FORM IS EMPTINESS (EMPTINESS IS FORM) — PART 2 OF 2
Emptiness does not differ from form, form does not differ from emptiness, whatever is emptiness, that is form, the same is true of feelings, perceptions, impulses, and consciousness.
SUMMARY: In which Eunsu leaves.
FEATURING: Fable ensemble
WORD COUNT: 9.1k
WARNINGS / NOTES: Off screen minor character death. Religious themes and discussions. If you’ve ever read anything from Eunsu’s perspective before in a previous Fable iteration, no you haven’t <3. You can also CLICK HERE or in the source link to read the whole thing at once in a Google doc.
66 DAYS — MINGEUN
Fable’s comeback showcase is delayed because Eunsu went to the bathroom ten minutes ago and never came back. Mingeun paces around backstage, anxious to perform. It’s his first time standing on stage in almost a year. He’s missed it so deeply his chest aches, like a legitimate physical ailment.
It should be difficult for him to pace with his bulky overcoat, but he’s gotten used to it over the past few years. He also has to dance in it, so walking back and forth down a hallway really isn’t a big deal.
“Stop it. You’re causing me stress,” Intak says, eyes half-closed. He sits on the ground, probably trying to keep his food down. Why did the guy with stage fright become an kpop idol? And how does he still have stage fright almost three years after his debut? Mingeun will never know.
He wishes he could be wearing a watch. His wrist feels naked without it. And he wants to know when they’re supposed to go onstage. He knows they have people in charge of coordinating all of that, but Mingeun wants to know too.
Jaeseop stops Mingeun on one of his passes. “You should go find Eunsu,” he says in a low voice.
“Me?” Mingeun asks. “Byeonghwi is younger—”
“You’re the second youngest. Eunsu is your best friend,” Jaeseop says, cutting him off. “Go find him.”
“Fine. I’ll go.”
Mingeun tries the bathroom first. That’s where Eunsu said he was going. He pushes the door open, and yells, loudly and shamelessly, “Eunsu?”
There’s no response. Mingeun double checks that he’s in the men’s bathroom—yep, those are urinals. Where the fuck is Eunsu if he’s not using the fucking bathroom? He forces himself not to panic, taking deep breaths in through his nose and out through his mouth, like his therapist always says.
He continues down the labyrinth of backstage hallways, getting farther and farther away from the stage. Forget his watch, Mingeun wants his fucking phone.
Then he hears the barest hint of a voice. Mingeun couldn’t call himself Eunsu’s best friend if he couldn’t recognize him from a whisper. He carefully grabs at the folds of his outfit, and continues down the hall, feeling like fucking Cinderella.
Eunsu’s voice drifts out from a small doorway Mingeun would have missed otherwise. The door blends in with the rest of the white wall, and carries the slightest scent of bleach. A cleaning supply closet? What is Eunsu doing in there?
With absolutely zero tact, Mingeun pushes the door wide open. “Eunsu! We need to go.”
“Oh. I didn’t realize I was late,” Eunsu says, blocking Mingeun’s view of the small, dark room. He seems down and not like his usual self, although that’s the way he’s been for the past couple of weeks.
Mingeun tries to crane his neck past Eunsu, to see if there’s a second person in the room. “You”—he pokes Eunsu in the chest—“are incredibly oblivious sometimes. What are you doing here? Are you seeing someone? Or are you talking to yourself? Is something wrong?”
He can’t help the way his voice rises in pitch with each question. Eunsu brushes him off.
“It’s nothing,” he says, closing the door not quite all the way.
Nosy as he is, Mingeun tries again to peek inside the room.
“You came here to tell me we have to go,” Eunsu says. “We have to perform now.”
They do have to perform now, so Mingeun lets it go. “You’ll tell me about it later, right?”
“Of course,” Eunsu says, hesitating only slightly as they almost run back to the rest of their group.
They meet Byeonghwi in the hallway, only most of the way back.
“What took you so long?” he asks. “They sent me after both of you. It’s like a horror movie, where one person goes off on their own, and the next person sent after them also disappears.”
“You were going to be next,” Eunsu teases, like he wasn’t melancholy and morose five minutes ago when Mingeun found him.
An hour later, after their showcase finishes, Mingeun corners Eunsu in the dressing room. Literally. Eunsu sits on a stool in the corner of the room, wearing half of his stage outfit. He’s discarded his jeogori in favor of a plain t-shirt, but he still has his baji on, more interested in his phone than changing.
“So what were you doing earlier?” Mingeun asks.
“Do we have to talk about it now?” Eunsu asks without looking up.
“We can talk about this now, or we can talk about it in the van.” Mingeun knows Eunsu probably wouldn’t want everyone involved in the conversation. There are some things that stay between just the two of them. Or mostly between the two of them. Andrew and Byeonghwi are the only ones still here, and Mingeun figures they’re close enough that it’s fine if they overhear whatever Eunsu has to say.
Eunsu finally puts his phone down. “It’s something you wouldn’t understand.”
“Really?” That just makes him want to know more.
With a sigh, Eunsu asks, “Do you believe in reincarnation?”
“No,” Mingeun says. “It’s…” He searches for the right word. He’s pretty sure Eunsu doesn’t, but what if he does? It’s not like religion is a common conversation topic for the two of them, unless Haksu is also involved.
“Then we have nothing to talk about,” Eunsu says. “Can you leave so I can change now?”
“I don’t see what reincarnation has to do with you delaying our comeback showcase by fifteen minutes.”
“I’ll put it a different way. You know how Haksu-hyung talks about God and his dreams all the time?”
“Idol Joan of Arc,” Mingeun says. He recalls Eunsu saying that once.
“Yeah. Religious experiences that leave a mark on you. Maybe fundamentally change who you are.”
Mingeun doesn’t like where this is going. “You had a religious experience backstage at the comeback showcase of our sixth mini album?”
“Yes. Sort of.”
“I thought you weren’t religious.”
Eunsu has the decency to look embarrassed. “I thought so. I think I was in denial. I was trying so hard to get out of my hometown and away from my parents that I thought the only way was to be someone completely different. But I didn’t have to run away like that. I think Haksu-hyung helped too. He’s just so… himself.”
Mingeun still has no idea what any of that has to do with their comeback showcase or reincarnation. He’s glad, though, that Eunsu is learning more about himself.
Eunsu must see the look of confusion on Mingeun’s face, because he says, “It’s a lot to explain.”
“It’s a lot to hear,” Mingeun says.
“Byeonghwi!” Eunsu calls. “What do you think of moths? Religiously?”
Mingeun turns around to see the youngest member pause two steps from the door.
“Ancestors,” Byeonghwi says with a thumbs up. Then he leaves.
“That doesn’t help,” Mingeun says.
Eunsu sighs. “It’s like this. A family member, someone you know, someone you were very close to, dies. Death isn’t the end, because of samsara.”
Mingeun opens his mouth to ask what that is.
Very clearly anticipating the question, Eunsu says, “The endless cycle of birth, life, and death, until we reach nirvana.”
“So you think your brother came back as a moth.”
“Not exactly. There are six realms—” He cuts himself off. “I can’t explain everything. But I left home less than forty-nine days after Yonggeum-hyung—” He stops again. “His spirit could have followed me. You probably think this all sounds stupid.”
There are tears gathering in the corners of his eyes, and for the first time, Mingeun thinks he pushed too far. The first thing he thinks of is how crying would ruin Eunsu’s makeup. He hates himself for it. He doesn’t even have the emotional capacity to comfort his friend, and their performance is over.
“I don’t,” Mingeun says. They’re the only two left now. Andrew must have slipped out at some point. “We don’t have to talk about it anymore, if you don’t want to.”
It shouldn’t have been him having this conversation with Eunsu. It should have been someone who would understand him more. But then again, is there anyone closer to Eunsu than Mingeun?
“Do you mind if I change now?” Eunsu asks, somewhat shakily.
“No, not at all,” Mingeun says. “Sorry I asked so much of you. I’ll wait outside.”
He trips over his feet in his haste to leave the room.
Standing outside the dressing room, Mingeun reflects on everything Eunsu told him. The moth. Reincarnation. Spirits. Yonggeum’s spirit followed Eunsu to Seoul and appeared to him as a moth backstage at the comeback showcase for Fable’s sixth mini album. Okay. Mingeun can wrap his head around that. It isn’t any more farfetched than the Eucharist.
Eunsu emerges not long after, wearing his own pants this time. He looks composed, like his normal self again.
“I’m sorry,” Mingeun says again, fulfilling a Canadian stereotype.
“Don’t you think it’s nice, sometimes, to talk about yourself?” Eunsu asks, completely ignoring Mingeun’s apology.
“I guess so,” he says begrudgingly. He wanted to say yes with confidence, but his only reasoning would have been that he enjoys talking about himself on camera. With Mingeun, everything goes back to being an idol.
“I’m not upset,” Eunsu says calmly. “We don’t need to talk about this again if you don’t want to.”
“Yeah,” Mingeun agrees, because he sucks ass at having any emotions other than anger and despair.
They step out into the not-quite-summer night. Jaeseop rolls down the passenger window of the van. “Is everything alright?”
“Yes,” Mingeun answers, because at the time, that’s what he believes.
59 DAYS — JAESEOP
“It’s not too late, if you want to take a break,” Jaeseop says. Their latest album released a week ago, and he can tell Eunsu isn’t into it the way he usually is.
“No, I can do this,” Eunsu says.
The pile of discarded tissues and the way he barely leaves his bed unless he has to say otherwise. Even now, Eunsu is buried under his blankets in the summer weather. It’s hard to tell it’s warm and bright outside with the curtains closed.
“I think you should take a break,” Jaeseop repeats. He sits on top the covers at the foot of Eunsu’s bed.
“I told you, hyung, I don’t need to. I can do this.”
It sounds like he’s trying to convince himself more than he’s trying to convince Jaeseop. Jaeseop is skeptical about all of this.
“Don’t push yourself too hard,” he says.
“I’m not,” Eunsu says. “This is my job.”
“No one expects you to do your job if you’re grieving.”
“I’m—we’re different.”
Jaeseop is not. He would take a break. There’s nothing embarrassing about wanting to step back for a bit, especially considering what Eunsu is going through.
“Idols are human too,” he says, as gently as he can. “At the end of the day, it’s just a job.”
“Am I just your coworker?” Eunsu asks. “What other job would have you at my bedside like this?”
“Nurse. Doctor,” Jaeseop says, even though he knows those aren’t remotely similar comparisons.
Eunsu shakes his head. He’s been different since he got back from his short trip home. Solemn, somber, older than his twenty-something years. He was always unflinchingly serious, but the air that surrounds him now has changed. Jaeseop knows exactly why. He doesn’t know if Eunsu recognizes himself in the same way.
“You don’t have to treat me like a kid,” Eunsu says. “I can take care of myself.”
Jaeseop raises an eyebrow, leaning back against the wall, flush against Eunsu’s bed. “I’m not treating you like a kid. I want you to consider all of your options. I know you don’t think you have any other choice but to keep going, but you do. There’s no shame in slowing down or pausing.”
“And I’m telling you, hyung, I don’t need to do any of that. I’m fine.”
Eunsu is obviously not fine. Jaeseop has never seen him so insistent on anything.
“What’s the name of our new album?” he asks.
Eunsu is silent. The names are often confusing and Jaeseop has started saying the wrong ones from time to time. Yet they’ve been living and breathing the party theme for over a month. Eunsu stands out in his misery. Jaeseop doesn’t want to think only of the group and the group’s image and the group’s public perception, but he has to at least consider it.
If Eunsu’s heart isn’t in to it, and he can’t fake it, then maybe it’s better if he’s not there. Taein could force Eunsu onto a hiatus. Jaeseop doesn’t want to involve his uncle in this. He can solve their problems himself.
“What are you trying to prove?” Eunsu asks.
“You want to promote something you don’t know the name of,” Jaeseop says. “You should be able to see how that sounds.”
“Byeonghwi probably doesn’t know the name of our new album.”
“Byeonghwi never knows the names of our albums. Don’t use him as your example.”
Eunsu sits up, incensed. “So Byeonghwi can never know an album name and promote just fine, but when I forget one of them, I need to take a break?”
Jaeseop says, very bluntly, “Your brother’s death makes this a completely different situation.”
He doesn’t expect Eunsu to hang his head and say, softly and sullenly, “I know. I thought I could come back and pretend nothing is wrong. To everyone else, there’s nothing wrong. Everyone around me—you too, hyung—keeps living their lives, and I’m the only one whose world is upside-down.”
He looks like he’s going to keep talking, until his phone rings. He picks it up on the second ring. “Hi Mom.”
Eunsu sounds almost chipper. “I ate earlier.”
Jaeseop knows that’s a lie. He figures Eunsu would want to talk to his parents in private. The bed creaks as he stands up.
Eunsu stares at him questioningly, and gestures for him to sit.
Jaeseop sits back down on the edge of his bed.
“Mm-hmm, I’m doing well. Don’t worry too much about me,” Eunsu says. He pauses briefly. “Yes, I’m eating and sleeping.”
The bags under his eyes become more prominent every day. He offers a few more words of reassurance, then hangs up the phone. The call is short, not more than a few minutes.
“She calls me every day now,” Eunsu says. “Sometimes multiple times a day. If I don’t answer almost immediately, it scares her. It scares me too, to see how she’s become. Sometimes think I made a mistake coming back.”
“I’m sorry,” Jaeseop offers, even though he knows it’s not nearly enough.
Eunsu waves him off. “Before, I liked being here. I liked being an idol. That’s why I thought I could come back and keep doing this like nothing changed.”
Jaeseop doesn’t like the past tense. He shifts in his seated position. “It’s your decision,” he says. Either way, whatever Eunsu decides is best, Jaeseop wants to support him. It’s his choice to make.
“I know,” Eunsu says, sounding miserable. “I was hoping you’d convince me, one way or another. You weren’t very convincing.”
“I don’t want to pressure you. I think you’d benefit from a longer break, but that might not be what you think is best for you.”
In this very specific situation, Jaeseop thinks he’s right. But to pressure Eunsu so much until he has no choice but to accept? That makes him just like Taein.
“I don’t know what’s best for me anymore,” Eunsu says, “but I want to promote this album. I’ll learn the title.”
Jaeseop supposes that’s enough for now. “Okay,” he agrees. “Remember you can always change your mind.”
53 DAYS — BYEONGHWI
In the bathroom mirror, Byeonghwi can only see the very top of Eunsu's head as he sits on the ground.
“Red?” Eunsu asks.
Byeonghwi nods, garbage bag crinkling over his shoulders.
“It's very bright.” It sounds like Eunsu doesn't approve of his choice.
“That's the point.” Byeonghwi doesn't have to be good at home-dying his hair; he just has to do a good enough job for the stylists to pick up where he left off. Taein will hate it, Daewoong will hate it, but Byeonghwi is beginning to care less of what they think.
It should be the opposite, really, because now Byeonghwi is somewhat famous. People see him and recognize him. He hasn’t decided if that’s a good thing or a bad thing yet.
He leans forward, closer to the mirror, to make sure he hasn’t missed any spots. The hardest part about doing this on his own and also having dark hair is how long it takes. When he’s satisfied, he pushes aside the boxes of dye, two toothbrushes, his and Haksu’s skincare collections, and sits on the counter.
“When you decided to become an idol, is this what you thought it would be like?” Eunsu asks.
“No,” Byeonghwi answers, quickly and honestly.
Eunsu seems satisfied. Byeonghwi is pretty sure most of them think like this. It manifests in different ways for everyone: he box-dyes his hair, Andrew is obsessed with writing a perfect album, Haksu pushes them all down for a chance to boost himself up, Mingeun is restless and always wants the next big thing. He hadn’t thought of Eunsu like that. Eunsu strikes him as someone who’s satisfied with his lot in life.
“I don’t think I gave it much thought,” he continues. “I thought an idol was just someone on TV, someone who could sing and dance. I could sing, so why couldn’t I be an idol?”
Eunsu nods, maybe in agreement, maybe in acceptance. “This isn’t what I thought it would be either. I thought being an idol was something I could do forever. That once I started, I’d be able to keep following this path, and everything would be laid out for me.”
“You’re only realizing this now?” Byeonghwi asks light-heartedly, in a very desperate attempt to lighten the conversation.
“I have a different perspective now. I wasn’t able to see any of this before.”
Byeonghwi so badly wants to say that maybe all Eunsu needs is to take a break, that maybe he’s burnt-out. Mingeun says that a lot. Maybe Eunsu is the same. He keeps quiet and lets Eunsu talk.
“It’s really changed how I think of my place in the group.”
Byeonghwi has a cold, sinking feeling in his stomach that has nothing to do with the cold, sinking feeling on his scalp.
“I think,” Eunsu says softly, almost to the point where Byeonghwi has to strain his ears to hear him. “I’m going to ask Taein-nim to terminate my contract.”
“You can’t.” The reply is reflexive.
“Why?”
Byeonghwi doesn’t have a good answer for that. “Fable wouldn’t be the same without you,” he says lamely. “It wouldn’t be the same without any one of us.”
“You’d recover,” Eunsu says dismissively. “I’m only thinking about it.”
“Stop thinking about it. Think about us instead.”
“I want to do what’s best for everyone. Myself, Fable, and my parents.”
Bringing his parents into the conversation is a low blow. Byeonghwi has spent the past three years being the exemplary son in Fable. Now he has no choice but to hear Eunsu out.
“Okay,” he says, idly swinging his legs. “What do your parents have to do with this?”
“They’re getting older,” Eunsu says. “I know my dad will keep his position for as long as he can, but what happens after that? The temple is his livelihood, and my grandfather’s livelihood, and my great-grandfather’s, and my great-great-grandfather’s, and back so far I can’t even count. I can’t be the one to give that up for some stupid idol career.”
Byeonghwi doesn’t think an idol career is stupid.
“Did your dad tell you this?” he asks.
“No, but—”
“It’s conjecture! You can’t leave the group because of conjecture!”
“It’s not the kind of thing my parents would tell me,” Eunsu says, sounding miserable. “They tell me that I can do whatever I want, and for so long, I’ve been doing whatever I want. Shouldn’t I start thinking about someone other than myself?”
Byeonghwi realizes what the problem is. Eunsu spends too much time with Mingeun. Mingeun has all these ideas of individualism and acts on the whims of his own desires and has probably never heard of Confucianism or filial piety in his entire life. It’s very clearly affected Eunsu.
“You should,” Byeonghwi says. It’s only after he speaks that he realizes his words are an admission of agreement. He doesn’t want to Eunsu to leave, but he also couldn’t imagine turning his back on his parents and a family tradition.
“I thought you’d agree,” Eunsu says. “Now you have to help me break the news to everyone else.”
Byeonghwi is blindsided and betrayed. “Did you plan this out?”
Eunsu nods. “A little. You know no one else would agree so easily. I couldn’t pull the parent line on anyone but you. I’ve been thinking about it a lot. Talking about it makes it feel a bit more real.”
He talks around the topic, never saying it’s his departure.
Byeonghwi swallows around the lump in his throat. He doesn’t want Eunsu to leave, of course. But to be stuck between your family and your personal ambitions? It’s a hard, terrible choice that he hopes he never has to make.
“I’ll miss you, hyung,” he says. “I’d give you a hug, but…” He holds up his gloved hands, tinged red.
“I haven’t left yet,” Eunsu says. “We’ll make the most of it. I promise.”
16 DAYS — ANDREW
Andrew has been writing an album for slightly over a year. He goes through phases: sometimes he's the best songwriter to ever exist, and it's a tragedy that no one's ever heard his songs. Other times everything he writes is the most cliché piece of shit to ever exist on Earth.
He doesn't have anyone to talk through it with. Intak moves so much faster, while Andrew obsesses over melodies and countermelodies and if his art is good enough. His friends are classical music enthusiasts who think it's slightly ridiculous that he's a kpop idol and indie enthusiasts who will listen to anyone, so long as they have less than a thousand Spotify monthly listeners. Fable isn’t included in that.
So Andrew works on the bits that he can, when he can. At the very least, he knows he wants to incorporate real instruments wherever he can. It always sounds better than samples or synthetic instruments.
The only parts he can do on his own are the piano parts, because that's the only instrument Andrew can play with confidence. Even then, using his keyboard isn't the same as a grand piano. Disgruntled, he deletes the recordings off his computer.
Then he recruits Eunsu. It's the bass, after all, that makes music sound better. Eunsu's short-lived cover band bassist career has always been a point of interest to Andrew. How did he have the resources, in his small town in the middle of nowhere? Growing up in a place like that is something Andrew knows all too well.
“I'm out of practice,” Eunsu says when he arrives, carrying his guitar case across his back.
Andrew dismisses his concern. “It's fine. I don't think the parts are too complicated. You’ve looked it over, right?”
It’s a bass line. How hard can it be? Andrew also sent him the music a few days ago. Surely he’s been able to practice at least a little bit, so that he’s not sight-reading when he should be recording.
Andrew busies himself with finding the sheet music of the correct parts for the correct songs. He gives up his seat to Eunsu to walk him through the process.
“The microphone is here. You can adjust the height or the position to whatever’s comfortable for you, as long as it’s within a few inches of your strings.” He pushes it around to demonstrate.
“Press the red button to record, and then again to stop. You can play back everything at once, or mute the other tracks. The recording will start at wherever the marker is. This is a draft. It doesn’t have to be perfect now.”
“This is overwhelming,” Eunsu interrupts.
“You’ll figure it out once you start,” Andrew assures him. “I’ll be here if you need any help.”
Showing anyone else his music is always a tense situation. He knows he can’t appease everyone, and even when it’s people he’s close too, it’s still stressful. What if they dislike it, and it changes their opinion of Andrew as a person? He wouldn’t be able to stand it.
But Eunsu doesn’t do any of that. He plugs his own earbuds into Andrew’s laptop, and listens. Andrew tries not to hover directly behind him and breathe down on his neck. Eunsu starts to play, a few hesitant notes echoing in the room.
It’s impossible to tell if he’s good or not. At the very least, he sounds like he’s in tune. Andrew doesn’t know what part of the song he’s listening to, if he’s warming up or experimenting. He should know what his own song sounds like, he thinks, slightly disgruntled.
Andrew expects Eunsu to ask for clarification, or something similar. Eunsu surprises him by rewinding to the beginning, and playing in earnest, foot tapping and head bobbing. Andrew pumps his fist in silent victory.
The instrument's low tones sound so much better than he had expected. He can see the rest of it coming together in his head: he'll make the piano part work somehow, maybe get a drum recording from Hwajung. Andrew entertains himself with fantasies of finally finishing some songs, then an album, polishing them to perfection, winning music shows and topping charts.
Eunsu's play style is by the book. He plays the music exactly as Andrew wrote it—down to each note's dynamic and articulation. It's devoid of any improvisations or new licks or riffs.
“Where did you learn how to play?” Andrew asks when Eunsu pauses the recording.
“I taught myself,” Eunsu says, spinning around in his seat. “My friends wanted to try and start a band. I had to be part of it, so I begged my parents to buy me an instrument until they gave in. The band never took off. We stopped after a few months. I'm the only one who still does music.”
He says it lightheartedly, like it's a story he's told over and over before. It reminds Andrew of himself, at probably that same age, making noise in GarageBand.
Eunsu changes the topic back to the matter at hand. “Let me try this one again, and then you can listen to it.”
He doesn’t wait for Andrew’s response, but goes back to the beginning of the song. He likes it, Andrew realizes, a bit belatedly and a bit hesitantly. It almost seems too good to be true.
The pride and recognition he feels buoys him throughout Eunsu’s recording. He isn’t listening too closely, content to let Eunsu play his music. Eunsu is a musician too; he can be trusted.
When the next take finishes, Eunsu hits the trackpad with maybe more force than necessary.
“Are you satisfied with that?” Andrew asks.
Eunsu hesitates for the barest second before he nods. “It was better than my first one by far.”
That doesn’t sound very promising, but Andrew refrains from passing judgment. He leans over Eunsu’s shoulder to stare down at the computer screen. From a quick glance, he can tell he’s going to need to adjust the track volume. Eunsu fidgets in the chair while Andrew reaches for the mouse.
“Don’t be nervous,” he says. “I’m sure you sounded fine.”
“Weren’t you listening?”
“With the rest of the music,” Andrew clarifies, bringing up the volume on Eunsu’s recording.
He switches the sound output to his speaker system, and presses play. Then he skips over the intro, eager to get to the parts Eunsu added.
It sounds fuller, more complete, with the bass line. Andrew was right. Of course he was right. The bass makes the songs sound better. There are a few places where Eunsu lags behind or pushes ahead of the beat. Andrew makes a mental note as he listens.
“It's not bad,” he says at last.
Eunsu taps his fingers against the body of his guitar. “If it was good, you would have said it was good,” he says sullenly.
“It was your second take.”
He leans forward to point out a few parts of the recording. “Try these parts again. You start to fall behind here.”
Andrew drags the cursor over the specific bars to specify what he means. Then he steps back to give Eunsu another chance.
It always amazes him how quickly Eunsu adapts to feedback. He’s seen it happen in the studio before: the producer or Intak will give him instructions, Eunsu will practice a few more times, and then he’ll perform flawlessly.
Today, it seems like something is off. Eunsu plays slightly better, but it doesn’t match up to the vision in Andrew’s head.
“Again,” he says.
“Did I miss something?”
Andrew ignores his question. He’s missing something, but it’s hard to describe. It’s more of a feeling—the song is fast and bright, and Eunsu’s playing doesn’t have the same energy.
“Same part,” he says instead. “Stay on beat.”
Eunsu plays it again. And again. And again.
Andrew rejects every take.
“Maybe you should learn how to play the bass,” Eunsu jokes half-heartedly. He shakes his left hand out, and Andrew sees the string imprints across the reddening pads of his fingers.
This is only the first song, and it’s going much worse than Andrew could have ever expected. He makes an executive decision.
“Let’s stop for now. You can practice a bit more, and then we’ll try again in a few days.”
For a moment, Eunsu looks like he wants to protest. Andrew is not in the mood to entertain him. But all Eunsu says is, “Okay, hyung. Let me know when you want me to come back.”
He appears eager to leave as he starts to pack up. Andrew is left contemplating. It seems the only way he’ll get anything done is if he does it himself.
14 DAYS — KIYOUNG
Eunsu’s departure is turning into an event. Which it is, of course, but he sends Kiyoung a meeting invitation titled, “Eunsu’s Departure Letter Writing Session.” Kiyoung adds it to his calendar.
When the time and day both arrive, Kiyoung meets Eunsu in the company meeting room. Eunsu sits at the head of the table, surrounded by an array of pens and paper. To his surprise, Andrew is sitting on Eunsu’s right—scowling, arms crossed, foot impatiently tapping out a beat. He’s never seen Andrew this mad before.
Kiyoung takes a seat on the other side of Eunsu, wondering what could have pissed Andrew off so badly.
“You didn’t need to invite both of us,” he says.
“I didn’t,” Eunsu says, arranging his pens. “I only dragged Andrew-hyung out of his studio a few minutes ago because he was there.”
“Do you know what he’s doing?” Andrew asks.
“I’ve had this in my calendar for a week,” Kiyoung answers.
“He told me”—Andrew checks his phone—“seven minutes ago.”
“Can you help me write my letter?” Eunsu interrupts.
Kiyoung doesn’t know the first thing about writing a departure letter. He’s written resignation letters—one resignation letter, to be exact—before, but that’s a completely different situation. It must show on his face, and Andrew’s as well, because Eunsu follows it up with, “You’re the only two people who have had jobs outside of being idols. Please?”
Andrew sighs. “Fine. Mingeun probably has a template for this kind of thing memorized.”
“Mingeun doesn’t know I’m leaving,” Eunsu says. “I haven’t told him yet either. He’s going to take it really badly.”
“He’s going to take it worse than me,” Andrew mutters.
“When are you going to tell him?” Kiyoung asks. It comes as a surprise—he thought Mingeun would know first.
“He’ll figure it out eventually. Or when I post this letter. Please don’t tell him.” Eunsu waves a piece of paper through the air. “How should I start?”
“‘Dear Fabulists’ or something like that,” Kiyoung attempts.
Eunsu puts his pen to the paper. An ink blot begins to spread from the tip. He holds it there without writing anything for a moment. Eventually, he puts the pen down. “I can’t do this.”
He buries his head in his hands. “It’s embarrassing. I know I’m going to hate everything I write. It doesn’t seem genuine.”
“If it’s how you feel, that should be enough,” Kiyoung says. This is most decidedly not the same thing as a resignation letter. He could lie out of his ass for one of those. Eunsu should not lie about this.
“That doesn’t have to be the only thing you say,” Andrew says, seemingly on board now. He scrolls through his phone. “You can write about how much you enjoyed being in the group, or how you’re thankful to your fans, or something like that.”
Kiyoung stares at him across the table. “Are you reading other letters?”
“Yes.” Andrew doesn’t even sound embarrassed. “Neither of us know the first thing about what should be in one of these letters.”
“Did you talk to Taein-nim yet?” Kiyoung asks.
Eunsu seems to shrink in his seat. “Not yet. I thought I could do this first. To show him I’m sure.”
To Kiyoung, being able to leave would come before writing the letter. But it’s Eunsu’s departure, and he gets to choose the sequence.
“Dear Fabulists,” Eunsu says as he starts to write. “This is Eunsu. Today I’m sharing with you my decision to depart from Fable and the company.”
Kiyoung interrupts. “You should add something before that to soften the blow. Like a ‘I hope everyone is doing well’ or ‘It’s been a while since I spoke to you.’”
Eunsu scratches the words “first draft” across the top of the page and adds another introductory sentence between his name and his departure announcement.
“Thank you to everyone who loved and supported me as a member of Fable. Because of you, I was able to create fond memories with my members that I’ll remember forever.”
“You’re not going to finish recording all the parts for my songs,” Andrew says suddenly, as if it just occurred to him.
Eunsu looks up from his writing. “I’m leaving the group. I don’t think it’s necessary for me to be part of an album I won’t even be here for. You don’t know how long it’s going to take you to finish it, or if Taein-nim will allow to release it.”
“I want you to be on the record,” Andrew insists. “You’re an important part of the group.”
“You thought I sounded like shit a few days ago,” Eunsu says.
Andrew shrugs, not denying it. “You said you’d practice and try again. You also didn’t tell me you were leaving.”
He seems hung up on that fact.
Kiyoung intercedes. “There’s still time,” he says, when he knows that’s the very thing Eunsu is running out of. The days will slip by, like sand through his fingers, and then Eunsu will be gone.
“I need to finish my letter first,” Eunsu says. “After that”—a shrug—“I’ll figure it out. One task at a time.”
Now that he’s started, it seems like it’s easier for him to write. The page begins to overflow with words, Eunsu’s neat handwriting stark against the white page. He edits his own writing as he goes, crossing out and replacing words, pausing only to think briefly before moving on.
Kiyoung tilts his head to read it. There are a lot of sentences about their fans, and how much Eunsu appreciates their love and support. Coming from him, it makes sense. Eunsu is an idol through and through. Kiyoung can’t imagine him doing anything else.
Eventually, Eunsu puts his pen down and stretches. “I think I’m done.”
Andrew takes the paper first, skimming over Eunsu’s words. “Do you mean all of this? Genuinely?”
“Most of it,” Eunsu says.
“Even this one?” Andrew taps one line. “‘Although I will no be recognized as a member of Fable, I will treasure these precious moments I spent with Fabulists forever.’”
Eunsu winces. “A little less on that one.”
“Then don’t write it.”
“Don’t you think the fans would want to hear it? It’s reassuring.”
There are still times when Andrew is immensely culture-shocked. Kiyoung figures this is one of them.
“It’s not a big deal,” he says. He reaches across the table and takes the letter.
It’s more or less what he thought would be in it. The line Andrew singled out isn’t even the worst one.
“The ‘I will support Fable just as Fabulists do’ is a nice touch,’” Kiyoung says.
Eunsu flushes. “Thanks. I really like that one. Do you think it’s too much?”
For Kiyoung’s tastes, it certainly is. But it’s not by him or for him. So he says, “The fans will like it.”
They won’t like his departure, but the point of the letter is closure and acceptance.
Eunsu turns expectantly to Andrew, who says, “If Kiyoung thinks the fans will like it, then it’s good to me.”
With that recommendation, Eunsu looks pleased. He takes a clean sheet of paper from his pile and starts to write a cleaner version.
“Thanks for helping me with this,” he says as he starts to write.
Kiyoung doesn’t feel like he did anything of note. He accepts the thanks anyway. “We’ll miss you.”
He thinks he speaks for all of them when he says that. There’s a lump in his throat. Kiyoung has no idea where that came from.
“I will too,” Eunsu says, pausing in his writing. “I’ll visit all the time. Don’t worry too much about me.”
He says it lightly and cheerfully. Kiyoung knows he won’t be able to do that.
6 DAYS — JAESEOP
“Get out.”
When Jaeseop asked to be treated like any employee and not like the CEO’s nephew he is, he forgot to consider all the times that it would come in handy. Like when one of your group mates wants to leave the group and you have no idea how your own family member will react.
“I’ll be alright if you go,” Eunsu murmurs softly.
Jaeseop shakes his head. “I have to be sure my uncle doesn’t try to do anything sketchy.”
Eunsu gives him a look that seems to ask something like, You don’t trust your own uncle? Jaeseop trusts him in family settings, not in business ones. He has yet to move on from when he first agreed to work with his uncle, and he was asked to break up with Seoyeon. Nevermind that they had been dating for two years at that point, and Jaeseop never asked to be an idol.
“Can you get another chair, Eunsu?” Jaeseop asks.
Eunsu looks hesitant, like he doesn’t want to leave.
“If I leave, Samchon will lock me out,” Jaeseop says pleasantly. He glances at his uncle, who doesn’t deny it.
Eunsu’s mouth forms an O. “I’ll be right back.”
For the time being, Jaeseop sits on Taein’s desk. “I hope you’re not too hung up on our image to listen to Eunsu.”
“A lot goes into running a successful business,” Taein says.
“Is that something you’d know?” Jaeseop asks with faux innocence. He could run this company better, but it’s not like his uncle would ever take his advice.
He doesn’t think it’s very sightly for CEOs to entertain the thought of murdering their employees, but that’s the look on Taein’s face.
“You always wanted seven members in the group. Have you changed your mind now?”
Jaeseop can practically see Taein seething. But what’s he going to do? Fire him?
“I made sacrifices for the eight of you. I’m the one who made it so that you could all debut.”
“You didn’t want to do it. You tried to make Mingeun lie for his career.”
“Mingeun has nothing to do with this. It worked,” Taein says.
There’s a bang on the door as Eunsu lugs a second chair in. Jaeseop jumps down from his seat and holds the door for him.
“Thanks,” Jaeseop whispers, taking a seat.
Taein steeples his fingers in front of him. “What did you want to discuss with me today?”
“I want to end my contract,” Eunsu says. If Jaeseop looks carefully, he can see the way Eunsu trembles ever so slightly, hands shaking in his lap. “I no longer think it’s right for me to be an idol, and I wish to leave on good terms.”
“You sound very sure,” Taein says. “But are you sure?”
What does that mean? “Samchon, I don’t think this is a decision Eunsu would make lightly,” Jaeseop says.
“I didn’t ask for your opinion, Jaeseop,” his uncle snaps. He turns back to Eunsu, calm again. “This is a very serious decision.”
“I’ve thought about it for a long time,” Eunsu says.
“Yet you stayed,” Taein says.
“I felt like I had an obligation to the group. I wanted to see all eight of us through the promotional period.”
“And you have an obligation to the end of your contract. Another four years.” Taein taps the pads of his fingers against his desk in an unnecessarily distracting motion.
Jaeseop doesn’t like this. Eunsu stayed because of the group, not because of his contract or Taein.
“You should explain,” he says, nudging Eunsu’s knee with his own.
“Is that necessary?” Eunsu asks, biting his lip.
“Don’t egg him on,” Taein says.
Jaeseop fucking hates talking to his uncle. “I’m not egging him on. You’re pressuring him and stressing him out.”
Eunsu takes a steadying breath, and says, “I know I have an obligation to you, and to everyone else in Fable. At the same time, I also have an obligation to my parents. Especially because”—he takes another deep breath—“because I’m their only son now. I can’t be here, in Seoul, so far away from them when they’re growing older and they need someone to learn about the family business before it’s too late.”
“It’s very tragic,” Taein says, looking as if he couldn’t care less. “That was something you should have taken into consideration before you left.”
“I was seventeen. I didn’t know any better.”
Jaeseop also thinks it’s ridiculous that death by drunk driver at the age of twenty-eight is something people should prepare for.
“I’m prepared for this,” Eunsu says, fishing out a folded piece of paper from his pocket. He’s hitting every talking point they went over in the past week. “I wrote a letter explaining my situation to the fans.”
He hands it over to Taein, who unfolds it and skims it quickly. Then he starts methodically tearing it into small pieces.
“You won’t need this,” Taein says, “because you won’t be leaving.”
Both Jaeseop and Eunsu stare at the paper scraps as Taein pushes them neatly into a pile. In every single one of Jaeseop’s daydreams, Eunsu would tell his story, maybe with some extra tears and groveling, and Taein would agree to let him leave.
“Why?” Jaeseop asks, standing up so that he can look down on his uncle. The sounds of his hands hitting the desk echoes in the small room. His palms sting, but he ignores it. “Why are you doing this?”
He can feel Eunsu tug at the hem of his shirt. “You don't have to do this for me. I'll be alright if I stay,” Eunsu says.
His voice sounds so small that Jaeseop's sense of justice rears its head. He fought for Mingeun and Kiyoung and won. He can do this for Eunsu. In the back of his mind, he thinks he should have made a PowerPoint presentation. Taein loves PowerPoint presentations.
“You won't,” Jaeseop says. He doesn't mean it in a mean way, but it's obvious, the way Eunsu is barely holding himself together.
He leans across the desk. “Samchon, are you oblivious or ignorant? You don't see how this is affecting him?”
Of course he doesn’t. That’s supposed to be Jaeseop’s job—leader and parent and therapist all at once.
Jaeseop has never done this with the person in the room before. He's sure Eunsu will forgive him for whatever he says, even if he talks about Eunsu like he isn't there.
“Letting Eunsu leave would set a dangerous precedent. Anyone else dissatisfied with their career would think they can do the same,” Taein says, looking unbothered by Jaeseop's words.
It’s obvious that he’s bluffing. As far as Jaeseop knows, no one else in Fable is dissatisfied enough with the group's direction to leave. A bit upset, sure. But to leave? That’s a completely different issue.
“I’m not dissatisfied,” Eunsu says. “I like being an idol. I like being part of Fable. It’s because of these extenuating circumstances that I’m asking to leave.”
“The reasoning isn’t important,” Taein says. “A departure is still a departure.”
“No one else wants to leave,” Jaeseop says.
Taein gives him a sidelong glance. “Not everything is about you.”
Behind him, Jaeseop hears Eunsu take another deep breath. “I can explain everything.” He pulls at Jaeseop’s shirt again. Jaeseop sits down reluctantly.
“You know who my parents are, and what they do.”
For a moment, Jaeseop doesn’t know who he’s talking to. Eunsu is almost secretive of his past. It’s like he sprang into being in Seoul when he was in high school. Jaeseop knows only the barest bones of his childhood. He sees Taein nod along, and he sits back and listens.
Eunsu weaves a tale of his older brother, inheritance, and the role he was expected to play. His voice catches every time he says Yonggeum’s name. Jaeseop has heard very little of this before, and it was all in the past few months. He wonders how long Eunsu has kept it all in. All his life?
“I think you can recognize, sajang-nim, how I never expected to be in this position.” He seems more composed now, words coming out smooth and even. “If the circumstances were any different, I wouldn’t be asking you for this.”
He stands up from his seat and bow formally, bent ninety degrees at the waist, arms pressed to his sides.
Jaeseop feels sick. Eunsu shouldn’t have to do any of this—bowing and scraping and pleading—to convince Taein of something so simple.
Taein spends a long moment taking in Eunsu’s words. Jaeseop is on the edge of his seat.
“I’ll think about it,” Taein says.
Jaeseop is almost optimistic as they leave.
“That wasn’t a yes,” Eunsu says. “I think I gave more than I got.”
“Coming from him, thinking about it is as close to a yes as you can get. Do you know any lawyers?” Jaeseop asks.
“Do you think I’ll need a lawyer?”
A shrug. “It might be nice.”
Eunsu ends up not needing a lawyer. He does need to rewrite his departure note, bemoaning about how hard it was the first time, and how he’s already forgotten what he’s written. It’s bittersweet for Jaeseop, to see him in relatively high spirits for the first time in months. He wishes it didn’t have to end so soon.
0 DAYS — MINGEUN
On August 2, 2021, a picture of a handwritten letter signed by Eunsu is posted to the official Fable Instagram. Mingeun sees the number of likes and comments jump by tens and hundreds. How is he learning about this at the same time everyone else is?
He bursts into Eunsu’s room, not even bothering to knock. “Why didn’t you tell me you’re leaving?”
Eunsu is sitting on the floor of his room, surrounded by his belongings, two suitcases, and some cardboard boxes. And for some reason Mingeun can’t even begin to think of, Byeonghwi appears to be helping him pack.
“You knew?” he asks, giving Byeonghwi in the most deadly glare he can manage.
The youngest member blanches in the face of Mingeun’s wrath.
“I told him,” Eunsu says, always the picture of calm and serenity.
“You told him and not me?” Mingeun asks, voice rising as he points accusingly towards Byeonghwi. “I found out through fucking Instagram?”
He storms across the room and grips Eunsu by the shirt collar. “Why?”
“You read the letter,” Eunsu says. He tries to extricate himself from Mingeun’s hold.
“You can’t tell me the same things you tell the fans. Does our friendship mean that little to you?” He drops Eunsu and looks wildly around the room, taking in the progress of his move out.
Out of the corner of his eye, he sees Byeonghwi slip out the door. He ignores him. Eunsu has stacked boxes and boxes and things, all over his bed and his desk and his shelves. Mingeun pushes them to the ground, one at a time, just because he can. Each one tumbles with a crash. It does nothing to assuage how Mingeun feels.
“Hey, whoa, Mingeun,” Eunsu says, like Mingeun is a fucking horse. Eunsu grabs his wrists, pinning them together.
Mingeun twists out of his grip. Between the two of them, he’s always been the stronger one. It’s a pity he isn’t strong enough to keep Eunsu from leaving.
“I know you’re upset,” Eunsu says, somehow still calm.
Upset is an understatement. If Eunsu leaves, it’s like half of him is carved away. Mingeun wants to wreck and tear and destroy, as if that will fix the soon-to-be-missing part of him.
“You think I’m upset?” Mingeun says incredulously. If he wasn’t so, well, upset, he would laugh. It’s ridiculous.
Eunsu shrugs. “Maybe a little more than upset.”
Mingeun takes a step forward and socks him across the jaw.
“Ow,” Eunsu says, massaging his afflicted face.
“You deserve worse than that,” Mingeun informs him. He feels ever so slightly better.
“I knew you’d do something like this,” Eunsu says. He starts to pick the boxes up off the floor. Mingeun doesn’t make a move to help him, even though it was his fault. “I had to wait until it was too late for you to stop me.”
“I wouldn’t stop you,” Mingeun says. It’s an obvious lie. He moves a pile of clothes from Eunsu’s desk chair to the floor and takes a seat.
Eunsu doesn’t even bother to call him out on it. “I didn’t want you to try to change my mind either.”
“When have I ever successfully changed your mind?”
Mingeun told him not to leave SM. Eunsu did anyway. He told him not to buy that ugly ass NFT (Minah told him they were scams). Eunsu did anyway, and was roasted alive on Twitter by their fans. Mingeun watched it all happen in real time in an almost self-satisfied way.
“This time could be different,” Eunsu says.
“If you say it like that, it sounds like you don’t want to leave.” Mingeun doesn’t allow himself to have hope.
“I don’t think I want to leave,” Eunsu says, beginning to stack his clothes in a suitcase.
“Then why?” Mingeun asks, frustrated. “Does it have to do with Yonggeum?”
He knows Eunsu hasn’t been himself ever since his brother’s death. He thought that was something he’d get over by now.
“It has everything to do with Yonggeum-hyung,” Eunsu says, sounding like he went to the Lee Taein School of Public Speaking. “It was his duty to inherit the temple. Mine was anything but that.”
Mingeun nods along like he didn’t hear all of this two years ago, when Eunsu tried to out-drink Andrew and got so drunk he threw up twice in the bathroom and once in his bed. The two of them had crammed themselves into Mingeun’s twin-sized bed, and Eunsu had overshared for probably the first and only time in his life.
So Mingeun knows how his idol dream took shape: Yonggeum’s wishful thinking for a way out, for Eunsu to experience everything he couldn’t; how Eunsu interpreted that as seeing the world and finding no other way to do it other than becoming a celebrity; discovering a passion for music and moving to Seoul to reinvent himself. He did that last part so well Mingeun is still jealous that he couldn’t do the same.
Eventually, Eunsu stops packing and keeps talking. “I don’t know if it was my dream or his dream. I keep asking myself what he would do in this situation. I wish he could tell me what the right choice is.”
“What about the moth?” Mingeun asks suddenly.
Eunsu tilts his head. “Moths don’t talk.”
“But when you were backstage, you had that conversation.” He feels like he’s losing his mind.
“It doesn’t work like that. It wasn’t a conversation. Moths don’t talk.”
Now Mingeun feels stupid. Of course moths can’t talk.
“So that’s it?” he says, trying to save face. “It’s over?”
“It is for me,” Eunsu says. “It’s not the end for you. You can keep performing. I know that’s what you want.”
Mingeun doesn’t have the heart to tell him that sometimes, he doesn’t know what he wants either. Sometimes he feels like he’ll cave to the pressure of everyone else’s perceptions and expectations, and he has no other way to deal with it except to continue on.
“I’ll do it for you,” he says instead.
Eunsu looks surprised. “You’d do something for someone else?” he jokes.
Mingeun scowls and hits him again.
It takes Eunsu the better part of a week to pack. In the end, he fits his whole life into three suitcases and five cardboard boxes. He overestimated the number of boxes he needed, and now the rest of them sit in piles in their living room, like a permanent reminder of his absence.
All seven of them—it’s strange to think of them as seven—see him off at the train’s platform. Taein and Daewoong are there too, but Mingeun couldn't care less about them.
He stays at the edge of the platform, watching as the train begins to pick up speed. Eunsu waves at him through the window. Mingeun waves back until Eunsu becomes a blur from some combination of the movement and his tears.
He feels Jaeseop’s hand on his shoulder. It has to be Jaeseop, because no one else would do that. Mingeun ducks his head away for a moment, drying his eyes.
He lets Jaeseop lead him away from the edge, resolute in some newfound determination. If he doesn’t take it upon himself to keep Eunsu’s dream alive, who else will?
8 notes
·
View notes