𝔏𝔦𝔨𝔢 𝔏𝔦𝔤𝔥𝔱𝔫𝔦𝔫𝔤
My blog is 18+ only. Minors DNI. 🔞 Don’t repost my work anywhere.
"𝔏𝔬𝔬𝔨𝔦𝔫𝔤 𝔦𝔫𝔱𝔬 𝔥𝔦𝔰 𝔢𝔶𝔢𝔰, ℑ 𝔱𝔥𝔦𝔫𝔨 𝔥𝔢'𝔰 𝔞𝔩𝔯𝔢𝔞𝔡𝔶 𝔥𝔲𝔯𝔱."
Words: 31.4k (I don’t know how this happened either!)
Additional Disclaimer: Tumblr won’t let me post the whole story in one, so I’m posting this simultaneously in two parts.
This one is the first part and technically 21.7k.
You can read the second part here.
Pairing: Billy Hargrove x Fem!Reader
Summary: He’s hot, he’s bold, he’s destructive, and despite your friends telling you to stay away from him, you can’t help but keep coming back for more. It’s the same thing for Billy, as he finds himself addicted to your touch and drawn in by the fire in your eyes. But it’s a dangerous game you’re both playing, and just like moths drawn to a flickering flame, someone’s bound to get hurt by the angry blaze burning all around the two of you.
Warnings: Drug and alcohol use. Shotgunning. Reader is quite the ‘maneater’ and uses casual sex in an unhealthy way. Swearing, arguments, daddy issues and minor anger issues, mentions of insecurities and insults. Slut-shaming (not from Billy!), and a fistfight. None-descriptive injuries and scars. Angry, rough sex in a public bathroom. Dirty talk, degradation, facefucking, dacryphilia, spanking, praising, spitplay, and unprotected sex. Billy and the reader both struggle with abandonment issues. Mentions and signs of self-destructive behavior, distress, and unstable home lives (Aka Billy’s past abuse and the reader’s dad being an alcoholic.) Minor jealousy, hurt feelings, angst and some breakdowns. There are mentions of difficult relationships to parental figures and the struggles that come with that, as well as implied past parental abuse, (Physical for Billy; emotional for both of them). But also: Billy & the reader opening up, learning to trust, and finally getting some healing. Fluff and a lot (!!!) of hurt/comfort along the way.
Read the story on AO3 here.
A/N: Parts of the Story and title are inspired by the Lana Del Rey song Happiness is a Butterfly.
I’ve been writing parts of this little beast for a while now, and I’m so glad I finally get to share it! This was initially supposed to be my take on a more toxic!Billy, but I failed that assignment completely. Turns out I just can’t write Billy to be overly mean or manipulative. The reader however is definitely written as a little more complicated and troubled, so please bear that in mind before reading. If topics such as commitment issues, self-objectification, and seeking male validation as well as emotional relief in rather unhealthy ways (in this case: lots of sex with men), upset or trigger you, please don’t continue reading!!
You meet him for the first time during one of your friend’s get-together down by the beach.
You arrived there with your usual lateness, so that the bottles of cheap vodka and liquor had already been passed along multiple times around the small bonfire, leaving most of your friends comfortably buzzed. It’s not like you’d join them in their pointless drinking games anyway, solely sticking to the little joints rolled up somewhere in the deep, dark pockets of your leather jacket.
It’s Heather who spots you first, throwing one of her hands up in a lazy greeting, before patting the warm sand next to her as an invitation to sit down.
“Wasn’t sure if you ditched us again or not.” She teases, and you just roll your eyes as a retort.
“Don’t tempt me.” You huff, but the smile on your face is playful, and Heather simply pokes your side in retaliation until gentle laughter is bubbling out of you like sweet, straw-induced milkshake bubbles on a hot summer’s day.
It’s a soft sound that the wind carries over the wide and open beach, and it’s the first thing about you that grabs his attention, but you don’t know anything about that yet.
You don’t notice him right away, too occupied with the task of catching up with your friends.
You’ve been going to less of the outings lately, so there’s actually stuff you managed to miss, like the fact that Heather has finally asked out one of the new girls, Robin, and now they have their first date set for Saturday.
It’s exciting, really, and you congratulate your friend with earnest joy, before pulling out one of your little joints. Heather isn’t big on smoking, so you don’t even try offering it to her. She’ll just snatch it from you instead if she feels like taking a drag or two, knowing that you’ll let her without much of a fuss.
Similar to him, it’s his laughter that draws you in at first. It’s a deep and raspy sound that fills the evening air around you with a certain electricity, and it has you stopping your dreamy gaze towards the darkening dusk sky, as you try to make out the source of the sound.
You spot him sitting almost opposite to you, across the bonfire, next to Argyle, while the two of them are talking rather enthusiastically about something.
You can’t make out any words, not with the way someone’s music’s playing in the background, accentuated only by the gentle sound of the crackling fire and the booming blend of voices and laughter coming from your friends.
But he’s pretty.
Really pretty.
Blue eyes big and bright, hair an endearing mess of curls, and his sun-kissed skin adorned with the faint traces of freckles.
He’s wearing a half-unbuttoned shirt in a deep red color, akin to that of the setting sun that’s currently in the midst of getting swallowed up by the ocean. But unlike usually, you’re barely paying attention to the breathtaking sunset, eyes instead transfixed on something just as beautiful.
“Don’t even think about it.”
Heather chimes up from beside you, following your gaze towards the new guy, before shaking her head, determined.
“That guy is trouble with a capital t and then some,” she whispers, “heard he’s good for a quick fuck, but the only thing bigger than his ego are his anger issues. So, I’d stay as far away from him as possible.”
“But he’s really pretty,” you whisper back, voice hushed but earnest, because, well, he simply is.
“Yes, okay, but so are plenty of things. So are the warm, flickering flames of the bonfire,” Heather states with a nod towards the burning wood in front of you, “still doesn’t mean you should go run through it. There are things better admired from a distance, and that,” her eyes fixate on the pretty stranger again, “is one of those things.”
You just huff in return, crossing your arms across your chest defensively, before biting,
“And since when did you become such a prude, exactly? What’s wrong with a quick fuck anyway. Didn’t say I wanted to become his docile, little housewife or anything. All I said was that he’s pretty.”
“Yes, a pretty little notch in your bedpost maybe, and then what?”
“Then I find someone else that’s pretty. Come on, Heather, you know the drill, it’s not like it’s anything new.”
The sigh that leaves Heather’s lips is somewhere between disappointment and defeat.
“It’s your prerogative at the end of the day. If you choose to fuck with him, that’s your call, but don’t say I didn’t warn you.”
“How bad can he be,” you grumble after another lazy drag from the joint you’re still nursing.
“Not any worse than you, I hope.” Heather states, and while you know she’s just teasing, there’s also a seriousness swimming in her eyes, one that has your mouth going slightly dry; drier than the hot smoke you keep inhaling, as you wonder what she’s on about.
“I know how to play with fire, don’t worry about me getting burned.” You whisper after a few beats of silence, turning the joint in your hand absentmindedly as you mull over your friends words in your head.
“But you know it’s bound to happen, don’t you? You’re going to get hurt at some point in time if you keep this up, this thing that you’re doing.”
“I’m not doing anything; I’m merely having fun.”
“Exactly. But just how many people can you burn through before the flames start catching up to you too?”
“You should really stop reading Bukowski or Platt or whoever inspired you with these silly, little fire metaphors, because I’m not having any of it.” You state, before getting up, patting the lingering sand from the little black dress you’re wearing.
“I’m gonna find myself something to drink,” you mumble, and before one of the other girls can point you halfheartedly towards one of the liquor bottles, you state, “Something non-alcoholic.”
There’s a little beach bar within walking distance, roughly 10 minutes away; but your steps are lazy as you stroll through the small waves that are playing and bumping against the shore, so it takes you a little longer.
You keep thinking about Heather’s words, as you gaze out towards the seemingly endless sea and the darkening sky above.
There’s something about the way she said the things she said, that doesn’t quite sit right with you. She’s not normally one to be that serious, and she’s certainly not one to curb your fun adventures, even if they might not be the best of ideas.
Whatever, you think. That guy was really pretty, and you’re rather picky, especially when it comes to guys. Being really good looking is like the only necessary expectation that men have to meet in your books. Yet they hardly deliver, so when someone does catch your eye, you’re intrigued.
You don’t really care about the rest because what for anyways? It’s not like you’d stick around to witness their great personalities.
You’d get a dog if you wanted a fun personality long-term in your life. You certainly don’t need a guy for that.
The woman behind the bar counter is someone you’ve seen around quite a bit. You’re pretty certain that her name’s Jamie, but you’re not a hundred percent sure, so you refrain from calling her that.
Your eyes flicker over the little signs behind her, as if you don’t already know what you’ll order. It’s only to gain some more time as you mentally go through the words you’re about to say just to make sure that they come out right.
You end up ordering a cherry slushy and a coke, and as you dig through the pockets of your leather jackets for a few coins, you feel a presence slide up right beside you.
“Didn’t think you’d be the type of girl who goes for a fucking soft drink.” The man’s voice sounds deep and raspy, and almost familiar.
It’s the stranger from the bonfire, you quickly notice, without looking up, once he leans his arms against the bar counter, the sleeves of his shirt still a deep, ruby-red.
“Didn’t think you’d be the type of guy who creepily follows girls around.” You retort as you grab your slushy, playing with the straw for a bit before pushing it slowly between your lips and turning around towards the guy, a challenging look on your face.
“I wasn’t following you,” he huffs, but you know a lie when you see one. And that guy’s definitely lying.
“Sure,” voice dripping with sarcasm, you force your attention back towards the iced drink in your hand, twirling the straw around some more, until Jamie comes back with your coke.
“There you go,” she states, as she puts the cooled drink down on the counter, “had to dig deep in the fridge for that one. Think we’re out of those for the night now, actually.”
“What a shame,” the guy next to you suddenly chimes in, “I was really craving a soft drink too.”
You’re not entirely sure if he’s being earnest or if he’s poking fun at you. If it’s the latter, it’s nothing you aren’t used to. Your determination to avoid alcoholic drinks is something most guys love to point out and have a laugh over.
“What, don’t tell me you’re that much of a lightweight, sweetheart.”
“Clearly you’ve never had a drink with me then.”
“Lighten up, pretty girl, a few beers won’t kill you.”
“Sure, they won’t, but I might.” You can’t help but let slip in those kind of situations, when guys can’t wrap their pea-sized minds around the fact that not everyone enjoys getting wasted as much as they do.
Assholes.
“Guess I’ll have to go for a slushy too then,” the stranger states, before adding, “I’ll have the blueberry one, please.”
You try to hide your surprise at his choice of drink with fake detached boredom; and while he’s busy watching Jamie making his slushy, you take the time to get a better look at him too.
He’s even prettier up close, lush lashes framing his aquamarine eyes, giving them a softer, dreamier touch. And the freckles on his skin are so detailed now, you could actually start counting them if you wanted to.
But there’s also a slight shadow underneath his left eye, and it takes you a moment to clock it as the faint traces of a bruise.
Heather’s words swirl around in your mind again.
Anger issues.
You wonder what exactly she meant by that.
“You done staring yet?” The stranger suddenly pulls you out of your thoughts, turning around towards you, a small smirk dancing around on his lips.
“Maybe,” you shrug your shoulders lightly, masking the embarrassment of getting caught quickly.
“Name’s Billy, by the way.”
He’s holding out his hand to you, rough yet slender fingers adorned with different silver rings.
You try not to notice how significantly bigger his hand feels in yours; how it almost swallows yours whole, like a predator might swallow its prey, or how his fingers linger around your wrist and pulse point for just a moment longer, before pulling away quickly.
His touch feels electrifying, and you love and hate it at the same time. It’s like you crave it but not without traces of guilt staining the subtle longing.
You try to ignore the pounding of your heart, as you tell him your name – but to your surprise he just gives you a lazy smile.
“I know.” This time around the startled look on your face is more difficult to hide, and the guy, Billy, quickly follows it up by saying, “Your friends told me all about you.”
You wonder who exactly he’s talking about. It certainly isn’t going to be Heather, that’s for sure. Maybe Argyle let something slip, or Tommy; that guy can’t keep his mouth shut for the life of him.
But it’s not like it matters now, anyway.
Not with the way Billy’s eyes wander with something akin to hunger over your frame, until his gaze finds itself transfixed on your cherry-stained lips.
God, you love slushies; and now you’re once more reminded of why.
You watch Jamie as she’s searching for a straw, and it’s only as the brief silence continues, that you notice there’s some music playing in the background.
It’s ABC’s The Look of Love, and you can’t help but hum along to it softly, tapping the beat with your fingertips gently against the still freezing plastic cup in your hands.
“Fuck, don’t tell me you’re into this new-wavy shit.” Billy looks genuinely appalled, and you just roll your eyes.
Great. So, he’s one of those guys who unironically think their music taste is so much more superior than everyone else’s.
“Well, shit, don’t tell me you’re the kind of guy who feels personally victimized by the use of some synthesizers.” You bite back, and to your surprise, there’s a catty grin spreading over Billy‘s face.
“So, what if I am?” He drawls, voice low, and eyes challenging.
“I don’t think I can fuck a guy who thinks music stopped evolving after the 1970s.”
“Who said anything about fucking?”
You give him a look that says, ‘haha very funny,’ but Billy tries to look all doe-eyed and innocent.
It hardly suits him.
Not with the way his eyes keep reflecting his intentions that his lips have yet to form into an actual sentence.
He wants you.
He wants you badly, and you hate the small spark of proudness that lights up somewhere deep within your chest at the realization, the confirmation; the simple achievement of being desirable to yet another man.
You know somewhere even deeper within you, that this isn’t healthy. That your body shouldn’t get into that kind of euphoric overdrive at the sight of even the smallest, positive acknowledgement and approval of a guy you deem pretty.
Or any guy for that matter, but it’s only the pretty ones you decide to take home.
Well, not even that is true, now that you think of it. You never actually take people home. That just feels too personal, too vulnerable. The sex usually happens in spaces private enough to not get caught, yet also impersonal enough to make your attentions of a no-strings-attached-fuck pretty clear.
“So, where are we going next?” Billy’s rough voice pulls you out of your thoughts again, and by now, he’s nursing his frozen, neon blue drink, too.
“We?” You question, eyebrows raised, but it’s just for show. Most of your acts are these days; especially the ones you keep up around men.
“You wanna go back to your friends?” he offers.
“Why? Do you have something else in mind?” You inquire because you know that he doesn’t actually want to walk back to the bonfire.
Not when the public bathroom’s right here.
“Don’t know,” Billy shrugs nonchalantly, “just don’t really want to share my slushy with the rest of the crowd, so maybe we can settle down over there for now?”
Right. Sure, you think. His reasoning certainly is shit, but you let that slide, and instead all that Billy gets is a sweet smile.
“Okay.”
You follow Billy to the abandoned spot he’s been pointing at. It’s close enough to the ocean that you can still dip your feet into the saltwater if you’d like, while still being vacant of any undesired beach visitors.
The two of you plop down unceremoniously into the sand, and the soft breeze that’s blowing feels nice on your skin.
By now the sun has completely vanished from the horizon, hiding somewhere below the calm surface of the sea. Its last and only trace is the small stripe of orange that keeps bleeding into the deeper blue above. It’s almost as if the sky’s getting drained, losing its color and vibrancy to the creeping and growing night.
You look up to see a few shiny stars slowly starting to poke through the vanishing daytime veil, and there’s a comfort in that.
A comfort that’s hard to explain, but a comfort, nevertheless.
“So, are you from around here?” Billy’s voice suddenly breaks through the silence.
“Something like that.” You respond, eyes still fixed on a spot high above you. It’s only when you repeat his question back to him that your gaze wanders over towards the pretty boy.
“Something like that.” He echoes your words, but there’s a teasing smile playing on his lips, and you huff.
Stop being so fucking cute, you think.
“Haven’t seen you around before,” you wonder aloud instead, and for a brief moment, you think you see Billy’s smile waver.
“Yeah, I, uh, I moved back here only recently,” he mumbles, while burying his hands into the sand, “but I’m initially from here,” he quickly adds, “California born and raised.”
“I see.” You say, because you’re unsure of what else to throw his way. You might not be a fucking psychology major, but even you can see that he seems slightly uncomfortable by the current talking topic.
“What else do you do, when you’re not engaging in the worst music taste ever?”
The question actually manages to make you laugh, because you didn’t expect it at all.
“For a guy who hasn’t told me anything about his music taste yet, you sure like talking a lot of shit, don’t you?”
“It’s because my music taste’s the best, sweetheart.”
“Like hell it is.”
“Wanna bet?”
“I’d rather not.”
The soft smiles you two exchange feel misplaced. You’re not normally in such a playful mood, and the smiles you grant the men you talk to rarely feel this genuine.
But for some reason, you’re a little more intrigued by this guy than you normally are by the men you hook-up with; and for the next half hour you two continue talking avidly.
The topics span from the superior Pop Rocks flavor to the latest W.A.S.P album, which Billy seems genuinely surprised by when you bring it up.
“So, you’re telling me you have both, a good and a bad music taste? How’s that even possible?” He jokes, and it made you stick your tongue out towards him playfully.
It’s a gesture Billy mirrors back at you quickly, and it has you laughing more.
“Ew, your tongue.” You point out in between soft giggles.
“What’s wrong with my tongue? Billy questions slightly concerned.
“It’s all blue, dumbass! You look like you went down on Smurfette and suffered collateral damage while doing so.”
“What?”
“You heard me.”
“I guess I did, but I didn’t expect you to have such a filthy mouth on you.”
You’d be surprised how much filthier that mouth can get, you think quietly to yourself, but he’ll probably find that out soon enough.
After the slushies there’s a joint and a few regular cigarettes shared between you two.
At some point, you feel like your senses are heightened, and you swear you can taste the saltwater of the ocean with every gentle inhale of air, tangy on your tongue.
Without really thinking, you find yourself getting up again, and with only a few steps your feet are buried deeply in the waves, that are still lapping gently up against the shore.
“What are you doing?” Billy questions, eyes sparkling with amusement and curiosity as he watches you twirl around in the shallow water.
“What does it look like?”
“A matting dance, perhaps?”
“Oh, that’s just you wishful thinking, pretty boy.”
Billy’s smile widens at your words, as he continues to watch you with fond eyes. He tries to forget the warnings Tommy gave him earlier, about how he should stay far, far away from you, if he treasured his heart at all.
Good thing he doesn’t, Billy thinks.
But he’s also rather confident that Tommy has just been trash-talking anyway.
There’s no way you’re quite the serial heartbreaker he painted you out to be.
No fucking way.
From somewhere along the beach there’s suddenly loud music being played, and it takes Billy only a brief moment to identify the opening riff as that of Crosby, Stills & Nash’s Dark Star. He watches with awe as you continue to swirl around to it, singing the lyrics softly into the darker growing summer night.
When his gaze finds yours, there’s something in your eyes that makes Billy feel defenseless; bare, almost. Like you just took one deep look into his soul, and he’s not sure if you liked what you saw.
He subconsciously plays with the buttons on his shirt, reminded of the ugly insecurities that hide underneath in plain sight, and he’s so lost in thought for a moment, that he finds himself caught off guard when you let yourself fall into the warm sand next to him again, moving closer until you’re almost sitting in his lap.
“Dance with me, Billy.” You whisper, tugging on his hand playfully, and he groans.
“Absolutely not.”
“Just one song, please?”
You give him your best puppy eyes, and most convincing pout.
“Oh, pretty please, Billy!”
“What’s in it for me, sweetheart?” Billy mumbles, voice slightly suggestive.
“What, like dancing with me isn’t enough of an incentive? That’s so rude, Billy. So rude.” You mumble, while your hand keeps tugging on his sleeve. It’s endearing, really; your childlike determination and stubbornness to get him to move.
“I don’t think I’m high enough yet to dance to some fucking folk-shit.”
The little offended huff that leaves your lips has Billy smiling slightly.
God, you’re even more adorable when you’re high.
“You’re so mean, Billy.” You pout, but at the same time you curl up more into him, and Billy decides to lift you onto his lap unceremoniously, arms wrapped around you tightly.
“Yeah, am I being a little too mean for your liking, sweet girl?” He mocks with fake concern, his knuckles brushing over your cheek gently.
“Uh-huh.”
You decide to bury your face into the crook of his neck, and he has to stifle the urge to coo at your cuteness.
“Just one,” you whisper, “just one dance, Billy.”
Billy pretends to ponder your words, like he’s actually considering it.
He is not.
“Maybe after we shared another smoke, hm?” He proposes, and the way you quickly raise your head out of your current hiding spot and your eyes light up, makes him actually feel a little soft.
He shifts you slightly on his lap while digging for his zippo as well as for another joint, and you lean your head against his chest as you watch him light it.
“You wanna shotgun?” He offers with a whisper, and you nod your head eagerly.
“Alright.” He murmurs, while you prop your head up against his shoulder, gazing up at him intensely as he takes the first hit.
You watch him inhale deeply, watch the way his chest rises; the way the joint’s end glimmers between his lips, the way his eyes flutter shut for the briefest of moments.
When he opens them again, they’re quick to find yours, before his hand comes up to the back of your neck, gripping and guiding you towards him until your faces almost touch.
You feel his fingers move from your neck to your jaw, holding you closer as his thumb presses up against your lips, and you part them instinctively.
He leans in, to an almost kiss, before blowing the smoke into your mouth. Without really thinking, you inhale deeply, feeling the shared smoke burn and tingle in your lungs.
Billy watches you with dreamy eyes, fingers still brushing against your jaw and cheek gently, even as you exhale.
“Good girl,” he praises, voice rough and low, but when he goes to take another drag, you stop him softly.
“My turn.” You whisper while slipping your fingers into his, taking the joint.
“Hey, what-“
But you’re already breathing in deeply with the joint tugged securely between your lips, and all that Billy can do is watch in awe.
Unlike him, you don’t close your eyes. Instead, you keep them locked with his almost the whole time through. Shifting on his lap slightly, you try and find a more comfortable position, and Billy can barely contain the small groan that’s bubbling up in his chest.
Fuck, you’re the devil, he thinks.
At this point you could ask him to dance to anything, really, and he would probably comply.
Then, without a warning, your hand finds its way into his curls, tugging lightly and pulling him incredibly closer again, and he feels his breath hitch at the action. But his mouth is quickly otherwise occupied when you press your lips against his softly.
And he’s eager, so fucking eager to swallow up the smoke you let drip out of your mouth into his. You both moan when he bucks his hips up slightly into yours, as you grind down onto him just as softly.
After his exhale, his lips find yours instinctively again, and he cradles your face as you deepen the kiss; nibbling on his lower lip playfully, and Billy feels like he’s going to transcend into heaven.
Shotgunning has certainly never felt quite this good, and he doubts it ever will again.
But then, suddenly, you’re up and out of his lap again, joint still secured tightly between your lips.
“You still owe me a dance, Billy.” The previous fire is back in your eyes, and Billy throws his head back with a groan.
“God, you’re the worst.” He states, but all you give him is a triumphant smile.
“A dance, Billy.”
“I don’t remember promising you one.”
“Well, then you should start promising and deliver.”
“And what if I don’t?”
“Then I’ll just have to find someone else. And trust me, I will.”
Billy contemplates you for a moment, head tilted to the side, and you hate how adorable he looks.
By now, the song that’s currently being blasted from who-knows-where is a different one, and Billy tries to figure out who the artist is.
“Are those the Bee Gees?” He questions, disgust clear in his voice.
“Almost. It’s Andy Gibb.”
When the frown between Billy’s brows doesn’t fade, you explain, “He’s like their younger brother, I think?”
Billy continues to gaze up at you as you sway to the melody, voice soft in the summer night breeze, as you sing: “We leave immediately after dark, where the lights start fading, sweet and low…”
There’s something hypnotizing in the way you move, and Billy feels like he could spend eternity just watching you dance underneath the waning moon that decided to rise and wander across the midnight blue ocean.
“Billy,” you drawl, looking at him expectantly, and he huffs.
“Can I not just enjoy the show?”
You consider his words for a moment.
“Fine, I guess the next song should do too. You’ll simply have to dance with me once this song’s finished, okay?”
Billy cannot believe the words he’s about to let slip past his lips, and he wishes he could block his own ears off just to keep himself from having to hear it too.
“Alright, fine. I’ll dance with you to the next song. I promise.”
Pleased with his answer, you continue to lose yourself in the music, and Billy finds himself completely and absolutely enchanted by it.
So much so, in fact, that he doesn’t even realize you’ve been hogging his joint this whole time.
When the current song is fading out, Billy's nervously anticipating what the next tune will be.
Please be Metallica. Please be Metallica. Please be-
It is in fact, not Metallica.
It’s a song he doesn’t recognize at all, until the artists start singing, and he’s fairly certain it’s America. Ugh! Just his luck for it to be a rather slow song too.
But you don’t let that deter you. In fact, you look rather pleased at the selected song that’s now softly floating through the salty air around you.
You reach out your hand towards Billy after taking a few steps towards him and with an overdramatic huff, he takes it reluctantly.
♪ Runaway, boy have you seen a girl like an angel, runnin’ in the night.
She’s run away, boy if you see her… ♫
In hindsight the lyrics seem like some really bad foreshadowing to Billy, but at the moment there’s hardly anything on his mind, other than you.
“I don’t normally-“ He starts, unsure of how to even begin dancing to some tune whose beat seems more akin to the heartbeat of a snail.
“It’s fine, just-“ You show him how to best hold your hands, and where to place them if he wants to hold you tighter.
You twirl around playfully, lifting his hand up into the air as you do so; and Billy can’t help but smile wide at your shenanigans, and the way you swing carefree in the wind, before pulling him closer again, hands coming up around his neck.
You however try not to notice how out of character this feels for you. Because, while you’re no stranger to dancing with people on sweaty and overheated dancefloors, this currently feels a lot more intimate and vulnerable.
And for the breath of a moment, you think that this is what it must be like to not fear connection as much as you do.
If you were less fucked, less of a burden, less difficult to love, you might even deserve it at some point in time.
But not tonight.
Not in the foreseeable future you’ve laid out for yourself.
And certainly not with Billy.
You lean your head against his shoulder, as he sways you both to the music, and for a guy who was rather adamant about not knowing how to dance less than two minutes ago, he’s surprisingly good at it.
Dumbass.
When the song stops and a new one starts, neither one of you is inclined to pull away. Instead, you take the moment to gaze in each other’s eyes, and you feel a shiver run down your spine like lightning.
You want to kiss him, badly.
Want to feel his lips all over your body if you're honest, just like you want to let your lips wander all over his body too.
Maybe it’s the drugs talking.
Please, let it be the drugs talking, you think.
To your own surprise, it’s Billy who goes for the next move, as he brushes his nose gently against yours, before moving in even closer for a kiss.
This would be the moment where the fireworks go off in the distance, you think, colorful flames reflecting in the almost black water of the sea.
But instead, there’s an ugly shadow crawling away within you, drowning out any of that. It's an intense anxiety that's fluttering in your stomach, like evil little butterflies gnawing away at your insides.
Maybe you shouldn’t be doing this, you think. Maybe you can break the cycle this time. Maybe repeating mistakes isn’t like the worst thing in the world. Maybe things with Billy could be different, maybe-
“For someone with a blade for a tongue you’re awfully quiet.” Billy whispers teasingly, pulling you out of the dark storm brooding within you. It’s only now that you notice that your lips aren’t even moving against each other anymore.
“You know, I just asked you a question.” Billy mumbles against your neck, and you can’t help the wide-eyed look that crosses your face.
“Well, don’t look that surprised, angel. I was just questioning if we should maybe migrate this situation to one a little less public, and a little more physical.”
The realization that drops in your mind seems unusually heavy.
Sex.
Of course, that’s what you two are here for anyways, right?
That’s why he’s even putting up with any of this in the first place, right?
That’s been the goal of this exchange from the very start, right?
It certainly had been the only goal for you; at least initially.
You feel foolish for even considering the idea that there might have been more to this situation.
That there might’ve been more to you than just the sex, that Billy wanted to seek out and cherish.
Foolish, foolish you.
But sex feels safe, and familiar, and comforting but in a fucked up way. You’ve always used it as a reassuring lifeline for self-validation and as a welcomed distraction from the unpleasant and overwhelming feelings swirling somewhere deep within you almost all of the time.
And now, with the nervous pounding of your heart in the back of your mind, you need such a distraction more than ever.
You need him to numb the pain, and the voices, and the fear of never, ever being good enough.
You need a distraction, and he’s the perfect one.
So, what’s the worst that can happen?
Nothing worse than what you’re already feeling, you think.
And with that, you give Billy a purposefully shy smile, before stating, “I think I need you to show me what exactly you have in mind…”
Billy smiles like a cat who’s got the cream.
Like a feline predator ready to pounce his prey.
And then, your lips meet in a messy kiss; one that’s more urgent and primal than the previous ones you shared, and you feel him gently move you towards the little, square building; the one with the shower stalls and the changing rooms and bathroom sinks you’ve been fucked against way too many times.
This feels good, you think.
This feels familiar.
And so, that’s how you find yourself in one of the public shower stalls, hands pressed against the sand-colored tiles while getting pounded from behind, hard.
Billy’s certainly on a mission to wreck your pussy, as his hands hold on to your hips so tightly you’re sure his fingers are going to leave bruises. It’s not like you mind, though, not at all.
“Fuck, didn’t think you’d have such a tight little cunt.” Billy groans while pistoling in and out of you relentlessly. He’s really putting all of his body strength into it and you’re not sure what will be left of you once he’s done.
You feel incredibly full to a point where it’s almost too much, almost too painful, like he’s going to split you in two and then put you back together; but not before rearranging your guts in the most impossible ways.
“That’s it, take it like the good little slut I know you are, fuck, knew from the very moment I laid my eyes on you that you would take it like this. Easy little bitch.” He curses.
You want to bite something mean back, but with the way he’s hitting that tender, spongy spot inside you, it’s hard to form a snarky reply - or any coherent words for that matter.
You hate the way that only little broken whimpers leave your lips like helpless pleas and prayers as he keeps pounding into you. You’re completely at his mercy and he’s not giving you any, rutting into you with a rough pace.
“Billy, Billy.” You sob, little hiccups breaking his name in two, but he just groans as his pace picks up. It’s a sound that’s deep and raspy and primal, and it has you clenching around him involuntary as another whine slips past your lips again.
“Fuck, listen to you going stupid on my cock. Taking it so well, didn’t even have to prepare you either, could just slide into your wet little pussy. Bet it’s been drooling for me ever since we first started talking, isn’t that right?”
When there’s no immediate answer coming from you, he’s quick to take a fistful of your hair, gripping it tightly and then pulling your head back hard.
“Isn’t that right?” He snarls, voice raised and rough, yet his pounding never wavers.
But the words swirling around on your tongue won’t form into any sensible order, leaving only a gasping moan to slip past your lips as the pain from his unwavering grip on your hair shoots through your skull.
And you love it.
God, you love it; love how your mind just goes completely blank. It’s like in that moment you don’t quite exist anymore. Not in the way you usually do, not as you lose yourself in the pain and the pleasure that’s being given and taken from you.
“Fuck, look at you, pretty little fucked out thing, letting me use you like I please in a public shower. Anyone could just walk in here and see us. But you’d probably get off on that too, wouldn’t you?”
You can barely nod your head with the way Billy’s hand is still tangled in your hair, before he’s letting go, curling the hand around your throat instead. You feel him press himself closer to you, nibbling on your earlobe before playfully pulling on it with his teeth.
“Listen here, little slut,” he growls, his breath hot against your skin, “You said you’d take anything I’d give you, so, I’m assuming that offer still stands.”
The faint nod you manage is enough for Billy’s finger to wander once more, gripping your jaw tightly before moving your face slightly in his direction.
You’re unsure of where he’s going with this, and for a brief moment you think he might lean in for a kiss.
He does not.
Instead, his fingers dig into the sides of your cheeks, pressing your mouth open for him.
“Swallow.” He orders, and it’s the only warning you get, before you see his jaw flex, mouth moving closer to yours and then he’s spitting right into yours.
It’s like your mind’s on autopilot because you don’t even have to think about swallowing his spit; you immediately do it, almost instinctively so, and Billy’s breathy groans only deepen.
“Good obedient little girl. Fuck, fuck, don’t think I’ve ever seen someone that eager, jeez.”
He starts leaving messy open-mouthed kisses along your neck and jaw in between dirty praises, and his thrusts increase their pace again, until all you can think about is the way his cock fills you up, over and over again.
Your gasps increase with every quick rut of his hip, pushing himself deeper and deeper, and you can’t help but fuck yourself back on him with little, timid thrusts too.
“Dick’s that good, huh?” Billy observes with a condescending smile when he notices your little movements.
“B-billy,” voice shaky, eyes teary, even you’re unsure what exactly you’re begging for, and the laugh that leaves Billy’s lips is almost cruel.
“What is it, little girl?”
His hand tightens around your throat again, yet he’s barely applying any real pressure, just gripping it in a possessive way, but that’s enough to have your mind spinning anyway.
Billy keeps his rhythm, even when the sounds that leave your pretty lips increase. And god, do those sounds drive him absolutely wild. He loves how responsive you are, while simultaneously wearing such a fucked-out and dreamy look on your face like you’re miles away.
Billy thinks he’s about to come when his fingers wander down to lazily rub your clit and even that slight contact makes you spasm around him.
“I know, I know,” he soothes when your whines are getting louder again, “that’s the little spot that feels real good doesn’t it.”
“Uh-huh.”
“Fuck, and you’re so wet, so wet, baby.”
Billy can’t help but moan at the feeling of your slick that collects around his fingers, dripping out of you and tainting the outside of your pussy sinfully.
But the movement of his rough fingers on your clit only makes you more vocal, and with the way his dick is pushing itself into you, filling you up in ways previously thought unimaginable, it’s hard not to gasp, and whine, and moan in response.
“Billy, please, please don’t stop.” You hick-up, voice breaking halfway through, and it only makes Billy’s dick twitch inside of you harder.
“Wasn’t planning on it, sweet girl,” Billy groans, “wasn’t planning on stopping until I’ve filled this filthy cunt with everything I have; because you want it, don’t you? Want me to make your pretty little pussy even messier than it already is. Gonna fill you up so good, my cum will be dripping out of you for days.”
You clench around him at the thought, and Billy laughs again as he feels you tightening around his thick length.
“Of course, you’d like that, cum hungry little bitch, fuck.”
“Feel so full Billy,” you whine in between little gasps.
“Yeah, well, imagine how much fuller you’ll feel once I had my fill. Once you’re actually full of me.”
And then out of nowhere he grabs one of your hands, pulling it down towards his crotch, where you two are intertwined.
The angle is a little awkward and you don’t know where this is going exactly, until he wraps your hand around one of his balls.
“Do you feel that, sweet little slut? Feel how full I am?”
And fuck, you do, you really, really do, as Billy’s hand keeps guiding yours, kneading his heavy sack while just rutting into you harder.
“Fuck, just like that, going to give it to you so good, and do you know what’s going to happen after that?”
You shake your head, too fucked out and overwhelmed to even form a little ‘no’.
“Then we’re going to put your slutty little panties back on you, walk back out there to your friends, and then we’ll see how much of an obedient girl you really are, because if you’re really good, you won’t let a drop go to waste. Keep it all in your messy little pussy of yours, where it belongs.”
God, you have to give it up to this guy, you think. He might actually have an even filthier mouth than you do. But Billy isn’t done with his little speech, only stopping to let his tongue run a messy trail down your neck.
“But if you fail sweetheart, if I push my fingers under your little dress later and feel my cum dripping and running down your lush little thighs, I guess I’ll just have no choice but to fuck it back into you again.”
That thought almost does it for you and you whine Billy’s name loudly.
“Shit that gets you going, huh? Probably isn’t even a punishment getting stuffed full of my cum and my cock.”
You’re whines increase again and Billy suddenly stops his assault on your pussy, the hand that’s been previously toying with your clit, leaving, until two of his fingers are tapping against your lips.
“Open up wide for me, sweet thing,” he mumbles with a groan, and without much of a second thought, without really any thought at all, you open your mouth obediently, and Billy’s quick to slip his fingers inside.
“Love your moans, they make me so hard, but god, you gotta be a bit more quiet.”
“’m trying,” you mumble against his digits, tongue dancing around them. They taste like you, and him, and the cigarettes you shared.
“Know you are, know you’re trying your best, but you’re also a dumb little slut who simply can’t help herself, can you. Cock so good it’s the only thing on your mind, huh?”
You’re not sure if the little moan that slips your lips in agreement can be identified as such, but Billy certainly seems to take it that way.
“It’s okay, it’s okay, I can help you stay more quiet, pretty thing. Gonna keep your mouth stuffed the way I stuff your pussy; and it also gives me the opportunity to test your limits here-“
He pushes his fingers into your mouth deeper until you gag around them, and he groans at the feeling.
“Fuck like that, like that baby, choke on my fingers while your cunt swallows my cock like the good little cocksleeve it is,fuck!”
His grith pushes into you quicker, faster, and with so much desperation now, that you feel the fire within you flare up to an almost explosive height.
“Come on little bitch, play with your clit for me, while I wreck your pussy and your throat.”
The speed of his fingers that are currently fucking your mouth increases, mirroring the thrusts of his hips, and you find yourself gurgling and spluttering around him, yet Billy’s pace never wavers, if anything your struggles only turn him on more, and he feels himself getting closer too.
But with the way you’re playing with your clit while being stuffed so incredibly full, the pleasure inside you only heightens and you’re hurdling down towards your climax much quicker than Billy does.
“You can come, baby,” Billy murmurs, “You can come on my cock, pretty thing.”
“Billy,” you sob, lashes thick with tears and lips quivering.
“Billy, I’m gonna-“
“I know, I know, sweet girl. Just let go for me. You’ve done so good already, just let go.”
Billy’s voice is still rough, but there’s a soothing undertone, one that’s triggering something odd in your brain. Something warm and comforting and weirdly enough, something safe.
“Come on, baby. Be the good little slut I know you want to be. You want me to be proud of you, right? So, cum and cream on my cock, pretty bitch.”
Billy emphasized his words with even harder thrusts, his cockhead kissing your cervix repeatedly, and you know you’ll feel the bruising effects of it for the next few days at the very least.
“Fucking slut, come now!” He orders, fingers pushing themselves as deep as they can down your throat, and you gag hard.
But Billy doesn’t pull them out again. Instead, he leaves them there, only the tips of his fingers moving slightly, applying repeated pressure to your throat.
You gurgle his name desperately, and Billy swears he almost comes then and there as he feels both your pussy and throat spasm around him.
The cry that leaves your lips sounds wet, and messy, and fucked out, as you come hard, back arching and thighs shaking. Your pussy’s griping him like a vice, but Billy fucks you through your high relentlessly, to a point where it’s almost cruel.
“Good girl,” he praises in between rough thrusts.
“Good fucking girl.”
His hips still slap against you with vigor, and you find yourself whining at the increasing overstimulation of it all. The weight of his fingers in your mouth, and his cock in your cunt seem suddenly twice as hard, twice as heavy, and twice as overwhelming.
Your hips instinctively try to wiggle away from him, but Billy’s not having any of it.
“Nuh-uh, I know it’s a lot, but you can take it, baby. Gonna let me get my fill too, remember?”
Your whines increase once more at the increasingly uncomfortable feeling, and while you try hard to be good and take it, your hips have a little mind of their own.
“Stop it, slut!” There’s a sudden harsh slap on your ass that makes you moan out and grip around Billy’s cock even tighter.
“Fuck,” Billy rasps out at the realization “Shit, you’re probably one of those girls who actually enjoy getting slapped around during sex too. Crying because of the pleasure rather than the pain of it all, god, that’s so fucked up. You’re so fucked up, baby, and I love it.”
The little delirious rambles that leave your mouth after that only spur Billy on more.
“You gonna let me take it, right?” He whispers, and after the small nod that follows his words, Billy suddenly pushes you forward, shifting his weight slightly to get better leverage, until you’re completely pressed up against the cold tiles of the shower.
"Pussy can’t run from me that way.” Billy grumbles, before moaning loudly, because this position right here is giving him an even deeper and easier access to your cunt.
One of his hands is holding your hips in place, as the other one pushes your face against the tiles, cheeks squished against it.
“Just let me use you, fuck, just like that.”
He’s pressing himself flat against you, bucking up into you with no way for you to escape it. Not that you’d want to anyways, but there’s something exceptionally dirty about getting used like that. Because right now you don’t serve any other purpose than to make Billy feel good and let him fill you up.
And with the way that you’re currently pressed up against the tiles, you can’t even play with your own clit; left completely at the mercy of Billy, who’s now more concerned with chasing his own high.
“Fuck, take it! Just fucking take it, stupid fucking whore.”
The little gasps and squeals that escape your lips with every rut of Billy’s hips are like music to his ears. They’re addicting, the perfect mixture of sweet and filthy, and he can’t get enough.
“Yeah, that’s it baby. Dumb little thing just waiting for her fill. Can’t do anything but let me use you. Use you to my liking, fuck.”
He’s getting closer, unimaginably closer, and for the first time his pace actually starts to falter.
He’s bucking into you quicker, more irregularly, and the pants that leave his lips have you clenching around him more.
You can feel his breath hot on your neck, especially since he’s hardly pulling out now, and instead keeps rutting himself deeper inside of you with desperate little thrusts.
“Fuck, gonna cum, gonna cum in your pretty little pussy and you’re gonna take it. Yeah, shit, take it just like that.”
You feel him twitch inside of you and then he’s coming with a loud and raspy moan.
He’s coming a lot, and you can’t help but whine too, as you feel his warm spurts fill your insides. He’s still rutting up into you softly, coming and twitching and mumbling little ‘take it’s and praises under his breath.
Once he’s completely spent he just stays there for a moment, pressed against you tightly while you’re both trying to catch your breath.
That’s until Billy slips out of you with a groan, taking a small step back. But without Billy’s body weight pressed securely against you, you find yourself in something akin to a freefall.
“Oh shit, easy there, baby.” Billy exclaims while rushing back towards you, steading hands coming up to your sides to keep you from buckling over or folding in on yourself.
“Fuck, you’re like Bambi on ice or something,” Billy mumbles when he sees the way your legs are still shaky, and without much of a warning he simply lifts you up, bridal style.
Your mind is just now slowly floating back to its rightful place. Words coming together like small little puzzle pieces that form into thoughts and more complex feelings.
You’ve done it again, you think, but instead of triumph, there’s shame bubbling up in your stomach. And it worsens at the feeling of Billy’s lingering hands around your body, and the way he keeps talking to you gently.
This is not how this usually goes, your brain notes in surprise and something akin to wide-eyed panic.
Wait, where is this guy taking you?
“Billy, what-“ You can’t help the small rise in your voice, or the way you try to struggle against him, despite your energy levels being completely drained.
“Hey, shhh, it’s okay, it’s okay, little girl. You’re okay, I’ve got you.” Billy tries to soothe, but he’s just making it worse.
The softness of his touch and voice feel entirely unfamiliar and unusual – so by default they also feel entirely wrong, because this is so not how this usually goes.
“Shit, hey, I’m not gonna hurt you.” Billy’s voice is still patient and gentle when he puts you down carefully on one of the wooden benches that are provided in the bigger changing room.
“There you go.” He murmurs, before his hand comes up to your face, thumb brushing over your cheek softly. “You can come back to me baby in your own time, it’s okay.”
There’s a warm and understanding smile on Billy’s lips, and it sends your mind into overdrive, because why is he suddenly nice after being so rough? He got what he wanted so why is he still here?
This is so not what you’re used to. It’s either you leaving right after, or them.
Lately it’s mostly you, but you don’t normally get fucked that good, so it’s much easier to slip away once the guy’s done. And usually there’s a liberated feeling afterwards, but somehow right now you just feel dirty, and Billy’s gentleness seems entirely out of place. Guys are nice to you before sleeping with you, not afterwards, for god’s sake.
Billy sees the irritation on your face, but he doesn’t know what’s causing it. Doesn’t know why you’re looking at him wide-eyed, like he’s grown two heads.
“You can go now, I’m okay.” You mumble, while fidgeting and pulling down parts of your black dress, restless eyes searching the empty room for something.
“Go?” Billy whispers, slightly confused, “Why would I just go?”
You’re still not meeting his eyes when he looks at you for clarification and something inside of him clicks.
“Oh.”
The little exclaim leaves his lips quietly, and you can’t help but feel slightly embarrassed by the pitying tone of voice.
He needs to leave, you think, so you can put yourself back together again.
You know Billy probably means good, but he’s truly just making things worse. The softness of his touch and voice just has your mind uncoiling further, like a ball of yarn that’s being carelessly played with by a kitten, not knowing about the destruction it causes.
His unsuspected gentleness is making you feel smaller and more vulnerable than you’re used to, and you hate it. You absolutely hate it.
It’s like he’s peeling away at the toughest layers that you’ve got. And how are you supposed to build yourself back up again when he keeps scratching away at your foundations within the fortress of your heart.
God, he’s not being what you imagined him to be like at all, you notice with a frown. Especially after Heather’s warning words, you expected someone else entirely.
You expected the usual rough sex and hasty departure. That’s all he’s in for anyway. But now, he’s doting over you like you’re precious, and despite still wearing your dress and looking less fucked-out than you did mere minutes ago, you feel incredibly raw and bare.
More raw and bare than you felt during the filthy sex you two just shared.
Why is he being nice, you think. The men you sleep with normally aren’t, and when they are you’re usually not; slipping out of their bed quickly and brushing away any questions about when they’ll see you again.
So why is he being nice.
“What?”
It’s now Billy’s turn to look at you, wide-eyed, and you realize you must have whispered your last words out loud.
Why is he being nice.
It’s a genuine question that your mind can’t comprehend; trying to come up with a reason why he would – until it finally hits you.
“We’re not doing this again, you know.”
The whisper falls from your lips with more bite than you intended.
“What?”
“We’re not doing this again, so you can leave now, Billy.”
For some reason looking at Billy’s bewildered face just hurts your brain more, or maybe your heart. In moments like this, you’re hardly in tune with everything that’s going on inside of you, so you can’t quite pinpoint the current anxiousness feeling that floats through your body, seemingly unrestrained and unregulated.
You just keep yourself occupied with the task of pulling down your dress, trying to get it to cover you up more.
Your eyes still scan the room, but it’s useless. You can’t make out your panties for the life of you, even though you know they should be lying around here somewhere.
“Watcha looking for, sweet girl?” Ignoring your previous words, Billy asks the question softly, because your troubled eyes and discomfort are hard to miss.
“Nothing,” you mumble, not looking up, head hung low as you keep fidgeting with the hem of your dress.
“You can go now, Billy. Just leave, please.”
You don’t notice the pained look that crosses Billy’s face or the helplessness that takes over his body.
This isn’t how his hookups usually go. He’s no Disney prince by any means, but he’s also not one to leave the girls he sleeps with high and dry, and a complete mess on a public bathroom floor.
Truth be told, that possible image of you stings more than he’d like to admit.
Strangely, it’s less the fact that you’ve fucked other men before and more the idea that you’d find yourself a crying and quivering mess afterwards on the cold tiles inside a public bathroom.
A bathroom in which anyone could just walk into and then take advantage of your situation, Billy thinks with an uncomfortable shudder, especially when you still have vulnerability written all over your features, like you do right now.
So, he’s not just going to leave you here, not when your fingers are still trembling, and your quiet little sniffles still echo through the empty room.
Billy decides to kneel down, getting more on your level, concerned eyes desperately trying to find yours.
“Is there anything I can do to make you feel better?” He whispers, while stifling the urge to touch you; because with the way you reacted earlier while being confined in his arms he doubts that’s a good idea.
“Anything other than leaving, that is.” He hastily adds, and for once you look up at him.
Fucking finally.
But the moment of eye contact is short-lived. You avert your gaze much to quickly again, but at the very least you mumble an incredibly quiet, and timid, “My panties.”
Of course. Billy almost groans at his stupidity. God, he can be dense sometimes.
That also explains the endless tugging of your dress; how did he not think of this?
“Okay, okay, don’t worry. Just stay here and take deep breaths while I hunt those panties down!” He gives you a small wink, before mumbling, “I’m not getting called a panty hunter for nothing.”
You watch Billy scan your current room quickly, before rushing into the next one. But you’re still wary of his apparent niceness and supposed worry.
“Got it!” You hear him exclaim suddenly, but it’s quickly followed by a deflated huff.
“Oh no.”
He comes back with his jeans in one hand and your black panties in the other, but the expression on his face is apologetic.
“Look, you have every right to hate me now because I might have, uh, I might have killed your panties earlier while trying to help you get them off.”
“Okay,” He sees the way you nod, trying hard to be nonchalant about it, but the shine in your eyes is giving you away.
That and the slight tremble of your lips.
“But don’t worry, I have an idea, okay?”
You look up at him with questioning eyes and something akin to hope reflected in them, and Billy actively has to keep himself from reaching his hand out to wipe away the stray tears on your cheeks.
“The solution is probably not going to be perfect, but it is a solution no less. I’ll just have to leave really quickly to get something, but I promise I’ll be back again in no time okay?”
You nod your head, trying to process his words.
“Okay, good, now, can you promise me something too?” Billy mumbles. He’s kneeling down next to you again, his rough fingers gently caressing your knuckles.
“Promise me you’ll be here when I come back again. It’s just gonna be 5 minutes but I need you to be here, okay. I need you to wait for me, can you promise me that?”
Once again, you nod your head softly, but that’s not enough of a confirmation for Billy.
“Need you to say it.” He whispers, blue eyes looking at you expectingly.
“I’ll wait, I promise.” Your voice is hushed and tired, but Billy still picks up on it.
“Good girl.” He praises, and without really thinking about it, he leaves a chased kiss on your forehead, before getting up and slipping into his jeans quickly. He’s been wearing his red shirt the whole time, you notice, as you watch him tug it into his denim hastily.
“Be right back, I promise.” He states with a careful smile, and then he’s out of the room with quick strides.
Once he’s left, and it’s just you in the empty building, taking deep breaths suddenly feels a lot easier, and your mind feels less like it’s in a fight or flight situation. But trying to wrap your mind around whatever is currently happening seems still rather difficult.
You don’t normally react that emotional after sex, but in the rare cases that you do, there’s hardly anyone around to witness it, so the way that Billy’s dotting over you feels incredibly foreign, constricting even.
Like you’re being backed into a corner and then smothered to death.
As you try to stand up, you have to defeatedly witness how your legs are still a little shaky.
‘Like Bambi on ice’, Billy’s words echo in your mind. He sounded so soft when he said it; so endeared, so smitten, so-
Oh no.
You have to leave, you think. You have to leave right now.
Screw your panties and your promise, you should be out that door immediately.
Wiping your eyes angrily and clenching your fists, you try to summon all the body strength you can muster. But before you can even try to stand up again, there’s a sudden sound coming from the entrance again, one that’s quickly followed by Billy’s voice, and you freeze.
“Hey, you didn’t run like I almost expected you to.“ He states with a little, teasing smile when he makes his way back into the room, and there’s a glimmer of proudness reflected in his eyes.
“Oh, and I got you this here.“
It’s only then that you notice him holding two pieces of fabric that are now being extended towards you.
“Billy, what-?“
“I know it’s not exactly evening wear, but it should do, right?”
It’s two pieces of clothing; a white shirt and red swimming trunks.
“It’s going to be a bit of a loose fit, but you’ll probably look way cuter in those than I do.” Billy mumbles, before adding quickly, “Don’t worry, though, I didn’t wear them or anything! Those are just my backup clothes for, uh, you know, being a lifeguard.”
“You’re a lifeguard?” You inquire, and Billy nods, cheeks tinted slightly red.
“Yes! I mean i-it’s not all I do, I also work as a mechanic downtown, but the early morning shifts are rather tame here at the beach and money’s tight so…“ He drifts off, hand rubbing some spot on his neck repeatedly.
“Billy that-that’s nice but I can’t take those.” You state, trying to give the clothes back to him.
“Why not?”
“How will you get them back afterwards?”
“Well, when we see each other again, obviously. You can just drop by at the little lifeguard station tomorrow, or at the next bonfire when-”
“But Billy, that’s not going to happen.”
“What?”
“I’m not- we’re not going to see each other again like that.”
“Like what?”
“Fucking.” You state, voice somehow colder now.
You take another breath, forcing your voice to come out devoid of any emotions.
“I don’t make the same mistake twice, Billy. So, you can really keep those.”
Standing up with a lot more determination, you push his clothes gently against his chest. Your fingers are still trembling, but you hope he doesn’t notice it.
“Mistake?” Billy whispers, trying to wrap his mind around what’s currently going on.
“You seem like a good guy, Billy.” Your voice is a lot softer now, almost hushed. “But I’m not going to break my own rules for you. So, take care.”
Standing up on your tiptoes, you lean in a little closer, until he feels your lush lips pressed against his cheek. It’s only for a split second, but he still feels like he’s being struck by lightning. He can’t move, or react, or do anything other than stand there frozen, for the briefest of moments.
Yet it’s still long enough for you to slip through the room, out the door, and then you’re gone.
“Hey, wait-“
When Billy finally manages to turn around, he finds himself calling your name repeatedly, but it’s too late. By the time he’s at the entrance door of the little building, you’re nowhere in sight.
He finds himself cursing as he scans the beach for even the smallest, tiniest signs of you, but it’s no use. Nighttime has rolled around and overtaken absolutely everything by now, and the faint, warm light of the lamps above are hardly any help in beating the surrounding darkness into submission.
Billy hates how worry bubbles up inside of him; eats his insides alive, and makes him feel completely sick.
Hates how his heart aches slightly.
Fuck, he should have listened to Tommy when he said that he should stay far, far away from you.
He had been quick to notice Billy’s curious gaze earlier, after the new boy had witnessed the sweetest laugh he’s ever heard.
Your laugh.
“Fuck, don’t even think about it. She’s like the worst little bitch around.” Tommy had stated after taking a big gulp from his beer, but Billy had been unconvinced.
You looked so sweet, so joyful, so kind. He couldn’t keep his eyes from watching you playfight with Heather, as she was tickling you because of some silly comment you made.
There was something in your eyes, in your laugh, in the movement of your body.
And he was intrigued.
“No, dude, believe me. I’ve seen her make grown man cry and shit. She’s like a fucking sex siren or something. You know that song, uh, Maneater?”
Now Tommy’s mumbling the worst rendition of Maneater Billy’s ever heard, and that song’s already complete shit to begin with in his books, so imagine his pain.
“Uh, yeah, that song definitely sounds familiar.”
“Yeah, well, she is that. Whatever Daryl Oates was singing about, that’s her through and through.”
Billy shakes his head, stifling his urge to correct Tommy on his wrong music trivia. But above all, Billy doesn’t believe a single word coming out of that guy’s mouth.
He didn’t believe it then, and he didn’t believe it when he chatted you up at the bar either, but things slowly started to change when the two of you found yourselves talking down by the beach.
There was something addicting in your little smiles, and laughs, and the challenging fire in your eyes, waiting for him to talk back. There was something in the way you would twirl around light-heartedly, between ocean waves, with no care in the world.
It was in the way you seemed free.
And it was also in the way that you’d kiss him and subsequently tugged at his heart, uh no, hair, softly.
And he definitely believed Tommy’s words when he found himself sheeted deep inside of you. He’s never had a pussy feel that good around him, never heard whines that sweet and filthy. Never thought his name could sound so good falling from someone else’s lips.
He was in deep, literally. And he knew that one fuck simply wouldn’t be enough. One night like this certainly wasn’t, and maybe nothing ever would, but he had to see you again, had to at least try to quench his thirst for you; craving your company like a touched starved fool. Addicted to your little laughs, and your moans, and the way you could be saccharine sweet in one moment, and challenging in the next.
Then, unsuspectedly, you ended up almost breaking down on the cold shower floor, and something else kicked up deep inside of him. Something protective and concerned, because behind your carefree attitude was someone, really, really hurt, and he got small glimpses of that.
Glimpses that he could relate to, if he’s being really honest.
Yet unfortunately his tender words and touches had the complete opposite effect on you.
He still doesn’t understands why. Doesn’t understand why your distress would seemingly worsen after he tried to help.
And now you were gone, leaving him with many questions, no answers, and a slightly aching heart.
Billy hates how he can already hear Tommy’s smug “Told you so.” And he doesn’t want to be faced with that at all. So, going back to the bonfire is a big no for him, until the thought that you could have gone there crosses his mind, and suddenly he’s heading in that direction hastily.
He knows it’s probably wishful thinking, but that doesn’t stop the small spark of hope from blooming up somewhere deep inside his chest, at the mere idea, that maybe, maybe he 'll see you again.
He just wants to make sure you’re okay, and make clear that he didn’t mean to scare you away. Whatever it was that had you this terrified and worried, he’s sure he could find a solution. Find a solution and maybe make you stay.
But once Billy reaches the gathering at the bonfire again, he has to confront the fact that it was all for nothing, cause you’re not there.
The disappointment seems like a cruel way to extinguish the little flames of hope that have been flickering away in his chest, and he feels physically deflated.
Some of your friends are still lingering around, though. He spots Tommy first, who just gives him a pitying glance, when he notices Billy’s restless eyes wander over the current scene, obviously scanning the crowd, looking for someone. Heather’s just giving him a wary side-eye, looking like she’d kill him in his sleep if she could. Not sure what her problem is, Billy thinks.
Unfortunately, he can’t make out Argyle anywhere for the live of him, so he decides to head home for good this time.
Getting black out drunk, trying to forget that this night ever happened might be better achieved at his own little place anyways.
And so, just like you, he leaves hastily into the night, thoughts occupied only by one specific person.
You don’t go to the next few outings that come up.
Metaphorically speaking, you’re still licking and tending to your wounds.
The last person you want to see is Billy, even when he’s also the only person on your mind.
You don’t know why, or what exactly went wrong during your hook-up with him, that left you in the emotional turmoil you ended up finding yourself in. But somehow you did, and somehow that didn’t scare him away, which is hard to wrap your mind around.
The only sensible answer your brain can come up with, is that he had just been kind to you out of pity, or because he wanted to get on your good side, maybe, just so he could fuck you again.
Or maybe, he’s just one of those guys with a savior complex.
You fucked your fair share of those; semi-decent guys, who thought that if they tried hard enough, they might be able to domesticate you like a goddamn cat.
As if a stable relationship and some second-hand love, handed down to you in sizes that never fit – always swallowing you whole or feeling to tight – are going to fix your issues.
Whatever.
You try not to think about it too much.
Try not to let Billy’s concerned eyes come up in memory too often. Try not to feel the embarrassment of having fallen apart in front of him. Try not to feel anything, really.
The sex normally helps to negate that particular issue, the numbing pounding of some stranger’s cock the perfect distraction to the emotional storm swirling around inside of you most of the time.
But you’re not even in the mood for that right now.
And so, you find yourself curled up in bed for a couple of days, ignoring the ringing of your phone and the repeated knocks on your door. It’s probably Heather, or Argyle, or god forbid Tommy.
But you ignore them all, turning around in your sheets instead, trying to suppress the memories of Billy.
Trying to suppress the pretty eyes of a certain stranger, who showed you a little sliver of compassion at the worst possible time, and now you fear that this will haunt you forever.
And when you’re not fighting your mind to stop thinking, and feeling, and wishing for Billy to just hold you, you’re taken by a dreamless, void-like, and utterly restless sleep.
It’s roughly two weeks later, when you’re back at the beach, back at the bonfire, and back in some pretty boy’s arms. His name is Jake or Jason or maybe it’s John? You’re not entirely sure, and you don’t really care enough to find out .
You’re giggling softly at one of his jokes, while giving him the most innocent eyes you can muster, but inside of you, something ugly is clawing to get its fix.
And you’re on your way to get it 15 minutes later, when you’re both stumbling towards the building with the empty shower stalls once again. The déjà vu doesn’t hit you immediately, and you’re still laughing at something pretty boy-what’s-his-name said, when your eyes find someone else’s in the distance.
Billy’s.
He’s leaning against the bar counter, sipping a can of beer while watching you closely, and suddenly you feel like you’re drowning.
What is he doing here? You think. It’s a stupid question, and you know that. You have no right to be upset by his presence, and he’s told you he works at the beach too, so he probably lives nearby anyway and-
There are lips now at your neck that serve as a welcomed distraction, and you try not to let it remind you of the last time you stumbled through those doors.
But it’s different this time, and you ignore the shift in your heart when you watch Billy avert his eyes, jaw clenched and hands tightening around his beer can.
Whatever. You don’t care.
The sex ends up being mediocre at best, and you have to edge the guy on repeatedly to get him to roughen you up a bit more; to numb out all of your pain with the quick strokes of his cock. He finishes before you do, but that’s nothing out of the ordinary, and of course he doesn’t even notice.
A Fool.
A simple, careless fool.
But it’s okay because you’ve gotten your main fix already. The storm brooding within you feels a lot calmer now, and you get to bask in the afterglow of your achievement.
The guy fulfilled his mediocre purpose, yet he’s hesitant to leave you alone. He almost follows you around like a lost puppy, as you smooth out your skirt and walk up to one of the mirrors.
You find yourself having to revert to a few quick lies; promising him that, sure you’ll meet him at the bonfire most definitely again. You just really need some alone-time to fix your smudged make-up in peace.
The lies fall from your lips perfectly, in promises already broken before they drip from your mouth in the warm light of the setting sun that’s breaking through one of the fogged-up windows.
As usual, he eats the lies up like a starved dog might eat a treat, and you smile at his eager eyes, and the hopefulness written all over his features.
Stupid little fool, you think, as you watch him leave. He even has the audacity to turn around towards you again with a little wave, and you stifle the urge to roll your eyes. Pathetic, you think while giving him one of your sweetest smiles.
You weren’t lying about wanting to quickly clean yourself up, though. Scrubbing the persistent mascara stains off from both of your cheeks, and applying a new layer of lip gloss.
Once you look less like the mess you feel, you make your way across the beach, only this time into the opposite direction of the bonfire, until you’ve found a spot that looks private enough for your liking. You let yourself sink into the sand with a sigh, and it doesn’t take long for you to nurse another one of your joints while gazing out towards the endless sea.
For the first time since your hook-up with Billy, you actually feel somewhat good again, as a weird peacefulness takes hold of your heart. Some might call it numbness, but you indulge in it, nevertheless – that is until a raspy voice comes up from behind you.
“Didn’t think I’d get to see you again, Cinderella.”
Billy.
You hate how your heartrate picks up at the roughness of his voice, of his presence, of his scent.
“Had hoped I didn’t get to see you again either.” You retort, gaze still stubbornly fixed on the ocean in front of you.
Billy just huffs, before you hear him sitting down next to you. He’s not as close as he was last time around, keeping some distance between you two. If for your sake, or for his, you’re not sure.
“So, you really meant it when you said you don’t do the same mistake twice, huh?”
“It’s nothing personal, I just wanna have fun.”
“Is that what you’re having?” He questions, and despite his simple words, you feel them hit a complicated nerve.
It’s like he’s trying to call your bluff.
“What is it to you?” You deflect while still refusing to look at him, because you’re not quite sure what will happen if you do.
“Just curious, really.”
There’s a moment of silence, safe for the gentle rush of the ocean. It’s an ethereal sound, akin to that of a lullaby, and it somehow reminds you of your mom.
“Was he worth it?” Billy’s voice calls you out of your thought, and back to the harsh reality again.
“What?”
“The guy you slept with, was he worth it?”
“That’s what you want to know about? Okay.” You mumble more to yourself than anything, and then, after another few beats of silence you ask, “Was he worth what, Billy?”
That renders the guy next to you silent.
You two stay like that for a while; quiet, deep in thought, trying to make sense of the other.
Billy wants to ask if you’re alright, but he also doesn’t want to seem like he cares too much, or at all, really. Even though he does. He does care.
Billy tries to think of something that will make you stay. Not for good, but for the moment.
Something that will make you see that he means no harm and comes in peace, even though your hasty departure two weeks ago still stings. So does the fact that you’ve been avoiding him ever since, or having to see you with another guy.
He now truly knows what Tommy was talking about. Knows that this is just a game for you. But he’s vary and unsure of your motives. He doubts however, that you’d tell him if he asked.
Your mind is currently also in some quiet overdrive, trying to figure out what to say, but coming up empty again.
There are words you thought about saying to him; thoughts you’ve never said out loud to anyone; but Billy’s witnessed you when you were at your smallest and most vulnerable already, and he didn’t run. He didn’t mock you; he didn’t leave.
And while you’re still vary of his motives, because most men you know usually aren’t nice to women out of their kindness in their hearts and their endless empathy for humankind, you secretly hope that Billy might be different.
It’s wishful thinking at its worst, but you thought about giving him an explanation within the last two weeks more times than you want to admit.
This whole situation can’t really spiral down any further, and you’ve let your guards down around him once already. Sure, it was involuntarily, but still; that has to count for something.
“I didn’t mean to be a bitch.” Your words come out hushed and hasty, but they’re earnest.
“You need to know that I didn’t mean to hurt you, if I did, that is. I know you meant good, probably, but I don’t need any pity, or help, or saving.”
Billy’s quiet for a moment, as he contemplates your words. He doesn’t try to hide his surprise at your admissions; doesn’t think he could if he tried.
“I never pitied you, and I never thought you needed saving either, but there’s no shame in needing help from time to time.”
You’re both silent now, letting the words spoken and the words unspoken sit in between you in the warm sand.
For some reason you want him to stick around, want to get to know him more, but even just that quiet admission seems endlessly scary.
You shouldn’t feel this attached to a guy you barely know and fucked once.
But unbeknownst to you Billy feels the exact same way, and there are words laying on the tip of his tongue, almost folded neatly into a simple question that he’s too scared to ask.
But then he reminds himself that he doesn’t really have anything to lose. You could just leave regardless of the things that are about to fall from his lips.
It’s a simple ask and it’s a bit embarrassing how worked up he’s getting over this, but he just tries to tell himself that the worst you can do is laugh and leave; and you might even do that without his proposition.
He repeats the words in his head, trying to make them sound nonchalant. Trying to make them sound like his heart isn’t in it, despite the fact that it’s right there, on the tip of his tongue, ready to tumble out and into your lap at the mere sight of you.
“So, what do you say, are you up for another joint and a slushy?”
The words fall out of his mouth, fast and jumbled, and not quite as detached and casual as he’d hoped. Still, you’re not yet on your feet and running away like last time. Instead, there’s surprise swimming in your eyes, but you cover it up quickly with a teasing smile.
“Joint and a slushy? Billy you’re spoiling me.”
You joke lightly, but inside of you is a new storm brewing. Because if you say yes, it’s going to be completely uncharted new territory.
And you want to say ‘yes’, but there’s the need to bark ‘no’.
Billy can see the dilemma in your eyes, the unsureness, the fear, and maybe, just maybe, some hidden layers of longing.
But maybe he just sees what he wishes to see.
What he wants to see.
The things that are being reflected in his eyes, too.
“Billy, I-“
“I know, you won’t be breaking your rules for me. You’ve already established that previously, remember? But we don’t have to repeat any of that, you know. We can just talk, and smoke and maybe dance to Andy Gibs a bit more.”
The smile on his face is playful, almost nudging, and you can’t help but mirror it, despite the internal battle that’s still taking place within you.
If you do this, a voice warns, this will be your downfall. You’re going to get attached and then you’re going to get hurt. And where’s the fun in that, huh?
But Billy’s also the most fun you’ve ever had in the guys you’ve hooked up with, and so, throwing all your apprehensions and cautions into the windy sea, you watch them drown, hoping dearly that their ghosts and warnings won’t come back to haunt you later.
“Fuck it, why not.” You mumble, and Billy beams like the distant bar lights that are still shining strong.
“You want your usual order, then?”
Things develop from there in a rather unusual way, and with the passing weeks you start to actually consider Billy somewhat of a friend. Kind of. Almost. Unexpectedly so.
At first, you two just start to hang out more during the beachy get-togethers; sneaking away to get high and on each other’s nerves. Though Heather doesn’t quite believe you when you say you two are just talking – you don’t really blame her, you wouldn’t believe it either, if you didn’t bear witness to it every other night.
But it really is just talks.
Talks, and joints, and slushies, and lazy gazes into the night sky, and sometimes, if you’re particularly brave, prolonged ones into each other’s eyes.
But you try not to think about the meaning of those too often.
Billy’s also turned out to be quite opinionated, not that you’re surprised by that discovery; but it definitely serves as inspiration for a lot of arguments, bickering, and disbelieving gasps when the other person says something particularly offensive.
Like when you told Billy that the best Queen album is obviously A Day at the Races, and he audibly scoffed, because how dare you? The only right and acceptable answer is News of the World, and you’d have to be musically on the level of a jellyfish to think differently.
“God, you’re so lucky you’re pretty and fun, otherwise I would most certainly revalue our friendship right now.” Billy had said in that moment, before passing the joint back to you, just as you watched him exhale the smoke into the starry night.
You tried really hard not to think about that night when you were on the receiving end of that smoke, inhaling it instead of the fresh august air.
But Billy keeps true to his promise to not try any ‘funny business’, and you haven’t fucked since that one night almost a month ago.
There’re still men you hook up with, of course. After all, that kind of an itch doesn’t just go away, but it’s a little less frequent now, since on most bonfire nights you seek out Billy’s company instead.
It’s weird, because you haven’t been this close to another person; haven’t felt this close to another person, in a long time. In forever maybe.
But you try not to think about that either; brushing it all away like Heather’s worried glances when she watches you two vanish from the crowds, to go somewhere more ‘private’.
It’s none of her business anyways, you tell yourself, and all of her repeated warnings just continue to fall on deaf ears.
It’s not like you don’t appreciate Heather, or the friendship you two share, but you do think she’s got it all wrong when it comes to Billy.
Because Billy is, as far as you’re concerned, none of the things she kept warning you about. During your weeks on the beach, you’ve never seen him get angry or violent.
Heated maybe, sometimes, but never terrifyingly so. And at this point you wonder if you and Heather are even talking about the same guy at all, really.
But you get your first glimpses of what she might have been talking about a few weeks later at some guys house party.
You’d arrived there in your usual late fashion, and initially you didn’t even think Billy would show up, because those kind of parties aren’t quite his scene. There’s new wave music being blasted from some rather expensive stereo, and that alone would be a reason for Billy to turn around and leave again quickly, huffing and puffing complains about the beyond questionable music choices.
You would know. You’ve witnessed it by now at least a couple of times. After all, trying to get Billy to stay at a small house party while Adam and the Ants was playing in the background turned out to be quite the challenge just a few days ago.
So, you didn’t think he would show up to this party either. Or if he did he would have left again immediately, especially with the way that this currently is the third Spandau Ballet song that’s rumbling through the speakers.
It’s To Cut a Long Story Short, and you’ve been looking for Heather ever since it started, cause it’s normally a tune you both quite enjoy dancing to.
There are some loud voices coming from the kitchen, and knowing Heather, you instinctively move towards the apparent commotion.
She’s the life of the party in both, the best and the worst ways, but instead of your best friend you find something completely different in the kitchen.
It’s a fight.
It’s a fight, and it must have just started recently because there’s hardly anyone rushing in to break it apart yet.
There’s too many people around for you to see who it is, or what it’s about, but you can certainly hear the grunting, and the punches, and the way a low growl of a familiar voice drawls, “You wanna say that again, fucker?! Come on, say it again!” The silence that follows is deafening and the rough voice huffs, “That’s what I thought you little bitch!”
And it takes a second to hit you fully, but when it does, it hits you hard, almost as hard as the last punch that had the crowd murmuring little surprised ohh‘s and ahh‘s.
It’s Billy.
Your assumption turned realization only solidifies when people start whispering once they notice your presence, and you feel like they’re in on something that you’re not.
But you don’t let that deter you as you try to push past all the people to get to the man your heart keeps worrying about with every added harsh sound, and the rustling of clothes as two shapes wrestle on the kitchen floor.
“Alright, alright, that’s enough.” Somebody finally says it.
It’s a tall dude with glasses who’s stepping out of the crowd, but neither Billy nor the other guy seem to care.
Still, that man’s words are enough for other people to try stepping in too, halfhearted hands gripping Billy to get him off the guy he’s been towering over, raining punches down repeatedly.
But as soon as he’s up, and the other guy is also semi-stable on his feet, there’s a bloody grin spreading across the stranger’s face before spitting, “Looks like your whore even came to your rescue.”
The nod in your direction is unmistakable, and Billy’s eyes flicker over to you only briefly before he’s pouncing on the guy again, and this time the sound of the heavy punch that follows rings in your ears for a lot longer.
They’re back on the floor again quickly but not without the sound of glass breaking and you shiver, panic bubbling up inside of you.
“Don’t. Fucking. Call. Her. That.”
The words are each accentuated with the sound of unmistakable hits, and now people are more desperate to break the two apart.
There end up being three guys that have to restrain Billy, and two guys who try to keep the other culprit both in line and somewhat steady on his feet.
Yet it’s hardly working, as Billy keeps struggling, trying to jump the other man again, and you can see how the guys holding him back are quite literally at their limit.
You finally manage to squeeze past the last few people in front of you, making your way up to Billy. You don’t really think as you step in, moving into his eyesight and coming up before him.
You call his name repeatedly, but at first he seems like he’s so lost in his rage, that he doesn’t even register you.
It’s almost as if he’s in some kind of trance, chest heaving with quick breaths, and his eyes still blazing daggers at the guy who looks a lot worse for wear. It’s not like Billy got out of the fight unharmed though, his knuckles are bloody and split, you can’t help but notice with a frown, and there’s a deep cut on one of his cheekbones that looks more than a little painful.
His lips are also bleeding and there are bruises already forming around his temple too.
Still, he looks a lot better than the other guy, who can barely keep himself upright at this point.
“Billy.” Your voice is as soft as the apprehensive touch of your fingers that come to rest on the upper part of his chest.
You can feel his thundering heart underneath your fingertips, rumbling away beneath his warm skin.
“Billy, stop.” You whisper, voice gentle, but the urgency in your eyes is hard to miss.
You instinctively cup his cheeks, mindful of the cuts and bruises, but you need him to look at you – need him to come back to you from whatever plane he’s still on.
You’re not sure if it’s your voice or the careful touch that makes him break free from whatever spell he’s been under. But when he finally does, the sigh of relief that leaves your heart is almost audible, as his eyes trail back to yours.
“Hey, Cinderella.” His voice is low and rough, and you wince at both, the way the cut on his lip moves with each word, and how he’s very clearly intoxicated, breath stained with the smell of alcohol and weed.
“Billy,” your voice is deflated, almost disappointed, and it wipes the growing smirk right off his face.
He looks almost a little hurt, like he didn’t expect your reaction to be that.
“You’re mad at me?” He mumbles, voice toying between a question and a statement.
“Let’s just get out of here.” You offer, ignoring his previous words, and taking one of his hands instead, fingers intertwining, before tugging on it gently.
“Okay?” You question, eyes searching Billy’s for an answer.
Billy huffs while puffing out his chest, but he’s calmed down enough now to follow you without much fuss as you make a beeline for one of the bathrooms.
Once you two arrive at your destination, you’re quick to lock the door behind you, after making Billy sit down on the closed toilet seat.
With your back turned, and a little space between you, you take a shaky breath to steady yourself, the emotions inside of you still running wild, before turning around, heat simmering in your eyes.
“What the fuck was that about?” You bite, and Billy looks like a kicked puppy for a brief second before turning defensive.
“What?”
He can’t believe the tone of your voice after what he’s done for you, and the furious look in your eyes has him sobering up quite a bit.
“You heard me just right, Hargrove.”
Looking at him expectantly, you wait for an answer, your left foot tapping irregular beats on the white bathroom tiles impatiently.
“Well, what do you want me to say?” Billy huffs, “he fucking deserved it, and I’m not going to apologize for something I actually still stand behind!”
“I’m not asking you to apologize, I’m asking you to explain it to me.” You shoot back, and Billy crosses his arms, anger rising in his eyes now as well.
How dare you make him the culprit of the night, like he’s the bad guy and not the man who-
“You weren’t there.” Billy defends himself, his heated gaze turning towards his bloody knuckles. “He said some really nasty shit about you, and I was not about to let him get away with that, alright?”
“What kind of shit?” You question, and Billy’s eyes turn somewhat softer when they take in your form again.
“Don’t make me repeat the things he said, Cinderella,” he whispers, “but it was completely uncalled for, called you a slut and every degrading thing under the sun he could fucking think of.”
You sigh, because this is nothing new to you, but apparently the same can’t be said for Billy.
“Billy,” you mumble, voice gentler now and tinted with some understanding, “guys call me that all the time, okay?”
“What, and you just let them?”
“Well, it’s not like I’m there to witness it most of the time, and it’s not like they’re entirely wrong either. I’m not exactly known to be the personification of virgin Mary, now am I?”
“Yeah, well, maybe not, but that still doesn’t give that shithead the right to be judgmental about it! Who is he to question the choices you make anyway? And what was I supposed to do, just listen and laugh?”
There’s a quietness taking over the room for the first time tonight, except for the loud music that’s still booming through the apartment, drifting into the space between you.
“I care about you, alright. And I’m not going to let him walk all over you, even if it’s just with some fucking words. You’re my friend, so, sorry for giving a shit.”
Billy tries to sound angry and annoyed, but there’s mostly hurt swimming in his eyes when he gazes back up at you, and something inside of you shifts.
“Billy,” you whisper, because the growing realization that he might have actually done this for you, rather than himself, settles in your mind slowly.
“You actually picked this fight for me?” Your voice is so hushed, it might as well be nothing but hot air leaving your mouth right now.
“Well, who else would I pick a fucking fight for?”
“I thought,” you mumble, feet shuffling nervously on white tiles, “I thought you just picked the fight for your ego.”
“What?”
“Well, you know. The guy probably said something about how you’re seemingly with me, a slut, and the implication of what exactly that says about you is what drove you over the edge.”
“Wait, you think I got my knuckles bloody because some prick thinks I might be settling for 'damaged goods'? Is that why you’re so angry? You think I broke that guy’s nose over some stupid ego shit?”
“I’m sure you broke a guys nose for less before.”
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
“Nothing.”
“Huh, doesn’t sound like nothing to me. If you have something to say just say it.”
Billy’s voice drops dangerously low before huffing, “Come on, you weren’t that quiet when I fucked you stupid, so don’t go all docile on me now.”
“I’m not.”
“Right.”
“Right, and fuck you.”
“Oh, Getting the big guns out now, are we?”
“Fuck off Billy, I’m not gonna pick a fight with you.”
“Weird, could have fooled me.”
You two are standing awfully close by now, with Billy having jumped up from his seat a while ago, eyes angry, and chest heaving.
“You can’t blame me for thinking this is just the usual shit.”
“What usual shit?”
There’s a heavy sigh that’s leaving your lips, but instead of an answer your hands come up to Billy’s shoulders again, pushing him back towards the toilet seat.
“I don’t want to have this discussion right now. It doesn’t matter anyway. What’s done is done. Just don’t pick a fight like that again, okay? It’s not worth it, getting hurt like this.”
It’s not worth it getting hurt for me, you think.
But Billy huffs, far from ready to let this go yet, but admitting defeat once he sees the tired look in your eyes.
As he’s settled down again, you quickly go through the bathroom cabins, searching for something.
“Watcha looking for?” Billy’s voice seems less on edge now, his curiosity getting the better of him.
“A fucking first aid kit, most responsible adults have something akin to that in their bathroom or kitchen space.”
“I don’t.”
“Well, what do you want me to say to that, Billy?”
There’s the hint smile playing on your lips as Billy huffs with fake offense, and when you look back at your friend he’s mirroring your little smile, blue eyes bright and fixed on you with a steadiness that makes your heart sway.
Shaking your head to get the lingering thoughts and feelings out, you try to focus back on the task at hand, until you finally find what you’ve been looking for all along.
“Ha! Got it! I fucking new it; see!”
You hold up the little box proudly, and Billy can’t help but think that you look utterly adorable while doing so.
“You gonna nurse me back to health, yeah?”
“You rather want to get this shit infected, Hargrove?”
Billy just mumbles a quiet, “It’s not that bad.” But he still makes space for you to stand in between his legs while you put down the box carefully on the bathroom sink beside you.
And as your eyes come back to rest on Billy, taking in the toll of his injuries, the unpleasant feeling of guilt keeps rising in your chest, manifesting as an ugly lump in your throat.
He got hurt because of you, you think, and you can’t help but feel like this is all your fault.
It’s not surprising that people talk, not when it’s so out of character for you to hang out with a guy more than once; and you’re sure something similar can be said for Billy, too. So, of course, people get ideas, convinced that they know exactly what’s going on.
However, you don’t really care, and you foolishly assumed that Billy wouldn’t either, but apparently he does care; even if it’s just a little bit.
“Listen, I-“
You’re not sure how you should phrase the next words that threaten to tumble out of your mouth, without admitting that you also care quite a bit about Billy.
Without admitting that you were scared for his safety just minutes ago.
“I, uh, appreciate what you did, Billy, but please don’t do something like this again, okay? I don’t want to see you get hurt.”
Your voice is mumbled, almost as if your words are stumbling over each other, because each one wants to move past your lips first and all at once.
Your hand brushes against his cheeks softly, before tilting his head up, so you can look at him better.
“I care about you too, Billy. And there are things worth getting hurt over but some guy calling me a slut isn’t one of them, I promise.”
His blue eyes keep softening with each admission, and both of his hands come up to your hips carefully, if to steady you or himself, you don’t know; but the gentle caress of his thumb over the smooth, silky dress you’re currently wearing does have a comforting notion, even if it’s a slightly foreign one.
“I wasn’t really thinking,” Billy whispers, “but I didn’t mean to scare you. I was just trying to look out for you. And I don’t wanna promise you that this will never happen again because…”
Billy doesn’t finish the sentence; he doesn’t have to; you already know what he’s implying.
He can’t promise you no more physical fights without the fear of breaking it again.
Can’t promise it because he’s just as reactionary as you, and anger is a default setting that’s hard to curb and even harder to swallow down.
“It’s enough for me Billy if you just try. Try not to pick those fights again for me, okay?”
“Got it, Cinderella.” Billy teases, voice a little lighter, and the smile you two exchange has your heart fluttering in your chest rapidly.
Traitor.
As you pick out the necessary tools to mend Billy’s cuts and bruises, the guy in question watches you with emotions unsaid swirling around in his chest. His heart like thunder, illuminated up by the mere sight of you like lightning in a darkened sky.
He wants to pull you into his lap and kiss the worried frown right off your face, but he knows he can’t; knows he shouldn’t. Yet it doesn’t make the longing reaching out in his chest any less intense.
“Okay, this is going to sting, I’m afraid.“
Your voice calls Billy back to the current moment, and his head spins from the mere compassion swimming in your eyes, as they come to rest on his injuries again.
“‘S Alright,” he mumbles, unsure of where to look or how to feel.
You dab the small cloth soaked in disinfectant on the smaller cuts first, and Billy tries not to notice how out of character this feels for him. How foreign it feels to have someone take care of him like that, tending to his wounds with such utterly gentle touches and hushed little soothing whispers.
He’s also not used to being witnessed like this - not after his father’s beatings and not after the physical fights he would get himself into as a way to cope; to feel something or nothing at all.
Sometimes, once in a blue moon, his little sister Max would give him a helping hand, when his fingers wouldn’t stop shaking and the cuts wouldn’t stop bleeding and the mess in the bathroom was too much to take care of all by himself.
But even then there were walls build up, tall and strong, between him and the little redhead. Walls that no sibling bond could ever break through, or at least not the dysfunctional sibling bond they were cursed with.
And Billy hated to be witnessed like that - a broken and bloody and teary-eyed mess. Vulnerable, and raw, and everything he didn’t want his little sister to see him as.
Yet even in those situations he craved the comfort, the help, the signs, and the illusions of somebody caring enough to take care of him.
And he always hated himself the most for that.
But now, he’s finds himself here with you in some stranger’s bathroom, as you clean his wounds with a tenderness that has Billy feeling beyond choked up.
There’s a lump the size of the earth stuck in his throat as he tries not to drown in the overwhelming feelings of it all.
As he tries hard to fight the tears back that threaten to spill with every added crumb of gentleness that you grant him, completely clueless to its significance, or the way it makes his head and heart turn around themselves.
But like usually, the fight against his tears is the hardest fight of all; one he just can’t seem to win, try as he might.
Unfortunately, you notice his watery eyes immediately, and it makes you halt in your movements for the briefest of moments.
“I know, I know,” you whisper soothingly, “this cut must sting a lot, but I’m almost done here, Billy.”
And that’s it, something inside Billy breaks, and he tries shutting his eyes quick and tightly as not to let anything slip out; not a tear and not a shard of vulnerability - but it’s too late.
He’s crying again.
“Oh, Billy, no.”
The worry in your voice only makes Billy cry harder as he shakes his head vigorously, trying to get you to back off.
“What’s wrong, Billy?”
Your hand coming up to his cheek is soft and careful, as you try to get him to look at you fully.
His eyes are still pressed closely together, but that doesn’t stop the tears from running down his freckled cheeks.
At first you think that he’s more hurt than he initially led on - at least physically speaking, but when you ask him about it he just shakes his head once more.
“’m fine,” he mumbles, “‘s just a lot.”
You, on the other hand, are unsure of what he’s talking about, or what you should be doing now exactly. You don’t want to overstep any boundaries, but you also want to help him, in any way you can.
You doubt however, that if you’d ask him about what he needs, he’d give you an honest answer. So, you do the only sensible thing you can think of; hugging him closely.
At first, Billy goes completely stiff as you curl up on his lap unceremoniously, before guiding his face into the crook of your neck, words hushed, and soothing.
You keep holding him, promising him to not let go, and at one point Billy’s arms come around you tightly, too, clinging to you like a lost and exhausted swimmer might cling to a lifeline.
“Shh, Billy, it’s alright. It’s alright, you can cry it out, I’ve got you. I’ve got you.”
Your understanding words only make him cry harder, but you assume that this is just what he needs right now; or at least you hope it is.
One of your hands keeps playing with the curls on the back of his neck, fingers tracing patterns on the sliver of skin that’s exposed between his hair and the collar of his shirt.
You can still feel his shoulders shake; hear his muffled sniffles and sobs that break through the otherwise quietness of the bathroom space.
You’re not sure how much time has passed when his crying starts quieting down, and the first words that leave Billy’s lips are an embarrassed, “I’m sorry,” which you shoot down immediately.
“You have nothing to apologize for,” you whisper against the shell of his ear, and you almost think you can feel Billy shiver.
“You’ve seen me cry, I’ve seen you cry, guess we’re even now, Billy.”
There’s a choked laugh coming from the man in question, before he mumbles, “Guess we’re both a little fucked up, huh?”
“I don’t think that there’s anything fucked up about you crying, Billy.”
“You would if you knew why.”
“You wanna talk about it then?”
But Billy just shakes his head, fluffy curls tickling the side of your face, as he’s still hiding away in the nape of your neck.
“I’d rather not.”
“Do you still want me to treat the rest of your cuts and bruises?”
The little nod that follows is only faint, but since it’s directly against your skin, you manage to pick it up easily.
“Just one more minute, okay?”
His voice sounds timid when the question falls from his lips, and all you can do is pull him even closer, before giving him a little nod of your own.
“Of course. We can stay like this as long as you need.”
That’s impossible, Billy thinks, because there’s no way you’d let him stay in your arms for eternity - but he likes the idea, the illusion, that you might care enough about him to take care of him like that.
After the events of the party, there’s something between you two that shifted; something that made you two grow even closer and tighter.
Maybe it really is the fact that you’ve both witnessed the other breaking down and crying; maybe it’s the vulnerability of it all or something else entirely.
Either way, the two of you are almost completely inseparable at any outing now, and you even start hanging out outside of parties and beach gatherings.
Billy takes you out to eat every Friday night, and you start bringing him breakfast at least two times a week to his early morning lifeguard shifts, when the sun is only slowly starting to break through the veil of the night.
You two usually sit there next to each other, on the old, wooden steps of the tiny lifeguard house, sharing smokes and donuts and little memories while the sun rises up.
The part-time job you’ve recently started at a local diner certainly helps with keeping the breakfast choices somewhat diverse, and the way Billy’s eyes light up each time makes it even more worth it.
There’s still the occasional party, still the occasional fight that Billy finds himself in the middle of, but just like your hook-ups, they become rarer with the passing of time.
There’s a slow rhythm that’s being established between you, but you both try hard not to notice, let alone acknowledge it.
And while the growing closeness feels foreign and a little intimidating, you’d be lying if you said that you hadn’t become a little addicted to it, too.
Because this closeness with Billy is a closeness you’ve never shared with anyone before. But as of recently, you’ve been getting the growing feeling that this isn’t enough; that you need more than that. That you want more than that.
And it’s getting harder and harder to mask the quick beating of your heart around him, or the longing gazes, or the urges to kiss him again; pulling him closer and never letting go.
“We’re just friends,” you keep telling Heather, whenever she calls you out on this thing you share with Billy, but the words start tasting more and more cruel in your mouth.
There’s a bitterness to it that no amount of weed, or drinks or sex can cover.
At first, you think that this storm brewing inside of you is something nobody else would notice. After all, telling lies isn’t a foreign language to you, but during one particular late summer night, Billy surprisingly calls you out on it.
You two have been browsing the isles of the tiny supermarket right by the shore for a while now, looking for some midnight snacks to bring down to the beach.
It’s almost an unspoken tradition at this point, to let the weekends fade out with some smokes and snacks while lying in the warm sand cuddled next to each other.
Billy wrapping his arm around your side is what pulls you out of your thoughts again. You’ve been staring at some strawberry-shaped gummy bears for the last few minutes, though, even you yourself are unsure as to why.
“What’s going on, Cinderella? You’re not normally one to struggle with making decisions.” You know Billy’s just teasing but the smile on your face still feels forced, uncomfortably so.
“Just thinking.” You dismiss Billy’s worried gaze, fingers brushing against the gummy bear package before changing your mind again and letting it go.
“If you want them, I can get them for you; my treat.” Billy jokes, but your hardly smiling.
“No, no it’s fine. I’ll just take the usual.”
“You sure?”
The answer you throw his way gets lost in the distance between you two, as you simply walk up to the cashier; but then again, Billy thinks, maybe you didn’t say anything at all, your action speaking for itself instead.
He can’t help but notice how your behavior has been a little off for most of the night, yet he doesn’t really know why. He hasn’t been in any fights for the last few days, so there’s no reason for you to be mad at him.
Besides, you’re not one to hold grudges. Instead, you tend to tell him when you’re upset right in the moment, rather than letting the anger simmer.
It’s an upside to being a bit more reactionary, he supposes.
Still, worry bubbles up inside of him, because even the mere thought of you pulling away, or worse, leaving him for good absolutely terrifies him.
He isn’t even in a position to call you his right now, but the lack of your company would at the very least leave a hole the size of the sun in his heart; he’s sure of that.
Billy’s convinced that he needs to talk to you, so, of course, he’s going to grab a few more beers from the fridge, assuming that he’ll need them, either before you talk or afterwards.
He’s about to join you at the counter, when something inside of him pauses, and without really thinking, he grabs a pack of the strawberry gummies you’ve been staring at earlier.
He’s unsure as to why, but what harm is there in getting one more snack?
When the two of you walk side by side to the beach, Billy watches you carefully. Even in the harsh light of the streetlamps, you look ethereal, he thinks.
You’re still laughing at his jokes, but there’s something in your eyes that feels distant. Like your miles away, and Billy doesn’t know how to follow you there, or how to bring you back to him again.
For the rest of the walk, he tries to think of a way to ask you if you’re alright, without you getting defensive. But he can’t think of anything that wouldn’t trigger your fight-or-flight response.
And he knows first-hand just how strong your flight response can be.
So, no thank you to that.
You, however, feel like you’re on fire, and Billy’s company is nothing but gasoline to your blazing longing.
A longing you have to hide, to dismiss, to never acknowledge in the slightest.
And it’s been getting harder and harder on a regular day, and almost beyond impossible on those days were he’s right there with you, like he is right now.
There’s an awkwardness settling in between you two, as you continue to walk through the sand to your regular hang out spot.
That is, until Billy’s voice suddenly breaks through the quietness of the night, disturbing the stillness taking shape all around you and the gentle whispers of the ocean.
“First one in the waves wins!”
You hear him drop his backpack and jacket into the sand more than you see it, and for a small second you’re entrenched as you watch him run up to the ocean, before mirroring his actions, letting go of your little purse and running right after him.
The water is a bit cooler than you expected it to be, but it’s still a welcomed distraction to the incurable heat you feel whenever Billy’s near.
Once you find yourself back by his side, he’s quick to wrap his arms around you, as he spins you around playfully. And for the first time tonight, the laughter bubbling out of you is nothing but earnest, and Billy feels his heart sigh in relief at the mere sound of it.
You might not tell him what’s wrong, but maybe he can at the very least distract you from whatever it is for a small while. Maybe that will make you stay at least a little longer.
And as you two continue to play fight, tackling and dunking each other in between the soft waves, you feel yourself come back to the moment without the fear of secret feelings getting discovered.
Without feeling like to have to keep up a mask around Billy, just to be safe.
By the time you two decide to leave the dark water behind again, you’re both still laughing, both still riding that high of each other’s company, both still lost in the secret longing for the other.
You don’t even really think about the fact that you’re stripping yourself of your clothing in front of Billy, as you shimmy out of your wet dress quickly, and Billy is about to mirror your action, when something inside of him freezes, his hands toying with the hem of his t-shirt.
“What, you’re gonna stay like this?” You gently tease, once you notice that he’s still wearing both - his dripping wet swimming shorts and his shirt, while you’re clad in nothing but your underwear.
Keeping the swimming shorts on, you can understand, but the shirt? Not so much.
But Billy doesn’t meet your eyes when you call him out on it, and if you didn’t know any better, you’d say that he almost looks shy all of the sudden. But Billy and shy are two words on opposite ends that hardly fit together.
“You wanna get pneumonia that bad, huh?”
“Fuck off, I’ll be fine!”
Billy doesn’t say anything more as he lies down, eyes drifting to the seemingly endless September night sky.
For a while, neither one of you says anything. The rumble of the waves with its unspoken secrets is the only sound filling the space between you two.
Time passes, but you can’t say how much, the endless lullaby of the ocean a bad indicator of time passed, and time left.
At some point, Billy’s nursing a beer again, while you’re nursing a joint, and when you offer your rolled-up little friend to Billy, he almost offers you his beer in return, before he remembers that you don’t drink, like at all, and a particular question comes up for air in his mind.
It’s a question that’s been swirling around in Billy’s mouth, like his tongue in yours when you two first shared kisses.
Kisses he keeps dreaming about both day and night, but that’s not the point.
The point is that he still doesn’t know why you refuse to even glance at the alcoholic drinks that usually get passed around at bars and parties, let alone drink any of them.
And there’s something in Billy that feels a little daring tonight.
Maybe it’s because he’s starting to feel lightheaded; if from your company or the drugs and the beers kicking in, he’s not sure.
Nevertheless, the question decides to drop from his lips, almost accidentally.
“Why don’t you ever drink, like, alcoholic stuff?”
The turn of your head towards him is so incredibly fast, it’s giving yourself a bit of a whiplash.
Part of you is ready to bark at him that that’s none of his goddamn business. That he should just mind his own, and leave you to your own devices.
But Billy’s question isn’t stained with judgement, the way those questions usually are, but with a sense of curiosity that is so very much Billy.
“If I tell you why I don’t drink, will you tell me why you’d rather risk a fucking lung infection than be caught with your shirt of?”
Now it’s Billy’s turn to get defensive, as he mumbles, “Fuck, no. Jesus, I was just asking a question.”
“So was I, Billy.”
“Yeah, well, but this is none of your goddamn business.”
“Wait, but wanting to know why I don’t drink somehow is?”
You kind of have a point, Billy quietly admits to himself. Still, asking you to open up feels a lot more justified than asking him to do the same in return.
There really must be something in the air tonight, though, because Billy’s seriously considering the trade.
“Fine,” he finally mumbles, “but I swear to god, if your answer is only a ‘I simply don’t like the taste of alcohol, Billy’ I’m not saying a single syllable for the rest of the night, and I’m keeping the gummy bears I bought for you.”
The soft laugh that falls from your lips has him feeling a little more at ease, and he watches you with attentive eyes before something inside of you shifts and you take in a deep breath, almost as if to steady yourself or the words that you’re about to say.
“Alright, sounds like a deal, I guess.”
As you take another breath, you can’t help but notice that you’re not as scared as you thought you’d be, and maybe there’s something about this night that makes you a little more daring too, a little more vulnerable, a little less on edge, as you find yourself mumbling into the midnight blue of the universe, “My dad.”
The admission is hushed, and it’s quiet, and it’s dripping with shame. Your voice feels rusty and unfamiliar even to your own ears, like you haven’t used it in centuries, and in some odd way you haven’t.
Not when it comes to your dad, at least.
You watch Billy as he takes your words in, eyebrows furrowed slightly, and you realize that maybe your words weren’t as self-explanatory as you’d hoped.
As they are to you.
“He’s uh- he just used to drink a lot; you know?”
There’s a clarity in Billy’s eyes as they wander over to you, or maybe the joint is really hitting in, and you’re imagining things.
Maybe you just want there to be clarity.
Maybe you just want him to understand.
“You mean, he’s an alcoholic?”
There’s a tenderness in Billy’s voice that feels foreign again. It makes you feel something, but you can’t quite say if it’s positive or negative. You decide that it just is, for now; some weird feeling deep within you.
Brushing that aside, you decide to answer his question with a quickly mumbled, “Yeah, I guess.”
“Has he, uh- has he ever … hurt you?”
There’s an apprehensiveness in Billy’s voice now too, mirroring yours closely.
“Not like, physically,“ you whisper after a brief pause, “but emotionally, yes. My whole childhood was a living hell, trying to tip-toe around a volcano that could explode at any moment. Feels like I was trying my whole live to not get burned by the fire he’d spit.”
There’s a silence filling the space between you two, until you mumble, “Don’t know if that made any sense at all but-“
“Yeah, no, no, it does.” Billy whispers, voice the most timid you’ve ever heard it.
“Yeah, I think that does make sense.”
The relieve that washes over you in shouldn’t feel like a fucking 7 feet tall wave, yet it does anyway.
“Guess my father was the same, kind of. Only difference being that he didn’t need the alcohol for that, and he would… well, you know.”
“He’d hurt you?”
Billy only manages a faint nod since he doesn’t trust his voice from breaking and failing.
There’s vulnerability and understanding swimming in both of your eyes as you look back at the other, until Billy averts his gaze, opting for staring at the stars instead when he mumbles, “There are scars littered all over my body.”
“From your dad?”
There’s another quick nod, before he states, “That and a kind of… accident.”
You instinctively take his hand into yours. It’s a small gesture, but you still want him to know you’re there.
“There was this …mall fire, I got caught up in. And now my body looks like a fucking battle ground with no goddamn survivors.”
“But you survived, Billy.”
There’s a bitter laugh coming from the guy next to you.
“I don’t know, did I?”
“Well, you’ve got to, otherwise you wouldn’t be here with me now.”
“Yeah, but for how much longer? How much longer will you stick around before you’ll leave again too. It’s not like you didn’t once already.”
You know Billy doesn’t mean to hurt your feelings, but his words still feel like a slap in the face.
“That was something different entirely.”
“Was it? Because all I remember is you leaving.”
“But I’m here now, Billy. I’m here now, and I’m not going anywhere again.”
“Funny, that’s what my mother used to say too.”
“What?”
You're caught off guard by his admission, and there’s the brief memory of a pause before he whispers, “You know, I initially came back to California to look for someone.”
“Someone or something?” You quietly question, because Billy’s voice has been so mumbled, you didn’t quite catch the last word.
“Both, I suppose, if home is a thing.”
“And have you found it yet?”
“I don’t know. Sometimes I think that I’ve almost got it, but then again-“
Billy doesn’t know why he’s telling you all of this. But now that he’s started, he doesn’t know how to stop either.
“She left me all alone with my dad when I was still a kid, but she would occasionally pop up again, just to break her empty promises over and over again. But it was okay, because at least she was still there, you know?”
“Oh, Billy.”
You scoot closer to the teary-eyed man, who looks more like a child right now, as he stares stubbornly into the night sky, lips and fingers unsteady and shaky.
You decide to unceremoniously roll on top of him, hugging him closely while doing so.
You don’t say anything; don’t think that there are any words deep enough to express your sorrow or how your heart aches at the thought of kid-Billy being failed by both of his parents. And how that failure still haunts him now; shaped him into existence.
You would know, it’s not like your story is much different.
There’s a reason why you crave male validation like a starved cat might crave some milk.
There’s a reason why seeing women out in public wearing your mom’s hairstyle still makes you feel uneasy.
There’s a reason why opening up feels like knives cutting something deep underneath your skin, and you were never taught how to deal with the rawness of it all.
How to handle vulnerability or love or being taken care of; because nobody ever did or showed you how.
But now, for the first time, you’re not the only one carrying that kind of a curse, because here’s Billy, with the same scars as yours etched into his heart.
Or at least their shapes look awfully familiar.
And for the next few hours you to share memories, thoughts, and feelings you’ve never shared with anyone before.
You talk about the misplaced anger of your fathers, and the inactions of your mothers, and your siblings, and the curses of being the oldest one.
The scapegoat.
The test-run they were allowed to fuck up, because they could just try to make it right the second or third time around instead.
And you talk, until Billy’s shirt has completely dried down and the sun’s slowly rising up, and sleep is only a heartbeat away.
Billy’s heartbeat, to be exact, which also turns out to be the most soothing lullaby you’ve ever listened to, as you curl up closer to the boy you share so many different memories with.
Because what had previously been an unspoken understanding of a distant similarity in both of your characters has turned into so much more.
You’re one and the same in some fucked up yet comforting way.
And you’ve never felt more at peace.
Never felt more at home.
And suddenly, you realize that the stains of the past tainting your present don’t look quite as fatal when you see Billy wear them too.
Unfortunately, Tumblr won't let me post all of the story at once, since it'd be too many paragraphs in one post 😅.
Read the rest of the story here.
279 notes
·
View notes