#That's When - Taylor Swift and Keith Urban

[awesomewithoutme]

If Fearless vault tracks were the original singles in 2008 & 2009:

[taylor-swift-bracket]

🎇Please reblog!🎇

[lightscamerabitchsmileee]

Vote for what you think best fits the album, reblog & feel free to share your thoughts in the tags as well 😊😊

This is gonna be a new mini series I've always been fascinated by how these vault songs came about and I'm curious to know everyones thoughts on this 😊😊

Thank you so much everyone and have fun 😊😊 also my Taylors Version singles poll is still open if you want to check it out 😊😊

[jakeperalta]

back on 23rd march 2023 my boyfriend and I both made surprise song bingo cards and mine took a long time (not helped by the many joe related love songs I included pre-breakup) but my boyfriend has STILL not got a full house because he put that's when on there 😭

[clairvoyantly-yours]

now that i think about it, the song "that's when" is kind of a sequel to "the other side of the door".

tosotd is about asking your loved one to leave, even though you actually don't want them to, because your true emotions are hidden by impulsive angst. you constantlyregret it later, wondering how it would've been if you'd handled it differently.

that's when is the "what if" of tosotd. it's about leaving all your pettiness behind. it's about learning to accept that both you and your loved one had been at fault in your own respective ways. it's about not letting childish outbursts and fights snatch away the love of your life, but instead learning from those dark phases of the relationship, and moving on towards a better and brighter future, leaving the darkness in the past. it is the correct way to end a tosotd story; a happy and passionate ending (though sadly, most people never get to that stage).

i think that's beautiful.

[radgeorgie]

HONNNNNNESTLY...... WHEN YOU WERE GONE DID YOU EVER THINK OF ME?????????

[standupcomedyhistorian]

Incredible photos!

If you're wondering what all three of them have to do with each other, I have a handy guide here (and yes...I am DEFINITELY adding these shots to that article haha) ✌🏼🐔

Taylor Swift with Bo Burnham and boygenius at the GRAMMYs!

[raingalaxy]

I love you that's when feat. Keith Urban

[marcieswift]

Round 1, Duel 11 🤎💛

[swiftiesam13]

I really hope he plays "Highway Don't Care" or "That's When" 😃

@taylornation @taylorswift

[footballandfiasco]

that's when is a top 3 featured taylor song, fight me

[torchickentacos]

I've only heard two Tim McGraw songs, and they both mention a county fair. Conclusion: this man really likes county fairs. One could even say he likes it. He loves it. He wants some more of it. He tries so hard, but he can't rise above it.

[asongperday]

Song of the Day — “That's When (Taylor's Version) (From the Vault)” by Taylor Swift feat. Keith Urban

And I knew my words were hard to hear And harder to ever take back

[melwnst]

────── ⋆⋅☆ TAYLOR SWIFT SONGS DEAN WOULD SECRETLY BE OBSESSED WITH!

first of all, his favorite albums are speak now and reputation because of the productions.

His favorite song is definitely haunted. Not in like an ironic way, but because the production, the lyrics speak to him. This is Taylor’s rockiest song in my opinion, so that would have to be his favorite.

We all know he secretly listens to shake it off. If he’s alone in the car, it’s a full on party. He shakes his ass and all. He’s pathetic I love him so much.

If he’s feeling horny… false god is definitely playing. Again- when he’s alone. Whether you like her music or not, he won’t share it with you because he’s embarrassed, although if you speak about her, he’ll seem to know a lot of information about her for someone who ‘doesn’t listen to her music’

That’s when with Keith urban. There I said it. He’s a damn country boy I won’t hear it.

So? 22? You belong with me? Love story? I knew you were trouble? We are never ever getting back together? Blank space? Basically all of Taylor’s big hits, they’re kinda on repeat..

He’s a pop girly too. I fully believe his favorite song from 1989 is New Romantics or I know places. He loves wildest dreams too.

He associates songs with you(DONT DO THAT! PROTECT YOURSELF! THATS DANGEROUS!)

He associates mine, sparks fly, change, state of grace, this love, you are in love, dress(wink wink), our song, gold rush and lavender haze with you. It’s a tumultuous relationship, so he might think of the lucky one, don’t blame me, miss americana&the heartbreak prince, the 1 and even delicate.

Unfortunately he’s NOT a folklore or evermore girly. He definitely wouldn’t be into ttpd either, he’s not a fan of slow or sad songs, so they’re not for him and that’s okay. It’s dean Winchester, what do you expect?

He’s definitely a swiftie, I think he would jam to Olivia Rodrigo too. Brutal? Ballad of a homeschooled girl???????? Deja vu? GOOD 4 U????????? He’s such a pop girly like… he’s so precious.

He’d have fomo over missing the eras tour but he WOULD NEVER GO! Even if he has the chance. You wouldn’t catch him dead there he’s so uncomfortable with being a Stan it’s almost sad.

Finally… when he finds the courage to either tell you about his little fan girling, or if you find out by accident, when Sam’s not around you might just get crazy and have dance parties to Taylor but Dean makes you swear not to tell anyone. Like legitimately threatens you.

[gaveyouigaveyoui]