Every once in a while I get asked about whether particular pairings are problematic, or if it’s allowed to like/dislike a specific pairing, and ultimately I think my advice is the same no matter what pairing it is: you have to make your own decisions for whether you like it or not instead of leaving it up to the discretions of others.
And this seems obvious! You would think that it goes without saying that you should base your opinion on your own taste and boundaries! But the saddest part is that it doesn’t— ive seen people who are obviously interested in a pairing defer to the “popular” opinion that it’s the worst ship under the sun, solely because they don’t want to be judged for it. Alternatively, I’ve also seen people claim that you’re not allowed to be uncomfortable with any aspect of a particular ship, and bend over backwards to pretend that there’s nothing unhealthy about it at all, when it’s perfectly reasonable for people to have different opinions on the subject. Ultimately, this rhetoric leaves people unable to form and enforce their own boundaries, and it’s kind of sad to see?
Like, I have plenty of pairings that I’m personally not a fan of, but I’m never going to pretend that my personal discomfort means that other people aren’t allowed to enjoy them, yk? I just keyword mute the terms and move on with my life.
Similarly, I also have pairings that I enjoy that I know have aspects that can make others uncomfortable! And I’m not going to push those onto people that I know might not like them, since I can respect that we have different tastes.
It makes me rather worried that fandom has gotten to the point where people aren’t encouraged to make their own decisions on what they can handle, but instead have to defer to the majority opinion… it’s isolating, isn’t it? To only allow yourself to be surrounded by those who share the exact same opinions on every pairing as you? How will you ever grow if you can’t handle differing opinions from your friends? I know it’s difficult, but it’s a journey everyone has to take eventually until they win the idgaf war
27 notes
·
View notes
So Vivienne’s wonderful and I love her forever
I stan her “well have you considered getting good” approach to literally everything in her life
She is very much still in the stage of “I shall bend the system to my will”, which is an interesting illustration of why she’s the only First Enchanter around right now;
The others have all been at it long enough to notice that the system is designed and built with Vivienne specifically in mind (and others like her)
An oppressive system does not survive decades without major internal dampeners to turn or break every single ambitious star that seeks to rise and make it their own
And it’s already working on her
Kirkwall is the bad Circle, but it’s an outlier; never mind that every single Circle has the potential to become as bad or worse, based only on which templars rise to control it
The ones she’s met are perfectly lovely, obedient little guards, and she has no complaints with her own treatment (which she ensures for herself by being a powerhouse and political goddess, something absolutely anyone could definitely do for sure don’t think too hard about it)
She’s seen the “good” outcome, so she thinks the system works because it’s working for her, and she can play within the bounds of the system… and she’s not exactly concerned with helping up those behind her
The interesting part is that she’s also not entirely wrong in her issues with the rebel mages; most of the other mages aren’t at court, and didn’t see the rising danger in public opinion that Vivienne did
(And they’re all likely a lot more affected by the restrictions than Vivienne, who only goes to the Circle when she wants to and lives where she likes)
She couldn’t understand their perspective on the suffering because… yeah, this was not a great time for the mages to rebel. Right after a possessed mage murdered hundreds?
Vivienne’s right; it makes them look like they care more for their comfort than the lives of citizens, because most of the citizens don’t know the conditions the mages endure
(Most citizens are part of the shitty conditions the mages endure, but again, Vivienne’s not had rocks thrown at her for being a mage)
The thing is that there would never be a politically acceptable time to rebel. That’s why it’s a rebellion, not a polite request
There would never be a single, perfect time that no one would spin to be about the mages being selfish and caring about their comfort over lives
Now is not a good time, but the other mages aren’t choosing it because they’re impatient and don’t want to wait
They’re rebelling now because they have been pushed beyond endurance by the templars (who still have not dealt with their own rogue people wandering around and murdering random civilians, but shhhhh don’t think about that, only mages are hurting the innocent for sure)
Vivienne can’t see their urgency because she doesn’t live that life, and because the system is already busily wrapping her in a shroud of comfort
Her actual view of what she wants for the Circles is still good; a safe place for mages to learn and come together
Magic schools, protected from superstitious populace by the templars (which requires a complete 180 turn of thinking by the templars themselves on if the mages are prisoners or people)
Maybe even some basic fucking protections to stop people from getting possessed, which literally everyone needs anyway because we’re living in wood and thatch houses and every single civilian has access to fire
EVERYONE is dangerous when possessed, mages just scale up faster the more powerful they are, but the more powerful they are the harder they should be to break
Unless they’re broken and mistreated and ground down until they buy into the “us against them” that the templars and citizens force on them, and stop caring if their tormentors are hurt
Which, again, is why Vivienne’s vision for the Circles cannot be realised under the system as it stands
As long as the Circles are a place to lock up mages so they can’t hurt “good, normal people”, someone will abuse it
And the person who abuses it the most, gets their mages the most “under control”, rises to the top on a tower of magic
And the rot spreads
And when you’re on the inside, but at the top? Not being stepped on but treated with respect and reverence? Well, how hard can it be to stay there all the time? Surely they can just wait for a better time to be free
The game’s trying so fucking hard to push its “Not All Templars” agenda but it’s actually only highlighting just how flawed this logic is, and I am FASCINATED with how perfectly they’ve replicated an oppressive system without even meaning to
They so clearly want you to buy the “not all templars are bad like not all mages are good”, but the problem’s right there on the surface:
The mages are dealing with their problems
They don’t want to get possessed either, and nor does anyone else
The templars are pretending their problems don’t exist
That they don’t need to deal with every rogue templar wearing their banner, drinking their lyrium, murdering random villagers and nobles left and right
You’re literally not allowed to even bring it up to the head seeker when he’s off grandstanding
Every mage who tells you “well not all the templars are bad” tattoos respectability politics on the insides of your eyelids because that’s the whole actual problem:
It doesn’t matter if not all the templars are bad. What matters is that the good templars cannot or do not try to stop the bad ones
The bad ones are the ones in power, making the rules
Good people who follow bad rules are complicit
A rotten apple only spoils the barrel if you leave it in there to fester
Anyway Vivienne > Cullen all day every day because
1) queen of Step On Me energy
And 2) we do not blame the actions of oppressors on the oppressed, even when they are propping up the same oppressive system
Also all the templars being mandatory drug addicts is a fucking wild twist and I can’t wait to see where that goes, I am blaming it for Cullen’s weird pinchy redness around his eyes and nose
31 notes
·
View notes
predictable consequences ensued.
the fact that some ‘fans’ are viewing this as a meltdown rather than someone putting up necessary boundaries when facing unreasonable and inappropriate behaviour is disturbing. and the fact this isn’t a wake up call for some of those fans, i guess some people will never get it.
“can’t take criticism” is the new “can’t take a joke”.
these fans also don’t realize they are actively sabotaging frank’s career when they do this. who will want to work with him when predictably his ‘fans’ will harass anyone associated in his act? there is a clear pattern forming. and this is fan specific to mcr fans following dunes. travis isn’t deactivating because of coheed and cambia fans. and because social media is necessary for promotion in the music industry this can be taken as damage to his career for joining ls dunes.
travis can have coheed and cambia’s twitter for his promotion, i think anthony will be forced to keep his as he is in so many projects that he can’t use one project’s social media to promote all of them. but he basically was already ran off twitter long ago.
and also fans aren’t just horrifying people in their professional lives, they are horrifying people in their personal lives. it is hard to justify this as a career when this happens.
on a lighter note, this really shows how strong travis’ and frank’s friendship is and how much travis cares for frank to stand up for him like this. i hope the fans don’t scare him away further because travis and frank are such good guitar counterparts to each other and i know them working together we could have so many more incredible songs coming our way.
(10/09/23)
19 notes
·
View notes