Chaos Theory | Michael Kinsella x Reader
Chapter 14: We'll Be A Fine Line
Masterlist ° Chapter List
Pairing: Michael Kinsella x Reader (she/her)
Summary: Before Michael’s first day at work, he overhears a conversation between you and your sister, and the day just keeps getting weirder from there. But he still has you. Right?
Warnings: Slight angst, fluff, foreshadowing, mentions of child abuse, spiders
Word Count: 7.4k (oops)
A/n: Giving you this because I won’t be able to post before Wednesday, probably, because of my last final. So yeah, here you go. Have at it. This is not full-on angst, I'm just warming you up. Chapter 15 hurts though. Everyone, say fuck you to the spider in my room that made me sleep in the bathtub last night :) I don't know how I'm supposed to move out and get rid of them MYSELF?! (also, how can a person be so cute WHILE FROWNING??)
The first day in a new workplace is always the most challenging because you don’t know what to expect.
Michael has never paid much mind to coffee before he met you, but thanks to you, his knowledge has expanded. Does he know how to make it? No. He gets confused by your modern machine at home, and he fears he might feel the same way at the café, but it’s the place he met you, so it’s connected to happy memories.
He is a fast learner, or so he has been told. And when you told him that you used to live off of instant coffee and couldn’t afford Starbucks or the like, and so you also paid no mind to good coffee before, he felt a little less alone.
You learned, so he will too.
“Caramel or hazelnut?” you ask, sitting at the dining table with your cup of coffee in hand and your phone before you on the table.
Until a few seconds ago, you were engaged in the New York Times’ new Wordle game that dropped this morning, and now you’re blurting out random questions and Michael is so confused, he almost drops his mug.
“Wha’?” he asks back.
He looks cute with his hair disheveled, wearing his boxers and a shirt, and his face still scrunched up from sleep.
You look at him with a smile. “Hazelnut or caramel?” you repeat your question.
“Uh… hazelnut?”
“Wrong, caramel.”
His frown deepens. “What?”
“Best topping flavor,” you say. “It’s caramel, not hazelnut.”
Shaking his head, he turns back to his coffee and pours some extra hazelnut syrup into his brew, right in front of your face.
You point behind him. “Toss me the caramel syrup, will ya?”
“If I toss it, yer not gonna catch it,” he says.
“And what makes you think that?”
“You put milk in the cupboard when yer sleep deprived.”
You pause for a second before nodding, a soft blush coating your cheeks. “That’s fair,” you reply. With a heavy sigh, you return to your phone.
Michael sits down next to you, peeking at the screen. “Ya still lookin’ fer a five-letter word?” he asks.
“Yeah. It’s really pissing me off. Like, what the fuck am I supposed to do with an E and an S?”
“Try ‘Feast.”
You type the word into the Wordle boxes. The letter T lights up orange and your eyes light up. He loves when that happens. You look like a child on Christmas Day, and something tells him you didn’t have many moments in the past where you got to be excited like this.
His thoughts flicker back to the drawer you religiously keep locked, and his curiosity flares up again. It’s dangerous; when he gets curious, he often gets curious enough to snoop around. But he knows if he deliberately breaks into the drawer, he will lose you forever, and he doesn’t want that to happen.
“Meets,” he blurts out.
You raise your eyebrows. “Meets?” you ask.
“Yes.”
You type the word in, and lo and behold, it turns out to be the word they were looking for, and the screen explodes with confetti. You squeal in excitement and jump off your chair before sitting back down, pulling your leg up to your chest.
“Amen,” you say.
He smirks. “You’re welcome.”
“Right,” you remember and add, “Thank you, baby.”
Humming, he says, “That’s better.”
You cradle his cheek with a playful glint in his eyes and kiss him, then indulge back in your coffee. You savor the taste, your eyes closing, and you slowly begin to wake fully. You have to get ready soon, but for soon you want to spend your peaceful morning with the man you love.
He hasn’t stayed with you that much the past couple of days, which made you a little sad, but he is here now. You spent the night together. You didn’t have sex, much of the opposite. When Michael heard that you like to watch football, he got excited and convinced you to watch the Manchester game. Needless to say, it ended in a discussion about your favored team against his, and you went to bed with popcorn still stuck in your hair. You can swear there is still a piece stuck somewhere from your food fight, even after a shower.
Though when your phone rings and Maya’s name shows up on your screen, your demeanor changes completely. Your body tenses up and the adrenaline starts coursing through your veins. “Excuse me,” you mutter, completely blocking out that it’s Michael you’re with, “I have to take this.”
He frowns again. Something isn’t right. You tense up instantly, and he catches a glimpse of a female name on your screen. Your smile fades. Instead, the corners of your mouth turn down.
You get up and pass by him without another word, disappearing into the bedroom. He knows he shouldn’t do it, but your behavior is suspicious and he feels the desperate urge to protect you from whatever got you switching attitude this quickly. So against his better judgment, he gets up and follows you, stopping just before the bedroom door.
And he is glad he decided to do so because as he stands there, he finally catches another glimpse of who you truly are beneath all the layers of endless defenses and brick walls you have built around yourself. They are almost impossible to break through, and hearing you talk in a hushed tone to whoever is on the phone opens up another door to your heart he hasn’t seen before, and apparently doesn’t get to see when you’re in his immediate presence.
You answered the phone with a sudden and firm, “Are you okay?”
“What?” Maya says. She sounds almost carefree, and you relax a little when she continues, “I just called to tell you that I found something very exciting for you during my field trip.”
“Are you fucking–” You sigh. Idiot. “I thought something happened to you,” you say.
There is a short pause. “I’m okay,” she says.
“Thank God! Next time maybe give me a heads up. Maybe a quick ‘Hey, I’m calling because I’m happy not because I’m half-dead in a ditch’ or something. I don’t know.”
“Sorry.”
“No, don’t– I don’t want you to even start that. I fell into a habit of constantly apologizing for things I didn’t do because of him and I don’t want you to feel like you have to do the same.”
“Okay… I’m sorry.”
“Maya,” you take a warning tone.
“Okay, okay, chill out! I won’t apologize,” she retorts. “Jesus, you old people are all so condescending.”
You gasp. “Old?!”
“You know what I mean. Anyway, can I tell you now what I got you?”
You can’t deny that teenagers are exhausting. As much as you love your sister, they tend to be a lot more honest than the general population.
Sitting down on the edge of the bed, you cross your legs to get a bit more comfortable. “Sure,” you say, your lip curling into a smile instead of a frown, and you listen intently as Maya tells you about a new historical romance book and that she got it for you.
“Anyway, I have to find a way to mail it to you,” she says. “If I can sneak past Dad and Mom somehow, I can sneak into the post office, and then off it goes.”
You’re not used to hearing her so cheery, and it melts your heart. That’s the kind of girl she’s supposed to be. Excited about buying a book and smiling about it, and skipping happily on the phone with you on her way home. She’s not supposed to live in constant fear of her parents, and she’s not supposed to feel responsible for taking care of her own mother. You went through the same thing, except that with her, your father isn’t as… violent. But control and emotional abuse are also a form of violence that will leave a child scarred forever. He has a weird way of showing his love.
And with you, he just didn’t like you that much. It took you a while to realize that what he was doing was abuse, but when you realized you were the only child of his getting caught in the crossfire because you were the oldest and the most disappointing, it hurt even more.
You wouldn’t wish it upon anyone, but you were so alone taking care of everyone and still not being enough. It hurts, still, but you don’t let it get to you. You try to, at least.
The reason Maya keeps the connection to you hidden is not to protect herself but you and your mom, and that is sad in itself because she’s only a teenager. She’s your little sister, your little girl, and it sucks absolute balls that every attempt to get her to live with you somehow failed or didn’t even end up in motion because of the fear of consequences and causing more harm than good. It sucks and you hate it and it makes you sad.
“Just be careful, okay?” you say. You love the thought of receiving a gift, but you can’t have her risking her safety because of it.
She sighs wearily. “I know.” And gone is her happiness, instead replaced by dread.
You can hear her shoulders slump as she continues walking, and it breaks your heart as fast as it had melted. Now it is hard as a rock again, and it breaks right through.
“How’s everything else at home?”
“It’s… okay. Dad’s been rather normal, and he doesn’t suspect anything. I apologized, we made up, and he eased the control a little. And Mom… well, she’s being Mom. She didn’t have a seizure again, so her meds are working, but she had some fresh bruises when I came home from the field trip, and I–” Maya takes a deep, shaky breath. “I hate it,” she says.
Your words exactly, and her helplessness makes you want to book a ticket for a flight home and just snatch her when nobody’s looking. At this point, you don’t even care about personal or legal consequences, you just want her to have a chance at a normal life. Like Michael.
Like Eleanor should have had.
“I’ve been writing mostly A’s,” she tries to lighten the mood, “So that is something good, I think.”
You can’t describe how proud of her you are for keeping her head up throughout all of this. You should have never left, but it got too much, and you were tired of being the one who had to take his rage all the time, and you were tired of being forced to stay strong when everyone else got a chance to grieve. Two years you took the abuse, and you took it almost nineteen years before that. You deserved a chance, and you took it when it presented itself.
But you shouldn’t have left her alone. You should have found a way to fight and win, and you should have taken her with you.
A tear escapes your tired eye. “That’s good,” you say, trying not to sound as broken as you are, “I’m so proud of you.”
“Thank you,” she answers, hearing it genuinely for the first time. “Dad’s been calm because of that.”
“That’s possible, yeah. He was like that with me when I brought home an A, but that wasn’t often.”
“I know… I’m sorry.”
“It’s okay. Don’t worry about it.”
“I’m just scared that he’ll find out about us and then… I don’t want him to hurt you again. You remember what he said—”
“Hey,” you interrupt her. “Stop. I know what he said, but it won’t happen because he won’t find out,” you say. “If we’re both careful enough, that is. I want nothing more than to protect you. You know that.”
“But this isn’t about me,” she argues.
“Yes, it is. It’s always about you.”
“He will take his rage out on you.”
“If he does, I will find a way to deal with it. As long as no one alerts him, I’ll be fine. My only concern here is and will always be you, Maya.”
“But what if someone does alert him?”
“I can’t think of anyone who would.” You don’t have enemies. You’re always kind to others and aim to please them. No one has ever been dissatisfied enough to threaten you or wish death upon you, so you’re confident no one in your life would ring the bells in England.
“I really can’t think of anyone, and that’s a good thing,” you insist. “So we just take care and I’ll be fine, and you are going to be fine, too. One day soon, I will get you here and we’ll be alright.”
You hope, at least.
She pauses again, taking another deep breath. “But let’s imagine he does,” she prompts.
“I’ll cross that bridge if it ever comes to it,” you say. “If he tries to kill me… well, let him. I will find a way to fight back. I survived eighteen years of his torture, and then another two years, and I will survive now, too. But he won’t come here. If he wanted to hurt me, he would have already. My whereabouts are no secret.”
“Your address is.”
“He probably found that out already. So you see, I’m fine and I will be fine. So stop worrying. Please.”
“Okay,” Maya caves eventually. “I believe you. As long as you promise me not to dig into anything that could alert him. And I’ll try to be careful around him.”
“Trust me,” but this time, you are lying to both her and yourself, “I won’t dig into anything.”
“You have the files.”
Damn her for being so smart and aware of everything.
“I haven’t dug into anything for a while and I’m happy just like that,” you tell her. “I won’t risk it. I promise.”
“How happy?”
You smile, looking at the door and thinking about the man in your kitchen–you believe he’s in the kitchen. You’ve kept your voice hushed and he’s not one to pry.
Except that he is, and he‘s standing frozen in shock in front of your bedroom door.
You bite your lip. “Oh, I’m just happy. Happy enough to admit it.”
“I’m glad. Out of everyone, you deserve it the most,” she says.
“Thank you…” You smile sadly. “I wish for you to find the kind of happiness I have here one day. It’s better than living in fear or pain all the time, anyway.”
“Thanks. I hope so, too.”
“I wish you could have grown up with Ellie, it would have been so much better for you,” you say. “But we’ll figure it out.”
The past always gets you so damn sentimental.
“I guess we will,” Maya replies. “Well, I’m almost home, so I gotta hang up now.”
“Right.”
“Talk to you soon?”
“Sure.”
“Okay… love you!”
You wipe another tear from your cheek. “I love you too,” you say.
The line clicks and she’s gone. Just like that. You put the phone down and stare at the wall. The emotions swirling in your chest drag you down and tear you apart, and it hurts so much more than any knife ever could.
You try to calm down, trying not to seem like you have been crying because Michael always notices, and your defenses come back up.
Time to face the day and be there for him, and then you will open that drawer and look at the file again because if you don’t, you might go crazy. The dominos have started falling; you can’t stop them now, anyway.
Once he’s in prison, you can get Maya because he will lose custody and visitation rights, and your mother is an emotional wreck, so you are the one they would grant custody to. Thirty years old, now in a relationship, a job with a stable income, and an apartment. They would give her to you because you’re family and she’s a teenager; she can take care of herself for the most part, and you’d be her confidant and caretaker when she needs it. You want nothing more than that.
Even if it means moving to London and leaving four years of Dublin–and Michael–behind, you would do it.
Surely, he would understand. And you could go for a long-distance relationship, or he could come with you. You would make it work without losing him.
But you would choose Maya over the man you love any day because when you love someone like a child, they will always come first.
Michael stands in the kitchen, leaning against the counter, and smiles softly when he sees you entering. “Ya alright?” he asks.
You nod. It’s a lie. You’re far from alright, but you need to focus on what lies before you, which is his first day at work, and maybe you can find it in yourself to forget for a while again as you did at the carnival.
“I’m alright,” you lie.
“Good.”
“Yeah.”
But now even Michael knows you’re far from alright. Not just today but in general; overhearing your phone call set off the alarms in his head, the most prominent one ringing for your safety. It sounded like you’re in danger, and that from your own father; he gets how it is. He had an asshole of a father and if he ever comes back and touches his daughter or you, he will rage. But it’s your father now, too, and he is scared of what might happen.
He has to protect you at all costs, no matter what.
He welcomes you with open arms when you place your head on his chest and hug your arms around him. You’re seeking comfort, and after what he overheard, that is no wonder. He wishes you would tell him and then you can find a solution, and he can find a way to protect you when he knows just what he has to protect you from. But you stay silent, closing your eyes and melting into the hug. This is what you need.
One hand rubs your back, the other coming to rest on the back of your head. He almost covers you whole and pulls you impossibly closer. You sigh. His touch is made of gold, it seems. It never fails to make you feel like you’re the most important thing in the world to him.
“You sure yer okay?” he asks.
“Yeah,” you murmur. “Can you just hold me?”
He places his chin atop your head. “Yeah.”
“Thank you.”
You shudder slightly but then relax under his soothing touch again. His heartbeat resonates in your ear. You match your breathing to him, and you can feel part of the weight falling off your shoulders.
“Do you think we’ll be okay?” you find yourself asking into the silence.
His thumb glides over your scalp. “Okay with what?” he asks.
“Just in general. Are we gonna be alright?” you ask.
Michael sighs, tightening his grip on you. “It’s a fine line between bein’ alright and not bein’ alright.”
“I know that. Can you just… answer me, please?” You don’t want to cry. “Just for now, tell me what I want to hear, even if it’s isn’t the truth.”
“We’ll be alright,” Michael tells you, not missing a beat with his answer.
He’s worried, but you relax in his arms and his heart beats a little slower when your tears subside before they can fall.
He sounds determined, his voice unwavering, and the softness of his touch tells you that even though the road ahead might be rocky, he will stay by your side until things are alright again.
You relax further. You should tell him, but you can’t. If things resolve themselves, you can figure it out on your own without bothering or endangering him. Once he knows, his family will find out, and the more people know, the more danger Maya finds herself in–and you’re not entirely safe either.
You like to pretend you’re not scared and it doesn’t bother you, but there is something terrifying about thinking about your own parent and feeling the goosebumps creep up your spine as your amygdala goes crazy with worst-case scenarios. It keeps the body awake at night as the mind reels around the conflicted emotions the soul is communicating, and every night, you feel like a piece of you is dying inside.
It has been like this ever since you were a child, and it only keeps getting worse.
While getting ready later that morning, you turn to Michael and ask, “Dinner tonight?”
He snaps out of his thoughts, spitting out his toothpaste and nodding at you. “I’d love to,” he says.
“Good, we have a date.”
“Date it is, then.”
You kiss him on your way to the bedroom where you left your outfit for the day.
You just want to forget, and a night with him having dinner and trying to be carefree sounds like the most conscious thing to do.
He helps you close the zipper on your dress in silence, adjusting the necklace you chose to wear today, and fixing your hair after it got a little messy. His lips ghost over your shoulder and he follows the galaxy of moles with gentle kisses.
Wrapping his arms around you, Michael inhales the scent of your perfume. “Yer so sweet,” he says.
You close your eyes and lean against him. “And you’re charming,” you say.
“That’s why ya love me.”
“Is it?”
He smacks your ass. “Yeah.”
You giggle, pulling away from him again. “Not today, sir.”
He pouts. You kiss him.
“I love you,” he whispers.
You return the sentiment with a gentle smile, “And I love you.”
Now his first day at work just has to go better than your morning, and then, you assure yourself, everything will be perfectly alright. Or it won’t, but either way, you have to try. For him, for Maya, and for yourself.
Once you arrive in front of the café, you stop him. “I have to warn you,” you tell him, “My friend, Sarah, isn’t too happy about you working here. She’s the one I keep telling you about.”
He straightens his jacket.
“Not your biggest fan,” you say.
“I figure not many people are gonna be,” he says. “I’m used to it. It’s fine.”
“No, really, she is a little firecracker. When she’s mad about something, she’ll show you, and she won’t be nice about it.”
“Not my first rodeo, love.”
“You shouldn’t have to deal with it though.”
He pulls you in, the nerves slowly getting to him, and your words don’t do much to soothe his nerves. They barely even prepare him. “I’ll survive,” he says, but he’s not that sure anymore.
His heartbeat picks up and you can feel his pulse racing against your fingers from where you’re holding onto him.
With a soft sigh, you smooth out his collar, pressing your lips on his as you do so. “I’ll get her to come around, I promise,” you say. “I always do somehow.”
And you wouldn’t let Sarah ruin Michael’s day.
He smiles. “I know you will. Ya always take o’ me.”
You sense the slightest shift in his demeanor, the unshed tears and the nerves. “Nervous?” you ask.
“A little, yeah.”
“You’re gonna do great. Be happy Ava appointed me to be your mentor for the day. I’ll be gentle.”
“You can be bossy with me,” he jokes, and his attempt to charm you works instantly.
The day is going to be interesting, indeed. But at least he takes your mind off of things. It’s like he knows and wants to take care of you, and it is working.
“Maybe I will be,” you say in the same sultry tone.
“Oh, don’t make me wanna bend ya over a table. That’s not gonna go well, pet. For neither of us.”
You shrug. “Keeps things interesting.”
Michael sighs, but there is an amused glint in his eyes that tells you he isn’t upset or annoyed with you. “I’m gonna have a hard time with ya today, don’t I?” he says.
Pinching your fingers, you answer, “Just a little.”
“Alright. Well, I can live with tha’, too.”
And so you make your way inside, praying to God and every other deity that Sarah won’t cause a scene.
Oliver is there, too, because it is the busiest day of the week, so maybe he will diffuse the situation. Maybe they can even become friends. He needs those. From what you could tell, he doesn’t have any, and that’s sad.
You walk into the café hand in hand, and that is something you thought would never happen. You’re used to being behind the counter and serving him; now you’re both going to be there. It’s an evolution, you suppose, but it’s a good one. Good for him, good for you, and good for everyone because he is charming and attractive–on second thought, you’re not sure if offering him a job was such a good idea.
You’re not jealous, you tell yourself, but you are possessive and it shows.
You’ve never had anything that was truly yours before, so meeting Michael and falling for him, even the process alone, makes you want to claim him the same way he has claimed you, and you will continue doing so.
“Would you look at that!” Oliver exclaims behind the counter. “My favorite person. And the newbie.”
“Good morning,” you greet him with your usual cheery attitude.
You pull Michael to stand beside you, and he awkwardly shifts. He’s tense and slightly trembling, so you squeeze his hand in reassurance, telling him that he’s got this. He can conquer anything he sets his mind to.
“Good morning to you too, sunshine. How’re ya?” Oliver asks.
“I’m good, yeah. This–“ you point to Michael. “This is Michael,” you say. You want to get this over with before he implodes.
“The boyfriend,” he nods, “and the newbie. Yeah, I figured. You wouldn’t be holding hands with just anybody.”
Michael gives an awkward smile before letting go of your hand and deciding to be bold. He remembers you told him that Oliver is a convict, too, and it makes him feel less alone in this space full of pure souls like yours.
“Michael,” he introduces himself.
Oliver takes his hand. “So nice to meet ya!” he says. “I’m Oliver, and you are very attractive.”
He stops and stares for a moment before the blood rushes to his cheeks. “Oh, I–“ he chuckles. “I’m flattered, but I’m– I’m taken.”
“I know, the beautiful specimen over there wouldn’t shut up about ya.”
You blush and shoot him a glare, but he brushes it off with a giggle.
Michael raises his eyebrows. “Is that so?” He looks at you. “Ya wouldn’t shut up about me?”
You should have known the revelation was going to boost his ego.
“I just mentioned you once or twice,” you defend yourself. “Don’t let it get to your pretty little head.”
“All I’m hearin’ is that yer obsessed with me.”
“You’re obsessed with yourself, that’s how it is.”
He smirks. “Sure thing, love,” he says, and you want to slap him for teasing you so obviously at work. “That’s how it is. I’m so obsessed with myself, my girlfriend talks ‘bout me at work.”
Showing him the finger first, you then pull him with you into the back room. His smirk never fades.
“Oh, what are we doin’?”
You shove an apron into his hands. “Working,” you answer.
He sighs. “Of course, we are.”
You continue showing him where everything is, handing him an apron to put on. He puts what few belongings he brought with him into your locker, and you lock it. You hand him his keycard for the register, emphasizing though that he’s not there yet and you will show him how to man the register some other time. Today, he has to learn all about coffee, and you are the best teacher for that.
Michael’s nerves fade into silent excitement. This is so much different than working at the dealership. Amanda only trusted him with washing cars, thanks to Frank, but here, with you, he gets to have responsibility, learn, and do something good with his hands that has more meaning than washing cars as some kind of punishment for not wanting to sell drugs or kill people for his family anymore.
He feels like he belongs. The scenery might be strange, still, but you make him feel at ease with your calm and kind demeanor that you show every customer who comes in, too, even the rude ones. He has a lot to learn, especially from you, but he is sure he can navigate it somehow. And with you, he isn’t afraid to ask questions.
You point out all the different machines behind the counter, the drawer with the topics that don’t need to be kept cool, and then those that need to be. You show him the wall with different coffee beans and whipped cream in case the current can run out. He notes what you tell him, your voice a soothing sound in his ear amongst the bustling of the café. Who would have thought that the Butterfly Effect would lead him to this particular position?
When Sarah finally comes out, you tense up. You have been anxious about their first meeting all day, and now that the time has come for them to actually meet, you’re not sure how it will pan out.
“Hi,” says Michael as he approaches her, and he is a lot more confident now. “You must be Sarah, right?”
She’s carrying a box that seems a little too heavy for her to carry. She eyes him, her smile fading, and her jaw locks.
“I’m Michael,” he introduces himself when she doesn’t answer. “Heard good things about ya.”
Sarah shoves the box into his open arms. “That goes over there,” is all she says and points over to the other end of the counter.
Even though he is confused, he remembers what you said about her not being very excited about him being here, and he figures she needs time to warm up to him. You’re friends so you must have told her about him long before you got together, and now she’s weary because you chose to date him despite his past, which he still hasn’t quite understood. You don’t care about what he did or the kind of person he used to be, and might as well still be; you only care about him because you love him, and you can overlook all of his dark sides. He doesn’t deserve you, and Sarah seems to think the exact same thing.
It hurts him a little. He can deal with judgment, but she is your friend, an important person to you, and he wants nothing more than to get along with your friends and everyone he works with. He wants to make a good impression to keep this job, impress Ava, and show his solicitor at the next meeting that people are willing to take a chance on him. And that he finally has a support system that isn’t limited to his family, which looks bad on all documents given their history.
But he has you and he has a good job, and maybe he can make friends with the rest of the staff, too. Oliver seems happy that he’s here, ready to teach him some things whenever you’re busy–Michael appreciates that more than he knows.
There is a silent understanding between them. Maybe it’s prison, maybe it’s the fact that they both carry the guilt of having hurt someone–in Michael’s case, it was someone he loved, but it still ended in death–or it is something else entirely. Whatever it is though, he is grateful for Oliver’s willingness to help him wherever he can.
“Sarah,” you approach her. “What was that?” Your voice is hushed so he won’t hear you giving her a run-down.
She rolls her eyes. “I told ya–” she begins, but you cut her off.
“That wasn’t fair, and you know it,” you say. “You should go and apologize to him, right now!”
“Hell no,” she says. “I told ya, I’m not a fan of him and I’m really not in the mood to try.”
“What is wrong with you?”
“I just care about you.”
“Then you’d accept him!” You say it a little too loud, and the customers closest to you shoot you a nasty glance. You apologize with a kind smile before turning back to your friend. “If you cared about me even the tiniest bit,” you say, “You’d try accepting him and not treat him like he’s scum on earth.”
She sighs. Her defensive demeanor slips a little, and she nods. “Fine, whatever,” she retorts. You doubt she means it, but at least she caved.
As she moves on to clean some tables, you watch Oliver and Michael from a distance.
Oliver has always been a patient man, but it seems even better with Michael. He explains everything, shows him the ropes, and he makes sure to praise him whenever he gets something right. That’s the kind of reaction you had hoped for from Sarah, but she can’t be persuaded so easily, and right now you don’t really like her, you’re just angry.
Oliver calls your name. You turn around.
“Would you be a dear and get some more milk from the basement?” he asks.
“The basement?” you repeat.
“Yeah, the basement. You know where the cooler is, don’t ya?”
“Of course, I do. I have been working here for years. But the basement,” you emphasize, “is not a place I wanna go.”
“Why?”
“Because it’s dark and there are probably infestations of gigantic spiders in every corner of the ceiling.”
“Mate, what–“
“I hate spiders!”
Michael, who has been washing the dishes at Sarah’s command–she is currently busy restocking the shelves–turns around with an amused grin.
“And you make fun o’ me ‘cause I’m scared of heights,” he says.
You roll your eyes. “If I’m not back in five minutes, a spider has probably eaten me,” you say.
“Oh, I’m sure they’d love a taste.”
“Michael, darling, I mean it very sincerely when I tell you to fuck off right now.”
He purses his lips and throws you a kiss through the air. You catch it, pretending to throw it away, and he feigns hurt with his hand on his chest.
Turning around with a dramatic sigh, you make your dreaded way to the basement, hoping you won’t encounter one of the spiders in the corners of the ceiling that you have been avoiding for quite a while–ever since you started working at the Butterfly Effect, actually. Seeming busy and avoiding bringing milk back up is your secret weapon, but with Michael there today, you don’t have as much work and can’t seem busy because you’re not, so you’re stuck on milk duty
You curse Oliver for making you face your fear. This is the last thing you wanted to do today.
Michael continues washing the mugs with a soft chuckle. He takes it very seriously, making sure everything is hygienic before putting it on the rack beside the sink.
Out of the corner of his eye, he can see Sarah reaching for one of the boxes on the highest shelf; she’s not nearly tall enough, even with the ladder, and he knows something bad is about to happen. Shortly after, as predicted, she bumps against one of the glasses and it tips over the edge of the shelf.
She gasps, trying to catch it, but it starts freefalling. Instinctively, Michael reaches out. He catches the glass before it can shatter on the floor. He’s not sure how on earth he managed to reach for it this fast.
Sarah stares at him in disbelief. He meets her eyes and smiles. “Caught it,” he says.
She climbs off the ladder with a huff, tearing the glass from his hand.
“Do ya want me to clean the top shelf? I may be better able to reach it.” His hazel eyes are soft as he gazes at her, his body language open and sincere.
Sarah’s fists ball and she tries hard not to look directly at him, but one look into his eyes is enough to decipher the honesty, and it makes her feral that he is so nice to her.
“Stop that,” she says.
“Stop what?” Michael asks, his eyebrows furrowing a little. He puts the glass aside where it’s safe and dries his hands with a towel. “Did I do somethin’ wrong?”
“Yer not s’posed to be nice,” she clarifies, glaring daggers into his skill, but there is something resembling kindness in them; she doesn’t know he caught it. “So stop being nice to me,” she keeps her voice low because it often causes people to recoil. Not with Michael though.
He stands there, watching her. He tries to read her or somehow interpret her body language. He tries to understand what she’s feeling and what he can do to earn some of her trust. She isn’t an open book, but she also doesn’t have a million walls around her like you do.
“I just wanted to help,” he tells her softly. “Sorry if I overstepped.”
She leans against the counter. “Fuck…”
“Sarah, I–” He takes a step forward, sorting his thoughts and trying to bring up the courage to continue, “I can't change my past, my blood, or my name, but I can assure ya that I love her more than anything,” he says. Your name is a mere whisper on his lips. “I would do anythin’ to protect her, without hesitation.”
“Anything?” Sarah cocks an eyebrow.
“Anythin’, yeah.”
Sarah's gaze flickers with a mixture of emotions—doubt, worry, and something else he can't quite place. She takes a step closer, her voice barely above a whisper. “She's been hurt in the past, and you... If you hurt her, I swear to God—” She doesn’t have to finish her threat because he knows what she means.
Michael knows he shouldn't do it. It is wrong and she already doesn't trust him, and it might seem desperate and suspicious, but the secrecy is starting to eat away at him because he doesn't understand the magnitude, and he needs to find a way to understand before it's too late.
“I understand. I do, but…” His eyes meet her. He looks almost guilty. “But I need to know... how badly was she hurt?” he asks. “What happened to her?”
He should have figured that if you didn’t tell him the whole story, Sarah probably doesn’t fall into your category of people worthy of knowing the truth, either.
Sarah takes a deep breath. Some of the sturdiness from before fades away. “You don't know what she was like when she first moved to Dublin,” she says, playing with the laces on her apron. “She was a wreck, and her relationships were just as messed up. There was this one boyfriend in particular... He seemed to bring out the worst in her. But she wouldn't open up about why she chose him or men like him.”
“Did she ever come home with bruises?”
“Not bruises in particular, but… mentally, she was a wreck, and he just seemed to make it worse.” She sighs. “He was a rugby player, and I truly thought it was the worst she could do.”
Michael scoffs. “But ya realized you were wrong because then she met me?” he finishes for her, the unspoken argument finally being voiced.
Sarah sneers, but he hit the nail right on the head, and she doesn’t need to agree to let him know.
He nods slowly, looking into the seating area before turning back to her. You got hurt, and you had bad relationships, but you were broken before that; you were broken before you even moved, and you came to Dublin heartbroken and alone, and you paved a way of heartbreak for yourself because you didn’t know better. You only knew hurt, so you chose your men like your father.
He should have never listened to that phone call. Michael is quick to connect the dots after hearing Sarah’s words, and it shocks him to his core. His blood freezes in his veins. He wants nothing more than to pull you aside and demand the truth so he can figure out how to help you, but he would lose you. He knows he would lose you, and he decides against it. You will talk to him one day, and when you do, he will be there for you in any way you need. Until then, he has to offer you silent support and catch you before you can hurt yourself again.
“Well,” he says and crosses his arms over his chest, “I never want her to go through anythin' like tha' again. I want to be the one who brings out the best in her, who helps her heal. I’m tryin’ to do right by her.”
Sarah studies him carefully. Slowly, a flicker of understanding begins to form within her. They both want the same thing for you, it becomes clearer now.
“You'd do anythin' to protect her?” she asks him again.
He nods without missing a beat. “And you wouldn't hesitate?” she asks.
He nods again. “I’d burn the world down for her.”
She purses her lips. “You’re different, Michael,” her voice is softer now. “I didn't think I'd ever see her with someone like ya. But I can't deny that she looks happier. It pisses me off a little because I'm not supposed to like a mobster as her boyfriend, but you seem to be a good guy.”
Michael's gaze never wavers. “I know I'm not... worthy of her,” he says, “And I know I'll never be worthy of the kind of person she is 'cause she’s fuckin' amazing, but I wanna try. I have to try, y'know? I promised her.”
“Michael, I–” She can’t find the right words to say whatever she’s thinking.
“I loved and I lost in the past, and I never thought I’d get a second chance, so I was thinkin’ about givin’ up before I came in here and met her. She’s the best damn thing that has happened t’me in eight fuckin’ years and I would never ruin that. Ya have to believe me, Sarah. I would never hurt her the same way she was hurt. I love her so much, I–” He takes a deep, shuddering breath. “I just love her,” he says, “and I won’t make the mistake of losin’ her.”
For the first time since he met her, her eyes soften visibly, and her heart opens up to him. “You really love her, don’t ya?” she asks.
“With every fiber of my being,” he whispers.
That's when she realizes you were right all along. All it takes is to meet him, and whatever she thought he would be fades into the background. Sarah realizes that Michael is not the villain and he will probably never be. He may carry the burden of his past, but his love for you shines through. A man like that deserves your devotion and a chance at redemption, and she feels foolish for how she acted around him.
She feels stupid for talking about him the way she did to you and making you feel like your relationship wasn't accepted. She probably made you angry and guilty at the same time, and she wants nothing more than to make up for her own idiocy now.
“You better keep that promise, Michael,” Sarah says. “She's been through hell, and she deserves nothin' less than genuine love and happiness. I can see how much she means to ya, and I want to believe in what ya told me. I'm... I'm sorry for how I treated you, tha' wasn't fair, but she’s my best friend and I will raise hell if she ever gets hurt again.”
“She won’t get hurt, not on my watch.”
“I hope fer your sake that’s true. And I hope ya know what yer getting yourself into. She's not an easy person to love, but she's worth it. Just make sure yer there for her when she needs you the most.”
“I promise,” he says. “And thank you fer– well, for tryin’ to understand. It means a lot.”
She raises a finger. “Don’t think yer out of the woods yet,” she tells him, “but I can see the love in your eyes and… no one has ever looked at her like tha’, so I will support ya. Both of you. And if you ever need anythin’,” Sarah offers him a smile, “Don’t hesitate to ask.”
His shoulders slack as the relief washes over him. “Thank you,” he repeats.
She brushes him off with a simple, “Don’t thank me, just be good to her.”
And he vows to do so every day, the same way he vows to protect her with his life if need be.
She bites her cheek, turning back to the ladder leading up to the shelf. He watches her features contort as she contemplates, and then she finally turns back to him. “Can ya help me with cleanin’ that shelf now?” she asks.
Michael smirks, putting his towel away and approaching her. “Happily,” he says.
They may not be friends, but they bonded over their love for you, and it is something important to have in common. They both want the same for you; they both want you to be saved and loved, and Michael will do everything in his power to give that to you.
Only a few minutes later, you finally find your way back from the basement, carrying four cartons of milk. “I was almost eaten by two very large spiders!” you declare. “They were the size of my fucking head and now I am very disgusted. I didn't know we were living in Australia. Also, Oliver-” you point at where your colleague is standing and switching out the offer signs at the door, “I hate your guts for making me go down there.”
Oliver only smirks, triumphant that it wasn't him in your position. “Well, as long as you got the milk, you won the Spider War,” he says. “You're Spider-Woman now. Act like it.”
You roll your eyes. “Yeah, yeah, laugh all you want,” you retort. “Just wait until I lock you down there to be eaten alive.”
Michael, finally done with the top shelf, approaches you. “So, the size of yer head, huh?” he asks. He uses his hands to measure your face, tapping the crown of your head gently, then squeezing your cheeks. “Are you sure they weren't just tiny little spiders?”
You scoff, crossing your arms. “They were gigantic, Michael!” you insist. “I'm not exaggerating.”
“Really? How big? Show me.”
“This big–” You demonstrate the size of the spiders with your hands. However, with each gesture, the space between your hands gets smaller and smaller, much to Michael's amusement. “See, they were huge! Like this!” you barely leave any space between your fingers. “This big,” you say. “And their legs were hairy. Hairier than your chest.”
He bursts into laughter, unable to contain himself. “What, that big?” he teases. “I didn't realize we have giant mutant spiders here in Dublin.”
Feeling a bit exasperated, you pout. “Stop making fun of me. It's not funny! They were scary!”
He chuckles softly and pulls you into his arms. “I'm sorry, love. I didn't mean it,” he reassures you, pressing a tender kiss against your temple. “I know they creep ya out. I’m sorry.”
“They do,” your voice sounds muffled through his chest.
“Trust me, if those spiders even dare to come close to ya, they’ll have to deal with me. No spider is going t’ lay a single leg on ya.”
You hum in approval, hugging him back as tightly as you can. “Good answer,” you say.
“And I am disgusted,” Sarah mutters behind you. “Can ya move this to the backroom or somethin’? I’m trynna focus on work.”
Oliver chimes in, “Leave the lovebirds be.”
“I would if their actions wouldn’t call me lonely in fifteen different languages.”
“Jealousy,” he sings.
She swats him with her towel. “Shut up!”
You and Michael exchange a glance before reluctantly pulling away. He presses another kiss on your forehead, but then it’s time to resume work, and you have a lot more to teach him before your shift ends.
Tagging: (let me know if you want to be tagged, too!) @bellaxgiornata @mattmurdocksscars @ms-murdockswift @your-not-invisible-to-me @shouldbestudying41 @glowstick-lesbian @acharliecoxedfan @roseallisonparker @norestfortheshelbywicked @1988-fiend @loveroftoomanyfandoms @mattkinsella @schneeflocky
45 notes
·
View notes