“All The Echoes In My Mind Cry, There’s Blood On Your Lies” - Cordelia Goode x Reader x Wilhemina Venable
Prompt: 11 - Angst Prompt List - “Don’t cry. Everything’s going to be okay” + 12 - Angst Prompt List - “Who did this? Who hurt you?”
Words: ~12,000
Warnings: Sexual assault and a LOT of overthinking. Listen, I took this angst prompt seriously. You’ve been warned.
Requested by: @darling-dontforgetme
You thumbed through your notifications, rolling your eyes.
It was just one picture. One tiny picture with one tiny caption, and it honestly shouldn’t have blown up the way it did.
Since you had checked your phone about six minutes ago, there were twenty-five new comments. Of those twenty-five, two of them were positive. One from a childhood friend, congratulating you on being so happy, and one from Madison, Madison of all people, saying a short “congrats or whatever” and commenting on Cordelia’s shirt not matching her pants.
The rest were all relatively the same, some version of “ew” or “disgusting” or “blocked.”
Your phone vibrated and you swiped to your messages. And you rolled your eyes again because Madison was being as impatient as always.
This place blows, where are you?
Almost there, two blocks away.
I’m going to kill Foxxy for making you walk me home.
Want to meet me out front?
No, let me at least finish my fucking drink.
And as another comment on your picture dinged, she texted you again.
Bouncer was easy, you should be able to walk right by him the way he caved under my spell
You typed back a quick okay and flicked back to the comments on your picture. This one was from your cousin.
Who’s the redhead with her tongue down your throat? Why have I never met her? ;)
You rolled your eyes, dread running through you because you knew he meant it in the absolute wrong way. But just as you were about to respond with something that was probably too possessive, someone rammed into you from behind.
You had stopped in the middle of the sidewalk. Not the best option on a Saturday night in New Orleans. You gave a soft apology and the man grumbled as he shuffled past you and into the crowd just ahead.
And then you pocketed your phone, comment abandoned as you zeroed in on the club across the street and made your way over.
Madison was right, the bouncer was easy. The crowds lined up and waiting to get in were not. There were too many people to push through just to get inside, and you were breathless by the time you reached the entrance.
Lord, you hated this city sometimes.
You slid past the bouncer without a second glance, shouldering the door open and wincing at the loud bass that thrummed through your skin.
It was a huge club, and honestly you didn’t know how it fit into this cramped little city. But here it was, filled to the brim with glitter and cocktails and pulsing bodies. The beat pounded at the back of your neck and you could already feel a headache coming on, so you flicked your messages opened and started making your way to what could only be the VIP lounge.
And of course, it was all the way across the dance floor.
Shit.
You did your best to push through the crowd of bodies, sticking to the outskirts of the dance mob and trying to keep your eyes pinned on the steps leading up to the roped off section of the club. But no sooner had you made it past the bar, caught a glimpse of Madison and texted her to tell her that you were there, then a hand wrapped around your arm and hauled you to your right.
You tripped over yourself, dropping your phone, and by the time you caught your footing you were halfway down a dark hallway, a red light illuminating couples writhing against each other on the walls.
“What the—“ you tried, ripping at the hand on your arm and yanking away. But you had barely gotten your hand around the fingers bruising into your skin when you heard a rough, “Calm down, it’s just me.”
And everything inside of you shot ice cold.
You looked up, terror freezing your attempts to get away.
“J-James?” you stuttered out as he spun you and slammed you up against a free space on the wall.
And he was over you in a second, mouth hot in your ear.
“James, get off of me,” you tried weakly, pushing at him. Shoving at him. But he was so heavy.
“Did you miss me, baby?” he growled, and his breath was hot and sticky and smelled of tar.
“Let me go,” you tried again as you scratched at his shoulders. “Let me go.”
His hand found your arm again and he slammed you back against the wall, hard enough that your head snapped back and the crack rang through your skull.
“S-Stop,” you said as forcefully as you could, stars blurring your vision. “Stop it James, what the fuck are you doing?”
“I know you missed me, honey,” he whispered in your ear, and you could feel his sickening smirk against your skin. “Come on. Let me make you feel good. Like I used to. What are the odds that we both show up here on the same night?”
You screamed, shoving at his shoulders harder and harder until your breaths pulled uneven and ragged. “Get off.”
“You know you want this.” And now his voice was snaking into your ears, hot and low and venomous. But you had lost track of his head, of his mouth. It was dark and the lights were flashing and your head was still spinning from the impact on the wall.
You felt his mouth ghost over your neck and you growled, kicking at his shins.
“Get off of me, James. I’m not yours anymore. I don’t belong to you. I don’t want this.”
And then the tears came, flooding what was left of your broken vision as your voice cracked and his hands slid up your waist.
“Oh, I know,” he murmured, and his mouth was back by your ear. “I saw your little post. Got yourself two girlfriends, hm? Maybe you should call them? Ask if they want to join us. The tall one seems a little stiff, but I’m sure I could loosen her up.”
There it was. The last straw. And as he slammed his mouth against yours, hot and wet and bitter, you shoved as hard as you could, pushing him off of you and smacking him straight across the face.
“Enough!” you screamed.
His hand came down across your cheek before you could blink, and you hadn’t realized he was holding a drink until he hit you square in the stomach, made you fly back against the wall, and his hand came down across your face again, glass breaking as his drink collided with you skull.
You crumpled, a shriek ripped from you, and cowered against the wall.
Small. Shaking. And helpless.
There were at least twenty people down this hallway, and none of them were doing anything. None of them heard you screaming for help. None of them cared.
You were trapped.
James’s foot came up, and you barely had time to register it slamming into your side before the breath was knocked out of you again.
“S-Stop,” you tried, and you sounded pitiful but at this point, you would beg. You would plead. You would do anything to get him away from you.
He crouched down to your level, face inches from yours. You blinked against tears and something hot dripping onto your nose.
And you gasped when his hand yanked your knees apart and slid straight between your thighs.
“This is mine,” he growled, squeezing too hard. You cried out. “And I don’t care how many women you sleep with, it will always be mine. Do you understand?”
You choked on a gasp and then his other hand was on your throat, squeezing so tightly that your vision started going black around the edges.
Instinct kicked in and you reached out blindly, hand fumbling on the ground for something, anything.
A sharp sting and you wrapped your fingers around the object, grabbed a shard from his broken glass. But before you could slam it into his skin there was a sickening choking sound and the grip on your throat loosened just enough for you to blink your vision back.
James was gagging in front of you, eyes bugging out of his head as his tongue curled back and back and back again.
His hands dropped from you to claw at his throat and his face reddened.
“What are you doing to me, you stupid bitch?” he choked out, and you pushed yourself farther against the stone wall, eyes wide as his eyes rolled back and he collapsed onto the ground.
And you almost reached out to him. Almost lost all sense and went to check that he was okay. But then Madison crouched down in front of you, eyes scouring every inch of you.
“Are you okay?” she started, pushing hair off of your forehead as she checked you over. Her hand was red when she pulled it away. “What did he do to you?”
You couldn’t find your voice, raspy whimpers the best you could manage as you shook against the adrenaline coursing through you.
She nodded like she understood you and grabbed your hands.
“Come on, let’s get you home. It’s okay, you’re safe now.”
As she pulled you out of the hallway and around the corner, pressing your phone into your hand, you glanced back behind you against your better judgement. And there he was, coughing and sputtering and lifting himself off the ground.
A piece of you broke at the fact that Madison hadn’t choked the life out of him. That he hadn’t gotten what he deserved. What you should have done, if you had remembered anything you had learned.
If you were any kind of witch at all.
~~~
You pushed your pleas at Madison as she helped you up the steps to the academy and she rolled her eyes, hands tightening as you winced and wobbled.
“I get it. Sneak you up to your room. Extra quiet. Don’t let Cordelia know.”
“And don’t tell Venable,” you finished, breathless by the time you hit the landing. “I don’t even want to think about what she would do if she found out.”
Madison paused by the door, eyes narrowing. “You’re going to have to tell them eventually,” she said softly, licking her thumb and swiping at your forehead. You had felt the scab bust when you were about a block from the house, but a tingling followed Madison’s thumb and you knew she had sealed it shut again.
“I know,” you panted softly. “But just not now. Not tonight. I can’t…”
You lost your breath, the events of the night flooding back into your mind. You shook your head, trying to find words, trying to explain, trying to ask Madison to promise you that she would let you tell them in your own time.
But before anything came out Madison nodded, wrapping her arm around your waist.
“Deep breath,” she mumbled, and then she pushed the door open.
You had barely crossed the threshold when her arm fell from your waist and you wobbled. She muttered a soft “shit”, and when you looked up your heart dropped into your stomach.
Cordelia and Wilhemina were standing at the base of the stairs, Mina mumbling something soft to Cordelia and stroking her hand. When the door slid opened they both looked up, Cordelia’s hand falling from Mina’s fingers as she locked eyes with you.
“Oh my god,” she breathed, and the blood drained from your head. The room spun, and the next thing you knew you were on the floor, Cordelia’s hands on your shoulders.
She hovered above you, hair falling from behind her ear, and she was talking to you, but as you blinked back stars all you could hear were Madison and Mina. Mina firmly asking Madison what had happened. Madison blowing her off as usual. Madison rushing up the stairs. And the tapping of Mina’s cane as she chased after her.
Cordelia’s hand on your cheek centered you.
“Oh my darling girl, what happened to you?”
You shook your head, wincing as your propped yourself up on your elbows. That blow to your side had stuck harder than you initially thought.
“Nothing happened, Delia,” you tried, throat sticky from screaming and crying and swallowing down terror. She stared at you, eyes narrowing as her thumb brushed your cheek, and you knew she wouldn’t stand for that. Knew that she deserved more than you blowing her off. So you added a soft, “I just fell” at the end. And after a moment’s hesitation, she gave you a small smile, nodding.
“Okay,” she started, but there was something behind her eyes that you couldn’t read. “How about we get you cleaned up?”
~~~
You had asked to bathe by yourself, but Cordelia had pushed just enough and hesitated in the doorway, and you couldn’t help it. You caved.
She sat next to the bathtub as you curled in on yourself, her finger tracing absent circles in the water.
“People don’t usually get this banged up from falling,” she tried again, probably the eighth way she had phrased the same question that night. But you hadn’t had time to process anything, and you wanted to at least run it through your own mind a few times before you got them involved. Before you had two other people telling you how careless you had been and how disappointed they were in you.
“Okay,” you mumbled softly. Cordelia’s brow pushed up and she made to say something, but then there was a soft knock at the door and Mina’s voice floated through.
“It’s me. May I come in?”
Cordelia flicked her free hand and the door opened, and then Wilhemina was looming in the doorway, eyes piercing through you as she shut the door behind her.
She walked over slowly, leaning her cane on the sink before sitting carefully on the edge of the tub.
You averted your gaze to your knees, tucking them further up against your chest, but not before you caught Mina reaching for Cordelia’s free hand.
You squeezed your eyes shut, dropping your head to your knees and hugging them. This was your fault. They were both so worried and it was becoming such a thing and you hadn’t asked for any of this, but you knew if you told them everything would be so much worse.
“What happened?” Mina asked, and the way her voice dropped, the softness there, you thought she was talking to you. But before you could blow her off Cordelia answered, voice breathless in that slight tell of her annoyance.
“She won’t tell me.”
Mina hummed. “Madison wouldn’t tell me, either.” She shifted, and then her finger was under your chin, pulling your gaze to hers. “Are you going to tell me, princess? Or am I going to have to get it out of you another way?”
Her lip twitched up at the corner and you knew exactly what that smirk meant, but then James’s mouth overtook your thoughts. The smell of it, the feel of it, the taste of it.
The room spun and the bath was too hot and your stomach twisted, but you swallowed it down. Forced it all down. Because they couldn’t know. They couldn’t know that you had failed so miserably in such a crucial way.
You were a disgrace of a witch, and they would never look at you the same way if they only knew just how much you had let them down.
A tear fell, and before you could swipe at it Cordelia’s thumb was there, brushing it away.
“What’s wrong, darling?” Cordelia tried again, and the way her voice shook made guilt shoot through you. “Just… talk to us. Please…”
Mina reached over and stroked her fingers through Cordelia’s hair, and Cordelia smiled sadly up at her in appreciation. And in that moment, that split second on the precipice of caving, you realized that what they had was so much bigger than you.
You had been naive before, so giddy and excited and idiotically smitten with both of them. And just yesterday you had gotten their permission to post a photo of the three of you, both of them kissing you. But as much as they spoiled you and pampered you and made you feel so special and precious in the bedroom, they hadn’t signed up for this. They didn’t need this in their lives. They had been a perfectly happy couple before taking you into their bed, and that kind of fun didn’t lend itself to this level of drama.
So you bit down on your lip, wrapping your arms around your legs and hugging them to you. Sighed.
“I told you. I fell. That’s all. It’s not a big deal.”
And after a long moment of Cordelia and Mina looking between each other and you, Mina got up, swiping her cane and skirting out the door.
Cordelia cleared her throat. “I don’t know what you’re not telling us, but it’s alright. If you say that you fell, then I believe you.”
You let out a long breath, closing your eyes and nodding.
“Thank you.”
And you meant it, because the relief of that pressure being gone, knowing they would let it rest for the time being, if not for good, was enough to pull some of the terror from around your heart and let you breathe again.
“Now, darling,” Cordelia murmured, finger lifted from the water and tracing ever so lightly down your arm, “where do you hurt?”
~~~
Cordelia’s arm twitched on your waist and you flinched, James’s hand flashing through your mind.
It had been like this for hours. You didn’t know exactly how long because you could’t see the clock on the nightstand, but long enough for both Wilhemina and Cordelia to fall asleep on either side of you, and for you to have had at least three small panic attacks after that.
They had both been very considerate, Mina’s fingers pulling skillfully through your hair as Cordelia skimmed her fingers over your ribs.
“Are they feeling better?” Cordelia asked, and you nodded, thanking her again for whatever touch of magic she had put in that water that made all of your broken bits mend up a little quicker. At least the physical ones.
But now, as you lay between these two perfect women and the world heated up, degree by agonizing degree, you couldn’t help but taste the thick air of that hallway. Every time you closed your eyes you saw the red lighting. Saw his face. Every time Mina nudged against you, you felt his hands, his mouth. And when she grumbled in her sleep, pressing a soft kiss to your head, you felt his hand come down across your face. Heard the glass shattering, again and again and again.
Eventually it was too much. You couldn’t breathe and you couldn’t think and you needed space to just be. So you crawled carefully out from under the covers and off of the bed. You tiptoed to the door, opening it, and glanced behind you as Mina rolled over, whining and reaching into the empty space. And you almost paused. Almost smiled. But then her hands met Cordelia’s side and Cordelia was in her arms in a second, tucked up under her chin and legs twined together. Like you hadn’t even been there. Like they didn’t realize you were gone.
You had been so caught up with the privilege of being between them that you hadn’t realized how perfectly they fit together without you there.
Without you.
And as you crawled into your own bed, under your ice cold, dusty sheets, you let yourself cry because you just wanted to make them proud. You just wanted to be good enough for one of them, let alone both. And you had utterly, miserably failed.
~~~
You woke to your phone ringing, and you swiped your thumb over the screen before registering that it was your mother.
“Hello?” you mumbled sleepily, sitting up and scrubbing the exhaustion out of your eyes. She was ranting before you had pulled the phone to your ear.
“—and I don’t pay thousands of dollars each month for you to fall into this kind of nonsense. And with the headmistress? Really? I had no idea, honestly. No idea. But this will not stand. I don’t want you here, but you’re sure as hell not staying there. Not if that’s what they’re telling you is okay. I’m going to call your father tonight and then you’re going to be put in some sort of psych ward. It’s what we should have done in the first place. Some nice, white padded walls. That’ll sort you out—“
You hung up quickly, phone falling from trembling fingers.
No. No, no, no.
You sat frozen on your bed for a long moment, visions of your mother screaming at you, yanking you awake as you floated above your bed, the way she had practically shoved her money at Cordelia and left you shaking and fighting tears in the middle of the lobby.
But in the four months or so that you had been studying here, you had found your family. Your friends. For the first time in your life you felt like you belonged somewhere.
With them.
You shook the thought away, steeling yourself against everything that had happened the night before and resolving yourself to the fact that they wouldn’t want you anymore.
And as you felt another panic attack settling in, you slid out of bed, changing into something clean and fresh. But somehow, even with fresh clothes and a nice bath and a few hours of sleep, you still felt dirty as you plodded quietly down the stairs to the kitchen and turned on the light.
It was unnaturally early and none of the other girls would be up for at least an hour. Which gave you plenty of time to make yourself a cup of coffee and sort out your brain.
But no sooner did you have a steaming mug in your hand and were just relishing the first sleep-clearing sip, then you heard something shuffle behind you.
You whipped around, James’s face flashing through your mind.
It was Madison.
You let out a long breath, hand coming to your heart.
“Jeez, Madison. You scared the shit out of me.”
She skirted around you, pouring herself a cup of your coffee.
“You’re not going to finish this, right?” she asked mockingly, and then she was settled down at the kitchen table, knees tucked up on her chair. She looked at you for a long moment and you blinked back. “Are we going to talk about last night, or…?”
You waved her off, making your way across the kitchen. But you stopped in the doorway, guilt washing through you.
“I-“ you tried, turning to face her. “Thank you for helping me. And for letting me tell Delia and Mina.”
Madison made a face, and you mentally scolded yourself because you knew she hated those little nicknames. You cleared your throat.
“Seriously. Thank you.”
She stared at you, and when she spoke her voice was flat. “So you told them?”
You nodded. A lie.
“Both of them?”
You rolled your eyes. “Madison, if one of them knows, it’s safe to assume they both do. You know how they are.”
And you chuckled softly at your own joke, but she wasn’t laughing. Her eyes searched your face. “You’re sure you told them?”
Another nod.
She hummed, sipping her coffee.
“What?”
Her eyebrows raised over her mug. “Nothing. It’s just my bedroom is close enough to theirs that I can usually hear everything you weirdos do. And it was pretty quiet last night.”
You swallowed hard. “They wanted to give me space.”
“Oh, I’m sure.”
And you relaxed for a split second before she spoke again.
“And that’s why you went back to your own room, right?”
You snapped your eyes to hers and she was challenging you, all wiggled down in her seat like a snake that was about to strike.
“That’s none of your business,” you tried weakly. She smirked.
“Alright.”
And your brow furrowed as you nodded. “Alright.”
~~~
You walked down the street, bundling your coat tighter around you and stuffing your nose into your scarf. It was cold, despite everything, and the icy wind was doing wonders to clear your head.
You had volunteered to go on errands today, and insisted that you go alone when Cordelia offered to go with you. She hadn’t pushed, and you had been grateful. But the two or three stops you were planning on making had turned to seven, the mindless shopping and browsing doing wonders to clear your head. You were grateful for the space. The privacy. The ability to get away from Cordelia and Mina for a day and just breathe.
It had only taken a fraction of a second. One man that got a little too close to you as he passed by you in an aisle.
And suddenly you were acutely aware that you were utterly alone. Unprotected. Vulnerable.
After that you saw him everywhere, tall and solid and looming. His brown hair bobbing through crowds, his face in strangers that passed by you.
You rushed to the grocery store, desperate to get the last of your errands done and swearing that you could feel his gaze on you. Hear his voice. And as you pulled fruits and vegetables and all of Madison’s ridiculous requests into your bags, you realized that he could be anywhere. Anyone. You could run smack into him on the street and he could drag you away and no one would know what had happened to you—
Stop.
You forced a deep breath in as you handed your groceries to the cashier, foot bouncing. Cordelia would always find you. Cordelia would always be there for you. Cordelia wouldn’t let him hurt you again.
Except she didn’t know he had hurt you in the first place.
Except now everything was different.
And you were alone.
The fear racked its way back up your throat as you walked determinately back to the school, heart hammering faster with every step. And as your pulse quickened so did your steps, until you were practically running from the ghost of his memory. Sprinting as far away from the idea of him as fast as you could.
The pounding of your shoes on the pavement morphed into the pounding of the bass in the club. The light from the setting sun tinted too red as you remembered the flashing lights. And his hands. His hands everywhere…
By the time you reached the school you were out of breath, cheeks wet from tears you hadn’t realized had fallen. You yanked the gate open, not bothering to shut it behind you as you blinked around your blurred vision.
You could feel him behind you, even though you knew he wasn’t there. Could feel him breathing down your neck.
You ran up the front steps to the academy, pushing away thoughts of him wandering the city. The fact that you could run into him at any point on any given day. The fact that you weren’t safe.
The doors to the house swung open as you hit the landing and Kyle greeted you with a small smile, but it quickly melted off his face as you pushed by him and forced the doors shut.
“I’m fine, Kyle,” you said in response to his unasked question. But the way your breaths were coming out of you, ragged and short and strangled from running, you knew it didn’t sound believable.
“Can you take these to the kitchen?”
His eyes caught your shaking hands as he took the bags from you and he frowned, but you brushed him off, heading straight for the stairs.
You just needed a minute to catch your breath.
And you almost made it.
You were only three steps away from the staircase when Wilhemina’s fingers gripped around your arm, pulling you back against her.
“Where do you think you’re going, sneaking upstairs before saying hello?” she murmured against your ear, and your knees went weak because oh lord, there was no air to breathe in this room. You swallowed around your dry throat, forcing steady breaths out of your lungs. Schooled your features.
But you didn’t turn around.
“I need to go to the bathroom,” you lied. And you should have known better. She could read you like a book, especially when you tried to lie to her. But after a brief pause, fingers twitching on your arm, she let you go.
“Alright little one, just don’t be too long.” Her voice was low and it floated up behind you as you made too quickly for the stairs. “We missed you terribly and Delia made your favorite tonight.”
And you nodded as you fled, retreating to the safety and privacy of the bathroom and forcing deep breaths down as you blinked at yourself in the mirror.
And that’s when the tears came. Hard, heavy, and fast.
You didn’t realize how long you had been crying in there, curled in on yourself and shaking, until one of the girls knocked on the door and told you that dinner was ready.
~~~
They both stared at you through dinner. And it was probably your fault.
For one thing, you hadn’t sat next to either of them, too afraid that if Mina slid her hand over your knee or Cordelia pushed a strand of hair out of your face you would lose it in front of everyone. So you situated yourself safely between Madison and Zoe, whispering with Madison that yes everything was back to normal, and thanking her quietly for not asking too many questions.
Cordelia ate quietly, laughing softly with some of the girls. But you could feel Mina’s eyes on you like a knife, could feel the heat of her gaze with every twitch of your brow or quirk of your lip.
At one point you gathered the courage to look up at them, but neither of them were paying you any attention, Mina’s eyes on Cordelia’s lap as Cordelia whispered in her ear. She nodded slowly as Cordelia slid her hand over Mina’s, and you saw Cordelia’s brow furrow, just so.
~~~
Cordelia caught you after dinner, sidled up against Madison and drying the dishes as she washed them.
“Can I see you in the greenhouse for a moment?” she asked politely, her voice hitting that pitch that it always did when she was around the other girls.
You hesitated, licking your lips slowly before nodding.
And as you left, Cordelia’s hand skating over your lower back, Madison called out, “You don’t have to ask so politely, Foxxy. We all know you’re going to bang her brains out.”
~~~
Wilhemina hit her cane on the stone of the greenhouse floor and you flinched in Cordelia’s arms. She squeezed you tighter to her and you pulled yourself down as small as you could in her embrace.
“You don’t keep secrets from us, princess,” Mina tried again, something like regret flicking across her features at your reaction. “Understood? Just tell us what happened and everything will be okay.”
“We can’t help you if you don’t talk to us, darling,” Cordelia tried, pulling away and holding you at arms length. She searched your eyes and you ducked your head.
“Nothing happened,” you said for the millionth time in the last twenty minutes.
And Cordelia released you this time, eyes finding Mina’s behind you as she swallowed.
“Alright.”
~~~
You planned on changing in the bathroom that night, brushing it off on the fact that you wanted to shower. And this time, when Cordelia offered to join you, you refused.
The water did wonders to clear your head, letting the past days, the past week, the constant nagging, wash off your back as you scrubbed yourself down with soap. And when you stepped out of the tub, wrapping the plush towel around you and swiping the steam off the mirror, you let yourself smile at the fact that you actually felt clean.
You pulled the comb through your hair slowly, relishing the quiet of the bathroom and the sheer space around you. No one pushing in. No one asking questions. No one’s eyes boring into your back as you tried to mind your own business.
But when you reached for your pajamas and your hand hit air, you frowned. You must have left them on their bed.
Shit.
A deep breath, and then you steeled yourself, tucking the towel tightly around yourself and plodding back to Cordelia’s room.
You passed by Coco on the way and she looked you up and down, biting down on a snort. “Someone’s getting lucky tonight, huh?”
You faked a smile, hand frozen on the doorknob. “Go to bed, Coco.”
“Will I be able to sleep? These walls are thinner than you three think.”
“Go to bed, Coco,” you tried again, rolling your eyes.
And then she was off, grumbling something about how she would have already been in bed if you hadn’t taken so long in the shower.
You knocked softly on the door and waited for Cordelia’s muffled “come in” before turning the knob and entering.
She was siting on the edge of the bed, Wilhemina standing next to her as she pulled the pins from her hair. And from the scowls on their faces they had clearly been in some sort of deep conversation.
They both looked up when you entered, Mina dropping her loose pins into Cordelia’s outstretched hand.
“Well, well,” Cordelia started, smirking as her eyes raked over you. “To what do we owe this pleasure?”
You cleared your throat, hugging your towel closer to your chest. You ignored the way Cordelia’s smirk faltered. “I left my pajamas in here. Sorry.”
She shifted on the mattress, crossing her legs as Mina leaned up against the post of the bed and looked at you through lidded eyes. Her brow raised.
“Why on earth are you apologizing, princess?”
And you gaped around words, because you really didn’t know.
“You know,” Cordelia drawled, glancing up at Mina and smirking at the unspoken words between them. “Mina and I were just thinking that it had been quite some time since we spoiled you.” Her hands skimmed down her thighs, fingers playing with the fabric of her nightgown. “And we’ve missed you ever so much.”
James’s voice flooded your mind, making you flinch.
This is mine.
Mina pulled herself off of the bedpost, stalking towards you. And you knew that look. You knew those predatory eyes. You knew what it meant when her fingers twitched on the head of her cane like that. And with every tap against the wood, James’s words rang in your ears.
“You know, you really don’t need that towel.”
Did you miss me, baby?
“Not when you have the two of us to keep you warm.”
I don’t care how many women you sleep with.
“To make you feel good.”
It will always be mine.
“To make you forget about whatever is worrying that pretty little mind of yours.”
Do you understand?
And she was almost to you, just out of arms reach, when you ducked around her and fled to the edge of the bed, scrambling to scoop up your pajamas.
“I-I think I’d rather sleep in my room tonight, if that’s okay.”
And when Cordelia frowned you mumbled some excuse about feeling ill.
“Do you need me to get you anything?” Cordelia tried, hand reaching out to catch your arm as you passed.
But you dodged her too, throwing a “no, it’s alright” behind you as you practically ran from the room.
~~~
“Did you and Foxxy break up?”
You rolled your eyes, flicking to the next page in your book.
“I’m trying to read, Madison.”
She sauntered over, perching on the edge of the couch. “I’m just asking.”
And as she snatched a cigarette out of the holder on the coffee table and lit it, you let your curiosity get the better of you and put your book down.
You sighed. “Why are you asking?”
She shrugged, dragging on her cigarette. “You took the Instagram picture down. You know, the gross one where Venny was practically licking your face.”
And you rolled your eyes again, half at her attitude, half at the nickname. “Not that it’s any of your business,” you started, shifting on the couch and crossing your legs under you, “but no. We didn’t break up.”
She let out a soft “huh”, blowing another puff of smoke. And just when you thought she had let it go and went to grab your book back, she spoke again. “Why’d you take it down?”
And your eyebrows raised in frustration as you looked over at her. “Because I felt like it.”
“That’s bullshit.”
And you flinched at her tone. “What?”
“I said that’s bullshit,” she tried again, dragging the words out sarcastically. “We both know you caved to your awful mother.”
And this time you actually froze. “Madison, what are you talking about?”
The only person who knew anything about your mother was Cordelia, and potentially Wilhemina. Cordelia had met her briefly and whether or not she remembered the woman enough to discuss her with Mina, you couldn’t say. You were definitely careful not to bring her up in conversation. And honestly, they never really asked about your home life. No one did.
There was an unspoken “no pry” policy between the girls, and it made it easier to forget the past and concentrate on your studies.
Madison flicked her cigarette, leaning back on the arm of the couch. “I heard Foxxy talking to her on the phone the other day. Damn, that woman can rant.”
You blinked at her, trying to find the right words. But all you landed on was, “Cordelia was talking to my mother?”
“Yeah, and taking some pretty detailed notes.”
You were off the couch in a second, heading straight for the door. But Madison caught your wrist, cackling.
“Jeez, I was kidding. Relax.”
You paused and seriously considered yanking your hand from her grip and smacking her across the face because honestly. But you took a deep breath instead, setting your jaw as you flopped back down on the couch.
“You’re a fucking prick, you know that?”
Madison hummed. “What are you so afraid of? That your perfect girlfriends will learn about your deep, dark past?”
You sighed. “I don’t have a deep, dark past. As boring as it may sound.”
She scoffed. “Exactly. So what’s the issue?”
You huffed, pushing your hand to your forehead. “She threatened to pull me out of here. Throw me in an institution somewhere and lock me away.”
“Shit…”
You glanced up at Madison, all traces of playful banter gone. She actually looked pale.
“What, no witty comeback?”
She shook her head slowly, studying you. “You know Cordelia would never let that happen, right?”
You waved her off.
“No, I mean it. Even if you weren’t screwing her. You’re one of us. And she would never let that happen.”
And you hated that tears were pricking your eyes. “Maybe before, but not now.”
“Now…?” Madison prompted, swinging her legs over and sliding down onto the couch with you.
When you spoke again, your voice was thick with unshed tears. “I failed, Madison. I couldn’t even defend myself from one stupid guy. I don’t deserve to be here. I don’t…” You swallowed hard. “I don’t deserve them.”
And she actually laughed. “You’re kidding, right? Do you think I knew how to choke a person out after only being here for a few months? You’re not supposed to know how to do that yet. Or really at all, I guess? I don’t know, I stole one of Foxxy’s books a while back.”
You chuckled, tracing the fabric of the couch and picking at it softly. “That’s all fine and good, but—“
Madison cut you off, waving her cigarette in your face. “I swear if you’re about to say that you’re ‘damaged goods’ and whine about how sorry I’m supposed to feel for you, I’m leaving right now.”
You groaned, smacking her hand out of your face and falling back on the couch. “What the hell am I supposed to do, Madison?”
She snorted. “You’re asking me for advice?”
You cackled, scrubbing your hands over your face. “Now do you understand how desperate I am?”
And as she leaned back on the couch and propped her feet up on the arm, dragging on her cigarette, she reached her hand out to you. When you took it, she squeezed. “You can start by saying ‘fuck the haters’.”
You quirked your brow, looking up at her. But she sure as hell looked like she wasn’t joking, and you were willing to do anything at this point. So you cupped your hands around your mouth, dropping your voice a few octaves.
“Fuck the haters.”
“There you go,” Madison laughed, and the two of you went back and forth, saying “fuck the haters” louder and louder as you giggled and smacked at each other.
You didn’t see Cordelia watching you from the doorway. Didn’t see her brow push up as you laughed. Didn’t see her nose twitch against tears as you fell back on the couch, legs kicking at Madison.
Didn’t see her bite her lip as she turned, sighing.
You didn’t see her.
~~~
A soft knock. And you knew she was expecting you, so you weren’t surprised when the door opened of its own accord.
You lingered in the doorway.
“You wanted to see me?”
Cordelia looked up from her desk, pushing the hair off of her face.
“Come on in, beautiful.”
You smiled at her, closing the door behind you. But you couldn’t help the slight tremble in your hands because somehow, in some way, you felt like you were in trouble.
She gestured across her desk. “Sit.”
And yes, you were definitely in trouble, because you hadn’t sat across her desk in months. She always had you sit in her lap. Pushed you against the wall. Sat you up on her desk.
You squirmed in the chair, fingers twitching in your lap. “Did I do something wrong?”
She shook her head, waving you off as she finished writing out some paperwork. She stacked the pages together and set them aside, and then her hands were folded on her desk and she was leaning forward, and you couldn’t read the expression on her face.
You could tell what Mina was thinking by the way she inhaled. Knew the language of Cordelia’s fingers twitching better than speaking. But this past week had proved more difficult, all of their actions and decisions shrouded in some sort of secret code that only they could decipher.
You were utterly lost. And it terrified you.
Cordelia cleared her throat. “I had initially thought that it was Madison that hurt you—”
“What?” you started, but she held her hand up.
“I had initially thought that it was Madison that hurt you, and that’s why you wouldn’t tell Mina or I what happened.”
You shook your head. “She helped me. It wasn’t her fault at all.”
And Delia hummed. “I see that now.”
You nodded softly. Cordelia’s eyes narrowed as she studied you. And after only a few moments you found it difficult to breathe.
It was different on this side of the desk. She was intense. Intimidating. You had never doubted her power, but you had always wondered how this woman who was always so soft and open and pliable with you and Mina could command an entire coven, let alone fight in wars against warlocks and voodoo queens and witch hunters. But now, sitting opposite her and very distinctly feeling like you were in trouble, not to mention that rooted gut feeling that you had let her down and the guilt of having lied to her — your skin was vibrating and your heart was pounding and you suddenly realized precisely why she was the Supreme.
She was power personified.
A powerful presence, a powerful love. A powerful voice. Powerful magic.
She could snap her fingers and make the entire human population bend to its knees. Or maybe it was just you. The other girls didn’t seem to be afraid of her.
“Your mother called me.”
Her words snapped you out of your thoughts. You swallowed.
“Oh?”
A nod. “Do you want to leave this coven?”
Your heart sunk into your stomach, and when you spoke, your voice was smaller than you would have liked.
“Please don’t let her take me.”
You heard the way it came out of your mouth, weak and broken. You saw the way Cordelia’s eyes softened and her brow pulled together. Watched her fingers twitch.
But where she normally would have reached for you, pulled you into her lap and kissed you until you were giggling, ravished you with reassurances, she only cleared her throat and leaned back in her chair.
“Alright. That will be all.”
You blinked at her for a moment, stunned, before standing and thanking her. And as you turned to leave, fighting tears at her casual dismissal as you realized that she was already done with you, that she had already stopped caring, she called your name.
You spun, hope flaring in your chest, but she wasn’t looking at you.
“You should thank Madison. She covered for you well.”
Cordelia dragged her pen through the air as she spoke, waving absently toward the door.
A soft nod as you swallowed, fighting yourself on whether or not you should answer. But Cordelia was already buried back in her paperwork and she clearly didn’t have time for you, especially not when she had already given up. Before she even knew how broken you were. Because you had lied to her. Over and over again.
This was all your fault.
So you turned, wringing your hands as you pulled the door to Cordelia’s office open. You paused in the doorway, working against your better judgement and looking back at her once more.
Nothing. You doubted she even realized you were still there.
You shut the door behind you with a soft click, leaning back against it and steadying your breaths out in the empty hallway, hands shaking against the wood.
That night, for the first time in months, you slept alone in your room without telling either of them where you were going. Without making an excuse. Without any sort of explanation.
And no one came looking for you.
~~~
The next day was impossibly long.
Cordelia and Mina were both out on errands, and they wouldn’t be back until the afternoon. You and Zoe has been left in charge of the girls, but while Zoe led the lessons, all you could do was watch from the corner, mind churning over the past week on an endless loop.
And by the time both women returned that afternoon, you had resolved yourself to studying alone in the kitchen. Cordelia would go straight to her greenhouse if you knew her, and Mina almost always went right to her study to get off of her feet and file whatever paperwork she had collected on their run.
So you startled when one of the younger girls scrambled into the kitchen, bouncing on her toes and looking around nervously.
“Millie?” you tried, putting your book down and walking over to her. “Are you alright?”
She nodded. Shook her head. Nodded again.
“What’s wrong?”
And when she spoke, the words tumbled out of her mouth like she was afraid if she paused they would bite her.
“Ms. Venable said she wants to see you in her room right now and if you’re not up there in two minutes she’s going to come find me and make me scrub the toxic ooze out of the bottoms of Cordelia’s rose pots with no gloves to protect my childlike hands.”
You couldn’t help but smile fondly, because it was honestly adorable how terrified everyone was of Mina. And you could tell Millie was repeating her words verbatim.
“Alright. Thank you, Millie.” You gave her a reassuring pat on the shoulder as you made to leave the kitchen. Paused as you heard her panting softly behind you. “And just so you know… Roses don’t produce ‘toxic ooze’. And you don’t have childlike hands.”
You saw her glance down at her fingers, nodding slowly, and then she scrambled out of the room as quickly as she had come.
~~~
It was less than two minutes by the time you made it up to their room, but when you opened the door, Wilhemina and Cordelia were standing in the middle of the space like they had been waiting for hours.
“We need to have a talk,” Mina said, and you braced yourself for what you knew was coming.
“You scared the hell out of Millie,” you deflected. Neither of them laughed.
Instead, Cordelia reached forward and took your hand, pulling you over to the bed and sitting you down on the edge of it. She drew back, fingers falling from yours, and her and Mina exchanged a look that you couldn’t read.
Cordelia wedged her thumb between her teeth as she looked you over, hand on Mina’s arm. And just when you started to brace yourself for your universe to split to pieces as they told you that this was over, just as you started building hard steel walls around your heart, Cordelia spoke.
“Who hurt you?”
Oh.
You almost groaned, annoyed at the fact that they wouldn’t just let it go. But you told yourself that maybe if they were still stuck on it after all this time, maybe it meant that they still cared about you. Maybe you had been wrong. And you certainly weren’t going to jeopardize that now. So you lied. Just like you had hundreds of times in the past week. And you hated the fact that it was almost getting easy.
“No one, Delia. I fell.”
All it took was a glance from Cordelia and Mina stepped forward, fingers twitching on her cane.
“Don’t lie, princess.”
“I’m not lying.”
She scoffed, hard and loud as she tapped her cane down. “See but we think you are, little one.”
And Cordelia hummed, moving to sit next to you on the edge of the bed. “Why have you been avoiding us, darling?”
“I-I haven’t,” you countered weakly, swallowing hard.
Mina tutted, walking over and tipping your chin up. “Lying again. What a naughty girl you are.”
You whimpered, fingers curling in the sheets as Mina’s hand moved to your throat. And she wouldn’t have known. Couldn’t have. But everything inside of you tensed, and you fought to keep yourself grounded in the moment. Refused to let your mind wander to that stupid red hallway.
“Looks like we’re going to have to do this my way,” she continued, tapping at your ankles with her cane. “Over Delia’s lap. Now.”
But Cordelia held up her hand, the heat of her gaze raking over you. You saw her eyes narrow and her brow furrow, and then her fingers were on Mina’s wrist as she pried her hand off of your throat.
“No,” Cordelia said firmly, tugging Mina down onto the bed next to you. “We’re going to do it my way this time.”
A look was exchanged between Cordelia and Mina, and Mina nodded, just so. And then Cordelia was running her hand over your shoulder, fingers pushing and massaging and working their way up to the base of your neck.
“Do you want to tell us what happened?” Cordelia tried again, and you went to protest, but something stopped you.
Cordelia hummed, brushing a strand of hair behind your ear.
“There we go,” she said softly, encouragingly, and your eyes went wide as Mina’s hand found your knee.
“Delia what did you mean when you said—“
Mina cut you off, shushing you and pressing a kiss to your temple.
Something pricked at your nose and you flinched, fingers twisting in the sheets at your side.
Cordelia stroked her hands through your hair, fingers leaving warmth in their wake.
“It’s alright darling, just relax.”
Mina hummed, adjusting herself on the bed. Your eyes fluttered shut at the tap of her cane as she shifted.
“You’re safe here,” Cordelia continued, and you felt Mina’s thumb brush over the dip of your knee. “We just want to help you. Now tell us what happened, beautiful.”
You had barely registered her request when the words pushed out of your mouth.
“I didn’t fall. He hit me,” you started, and your eyes went wide as you dug your teeth into your lip. Cordelia’s brow creased and Mina’s fingers tightened on your knee.
A pause as they looked at each other.
“Who hit you?” Cordelia asked.
“My ex.” Your teeth came down on your lip again, harder this time. You tasted blood.
“And why did he hit you, princess?” Mina’s voice was low. Steady. Surprisingly calm.
“Because he was—“ you started, the words snaking past your teeth before you bit down on your cheek. A deep breath. “Delia, what are you doing to me?”
Her smirk twitched up at the corner, tugged up with her brows as her fingers strung through your hair. “Why did he hit you?”
“Because he was trying to—“ And this time you covered your mouth with your hand, determination locking into your features.
Cordelia furrowed her brow and shook her head, just so. “Don’t fight it honey, it’ll be so much easier if you just tell us what happened.”
“I don’t want to.” And now tears were pricking at your eyes because you knew what she had done. And you knew that you had driven them to this. And you knew that there was no way you could fight it.
“Why not?” It was Mina, thumb brushing over your cheek.
A sniffle. A shaky breath. And then you couldn’t hold onto it anymore and the truth fell out of you.
About how you had failed them, how you had failed as a witch. How he had pushed himself on you. Had hit you over the head with his glass. How Madison had saved you and defended you and covered for you like you had asked. How you were a disappointment. How you understood that they wouldn’t want to be with you anymore. That they didn’t sign up for this.
At some point during your explanation, Cordelia had vaulted off the bed, pacing the room as Mina’s hand rubbed slow circles on your back.
They let you go, let you talk, let you stumble over your thoughts and squeeze every last detail from your memory. And you weren’t sure how long it had taken, but by the time you finished the sun had set and a cool chill was billowing the curtains.
You finished your explanation with a soft “I’m sorry”, more a breath than a final statement. And your body deflated as Mina pressed a kiss to your temple, the weight of the week and the pressure of keeping a secret from them finally lifting from your shoulders as sobs pushed up your throat.
You thought that maybe you had done the right thing, letting everything go. That maybe, somehow, everything would fall back into place. But while Mina’s touches were soft and her mouth was warm as she pressed kisses along your hairline, Cordelia had hardened and a cold energy poured off of her.
“What’s his full name?” Cordelia’s voice was as firm as you had ever heard it, pitched deep and low.
You wiped sloppily at your cheeks and sniffed hard. “James Conroy.”
Mina hummed, and it was almost a growl, but when you looked over at her she smiled reassuringly. “You’re doing great.”
“And his address?”
“I-I don’t know,” you tried, your brain pulling every piece of information you had on him to the forefront of your mind. Pushed the words onto your tongue. “He used to live by the French Quarter, but he might have moved.”
“His full address, Y/N. Now.”
“I—“ you tried, but your voice broke because you really didn’t know. Your mind was blank. Your mouth was empty. There was no other information you could present.
“I said now!” Cordelia whirled on you, fire in her eyes. And Mina’s hand froze on your back.
“Delia,” Mina started, voice low. “She said she doesn’t know. Let it go.”
Cordelia flicked her hand up. Wilhemina’s fingers sprung off of you and flew to her throat, and you watched in horror as her mouth moved around silent words. As she clawed at the soft skin under her jaw, brow creased and hot eyes on Cordelia.
But then your head was whipped back to Cordelia, heat pressing in on your cheeks as you were held in place by an invisible force. Frozen in time.
“Address,” she said again, voice thick and deep.
“I don’t know.” The words left you before you had decided to open your mouth.
“Last known residence.”
“I don’t know.”
“Workplace.”
“I don’t know.”
And your throat was heating up with the rapid fire questions, cheeks pressed in firmly to keep you still as your hands dug into the bedsheets. Found Mina’s thigh and squeezed. You heard a gasping sound and glanced over at Mina, saw her jaw set as the gears turned in her head.
“Physical description,” Cordelia continued, fingers twitching on the outstretched hand holding Mina’s voice in place.
“B-Brown hair,” you choked out, and tears flooded your vision when you felt pressure constrict on your throat. It was starting to hurt, your brain working faster than you could fathom, swimming with information you thought was long forgotten. You could feel Cordelia digging through it, digging through your memories like a hungry animal.
“Eye color.”
“Brown.”
“Height.”
“S-Six foot.”
And her fingers twitched at her side as the invisible fingers on your throat tightened.
“Build.”
“A-Average. Broad shoulders,” you choked out, gasping around the crushing of your windpipe. And then James’s hand was there, pushing you, pinning you, choking you, sliding between your legs.
You gulped down air, struggling to breathe, struggling to think. Tears streamed down your cheeks as you sobbed and snot ran past your lips. It was too hot. It was too much. And your eyes rolled back in your head as every nerve was set on edge.
It all happened so fast.
The world swam in black and red, thoughts and memories whipping across your vision faster than you could comprehend. Cordelia’s voice cracking as she yelled at you, something about not being good enough. Not being enough. And the pieces of her chastisement that you could hear made you scream because you were trying for Christ’s sake. The sound got stuck in your throat, fire against the words that were trying to fight their way out of your mouth. A growl from Cordelia that fell straight inside your brain. Your lungs constricted as everything was pulled from inside of you. And then the sharp rap of Mina’s cane cracked through your mind.
It hit so hard it should have split the wood, and in that second, you were released.
“Enough, Cordelia!”
You gulped down air as your vision came back, and the relief of having the pressure pulled from you made you feel like you were hovering off the bed.
There was a long silence as you sobbed, choking on snot and air and tears. And it wasn’t until you tore your eyes from Cordelia that you realized Mina had an arm across you, blocking you with her body and pushing herself between you and Cordelia.
Cordelia froze, blinking. “I—“ she tried, voice raspy. And her eyes went wide as tears welled. “I…”
She must have still been holding some piece of you, however small. Because in that moment, whatever spell was still on you broke and you crumpled in on yourself, doubling over Mina’s arm and curling against her side as you gasped and sobbed into your knees.
And when Mina spoke again, you could barely hear her low voice through the sound of your sniffling, your face buried too far into her shoulder.
“That’s enough.”
A long silence stretched. You felt Mina move softly with her breaths, hand stroking your thigh. But she was stiff. Too tall. Challenging.
And after what felt like an eternity you heard the heavy click of heels, a soft “Mina…” Felt Mina shake her head slowly. And then the door slammed.
Mina took a deep breath, shoulders falling just so as she sighed.
“Alright, princess. It’s okay. She’s gone. It’s just me.”
She pressed a kiss to the top of your head and then she was pulling her arm from your grip and sliding her hand across your cheek, tugging your face from behind her shoulder.
“Come on, little one. Look at me.”
You sniffed, leaning into her touch as you let her pull your face to hers and press a soft kiss to your lips. Your eyes fluttered open, vision blurred by tears that were still falling.
“No no, princess. Don’t cry,” she started, brow furrowed as her eyes searched yours. “Everything is going to be okay.”
You sniffed, wiping at you cheeks. And the way she was looking at you, so worried. So tenderly. She had only looked at you that softly once before, after the first time she had used her cane on you. You wouldn’t have even noticed if you hadn’t squinted your eyes open that night after she thought you had fallen asleep. But as much love as she normally poured over you, this look was something different.
And suddenly you felt very small and very, very stupid.
You straightened, clearing your throat and sniffing against more tears.
But Mina knew what you were doing and her fingers were instantly in your hair, scratching your scalp in that way that always put you straight to sleep.
“Shh, princess,” she cooed, tipping your chin up. And you fought to avoid her gaze, but her fingers twitched and she whispered your name, and when you met her eyes she smiled. “You don’t need to do that.”
You shook your head, brushing her off, but her fingers tightened on your chin, just so, and your eyes snapped back to hers. “You don’t do that with me, okay?” A pause. “Ever.”
You gulped, sniffing as fresh tears welled in your eyes.
And when Mina spoke again, her voice was low. Hoarse. “Please don’t do that with me. If you’re not okay, tell me. If something happens, tell me. You scared the hell out of us.”
You choked on a whimper, sobs pushing up your throat. “I’m sorry,” you whispered. But she cut you off.
“No, no. Don’t apologize.” A soft kiss to your forehead. “Just don’t shut us out. Okay?”
You nodded softly. “Okay.”
“I love you,” she said softly, brushing a strand of hair from your eyes. “And Delia loves you, too. That’s the only reason she lost control.”
You sniffled at her words, and this time when the tears fell onto your cheeks you weren’t sure if they were fresh or bottled up somewhere from before.
“You’re not going to leave me?” Your hands fidgeted in your lap and you picked a point on Mina’s dress to study, too afraid of what would happen if you were looking her in the eye and she said yes.
“What? I—“ Mina cut off, trying to catch your gaze. “Who told you that? Was it Madison, because I swear—“
You shook your head, swiping at your tears. “No, I just... figured you wouldn’t want me if I was...” A sniff, and the words got caught in your throat but you pushed them out. “If I was broken like this...”
Mina’s eyes went wide as her brow furrowed and she let out a soft “oh, no no” before licking her lips and swallowing.
Her hand fell from your chin and she shifted, patting her lap. “Come here.”
She helped you lean over, still shaking from the vice grip Cordelia had on you earlier, and you rested your head on her lap, curling up on the edge of the bed. Her hand was back on your thigh in an instant, tracing soft circles as her fingers carded through your hair and over your scalp.
“Relax, little one.”
And you barely had time to nod, to sigh against the love her fingers were pushing into you, before your eyes grew heavy and you were lulled into a deep sleep.
~~~
Soft voices woke you from dreams of Cordelia’s hair and Mina’s hands, and you whined softly as you shifted, waiting for one of them to grab you and pull you close. Reaching for their heat.
Nothing.
You shifted in bed and noted that you had been tucked under covers and that there were plush pillows fanned around you. But you didn’t open your eyes, sinking back into that soft twilight of warmth and peace between sleep and consciousness.
At the rustling of the sheets the voices paused and you froze, face buried in your pillow. After a moment they continued, though, and you smiled to yourself at the warmth that threaded through you from those voices alone. The sense of safety and security that the sound brought with it.
“You need to eat.”
“I’m not leaving her, Mina.”
“Then let me bring something up—“
“No, I’m… No.”
A pause, a dissatisfied hum, and Cordelia spoke again.
“Where was he?”
You frowned.
“Madison found him scrounging some bar. She might not be much, but she sure can pick an asshole out of a crowd.”
A soft chuckle, and then a long silence.
“What’s wrong, little duck?”
Cordelia took a shaky breath.
“I feel like I failed her…”
You heard Mina’s cane tap, heard fabric shuffle.
“You found him, you did everything you could do.”
When Cordelia spoke again she sounded so small. Her voice wavered. “But I wasn’t there for her. I— We weren’t there for her, Mina. Our girl. She was scared and she was hurt and she was alone—“
Her voice cracked and you heard shuffling, and you propped yourself up in the bed as heat flooded your cheeks.
Cordelia sat in the plush chair by the window, sunlight streaming in and turning her hair to gold. Her head was buried in Mina’s stomach as Mina smoothed her hands over her back, shushing her and cooing at her and holding Cordelia against her. Cordelia’s shoulders shook and you heard a soft sob catch in her throat as her hands tightened over Mina’s arms.
And watching your Supreme, so small and helpless and broken. Because of you. Because she felt like she had failed you. After you had been so worried you had failed her.
Something broke in your chest and you sniffed against tears as they dripped down your cheeks.
And Mina, ever present and always impeccably observant, caught the sound. She looked over at you and a soft smile played across her lips, eyes softening.
“Good morning, little one.”
You gave her your best smile, eyes flicking back to Cordelia as your brows pushed up.
“Delia…?” you tried softly, and in an instant she had pushed herself off of Mina, wiping hastily at her eyes and schooling her features. She smiled at you, clearing her throat as her nose twitched around the ghost of tears.
“Hi, darling. How are you feeling?”
She gulped, and you watched her throat bob, and then you couldn’t help it. You climbed off of the bed, drawn to her like a magnet despite everything that had happened. Because she had just been trying to help. She had been doing the only thing she knew to keep you safe. To protect you. You had hidden and lied and locked them both out. And they both deserved better than that.
Cordelia deserved so much better than this guilt that slumped her shoulders and pulled the light from her eyes. She had been there for you when you wanted nothing more than to block her out. Desperate not to lose her. And now it was your turn.
Mina stepped back as you approached, and you slid your hand over Cordelia’s as she offered you a weak smile.
“Feeling better?” she tried again, but you only laced your fingers together, pulling her arm around you as you curled up in her lap and rested your head on her chest. Her free hand stroked through your hair on instinct and you felt her brow furrow. “What are you doing?”
You nuzzled your face into her chest, humming. “Thank you.”
She tilted her head and her hair fell into your face, tickling your nose. “What?”
Mina chuckled behind you, and you heard her cane tap as she perched herself on the edge of the chair. You looked up at both of them, trying to push the love and gratitude that was threatening to burst out of your chest through your eyes and into them. Mina smiled at you knowingly, fingers playing absently through Cordelia’s hair.
You reached out and took her free hand, squeezing their fingers as you spoke.
“Thank you. Both of you. For everything. I’m sorry I kept all of this from you.”
They both murmured soft reassurances matched with warm smiles, but you felt like it wasn’t enough. So you brought both of their hands to your lips, kissing their knuckles.
“I love you both… So much.”
“You know we love you too, darling. That’s why we needed to know what happened.”
You nodded. “I know.”
“I’m sorry that I hurt you,” Cordelia continued, and her voice went from sultry to strangled in a second.
You shook your head. “You don’t need to apologize.”
“Neither do you,” Cordelia countered, nails scratching lightly against your scalp. “Not one bit.”
“But I lied to you.” You shook your head, gaze dropping to your lap. “To both of you. After you have been nothing but kind to me. After you let me in and let me love you… And I—“
“No no no,” Cordelia tried again. “I should have never lost my temper like that—“
And then she squeaked and you whipped your head up. Mina was leaning over you, kissing Cordelia deeply, and it shouldn’t have made you squirm, especially after everything that had happened. But it did.
Cordelia giggled as she felt you shift in her lap and she broke away, looking down at you knowingly.
“Are you alright, darling?”
You cleared your throat. But before you could speak, Mina’s hand was on your cheek and she looked between you and Cordelia.
“We’re stopping this nonsense now. Understood?” She arched a perfect brow. “You’re both sorry. You’ve both apologized. And you’ve both learned your lesson. And if you haven’t, well then leave that bridge for me to cross.”
And the look in her eyes as she smirked at you was so predatory that you couldn’t help but whine.
“Alright, little one?”
You nodded, mouth gone dry.
“Little duck?”
And Cordelia nodded, clearing her throat. When you looked up at her, her cheeks had flushed pink, and you knew it was because she still wasn’t used to being so exposed in front of someone other than Mina. That little name got straight under her skin and it never failed to make you grin.
“Good,” Mina continued, squeezing your hand in hers and pressing a kiss to the top of your hair. “Now how about we all go get some lunch?”
Mina helped you slide off of Cordelia’s lap, untangling your arms and untucking your legs. And as you followed her to the door, Cordelia’s fingers ghosted hesitantly over the small of your back, over your waist, like she didn’t want to touch you but couldn’t fathom doing anything else. You glanced back, slipping your hands over hers and guiding them around your stomach. And the smile she offered you made your knees go weak.
“Oh, and Delia?” Mina threw over her shoulder, reaching for the doorknob. “If you even think about going that hard on her again, let alone taking my voice, I’ll cane you in the foyer in front of everyone. Understood?”
662 notes
·
View notes