
Historical Context and Colonial Legacy
- Metcalf, Barbara D., and Thomas R. Metcalf. *A Concise History of Modern India*. Cambridge University Press, 2006. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/concise-history-of-modern-india/AD6CE4A65BC58B4907CC54E2D92B9200 )
- Bose, Sugata, and Ayesha Jalal. *Modern South Asia: History, Culture, Political Economy*. Routledge, 2017. https://www.routledge.com/Modern-South-Asia-History-Culture-Political-Economy/Bose-Jalal/p/book/9781138243685
Media Narratives and Representation
- Nandy, Ashis, et al. *Creating a Nationality: The Ramjanmabhumi Movement and Fear of the Self*. Oxford University Press, 1995. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/creating-a-nationality-9780195635074
- Ahmed, Hilal. "The Media and the Politics of Representation: Case Studies of Muslim Representation in Indian Media." *The International Journal of Communication and Social Sciences*, vol. 1, no. 2, 2015.
https://ijoc.org/index.php/ijoc/article/view/2042
Geopolitical Considerations
- Ganguly, Sumit. *Conflict Unending: India-Pakistan Tensions since 1947*. Columbia University Press, 2001. https://cup.columbia.edu/book/conflict-unending/9780231111252
- Fair, C. Christine. *Fighting to the End: The Pakistan Army's Way of War*. Oxford University Press, 2014. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/fighting-to-the-end-9780199892701
Case Studies and Examples
1. Bangladesh
- Human Rights Watch. "Bangladesh: Attacks on Hindu Sites." *Human Rights Watch*, 2014. https://www.hrw.org/news/2014/02/28/bangladesh-attacks-hindu-sites
- Minority Rights Group International. "World Directory of Minorities and Indigenous Peoples - Bangladesh: Hindus." https://minorityrights.org/minorities/hindus-2/
2. Pakistan
- Shaikh, Farzana. *Making Sense of Pakistan*. Columbia University Press, 2009. https://cup.columbia.edu/book/making-sense-of-pakistan/978023170046
- Human Rights Commission of Pakistan. "State of Human Rights in 2019." http://hrcp-web.org/hrcpweb/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/State-of-Human-Rights-in-2019-English.pdf)
3. Kashmiri Pandits
- Kaul, Nitasha. "Kashmir: A Place of Blood and Memory." *The Guardian*, 2019. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/aug/09/kashmir-place-of-blood-and-memory)
- Lamb, Alastair. *Kashmir: A Disputed Legacy 1846-1990*. Roxford Books, 1991. https://books.google.com/books/about/Kashmir.html?id=c7oOAQAAIAAJ
4. Afghanistan
- The Hindu. "ISIS Attack on Sikh Temple in Kabul." https://www.thehindu.com/news/international/isis-attack-on-sikh-temple-in-kabul/article31183775.ece
- Afghanistan Analysts Network. "The Vanishing Hindus and Sikhs of Afghanistan." https://www.afghanistan-analysts.org/en/reports/context-culture/the-vanishing-hindus-and-sikhs-of-afghanistan/
5. Malaysia
- Al Jazeera. "Hindu Temple Demolition Stokes Tensions in Malaysia." https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/11/27/hindu-temple-demolition-stokes-tensions-in-malaysia/
- The Diplomat. "Malaysia’s Ethnic Tensions and the Hindu Temple Incident."
https://thediplomat.com/2018/11/malaysias-ethnic-tensions-and-the-hindu-temple-incident/
6. Sri Lanka
- Tambiah, Stanley J. *Leveling Crowds: Ethnonationalist Conflicts and Collective Violence in South Asia*. University of California Press, 1996. https://www.ucpress.edu/book/9780520206420/leveling-crowds
- International Crisis Group. "Sri Lanka's Conflict-Affected Women." https://www.crisisgroup.org/asia/south-asia/sri-lanka/sri-lankas-conflict-affected-women-dealing-legacies-war
7. Indonesia
- BBC News. "Bali Bombings: What Happened on the Night of October 12, 2002?" https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-19904019
-International Crisis Group. "Indonesia: Jemaah Islamiyah's Current Status." https://www.crisisgroup.org/asia/southeast-asia/indonesia/indonesia-jemaah-islamiyahs-current-stat
8. Fiji
- The Guardian. "Fiji’s Coup Culture: Why the Military Holds Sway." https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jul/01/fijis-coup-culture-why-the-military-holds-sway
- Robertson, Robbie, and Akosita Tamanisau. *Fiji: Shattered Coups*. Pluto Press, 1988. https://books.google.com/books/about/Fiji.html?id=_UtVAAAAYAAJ
9. Myanmar
- Reuters. "Exclusive: Hindu Refugees Tell of Rohingya Insurgent Attack." https://www.reuters.com/article/us-myanmar-rohingya-hindu-idUSKCN1C91YY
- Human Rights Watch. "Massacre by the River: Burmese Army Crimes against Humanity in Tula Toli." https://www.hrw.org/report/2017/12/19/massacre-river/burmese-army-crimes-against-humanity-tula-toli
Hindu Persecution in Western Countries
10. United States
- The New York Times. "Hindu Temple in Kentucky Is Vandalized With Hate Messages." https://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/15/us/hindu-temple-in-kentucky-is-vandalized-with-hate-messages.html
- HuffPost. "Bullying of Hindu Students in American Schools." https://www.huffpost.com/entry/bullying-of-hindu-students-in-american-schools_b_563c2ff1e4b0b24aee4a3241
11. United Kingdom
- BBC News. "Hindu Temple Attack in London Condemned." https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-49495195
- The Guardian. "Hindus in Britain: The Misunderstood Community." https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/oct/22/hindus-in-britain-misunderstood-community
12. Canada
- CBC News. "Vandalism at Hindu Temple in Brampton Sparks Outrage." https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/brampton-hindu-temple-vandalism-1.5748455
- CTV News. "Hindu Swastika Misunderstood in Canada." https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/hindu-swastika-symbol-misunderstood-in-canada-expert-says-1.4799156
13. Australia
- *The Sydney Morning Herald*. "Indian Student’s Turban Pulled Off in Racist Attack." https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/indian-student-s-turban-pulled-off-in-racist-attack-20191112-p539si.html
- *ABC News*. "Understanding Hinduism in Multicultural Australia." https://www.abc.net.au/religion/understanding-hinduism-in-multicultural-australia/13000130
14. Europe
- *Deutsche Welle*. "Hindus in Germany Face Integration Challenges." https://www.dw.com/en/hindus-in-germany-face-integration-challenges/a-1924135
- *France 24*. "France’s Hindu Community Navigates a Secular Landscape." https://www.france24.com/en/20191111-france-s-hindu-community-navigates-a-secular-landscape
15. India
Srinivas, M.N. “Social Change in Modern India”. University of California Press, 1966.
Thorat, Sukhadeo, and Katherine S. Newman. Blocked by Caste: Economic Discrimination in Modern India. Oxford University Press, 2010.
Deshpande, Satish. “Exclusive Inequalities: Merit, Caste, and Discrimination in Indian Higher Education Today”. Economic and Political Weekly, 2013.
1 note
·
View note