The Last Song - Chapter 13
Series Masterlist
Pairing: Eren Jaeger X Female Reader feat. Armin Arlert
Genre: Rockstar AU, Friends with Benefits, Angst, Smut, Fluff, Romance, Hurt/Comfort, Mutual Pining, Slow Burn
Series Summary: Eren Jaeger has two personas, a charismatic lead vocal who has lost himself in fame, and a boy who struggles with depression, seeking for someone to bring him back to where he was twelve years ago. Where he only knew love in the form of your name.
Chapter Summary: Professing your love to one another is the easy part. The hardest one has yet to come. Are you ready to be in a relationship with him? Should you even be in a relationship with him? Are you ready to risk your friendship for it? You need to be able to answer these questions before you take a step further.
Content Warnings: explicit sex (cunnilingus, blow job, fingering, hand job, car sex, dry humping, drunk sex, public sex, unprotected sex, one night stand, choking, treating women like objects, dub-con, corruption, face-sitting, sex toys, daddy kink, praise kink, slight degradation, etc), substance abuse (use of drugs, alcohol, tobacco), severe abandonment issues, childhood trauma, anxiety attacks, depression, adultery, physical abuse towards men and women, family issues, abusive parents, crude words, dark humor, mention of sexual assault/rape, harassment, car accident and child abuse.
Poster art by the most talented @rainbuniart (follow her on Twitter)
Eren calls out your name.
His velvety voice feels like a hand clasping against your own, drawing you close to the surface until you fully emerge from what felt like the longest yet sweetest dream you’ve ever felt in years. You blink your eyes awake, slowly drifting back into reality, and the first thing you’re aware of is the softness of his lips as they draw designs on the bare skin between your shoulder blades.
“Sweetheart, wake up…” He showers you with delicate kisses that speak nothing but the affection and the adoration he holds for you. His fingers gently push your hair to the side so he can trail his lips from your nape down to the shape of your spine. You’re lying down with your stomach pressing against the sheets, your face sinking in the comfort of your pillow. “Baby…”
You slowly turn around to face him, eyes blinking unhurriedly as you’re spellbound by how handsome he is with his hair down, silky strands cascading beautifully to his shoulders. His viridian irises are a shade brighter underneath the morning sun, like every green hue of the forest in summertime. How is he real? You ponder, as he looks almost ethereal.
“Hey…” He casts a smile, so fragile, it looks like it’s made from glass on the verge of breaking.
“Hey…” You mirror him the same way, albeit still hazy from sleep.
His eyes begin to droop, one hand reaching out to frame your face, his thumb sketching comforting circles along your cheekbones. So beautiful, he wonders, his gaze softening as he tucks some loose strands behind your ear. “Did you get a good sleep?”
You hum, nodding weakly as you turn a bit sheepish from how tender he’s staring at you. “Why are you already dressed up? It’s still early.”
“I’ve got a signing event in a few hours so I gotta go.” He ends his sentence with a light touch of his lips against your temple. “Sorry for waking you up. I wanted to let you rest longer but I couldn’t just… I didn’t want to leave without saying goodbye.”
His lines cause something delightful to swirl inside your stomach. You promptly rub your eyes away from sleep, sitting up on the bed. “Must you go?” You question him with a little pout, bottom lip jutting out cutely. “It’s Sunday. Can’t we just lie around in bed all day?”
“Don’t do that,” Eren pleads with a yearning sigh. “You know how much it kills me to resist you when you’re being cute like this.”
“Sorry,” you titter. “I’m kidding, I’ll be fine. Good luck with the event. I’m sure you’ll do great.”
“Thanks.” The boy, who’s taking a seat at the edge of the bed, frames your chin. “You’ve got a little bit of drool here,” he chuckles, rubbing the corner of your mouth with his thumb.
“Oh—umm—you shouldn’t look at me.” You attempt to swat his hand away from your face in shame but Eren catches it instead, leaning in to let his lips linger on your knuckles. He peppers soft kisses as if he had all the time in the world to spoil you. You peek through the curtain of your bangs, meeting his gaze when he pulls away, both touched and mortified at the sudden tenderness.
He’s being much sweeter than usual, but there’s something heartbreaking in the way he sees you. Even if his mouth is shaping a grin, there’s still a spark of sadness in his eyes and you wonder what causes it. Have you said something wrong? Something out of line? Did something happen last night—
I love you.
Your eyes widen at the memory of the lines you exchanged with him just a few hours ago. The words he said, the way he said them, those saccharine kisses you shared, and the way he kept your hand intertwined with his like he couldn’t bear the thought of letting it go—everything came back in a flash. ‘I’ve never loved anyone else as much as I love you,’ he told you, ‘I’ll never be able to love anyone else the way I love you.’
Your cheeks heat up instantly, your hands threatening to jump up and conceal your face behind them. Oh my God… Panic floods your chest at once, causing your heart to pound excruciatingly fast inside your chest. You recall the way you replied to him in the same way, baring everything you felt in your heart out in the open. This is it. There’s no going back. You’ve both finally taken a step further in your relationship and some consequences need to be taken.
What has our friendship turned into?
Eren scrutinizes you with his eyebrows raised in question but it doesn’t take long for him to notice the way you turn pale, your hands gripping so tightly against your duvet for comfort until every bit of your nails turn white. He knows that you must have remembered what happened last night. He can see how you’re trying to hide your anxiety, and although it kills him, he decides to play his role. He’s not perfect, but Eren is always a much better actor than you are.
“You don’t have to act on it,” he says, snapping you out of your stupor.
“H-huh?”
“Those words you replied to me last night. We can pretend that never happened.”
His eyes no longer peer into yours as he turns around to face the other side of the room. He laces his fingers together, resting his hands on his lap, his head hanging low.
Your grip around the fabric tightens, as well as the invisible knot inside your chest. “You…” Your throat feels like it’s made of broken glass, scraping against your skin every time you speak. “You want to pretend we didn’t just say I love you to each other?”
His jaw clenches, his shoulders sagging forward as he fiddles with his fingers. “I don’t,” he says, so quietly, it almost sounds like a distant echo. “But if that’s what you want, then—“
“I don’t.” Your response startles him, and Eren promptly spins his head toward you, eyes largening in surprise. “I’m sick of pretending, Eren. Last night, we were brave enough to tell each other how we truly felt. I’m not gonna go back when we’ve finally reached this point. I won’t let you.”
The throb inside his chest is intense enough to cloud his mind, and he turns speechless, unsure if he’s hearing this right.
“Did you mean it?” You query, causing him to stiffen. “Eren, when you told me you loved me, did you mean it? Or was it just a spur at the moment?” He can hear the quiver in your voice, can tell the way you’re still panicking inside and how you’re trying your best to prioritize his feelings over yours. “Be honest with me,” you add in a whisper. “Please…”
His eyes turn hooded, his fingers clasping against one another a little too tightly. The only time he’s ever this restless was on the morning after you two shared your first kiss in the car—one that you did because of the alcohol that took over your system. Even when he had heard you responding to his feelings the same way last night, Eren is still doubtful of how you truly feel. For him—for someone who has been lied to countless times by the person he loved the most— the words I love you that came out of your mouth sounds too good to be true. Like a dream. A mere fantasy.
Nevertheless, he speaks the truth. “I meant it.”
You hold your breath, your heart hammering against your ribcages. “You’re in love with me?”
“Yes.”
Last night, you were too shrouded by emotions to think but now… Now you can ruminate more with your head instead of your heart, and even though joy still runs thickly through your every vein just as much as last night when you first heard the words, uncertainty also follows right behind it. What comes after this? you wonder as you feel like the floor begins to crumble underneath your feet. Now that we know each other’s feelings, what’s next?
No, before that, there’s something you need to know. “Eren.”
“Hmm?”
“How long have you been in love with me?”
Twelve years. “Does it matter?” He utters instead, smiling timidly.
“It does,” you stoutly say, though there’s a hint of a quiver in your voice. You’re in frenzy, afraid of finding out the truth. If he’s only been in love with you recently, you can probably breathe easy. But if he’s been in love with you for years—before this friends-with-benefits relationship even started—then…
I will never be able to forgive myself.
How could you ask someone, who’s so deeply in love with you, to engage in a relationship that only revolves around physical touches and nothing more? Just how much have you hurt him in these last few months by saying that you didn’t want to fall in love with him when he already fell too deep for you? All those rules you made to keep your relationship strictly physical; just how many times have you torn his heart open with them?
You’re so overwhelmed by panic and fear, that your eyes are already glazed with unshed tears. You nip at your lower lip, forcing yourself to stay calm. Please…. You beg. Please tell me you’ve only fallen for me recently. I can’t stand the thought of hurting you any further than this.
Eren doesn’t have to be a psychic to be able to read your mind. To him, you’ve always been so transparent. So when you vocalize his name again with your voice breaking on the edge, he draws you into his arms, cradling your head against his chest as he lays his chin on top of your hair.
“I can’t remember exactly when I started to have feelings for you,” he answers, his voice soothing as he lies through every word. “But it’s all I’ve been thinking about these last few days and—” There’s a crack in his voice that he tries to solve by clearing his throat. “I didn’t mean to blurt it out to you like that but I guess I was just too caught up in the moment.”
You want to pull away so you can read his face but he lays a hand on the back of your skull, keeping you still in his embrace. There’s a fat chance he won’t admit it, but you keep asking the question. “You’re not lying to me… Are you..?”
His heart skips a beat. “When did I ever?”
And it breaks him because all he’s been doing is lie by hiding his feelings from you, or the fact that he’s been in love with you for years. He’s too big of a coward to confront you about it, afraid that you might agree to be in a relationship with him just because you want to respect his feelings. Just because you don’t want to lose him. He doesn't want that. He wants to hear you say you love him because you are in love with him. He doesn’t need your pity. He needs your honesty.
“But we don’t have to do anything about it,” he repeats, his lips are grazing against your strands as he quietly speaks. “I just told you how I felt about you, that’s all. Nothing’s changed. It’s…” He breathes out heavily. “Maybe you didn’t mean it in the same way as I did but when you told me you loved me too… It already made me feel so happy and that’s enough.” He embraces you tighter, his fingers slipping between your locks. “You don’t have to do anything else. That’s more than enough for me.”
Then, Eren… Why do you sound like you’re about to cry?
“I meant it,” you say and he goes rigid in your arms. This time, he allows you to break away, wanting to see the look in your eyes as you elaborate further. “When I told you I loved you, I meant my words. I love you, Eren,” you confirm it once more, cupping his cheek with one hand. “I really do. So much that it scares me.”
Blush blooms on his cheeks, brighter than it has ever been. He rubs his nape—a habit that occurs whenever he’s abashed—as he tries to figure out words to say, but what else is there to speak of? You’ve already said everything that needed to be said, even the ones that he couldn’t yet convey.
“I feel the same way too,” he covers your knuckles with his palms, keeping your hand pressed against his face. His breathing rags. “I love you so much, it scares me.” You share smiles and soft chuckles for a moment before Eren turns jittery once more. “Do you… love me as a friend?”
“As a friend, a brother, a lover—I love you as everything at once. I care about you more than anyone else. I want you more than anyone else. When I said you were the only one for me, I didn’t mean just now. You’ve always been the only one, and you’ll always be.” You retract your hand from his face, taking his between yours and holding it tightly. You don’t know what’s gotten into you—all this bravery to speak everything you’ve been keeping to yourself. Maybe it’s because he seems like he’s still afraid of putting his faith in your words that you’re trying your best to convince him of the truth. “I’m in love with you just as much as you love me, Eren—probably even more. So please don’t look like I’m breaking your heart to pieces because the feelings are mutual.”
“I don’t—” His flush spreads down to his neck, painting both tips of his ears crimson. “You’re saying so many things right now, I’m—I don’t know how to respond—”
It’s adorable the way he loses his composure, completely baffled by how blunt you’re being but no amusement creeps to your face. You’re too heavily focused on getting him to understand your point. “You don’t have to respond,” you tell him. “Just say that you believe me.”
Eren’s eyes move back and forth as they search yours. “I… believe you.”
“Good, because I truly meant what I said.”
“Every… word?”
“Every word.” With a smile, you circle your arms around his neck, pulling him close until what separates your body from his is the thin layer of his shirt and nothing more.
He melts in your arms, letting out a breathy sigh out of content. “I’m so glad…” Eren whispers as he embraces you tighter, his lips brushing against your bare shoulder. “I’m so glad you feel the same way…”
You can sense just how much relief washed over him through his words and you realize that oh, so this is how it feels like to be in love. You feel more than just joy. You feel grateful. You feel lucky. You feel… truly alive. You didn’t realize that there was a part of you missing, that there were words itching to be said, and now that you’ve crossed the line, now that you’ve spoken everything you wanted to say, everything feels complete. You feel complete, and so does he.
Is it okay for me to be this happy? You can’t help but wonder. To be this loved by someone as perfect and beautiful as him? It just feels so surreal, like a dream that you’re afraid will end the moment you wake up. And the reality is that, even when you both love each other, there are still risks lying on your path.
“Eren,” you pull away slightly. “Do you… remember what I told you that night?” One look at your face and he knows what you’re referring to but he gives you a moment to speak. “Admitting that I’m in love with you doesn’t mean I’m no longer scared of having a relationship with you. I’m still afraid. With anyone else, I won’t think too much about it because if things don’t work out, I can move on with my life and say goodbye to them forever. But I can’t do that with you—I won’t do that with you. I’m not gonna take that risk. If there’s even the slightest chance of me losing you, I’d rather—”
Eren bends his head down to meet your lips, his hand grabbing a handful of your hair to hold you in place. The kiss only lasts for three seconds before he breaks away, scrunching his nose when he says, “Okay, first, we’ve got to do something about your morning breath.”
“Wha—” Your face glows instantly and you launch a light punch toward his chest.
Eren laughs as he catches it with one hand. “Second,” he continues, washing your pout away by landing a cute peck on your nose. “You need to calm down. I didn’t ask you to date me, did I?”
“Yeah, but…” You shift away. “You told me you loved me.”
“So?”
“So…” You were jumping to conclusions, you just realize that. You got way ahead of yourself. Flustered, you weakly mumble, “I just thought you also wanted us to become official. Like, putting a label on it.”
“I do want to put a label on it and I’m sure you do too, eventually.” He lands a hand on the top of your head as a way to comfort you. “But we don’t have to rush. I think we both need time to process this.”
You feebly nod, looking up at him through your fringe. “But are you… all right with that?”
“Of course I’m all right with that.” He ruffles your hair, grinning. “Actually, it puts me at ease. This way, I can finally stop telling myself ‘no, I’m not forcing her to do anything she doesn’t want to.’ You’ll come to me when you’re ready, and whether you want to be with me or not, it will be your own decision to make.” He bends his head down, meeting you eyes-to-eyes. “And when you agree to be in a relationship with me, which I’m sure you will,” his lips curve up into a smirk, slowly regaining his confidence little by little. “I’m gonna love you so hard, you’re going to regret not agreeing to it sooner.”
You gulp, cheeks blazing hot as you look away. “W-well, until then, we, uh… We’re okay, I guess?”
Eren chuckles, gathering you in his arms again. It’s more playful the way he hugs you this time, like how a sibling would hug another, squeezing your body until you’re having trouble breathing. “We’re more than okay,” he snickers. “We’re in love.”
“Oh my God, stop it.” But you squeeze him back, loving his warmth, loving his deep laughter that rumbles through the air, loving him.
When a moment has passed and the sound of the ticking clock on your wall reaches his ears, Eren says, “As much as I love staying with you like this, I really do have to go.”
“Oh, shit, yeah.” You yank yourself away. “Can you give me five minutes to wash my face? I want to walk you out.”
“Sure.”
You hurriedly step down from your bed, only to notice that you’re still in nothing but your birthday suit. “Can you, uh, turn around?” You ask him as you gather your blanket to cover your front.
“No.” He smirks. When he sees you glaring at him, he adds, “Look, I’m gonna be gone for a while and I won’t be able to see you naked until then. I’m trying to make every second worthwhile while it lasts.”
“You’re so annoying.” But you sigh in defeat and climb down from the bed, making your way to the bathroom without sparing him a single glance, knowing that you’ll explode from shame if you do.
Eren observes your nude body from behind. “Slap your ass for me, baby.”
“Gross!”
***
“So, I haven’t told you this but CBN’s Music Awards is happening in a week,” Eren reveals as you walk him out to the front door. “It’s a three days show. I think you can watch it live on TV. We got nominated for two different categories.”
“What—CBN?!” You gape, jaw dropping in shock. “That’s amazing! Congratulations!” You stand on your tiptoes to plant a quick kiss on his cheek. “I’m sorry, I haven’t been keeping up with stuff other than my job, but oh my God, I’m so proud of you! You’ve gone so far, Eren.”
In his eyes, you’re like a little puppy that wags her tail excitedly at the thought of seeing her owner being clouded with joy. “Thanks,” he says, stepping out of the doorframe and turning around to face you. “The thing is, I need to prepare a lot of things for the show. We’re one of their opening acts so we’ll be performing on day one. There’s gonna be a special performance where we’ll be covering another artist’s song.”
“Oh? Have you made your choice?”
“Well, it’s not final yet, but I’m planning to go with one of Harry Styles’ songs.”
“Harry Styles?” You frown. “Really? Never pegged you as a 1D fan.”
“Hey, he’s actually a pretty brilliant songwriter. Plus, we’re doing it as, like, a tribute for last year’s winners so we don’t have many options to choose.”
“Whatever you say, bestie.” Your cheeky grin is shortly replaced by a whine when he pinches your nose. “I don’t think his songs would suit your style, though?”
“I’ll make it work.” There’s confidence in his voice, lips curving into a cocky smirk. “Anyway, just letting you know beforehand that I’ll be busy for a while. There will be a lot of photoshoots, interviews—” He interrupts himself with a groan, “—and everything else that’s equally boring.”
“Keep your spirits up. It’s gonna give Empire more exposure.”
“I don’t care. All I wanted was just to make music.”
You chuckle at his grumble. “You can do that and do your interviews.” You playfully pat his cheek, making fun of his pout. “Cheer up, Rennie.”
The nickname only makes him act even more childish than before. “But we won’t be able to spend much time together,” he mumbles, his bottom lip protruding.
“It’s okay.” You assure him with a smile even when you can already imagine how lonely it would feel being alone in your apartment. “I understand that it’s your job and that you need to focus on it. I’ll still be here. I’ll wait for you every day.”
His hand finds your face, thumb brushing against your lower lip as he promises, “I’ll make sure to come home to you no matter how late it is. Even if it’s five in the morning and I have to get back to the studio at eight for another practice, I will come home to you.”
Your skin tingles, heart palpitating. “If you’re too tired, you can just crash someplace near the studio—”
He cuts you off with a kiss. “I want to.” He lets his face hover near, shyly staring at you in the eyes. “Is that… okay?”
You lean into his hand, cupping his knuckles with your palm. “Of course. I’ll be waiting for you at home like always.”
Eren lets out the softest of giggles but you can feel the elation that washes over him. “Is it also okay for me to say, honey, I’m home when I—”
“Oh, shut up.” You step forward and claim his lips in another kiss. You are laughing against each other’s mouth before Eren seizes your jaw and angles his head to the side. He presses your lips together like how people share kisses at airports, full of love and desperate longing. It reminds you of the day when you exchanged goodbye kisses before his trip, only now, it’s ten times harder to let him go. These kisses are no longer driven by lust, only affection. And the moment you hear him whisper, “I love you,” between his soft, languid kisses, and the passion that melts his lips together with yours, you know that waiting for him to come home would be torture. Being separated from him for even an hour would already feel that way.
Your heart beats so thunderously, you’re afraid you’re going to faint. His three words send goosebumps breaking all over your skin, and when you sigh into the kiss, Eren imprisons your face with both hands, kissing you deeper.
“I’m gonna be back soon, okay?” he says as he presses your foreheads together and you nod. He kisses you again once before he parts ways. You bid him goodbye with a smile and your lips tingled from his warmer ones; your hand having the hardest time disentangling itself away from his. Eren has only taken a few steps away before he turns on his heels and runs back to you. He scoops you into his arms for one more kiss, filled with muffled giggles and juvenile grins before he lets you land back on your feet. “Go,” you say, playfully shooing him away.
“Oh, before that,” he says. “Harry Styles’ Adore You. Play it, listen to the lyrics, and think about me.” He winks, a bit naughtily. “Like how I’ll be thinking of you when I perform it on the stage.” Ignoring your blazing cheeks, Eren ruffles your hair, pecks your head once, and walks away with spring on his steps. Not a few seconds later, he disappears from your sight but not from your mind.
Come home to me soon, Eren.
***
As he waits for the elevator to arrive on your floor, Eren retrieves the ring he placed on your finger last night. Holding it between his thumb and index finger, he stares at it fondly, his imagination running wild. The three words you said to him—the words he’d been dying to hear—reverberate once more through his ears and he can no longer keep his smile from breaking widely on his lips. One day, he promises with nothing but joy erupting in his chest, I’ll ask her to marry me one day.
If he could do it today, he would’ve done it but his mind doesn’t allow him to just yet. He’s getting ahead of himself, he knows. But even if it seems too far-fetched, confidence is building within him. It no longer feels like a dream that would never see the light of day. It feels like something he can turn into reality. Something that you can turn into reality.
“Ah, fuck,” Eren throws his head back, his smile never leaving his face. “I wanna marry her already!”
I want to make her mine.
Forever.
***
Eren has been coming home very late or returning to the studio very early in the morning in the last five days, there’s no in-between. Even so, he stayed true to his words. No matter how little time he had, or how exhausted he was, he would always come home to you. Though he was too drained to hold up a conversation, he would never forget to surround your body with his warmth as he laid next to you in bed, limbs tangled underneath the sheets until you could no longer differentiate which ones belonged to you. He’d have his lips brushing against your nape, his chest completing the dip of your spine as he murmured a soft, “I love you,” a moment before he waned to his dreamland. For him, it was enough. Even just a glimpse of your face was enough to keep him energized through the day.
Eren isn’t a morning person. In the past, whenever he had no schedule for the day, he would wake up around two in the afternoon, or maybe ten if he was in a mood for brunch. He rarely had breakfast on his own, but knowing how you always had to go to work at eight in the morning, he would make sure to wake up around the time you were having your breakfast. He would take a seat on your opposite at the dining table, pouring cereal into his bowl with his eyes barely opened. He’d spend the next ten minutes, at the very least, just staring vacantly at his bowl.
“You really don’t have to wake up early to have breakfast with me, you know,” you would always tell him, eyebrows adjoined together in concern of having him fall face-first on the table.
Eren would then take a spoonful of his cereal, jam it into his mouth and reply with his mouth full and his eyes bleary from sleep. “It’s okay. I want to.” It was very sweet and endearing of him so you let him be, mumbling out your gratitude which would paint a drowsy smile on his lips. One time, he even tried to make you a cup of coffee, pouring a huge amount of salt into your drink as he mistook it as your creamer. You never allowed him to step close to the kitchen counter ever again.
In these last five days, however, the roles are reversed. Eren wakes up at six in the morning since he has to be back at the studio for an early meeting at seven. You try your best to do the same, making sure that he gets to have his breakfast and morning coffee before he starts the day.
“You’re really acting like a wife,” he coos, sitting on the counter with his legs dangling a few inches in the air. He’s been watching you cook in the last fifteen minutes while he sips his coffee, loving the way you wear your apron around your waist with your hair messily tied up in a bun. “Look like one too.”
“Be quiet, you’re distracting me.”
“Distracting you?” He settles his cup aside, jumping back to his feet. “Believe me, darling,” he moves closer, gliding one hand down from your waist to your thigh. “I haven’t even tried.”
You playfully slap his hand away. “Keep doing that and I’ll let your eggs burnt.”
Giggling like a child, he embraces you from behind, landing his chin on your shoulder. “Smells good, Wifey.”
“You are so embarrassing,” you mutter in response and yet, there you are, trying extremely hard not to ruin your poached eggs as you turn bashful.
You sit at his opposite at the dining table like always, exchanging conversations with smiles staying permanently on your faces. Eren sometimes has his leg stretched out, playfully nudging you with his foot to get your attention. When you raise a questioning brow, asking him with your mouth full, “What?” He simply replies, “Nothing. You just look cute today.”
“Finish your breakfast. You’re running late.”
“Hey, how about you cook for me again tomorrow, wearing only your apron?”
“Eat, Jaeger. Or I swear to God, I’ll shove it down your throat.”
“Boo, meanie.” He’s acting younger than his age with his pout and his mischievous grin, and you didn’t think it would suit him, but it does.
***
You’re about to hit the bed in your sleepwear when you heard your front door being dragged open. Eren walks in with his bag slinging on one shoulder, uttering, “Honey, I’m home,” as he steps further inside your apartment. You roll your eyes but your heart thumps faster.
“Stop saying that.” You welcome him with a kiss as always, with Eren tapping his lips once more with a boyish grin, asking you for another.
“Can’t. It’s already a habit,” he snickers, dodging your little punches.
“I didn’t know you were going to come home early today.”
“Yeah. Levi’s giving us some time to rest before the event tomorrow,” he says as he lets his leather jacket slides off his shoulders, leaving him only in his fitted black shirt and jeans. You make him a cup of coffee as you both stand in the kitchen, making small conversations about his day. Eren always enjoys telling you what he did in the studio as he can see the curiosity in your eyes. He can tell how you’re genuinely interested in what he’s doing for a living and it makes him adore you even more.
A moment later, Eren strolls away to the living room with his mug in one hand. He takes a seat on the couch, tilting his head cutely to the side as he pats his thigh. “Come here, babe,” he says.
Your couch is big enough to fit four people sitting in a row but whenever you took a seat beside him, he would always pull you to his lap. Today, however, he just straight out asks you to do it. Knowing how persistent and stubborn he can be, you sigh in defeat and take a few steps forward with a cup of hot chocolate between your hands. You try to take the empty spot beside him but he quickly wraps both arms around your waist, pulling you down until you’re perched on his thighs.
“What about you?” he asks, nuzzling his nose against your strands once before he lays his chin on top of your head. “What have you been doing when I wasn’t around?”
By this point, you can manage to stay unfazed even when you’re being this close to him. You take a sip of your drink, licking the chocolate off your lower lip as you lie your head on his shoulder. “Nothing much. Went to work, did my articles. Did some laundry too when I got home.”
“Hmm, very productive.” He chuckles softly, taking your glass with one hand when you offer it to him for a taste. He raises it to his lips, blowing air to reduce the heat. “Did you think about me?”
“I did when I masturbated earlier.”
He chokes on his drink, holding his mug mid-air as he coughs a few times. “Wha—you—” His eyes turn watery, cheeks glowing red. “You jerked off?! Without me?!”
“No,” you snicker, taking the glass away from him and setting it down on the table, next to his own mug. “But I’d lie about it again to pull that reaction out of you.”
“You are so annoying.” Eren punishes you with a kiss, his fingers slipping between your strands, tugging firmly at the locks. The kiss doesn’t turn too deep or too long, and he playfully bites your shoulder before he returns to his earlier position. “Now that I think about it, we haven’t had sex in like forever.”
“It’s literally only been five days, Jaeger.”
“That feels more than a year to me.” When you turn around to give him a look, he just shrugs. “What, I’m a man, okay? Men have needs.”
“Yeah. That’s why you sleep with your fans all the time during tours.”
It was a joke. It was supposed to be a joke. You didn’t mean to sound so jealous, but that’s exactly how you seemed in his ear the second your words leave your mouth. Even when you try to cover it up with a laugh, and say, “Sorry, that wasn’t funny,” Eren still notices the discomfort in your chest. He always does.
Tightening his arms around you, he grabs a hold of your chin, turning your face slightly to meet his. “Hey,” he calls out gently. "You know I don't do that anymore, right? Nor am I going to do that again. I only have you now.”
You look away, stomach somersaulting at his words which sound more like a promise than anything else. “It’s okay, you really don’t have to say anything to assure me. I was just kidding, really.”
“Even if you were, I still want you to know.” Eren pushes your hair to the side so he can marvel at the bare skin of your shoulder. He settles a kiss on the spot that makes you shiver, the spaghetti strap of your camisole slipping off to your upper arm. “I love you,” he whispers, mouthing each syllable directly to your skin. “There’s no one else but you for me.” And it’s always been that way, Eren wishes he could say more, but the way you’re growing stiff in his arms makes him stop. He tilts his head, attempting to catch a glimpse of your expression. You have your lips pressed tightly together, cheeks heating up at his confession. “Baby,” Eren smiles, soothing fingers resting against your jawline. He spins you around to face him once more. With only a single look, he can already tell how you’re feeling. “You’re turning shy. What is it?”
“Nothing,” you mutter, growing more abashed. “I’m just not used to it.”
“Used to what?”
“You…” You exhale, your heartbeat thundering in your ears. “Saying those words to me.”
“What, you mean 'I love you’?”
You answer him with the tiniest nod, face aflame.
Ah, how can she be this cute, Eren wonders, sighing as if all the strength is leaving his body. You leave him powerless, sometimes even breathless with that pout and that beautiful scarlet flush painting your face. Eren carefully whirls you around on his lap and you follow his lead, straddling his thighs until your chest is a few inches away from his. He gazes softly, dragging his eyes slowly from one corner of your face to another. He tucks a few strands of your hair behind your ear. You don’t know how much I adore you, do you? He speaks with his eyes, lips slightly parted as he’s captivated with your beauty. Every touch of his delicate fingers feels like tiny sparks of fireworks on your body, thrilling. “Well, then…” He smiles, cupping your face. “Let’s change that, shall we?”
You’re not sure what he’s referring to until he takes you in his arms and carries you to the bedroom. He lays you down so carefully on the bed as if you’re bound to break. When he peels your clothes off one by one, he always makes sure that you’re enveloped by his warmth, either it’s from his lips, his hands, or his breath as he speaks praises to your skin. He locks gazes every time he gets the chance, his smile never falters, only growing tender with each second passing by.
“Can I make love to you?”
That’s a line you would never think he’d say. Eren, who treated women as sexual objects in the past; Eren, who you had friends-with-benefits relationship with; Eren who always used the word ‘fuck’ when referring to having sexual intercourse with you before, is asking you with his fingers fluttering against your cheekbone, his eyes tender and amatory, his nose nearly grazing against yours.
He waits, not wanting to take a step further until you offer him your consent. He doesn’t need to ask, he never needs to, and yet there he is, giving you all the power to pull him close or let him go.
You’ll never let him go.
With thunderous heart and butterflies coming alive in your stomach, you whisper, “Yes, please.”
The next time he kisses you, it’s laced with the need he’s been holding back. His breathing soon turns ragged but there’s no lust in his eyes. Eren is patient. For the first time in what feels like forever, he finally has the moment to truly surrender himself to you, as you do to him, body, mind, and soul. And he will make every second worth it, make it last for eternity.
Eren doesn’t speak much. He doesn’t tease you with mischief and seduction in his words, even when you’re pleading for him to touch you deeper, to move faster. His mouth doesn’t form the devilish smirk he showcased often during your intimate moment together. Eren touches you not solely because he craves physical connection. He touches you because he wants to love you.
Following your demand, he sits upright on the bed with his legs crossed and you straddle his lap, legs tangled around his waist. He lets you lead, gives you the time to breathe and find the angle you need to discover your sweet spot. He tries to make the experience better by making his mouth busy on your chest, his hands touching places you want to be touched. But you don’t seek for a release. This is what you want. As long as he’s close enough to touch, to taste the sweetness of his lips, to become one with him—you don’t wish for anything else.
But Eren is Eren and he knows which way to make you slowly go insane with ecstasy. When your orgasm washes over you, a breathy moan escapes your lips and caresses the skin below his earlobe. Your arms are winding tightly around his neck, holding onto him as he waits for you to climb down from your high. He kisses your shoulder, lets his lips linger over the supple skin, tasting your scent. You pull away to kiss him with your thoughts still hazy with bliss, and Eren holds you with one hand on your back, and his other one trapped between the strands of your hair.
“You’re trembling,” he whispers as you press your temples together, eyes closed.
You can only offer him a timid nod. It was intense, the way the knots inside your stomach tightened and untangled at once when he murmured, “You’re the only girl I’ve ever loved,” against your ear. The yearning, the love, and the admiration he held for you, you could feel it all.
Eren still has his sentimental smile plastered on his face as he caresses your cheek. “Did it feel good?” He quietly asks, his face flushed, his forehead glistening with a thin layer of sweat.
You’re still catching your breath. “Yes.”
His gaze softens, drawing a chaste kiss on your lips when he murmurs, “I’m glad…”
“Your turn,” you say, almost begging. He wants to give you some time to rest but you lay your spine against the sheets, pulling him down to you. “Please… I need to feel you…”
He does as he’s told, moaning in gratitude against your mouth when he feels your walls clenching around him. He keeps checking your face for a sign of discomfort, but even if you’re completely submerged in rapture, Eren would still ask whether you’re okay. And you’ll answer each question with a smile, one that is so sweet and graceful, it makes his heart clench at the sight. This is the happiest I’ve ever been, you want to convey, You make me feel so complete, make my heart feel so full, it feels like I’m suffocating. I want to feel this way—want you to make me feel this way for the rest of my life. And I hope I can make you feel the same way. But it takes courage to say these words and you’re not sure your poor heart can contain it. So instead, you just draw his face closer to yours and you kiss him once, lightly yet intoxicating. “Eren, I…” you whisper. “I’m so in love with you.”
And he blushes, instantly and madly, like it’s the first time he has ever had someone confessing their love to him. No. He didn’t even feel nor react this way when he received his first confession. So maybe it wasn’t the words that have this much power over him. It’s the person.
Maybe you’re both need to get used to this—to love and be loved. You’ve devoted yourselves to one another longer than you realize, but these words still feel foreign on your tongue no matter how many times you’ve repeated them in your head. Eren feels the same way too, but he’s braver than you. Even when his heart feels like it’s seconds away from exploding, Eren kisses your lips as he picks up his pace, vocalizing “I love you,” in the most beautiful way possible with his hand clutching tighter against yours, fingers lacing perfectly like a set of a puzzle. “I love you.” It almost feels like his words match his every thrust. “I love you.” And he’ll repeat it a thousand times more if that’s what it takes for you to know just how much.
When he’s nearing the edge, Eren buries his face in the crook of your neck, alternating between painting soft kisses on your sensitive spot and speaking the words that are tainted by fear. “Don’t leave me…” he whispers. “Please… Stay with me…”
You detach one hand away from his, moving straight to the back of his head, slipping your fingers between the silkiness of his strands. This is the second time he begs for you to stay, and you wonder if you’ve been giving him the wrong signs but you know it’s not true. How could you when all you want is to spend the rest of your life with him? To love him in the way you’re doing and more. So it strikes you harder, heart dropping to your stomach when you notice that even after all this time, even when he’s forgiven himself and learned to love another, the fear of being betrayed and abandoned is still running thickly through his veins.
God, I want to let him know. You feel like crying, your heart feeling so full, you’re scared that it’s going to break. Or maybe it has. Every time you hear his plea, it breaks harder and harder for him, hoping that the pieces that were torn away from yours, could fill the empty spaces in his.
I want to let him know that he’s no longer alone. That he’ll never be alone.
“Forever and always,” you breathe out and Eren’s movements come to a halt. He pulls away just enough to meet your glassy eyes. You stroke his cheek, a delicate smile forming on your lips. “I’ll stay with you. Forever and always.”
Eren can feel it. Can feel the promise behind those words. Melting under your touch, he mirrors your smile. “Forever and always.”
And when he recalls the promise you made him that night, he believes it—truly believes it this time. How you would stay in his life as long as he wanted you to. Eren will want you for eternity, and eternity you will stay. And he’ll engrave these three words to your skin, your mind, your heart, and your soul for just as long.
Forever and always.
***
Shooting pain burns across his skin, like a feeling of a knife splitting his face into pieces the second Levi’s fist meets his jaw. It’s enough to shake his vision, to make the world spin below his feet, but it’s nothing compared to the one he feels throbbing inside his chest. But it’s not the pain he bears inside, it’s rage. This blazing flame, triggered by his bottled-up anger from the incident that happened several hours ago.
Jean and Reiner, still sharply dressed in their three-piece suits, avert their gazes. They can’t handle the sight. They don’t intervene because Eren deserves every consequence of his action, but Levi never holds back his punches. Once the raven-haired man took off his rings to avoid tearing the skin of his artists, he would go all out. Jean had been on the other side of his punches many times before, and he knew Levi wouldn’t stop until his opponent began to spit out blood or collapse on their knees. “This is just my opinion, but when it comes to teaching somebody discipline, I believe pain is the most effective way,” his manager once said as he drilled the heel of his shoes against Jean’s spine, driving his chest harder to the floor. The same thing is happening to Eren right now but Jean puts a blind eye. It’s easier that way.
Reiner sucks in his teeth, nervous and worried. “Shouldn’t we stop him?” he asks, walking back and forth. “He’s killing him over there.”
“He got that coming.” Jean leans his back against the wall of the expensive suite they’re staying in for the night. He tucks his hands inside the pockets of his black trousers, his breath still smells like the expensive wine he tasted. “See, this is why I never agree with being in a relationship. That suicidal blockhead wouldn’t get socked in the face if he just kept fucking whores like I do.”
“Being in love isn’t a sin, Jean.”
“Fuck you, Reiner. You saw what happened today. He’s gonna put Empire’s whole career on the line if he keeps doing that and for what? ‘Cause he wants to keep fucking one girl for the rest of his life?!” He snorts loudly, utterly vexed. “I’m not gonna let him ruin this. I’ve worked so fucking hard to get to where we are now. He’s a fucking idiot and he deserves every punch coming his way.”
Reiner sighs and keeps himself mute. Jean’s words might sound spiteful, but it’s true. What Eren did earlier today was out of line. If Levi fails to negotiate with the press, his name would make headlines by tomorrow morning, and both he and Jean are going to have to answer millions of questions regarding this every time they got invited for an interview.
Eren takes punches after punches, kicks after kicks, but he doesn’t budge nor even flinch. It wasn’t the first time Levi disciplined him with his knuckles and knowing how stubborn Eren is, it’s most definitely not going to be his last time either.
“Avoid hitting him on the face, Levi,” Reiner reminds him with one hand stretched out, but he’s standing nowhere near to stop him. “We don’t want bruises on it.”
“Fuck if I care,” Levi says, ramming his fist against his stomach and Eren falls to one knee, coughing and gasping for air. “I don’t give a rat’s ass if he looks like a giant piece of shit tomorrow. This fucker’s not gonna join us for the rest of the event anyway.”
“What do you mean he’s not—” Jean takes a breath, nose flaring. “Levi, he’s the frontman of Empire. We’ve finished our performance, true, but tomorrow is the main show! We’re nominated for the first time—how are we supposed to—”
“I don’t care,” Levi says through gritted teeth as he watches the man before him wipe the blood away from his mouth with the back of his hand. “I’m not gonna let this motherfucker stand in public before I got everything sorted out. He needs to cool off his head.” He squats down in front of him, grabbing a handful of Eren’s messy tied-up hair before he lifts his face. The boy’s electric green eyes are showing no signs of fear. If anything, the fury in them only burns so much brighter.
“How are you feeling, fuck face?” Levi asks, looking down on him. His expression is cold, unreadable as always.
“Never been better,” Eren answers with blood staining his lips. He doesn’t seem the least apologetic for what he did. Levi slaps him once with the back of his hand, splattering a few droplets of blood to the carpeted floor.
“Oh, but then again, maybe I should avoid the face.” Levi yanks him by his locks, hard enough for Eren to have his head thrown back, his eyes narrowing as they try to adjust to the light that shines above him. “That’s the only thing you can sell, isn’t that right, Jaeger? Nobody gives a shit about your music. All they want to do is to fuck this pretty mouth of yours.” The words cut deep as Levi never spoke like that to him before. Out of everyone else in the industry, Levi is the only one who believes that Eren truly does have talent behind his pretty face. But fury consumes him and Levi chooses the words that hurt him the most.
Eren’s jaw clenches but he bites back his words.
“Tch.” Levi clicks his tongue, releasing the boy from his grip. Eren has his head hung low, half of his face concealed by the hair that falls out of his bun. “You’re gonna take two weeks off,” his manager announces, deep and low with his silver irises glinting underneath the light. “And you’re gonna use that fucking shithole brain of yours to reflect on what you did. I’m also going to take your next month’s paycheck to compensate for your shitty act. In two weeks, you’re gonna come back as good as new, and you’re gonna promise me that you’ll never pull this kind of stunt again. You understand me?”
Like a wolf being backed into the corner, Eren nearly bares his teeth. Another slap and the boy coughs, breathing heavily through his mouth as his nose is clogged by his blood. “I asked you a question.”
“I understand,” the artist says through gritted teeth.
“Good.” Standing back on his feet, Levi retrieves his rings from the pocket of his suit. “Marco will drive you home,” he says, placing back the two silver rings on his fingers. “Lay low. If you attract unnecessary attention again in the next two weeks, I’m gonna kill you myself. Now get that fucking face out of my sight.”
Eren stands up and fixes his suit, not performing a bow or even taking a glance at the rest of the people in the room before he walks away with a security guard on his side. His nails are sinking into his palms, almost hard enough to tear his skin apart. He may seem docile, obeying Levi’s words and taking the consequences of his action without even muttering a single word back. But he’s not going to learn his lesson. If the same incident happens, Eren would lash out again in public. He doesn’t care about his image. He cares about you.
This happens because of you.
Just five hours before, everything was normal. CBN, a prestigious music magazine company, has rented out a five-star hotel for the artists to do interviews, press conferences, and preparation before the main event started. Empire had been given a suite where they could stay for the night and do interviews with various reporters and journalists during the day. Eren, Reiner, and Jean had been sitting for hours on the same couch, dressed impeccably handsome in their suits with their stylists waiting in another room to do a quick retouch between interviews. Journalist after journalist came walking into the room with their long list of questions and Eren’s mind often drifted away, wishing that he could abandon everything and just stay at home with you with his head on your lap and your fingers tangled in his hair.
Despite his exhaustion, Eren kept things professional. He smiled when he needed to. He laughed when he was supposed to, and he answered every question clearly and efficiently. Most of the questions were about the performance they did the day before as one of the opening acts for the show, and how they felt to be nominated for the first time in one of the most notorious music awards in the world. His answer was always the same, sounding precisely like the script Levi had handed to him right after he woke up.
It was on his ninth interview when he felt like his brain was going haywire. A male journalist with a buzz cut, dressed sloppily in a flannel shirt and sneakers, with a smile too wicked to be genuine, handled the interview. Eren hated him since the first second he leaned forward to shake his hand, but then again, he hated everyone who took his time away from you.
There were two cameras in the room, one facing the band members, another one facing the interviewer. There were also a few professional photographers on standby, documenting every interaction they made.
“Hey, everyone. It’s your boy, Connie Springer here.” He greeted the camera, holding a wireless microphone in one hand. “Joining me here today is one of the hottest rock bands in the world who’s nominated for not one, but two different categories for CBN Music Awards.” He dragged his eyes toward the members. “Hey, guys, how are you doing?”
“Pretty awesome, dude,” Jean replied with a smirk, holding his fist in the air.
“Whoa, a fist bump. Never had that one from rockstars before.” Connie chuckled, knocking their fists together. “Cool. Can I just say something real quick? Your rendition of Harry Styles’ Adore you last night? Blew my mind.” Reiner chuckled in response. “Seriously, bro. It’s like it was your song all along. To me, it was no longer a pop song. It was pure, classic rock—sounded better than the original, if you ask me.”
“Please don’t say that,” Reiner quickly adds.
“Of course, sorry. I didn’t mean to be rude.” But his laughter surely was. “So, you guys have only been playing for four years, almost five?” This time, it was Jean, the guitarist, who replied with a nod. “Yeah, and now you’ve been nominated for the Best Rock Band and the Best Live Act categories. That’s friggin awesome, man. How do you feel?”
“To be honest, it still feels surreal to us,” Reiner answered politely, while Eren looked away from the camera, trying to conceal his yawn by using the back of his hand. Reiner’s answer was always textbook perfect, accompanied shortly by an affable smile to charm his interviewer but before he could finish his sentence, Connie jumped straight into another topic.
“Right, of course,” he cut him off, leaving Reiner a bit baffled but even if he was aggravated by it, he didn’t comment on it. “So, I've gathered a few questions here from your fans. These are the real questions that need to be asked. Eren Jaeger—“ he paused to give him a salute. “Big fan of you, Sir. Honestly, I think you’re one of the most promising young artists we have in our generation.”
Eren smiled, feigned but good enough to deceive. “Thank you.”
“But is it true that you used to date Historia Reiss? Because just a week ago—and I’m sure you’ve heard about this—she revealed that she was a lesbian, so now people are thinking that maybe you were just teaming up with her to increase your popularity. What are your thoughts on that?”
Eren just stared at him, and if Connie had been a normal, sensible human being, he would’ve noticed that he just pushed the wrong button. Reiner and Jean exchanged a glance, keeping themselves mute as they grew nervous.
Running a hand through his slicked-back hair, Eren kept his smile intact and said, “Why don’t you ask her about that yourself?”
“When I got the chance, sure. I want to know what you think about it first.”
“Yeah, well, I’m not gonna answer that question for you, Connie, sorry.”
“Sheesh.” Connie hissed, clearly making fun of him. Eren’s face turned grim, biting the inside of his cheek to shift his attention away. “Alright then. Well, for what it’s worth, I think you two made a really good couple.” The journalist’s snicker was as inappropriate as the rest of his body language. Returning to his phone, Connie asked his next question. “What about Mikasa Ackerman, then? In the new MV for Hero Heroine—such a great song, by the way—you guys had so many steamy scenes together. Is there anything going on between the two of you or is it just strictly business kind of thing?”
Connie was sneering as he asked the question and it made Eren’s blood boil in his veins. His smile turned sinister. “I don’t think your question has anything to do with my band—“
“I’m just asking the questions that your fans want to know,” Connie retorted, almost contemptuously. Jean and Reiner were beginning to send signals to the rest of the staff to cut the interview short, but Levi, who was in charge, was not available in the room.
“Okay. Dude?” Jean interrupted before Eren’s glare turned even more menacing than it already was. “You can either stick to the questions that are relevant to our music or leave. We’re not here to discuss our personal lives.”
“Cool, cool, yeah.” Connie had the nerves to ignore him, turning his body to face the lead vocalist, and insisting to ask the question. “What about the girl you sang Happy Birthday to on stage? People are dying to know her name. Can you tell me who she is?”
“That’s it, we’re taking a break.” Jean stood up from his seat, tugging Eren by his arm. “Come on, let’s get some fresh air. Levi will deal with him later.”
Connie kept directing his mic toward the vocalist. “People are saying she’s the same girl who’s been seen with you lately. The one who’s working as a journalist in PMC.”
“Dude, we’re done.” Jean almost lost his patience. Reiner agreed with a nod, following his trail right after as Jean made his way toward the door.
“How long have you been dating her?” The man was persistent. “It was bold of you to pull that kind of stunt on stage. Your fangirls aren’t gonna like it but, I guess, you got the attention you wanted, right?”
Eren’s nails were sinking into his thighs from how hard he tried to keep himself composed. Releasing a breath, he stood up, fixed his suit, and walked past the interviewer without saying a word.
“Jesus Christ,” Connie said a few seconds before the three men exited the room, throwing one hand in the air in frustration. “Just tell me if you fuck that bitch, bro! I need to make some money over here!”
“Oh, fuck.” Reiner was the first one to react, panic escalating quickly in his chest when Eren stopped dead in his tracks. “Eren,” he called, turning around to warn his frontman. “Eren, just walk away, man.”
But the said male already had his ears closed and his fingers curling into fists. Turning around, he walked back with angry steps and his jaw clenching hard. A voice inside his head screamed at him to be a better man—to remind him that taking a further step than that would put his image on the line. But it wasn’t enough. He was furious.
“What did you call her?” Eren asked as he made his way to where Connie was standing. He didn’t shout or even snarl at the other male. He was calmer than he had ever been. But his voice is laced with venom, deep and menacing, matching the way his emerald eyes were glinting in fury—a pair of piercing daggers that would make anyone cower at the sight.
Connie had his mouth open, swallowing hard. “W-well, I—“ His words fell dead when the vocalist took him by the collar of his shirt, forcing the shorter male to stand on his toes as he was. Not a split second later, Eren landed a hard punch on his jaw before he could utter anything else and the man fell to his knees, his palms pressing against the carpeted floor as his ears began to buzz. If he had packed a little more strength into his punch, Connie would’ve lost a tooth.
“Oh, shit,” Jean cursed, a second before he and Reiner hastily made their way back to the couch. They caught Eren by the arms, trying their best to keep him away from the journalist. “Eren, goddammit!” Jean’s face turned scarlet as he struggled to keep the other man still. “Calm down!”
Even under their hold, Eren kept launching himself forward toward the journalist, teeth-gritting as he screamed, “WHAT DID YOU FUCKING CALL HER?!”
It was at that moment, Levi entered the room. The camera flash went off under his command, but it was too late.
Everything was already recorded.
***
It’s a little bit after eleven pm, you notice, as you take a glance at the digital clock sitting on your desk. You’re already settled in bed, planning to drift into your slumber once you’re finished watching Empire’s version of Harry Styles’ Adore You for the fifth time that night. You’ve got an early day tomorrow, a pile of articles to work on and a seminar to attend, so you need to catch some sleep, but the thing is, you can’t stop.
No matter how many times you’ve seen this, you kept hitting the replay button to watch the video all over again. Eren was playing on the stage, doused in bright lights with people cheering his name. He was singing one of the most notorious hits that year and he performed it shirtless.
He was wearing black jeans, black combat boots, and a black jacket—which is nothing new, obviously—aside from the fact that he was wearing no shirt underneath. The strap of his bass and his gold, key-shaped pendant that dangled in the middle of his chest were the only things that hid the way his abs muscles contracted with every movement he made. He was dangerously captivating, masculine with a hint of sensuality.
Walk in your rainbow paradise
Strawberry lipstick state of mind
Eren’s voice rumbled deep, his husky voice suited the song more than you had expected it would. It was a perfect choice, just like he had predicted. Though the melody was the same, Empire had their own style and Eren wasn’t lying when he said he would make it work. You had listened to this song several times before on the radio, but it was almost unrecognizable under his hands.
I get so lost inside your eyes
Would you believe it?
This performance reminds you of the way Eren sang I Only Lie When I Love You with Historia during Harlequin’s solo concert. The way he was being seductive throughout the song, not too much, just the right amount to make you hold your breath every time the camera got a close-up shot of his face. His jade green eyes were hooded, something that you would call to be his bedroom eyes, which makes you feel a bit jealous as you wish they were reserved only for your own to see. His smirk oozed sexiness with the perfect amount of mischief that made him look more juvenile than usual.
You don't have to say you love me
You don't have to say nothing
You don't have to say you're mine
The conversation you had with him the morning after your confession returned to your mind. Eren made sure to let his lips brush lightly against his microphone as he stared directly into the camera, singing the words like he was speaking to you.
Honey
I'd walk through fire for you
Just let me adore you
Like it's the only thing I'll ever do
Listen to the lyrics and think about me. Like how I’ll be thinking of you when I perform it on the stage.
“Oh, God.” You have your face hidden underneath your palm, your heart pumping more blood to your face. He’s going to be the death of me, isn’t he?
Your heart jolts and your ears perk up at the sound of your doorknob being turned open. You’re startled to hear Eren pushing open your front door as you didn’t expect him to swing by. He had told you earlier this morning that he’d be staying at a five-star hotel where the event was held for a couple of days until the entire show was over.
Why is he here? You ponder. Maybe he just wanted to spend the night here instead of staying at the hotel?
A gleeful grin naturally finds its way to your face and you jump down from your bed, half-running toward him in your silk nightdress to greet him with a kiss. But the second you’re close enough to see his face, your warm smile morphs into a shock-filled gasp. “Eren,” you scurry close, carefully resting your fingers on his cheek as you examine his face. “Oh my God, Eren, are you okay?”
With his jaw tightened, he averts his gaze to the side, weakly swatting your hand away from him. “I’m fine.”
There are fresh bruises on his skin, angry red marks that make your heart palpitate in horror, wondering how much pain did he have to endure when he took those punches.
What happened? Did he get into a fight? With who? No, why did he get into a fight in the first place?
Your head is spinning and you realize you’re panicking once the thought of it having anything to do with you enters your mind.
This is not the time.
Taking a breath to keep yourself composed, you hurriedly move back to your fridge. “Sit down, please—we—we need to ice the bruises—” Your fingers shake as you retrieve the ice pack, almost letting it slip from your hand before you grab a towel to wrap around it. Eren doesn’t comply right away, so you guide him deeper into the kitchen. Circling your fingers along his wrist, you tug forward and he follows. But instead of taking a seat on the nearest stool, Eren spins you around and smashes his mouth hotly against yours.
“Eren—mmph—“ You’re being pushed hard against the kitchen aisle, the marbled edge pressing uncomfortably against the dip of your spine. “Wait—“ you manage to let the word slip but it’s not enough. He kisses you roughly, almost desperately, demanding your response. They feel suffocating, and you grab onto his dress shirt as if it would help you breathe. You kiss him back with a whimper, your eyebrows adjoined in the middle when you feel his teeth bruising your lip. His tongue, even if it already remembers the way you taste, still explores your mouth like it’s desperate to satisfy its curiosity.
Eren is acting like a stranger, and you could tell that he’s been drinking from how thick the taste of alcohol is sitting on his tongue. He seems both angry and heartbroken, impatient and lonely at the same time.
I need you to tell me what’s wrong.
“Eren,” you take the opportunity to speak when he moves his mouth to your jaw, his large hands traveling all over your body. “I need—“ He tangles his fingers around your strands, yanking at your roots until you have your neck exposed. “L-let me take care of your bruises first.”
Paying no mind, Eren trails his tongue along the throbbing vein, nipping harshly at your skin. You place both hands on the edge of the counter, gripping onto it like the floor is crumbling underneath you. The thin strap of your dress is falling over your shoulder, showing him a glimpse of your chest that heaves up and down, desperate for air. “W-wait—please—you need to rest—”
“Can I fuck you?” He asks in such urgency, almost in a form of a growl, just a second before he catches your earlobe between his teeth. The coldness in his voice strikes deep within you, but it’s not fear that you feel, though it does seem quite similar. He’s being hasty, more aggressive than he’s ever been but he’s not forcing you to obey his orders. Because, despite the raging storm that wages in his heart, Eren still waits for your answer.
He stops what he’s doing, pulling away just slightly where you can still feel the warmth of his breath caressing your cheek. “I really need you right now.” His voice trembles, but from fear or sadness, or something else you haven’t noticed, you couldn’t tell.
With a little, shaky nod, your mouth forms the word, “Yes…”
And that’s all it takes. His feelings pour like raging waterfalls. All this anger, all this frustration he’s been keeping to himself—they break through the barrier and you can feel every spark of that bottled-up anger through his touch. His kisses don’t taste the same—don’t feel the same, and if you closed your eyes, you would’ve thought he was someone else.
Eren doesn’t waste time. He no longer has the patience to. He spins you around, forcing you to bend over the kitchen aisle with the heel of his palm pressing against the spot between your shoulder blades. You can hear the sound of his belt being taken off with one hand. His other one moves down to grab the hemline of your dress, pushing the fabric upward until it passes your waist. He moves your panties to the side, spreading your thighs apart and you obey. Your heartbeat sounds like a beating drum in your ears, loud and heavy. Spitting into his palm, he lathers his cock with his saliva, pumping it fast for a few times to get to his full length.
You’ve never been this nervous. You can't deny the thrill that colors your blood, unfurling like wildfire to every inch of your body, from the thought of being used as a way to vent out his frustration. You can feel the anger from the way he grips onto your skin, his nails sinking deep enough to make you wince, but you know it’s not directed at you. It feels different from that time when he fucked you to avenge the horrible prank you pulled on him. That time, even when he was visibly furious, you could also catch a hint of impishness and teasing behind his touches. Today, there is none.
Eren pushes in.
It all happens so fast that even when you already know what was coming, you still gasp the second you feel his tip stretching you without proper preparation. You take a sharp intake of breath, your front teeth nearly cutting your lip from how hard you’re biting on it to muffle your voice. He leaves no room for you to adjust, already moving his hips back and forth. He’s not moving fast just yet, but his thrusts are deep and powerful, pushing your body forward with every pound. Your head hangs low, your hands wobble as they try to prop your upper half.
But him being so forceful like this? This doesn’t scare you.
What scares you is that he doesn’t let out any sound. He doesn’t praise you, doesn’t call your name. There’s no mischief or the usual haughtiness written on his lips. They’re slightly parted to let out a breath, but he’s being so quiet, it’s chilling.
But maybe you’re not one to say, as you can’t find your own voice. Eren takes a firm hold of your hips, his hooded eyes seeming more black than green in the dimness of your apartment. His thoughts are too clouded, both by his rage and the alcohol in his system. He can barely think. Right now, he just wants to release everything he feels in his bones at once, so he can go back to how he was before.
“Eren.” Your voice breaks but you continue. He’s relentlessly pounding into you from behind, his trousers sliding to his mid-thigh as he pushes in deeper. You reach out blindly behind you, taking a hold of his wrist. “Calm down—”
He twists his hand and breaks free from your grip. In return, he clamps his fingers around your smaller wrist and pins it down behind your back. You fall forward, lying your upper half flat on the aisle, the coldness of the marble top sticking to your cheek and chest. You groan out of pain, your legs begin to shake. “Eren—”
He leans forward, his chest filling the curve of your spine as he hovers beside your ear. “I’m sorry,” he says in a whisper. “I’m sorry.”
But I don't want you to look at me right now.
There’s a bit of a stinging pain that echoes through your body every time he slides in and out. The ledge is digging into your stomach the harder he pushes you against it. Mustering every strength you have, you push yourself away, turning around to face him. You stand on wobbly legs, your arms circling his neck as you kiss him to steal his attention away. Eren responds to it by instinct with his eyebrows furrowing together, his fingers fisting against the back of your dress. Without warning, he slides his hand down to your thighs and lifts you, placing you down on the aisle with your legs dangling in the air. He spreads your thighs again, settling himself in between. You try to slow down his pace by resting your hand on his chest but he snatches you away by the wrist and holds it mid-air. He buries himself inside you once more, sinking his face in the crook of your neck, and picks up his pace.
You can’t keep up, your head turning to mush. You stretch out your hand, framing his face. “Look at me.”
“No,” he growls, pushing your hand away. He doesn’t look at you, not even a glance, as he’s afraid to see the expression you make.
“Eren!” The desperation in your voice turns him still and his eyes find yours. You exhale in relief, cupping his cheek. “I’m not going anywhere,” you tell him, pressing your temples together as you close your eyes and catch your breath. “I’m not going anywhere so, please… Calm down…”
For a moment, the world slows down. It soothes him. Your voice. Your gesture. Your little touch. Enough for him to realize the shivers running through your fingertips. His heartbeat still races but the ominous black clouds that fogged his brain are thinning. And the second he’s able to think clearly, to let his emotions bottled down again, a thought begins to form.
What the fuck am I doing?
You can see the regret and guilt filling his eyes, and that’s not what you want from him. “You’re not hurting me,” you tell him, resting your hand on his cheek. “I’m okay. I just… I just wanted you to know that you’re not alone. I’m here with you and I’m not going anywhere.”
She will stay.
That thought, one that’s born from your words, makes him realize that it’s not anger he’s been feeling. It’s dread. Somewhere in his heart, he knows that he just did something wrong—something that could make you feel terribly upset from how he behaved, something that might drive you away from him. And he’s scared. He needs reassurance from you. That you won’t hate him no matter what, that you won’t leave him no matter what. Ironically, it translates into the need of having physical touch, as it’s something he’s grown familiar with, especially with you in the last few months.
And you understood that. You understood that even when he couldn’t.
“Kiss me,” you tell him quietly and his heart swells. He’s still scared of making the first move, afraid that he might hurt you again because he knew he did, even when you claimed he didn’t. You place one hand on his nape, fingertips brushing against his baby hair as you pull him forward to slant your lips together. Eren lets you lead, follows the movement of your lips with his heart threatening to leap out of his chest. The kiss is slower. Languid. It doesn’t feel as sweet as his usual ones just yet, but it’s a start.
“Eren…” You guide him with a lift of your hips, your arms enclosing his shoulders. “You can move now…” There’s hesitation within him but you wash it away with a moan. When he starts to move again, your body matches every thrust better. “Faster, Ren…”
He’s panting hard, working his hips fast to find his release as you told him to. His groan turns louder when he reaches his high, emptying himself inside you with his forehead resting on your shoulder. You hug him close, gently stroking his strands before you move your hands to follow his spine.
When he’s finished, he slowly breaks away, still catching his breath. His cheeks are flushed, his eyes hazy with the aftershock of his orgasm. You smile at him, weak but tender. “Feeling better?”
He breaks down, crushing you with his embrace as he continuously whispers, “I’m sorry. I’m sorry. Please forgive me.”
“It’s okay.” You extend the space between you, pressing a sweet kiss on his forehead. “We’re okay.”
Eren searches your eyes, his own filled with nothing but concern and guilt. “Did I hurt you?”
“No.” The word comes out without taking a second to process his question. There was pain, yes, but it wasn’t anything unbearable for you to take. Either way, you won’t say it to him. He already looks like he’s going to punish himself forever without hearing your answer. You kiss him once, keeping your lips pressed until you feel his tense muscles relaxing. Ending the kiss, you push the stray hair away from his eyes. “Can you tell me what happened?”
He casts his gaze downward, shaking his head.
“Eren.”
“Let me take care of you first,” he says, catching your eyes. “I want to make it up to you.”
“You really don’t have to—“
“Please.” His thumb is rubbing comforting circles along your cheekbone. “I promise I’ll tell you everything you want to hear afterward.” Your lips meet again, with him whispering his next words against them. “I won’t be able to forgive myself until I make it up to you.”
The sincerity in his voice is what makes you agree to his offer. “Okay…” You circle your arms around his neck. “I’m all yours.”
***
“So, was it a fight?”
Your fingers are intertwined with his as he embraces you from behind. Eren has his back pressed against the headboard of your bed, with you sitting on his lap. You’re both bare from top to toe, seeking warmth from each other’s skin instead of the fabric of your sweater. You snuggle close to him with your blanket shrouding your front, sighing in content at how hot his chest feels against your spine.
“No,” Eren answers, vacant eyes watching the way your hand fits his perfectly. He turns pensive, speaks nothing louder than a mumble. “I let Levi beat me up.”
“Why?”
“‘Cause I fucked up.”
You turn slightly to take a glimpse of his face. His expression doesn’t reveal much, a mystery that you need to solve. But if you ask the right questions, you’ll get the answers you need. “What did you do?”
“I… punched someone in the face.”
“Who?”
“The guy who interviewed me.”
“What?” You shift your weight, spinning around until you can lay a hand on his chest, your eyes growing wide. “What do you—why?”
“Because he asked questions that didn’t have anything to do with my music.”
“Doesn’t mean you can punch him, Eren.”
“I know, but I was so—” The frustration from a moment ago flits through his eyes but this time, he doesn’t let it stay for long. There’s a shiver in his voice from restrained anger. “I was so pissed off.”
He’s always been quite a temperamental person, and if he’s aggravated by something or someone, it immediately shows on his face. But you thought that he was better at pretending this time around—that he was used to showbiz and wouldn’t let himself be easily vexed by something like this. So if he was furious enough to punch someone, it would’ve been for a serious reason.
Our relationship, you dread, swallowing thickly. Eren doesn’t want to elaborate further unless you ask him. So with a heavy tongue, you query, “What, uhh… What did he ask you?”
A pause. “Something about my personal life.”
Shit. “Like…?”
He contemplates for a few seconds before he heaves a heavy sigh, giving up on trying to keep it hidden in the dark. “Well, he asked about Historia. Wanted to know if what happened between us was just an act.”
“Oh…” Relief washes over you but it doesn’t stay that way for long. Judging by his tone, you know he’s nowhere close to disclosing everything. “Did he ask about Mikasa too?”
His jaw clenches. “Yeah.”
“Was that…” You wet your lips. “The reason why you got angry?”
“No.” He exhales sharply through his nose. “I don’t give a fuck about her. Honestly, I got questions like this all the time and I never cared about them before but when he brought you into the conversation, I just couldn’t—“ He stops himself when he notices you’re flinching. His hold around your hand was getting too tight, it begins to hurt. He calms himself, relaxing his muscles. “I got so angry…” He continues, playing with your fingers carefully this time, kissing your knuckles once as a form of an apology. “So, I lashed out.”
You splay out your fingers and let your palm meets his, watching the way they are a tad smaller than his. “What did he say about me?”
“I don’t wanna talk about it.”
You lace your fingers together, squeezing them gently for comfort. “Then can you at least tell me what’s on your mind?”
You offer him the serenity he needs, making it easy for him to let go and share his burden with you like the time he opened up about his past. “I think that…” He tentatively starts. “Rather than angry, I was… scared. I’m still scared. I’m scared that I’ll end up hurting you because of this. Because of my popularity as an artist. I’m worried that people—who clearly don’t know how amazing you are and how important you are in my life—would talk shit about you and I know you’re strong, I know you can handle this, but I just…” His voice turns quieter, not yet a whisper but close. “I don’t want them to get into your head. I don’t want them to hurt you, but I know I can’t protect you all the time. And I’m afraid that one day, you’ll get tired of it all and—” He stops, switching quickly to nibble at the corner of his lip instead.
“And?” You insist on him to continue, but your tone is gentle. “And I’ll leave you because of it? Is that… what you want to say?”
He brings his gaze down, letting his hair drapes over him like a curtain to mask his expression. “I’m sorry,” he faintly mumbles. “It’s not that I don’t trust you—I do, it’s just… I don’t want you to get hurt.”
How is he so kind, you wonder. So mature and caring, yet at the same time, fragile.
You gather his face in your hands, lifting it so he no longer has the option to hide. “I think you underestimate my strength, young man,” you tease him, hoping it would light up the tension. “Don’t you remember? I got bullied a lot during our school days. Did you ever see me cry about it?”
His heart warms at the memory of summer and the neverending laughter you shared in the corridor. “Many times, actually,” he says, and you both laugh softly, eyes turning crescents just like how they used to twelve years ago.
“Right, I forgot I was a bit of a wimp back then. Well, I can assure you that I’m definitely not a wimp now, so I don’t need you to worry about me. Or protect me. I can do it myself.”
“I know,” he answers in a sigh, his hands naturally curling around your waist when you turn around on his lap again. “I just... Sometimes I wish I could just stop doing this, you know? Quit the band so I can live a normal life with you.”
If only it was that easy, you ponder as you lean your back against his chest, your head resting on his shoulder. But then again, I don’t want you to give up on your dreams.
“Would you… like that?” He sounds so uncertain when he asks the question as if he’s afraid that he might upset you with it. His lips are brushing against the skin of your shoulder as he speaks. “To live a normal life with me..? Just the two of us…”
It doesn’t sound like a plan to escape his fame, it sounds like a marriage proposal. Your cheeks heat up at the thought but you try your best to stay unfazed. “You know you can’t do that. You haven’t finished your contract yet.”
“I know. That’s why I’m so frustrated.” Eren closes his eyes, tightening his arms around your curve. “But if I could… Would you..?”
Would you marry me and stay with me forever?
Before Eren has the bravery to enunciate the words, you untangle his limbs from your body and climb away from his thighs. His heart throbs instantly, worried that he’s crossing the line too far. “Baby, I’m—”
You turn around and straddle his lap, every bit of your body is facing him properly this time. “Can I have a word?” You ask, face solemn.
“S-sure.”
“First of all, I’ve promised you I’d stay,” you state out firmly, cupping his cheek and peering deep into his eyes. “As long as you want me around, I’ll stay with you. You don’t have to ask me this. You just have to believe me.”
Eren noticeably gulps once before he nods, his eyes entranced with the conviction that’s written in yours.
“Second,” you continue, taking a deep breath. “I got scared at the beginning too when I read what people said about us being together. How I’m not pretty enough for you—”
“You’re beautiful.”
“Or when they compared me to Historia or Mikasa—”
“They are nothing compared to you—”
“Eren.” You chuckle. “Will you let me talk, please?”
“Right.” His face reddens slightly. “Sorry.”
He’s cute. He’s always been so cute, even if he’s six feet tall with glare sharp enough to pierce through the glass. “I was angry. Of course, I was angry,” you confess. “I had to put my accounts into private so they won’t leave nasty comments on my articles or send death threats through my DM.” Eren appears to be in shock as this is the first time he’s hearing this. He’s about to ask further but you shake your head, reminding him to not interrupt just yet. “I don’t want to talk about it. Besides, it’s fine now. It’s not a problem anymore once I went private. I also try not to look up my name on the internet or go through the comment section of your performances or interviews. What I’m saying is that I’m all right. Right now, I’m all right. I’m happy—the happiest I’ve ever been—because now I get to have you like this. I get to belong to you, properly, just as much as you belong to me.” You let your hand linger on his skin, pushing back his bangs so you can marvel at how brilliantly his eyes gleam. He drags it down to his cheek, tilting his head to kiss the lines of your palms. You fondly smile at the sight, bending your head down once to capture his lips between yours.
“But…” Your gaze saddens as you break away, gliding the pad of your thumb against the redness of his bottom lip. “If I could be honest with you, a part of me is still terrified about it. What if it becomes worse? I don’t care about me but I knew you would lash out, Eren, and you did. That’s why I never told you about any of this until now. I didn’t—I don’t want you to behave this way.”
He cowers, looking dejected. “Do you… hate me?”
“No,” you titter. “How could I? I’m in love with you.”
Seeing him turn mortified makes you grow flustered as you don’t intend to make him feel that way with your words. You spoke without thinking, feeling a sudden urge to convey the words just because you wanted to say them. But you don’t regret saying it. You never will.
“Anyway,” you clear your throat, bashful. “The most important part you need to understand is that I don’t want you to ruin the image you’ve been building for years. The dream you’ve been chasing for years. I don’t want you to put your career on the line, just because you don’t want people to hurt me.”
He turns pale. “But—”
“Think about Jean and Reiner,” you remind him. “They need this band. Unlike you with your modeling gigs and commercials, they have nothing else going on besides Empire. Think about Levi. Think about Marco! He adores you. Think about the people whose lives you changed with your music. They need you. We all need you. And if you’re gonna throw that all away for me, I’m sorry, but I’m going to end whatever it is between us right now.”
“What—“ His eyes promptly turn wide. “No—why would you—”
“Because I don’t want you to give up on your dreams!” You’re almost shouting at this point, desperately trying to make him see through your point of view. “Eren, you’ve come so far to get to where you are now. And maybe the reality is not like how you expected it to be so you no longer care just as much as you used to. Maybe now you feel controlled or pressured by the fame and all of these business contracts you have to follow, but this is it. This is what you dreamt of when we were young. Empire is rising to fame and you deserve it. You deserve every attention, every award, and every praise coming your way and I’m not going to take that away from you. I won’t.”
Your chest is heaving up and down, desperate for air from how fast you’re talking. “Rennie, I know you care about me and I thank you for it. You’re so sweet, so kind, but if it’s hard for you to understand, try seeing it from my point of view. How awful do you think it would make me feel if you abandon years of hard work just to be with me?” Your eyebrows are sewn together, stroking and holding his cheek firmly with your hand. “I can’t live with that.” Eren’s eyes move back and forth, his frown deepens as he searches yours. You lean up to kiss him once and let your hooded eyes stay on his lips as you whisper. “I don’t want you to worry about me.”
“I… can’t,” he softly replies. “You’re the only one I can think about.”
“You’re the only one I can think about too.” You smile at him, kissing the spot between his eyebrows to erase his furrow. “But you need to protect your image. You need to be on your best behavior or I swear to God, I’m not gonna date you.”
He pulls away instantly, blinking his eyes twice. “You’re… You were planning to date me?”
“Maybe.” Your sheepish smile is accompanied by the mischievous twinkle in your eyes. “I mean, honestly, Ren, isn’t it obvious? I just told you I loved you.”
“I love you too,” he responds naturally and you snort to conceal how successful he is at making your heart pound. You can see how lovestruck he is with you, can tell by the little gestures he makes—the way he nuzzles his nose against yours, the way he gazes at you. It still feels surreal to have someone like Eren Jaeger to love you this deeply. You just hope you can return everything just as much. Ten times—no, a billion times more, if you could.
“Yeah, well,” you avert your gaze, trying to focus on the matter. “Now that this happened, I’ve got some thoughts I need to figure out first. You see, this guy I’m planning to date just punched a journalist for my sake. I need to think about that.”
You both laugh a little, his crooked teeth peeking behind curvy lips. “God, I wanna keep you in my pocket,” he says, embracing you and placing his chin on top of your head—another one of his newly discovered habits, it seems. You nuzzle close enough that you can listen to his heartbeat if you want to. “I wanna carry you with me all the time.”
“That sounds both fun and impractical.” Your giggle fades when Eren spins you around and lays you back down on the bed. “What are you doing?”
“You didn’t cum before, did you?” He crawls down your body, tucking his hair behind his ear before he slides your panties down your thighs. “I said I’d take care of you so…”
“But I—“ You flinch when the warmth of his breath fans your sensitive skin. “I have work in three hours and I haven’t gotten a wink of sleep.”
Eren lifts his face just enough to give you a glimpse of his pleading eyes and his tiny pout. “I won’t waste time so… Please..?” He kisses your thigh, half-lidded eyes never breaking away from yours. “I just want to make you feel good…”
Maybe, just maybe, this Eren—this sweet, loving, and sensual lover—is a much more dangerous version than his usually playful, naughty self. Just look at the way he blinks his eyes, eyelashes fluttering against his cheeks. How can you say no?
“Okay…”
His smile is saccharine sweet. He draws a soft “Thank you,” against the inner part of your thigh before he settles his head between your legs.
***
Ten minutes before your lunch break starts, your raven-haired female co-worker has already slid her way into your cubicle with a box of her Caprese salad on her lap, abandoning her article without care even when she’s already an hour past her deadline. Humming the tune of Ariana Grande’s latest hits, Pieck Finger pops open her lunchbox. “Shut down your laptop,” she says, twirling her fork around her fingers with an indecent grin. “It’s time for you to rate which BTS member you’d like to bang in a parking lot. Personally, I’d start with—“
“I am so fucked,” you confess to her, spinning your swivel chair around to face her.
Pieck, who is just about to stuff a piece of cherry tomato inside her mouth, sighs heavily into the air. “I literally just wanted to eat my salad in peace while thinking about RM’s supposedly massive dong, but okay.” She drops her fork, crosses her legs, and folds her arms on her chest. “Let me guess, you’re pregnant. For real, this time.”
“No. Worse. I told him I loved him.”
“You fucking what?!”
From her reaction, you can already tell how much she’s going to scold you—or make fun of you—the second this is over. Probably, shouting something along the line, “Honey, how many times do I have to fucking tell you? THIS IS NOT HOW FUCK BUDDY RELATIONSHIPS WORK!” Just the thought of it already makes you flinch.
But you’ve got to tell her. There’s no one else you could talk to, and even if Pieck can’t offer you the consolidation you need, at least you can get this out of your chest. “Okay, a lot of things happened in the last three weeks—”
“And you just told me that now?!”
“I’m sorry!” You clasp your hands together, wincing as you apologize. “I didn’t know how to tell you before. And I wasn’t ready.”
Pieck holds up a hand. “It’s okay, I’m just—” She’s lost for words. “Honey, this is huge! I mean, I saw it coming—totally—but, like, you guys took forever to get there, I thought that you’d end up raising a baby together first before you got to exchange those disgusting three words with each other.”
“I don’t follow your logic in that, but okay.”
“How did it start?”
“From that prank you told me to do, actually. Which, by the way,“ you narrow your eyes menacingly at her, “Ended terribly—”
“Terribly how?” She derides. “Him professing his love to you with the moon and the stars dancing in the background as your witness?”
You hold back your retort. “We’ll talk about that later.” Pieck simply rolls her eyes at your response. “Eren was furious at first, but one thing led to another and we ended up having a heart-to-heart conversation. He opened up about his past, I was crying, he probably was too—”
“Oh, Jesus.” She’s already rubbing her temple. “Spare me the sappy details, please.”
“Sorry.” You awkwardly clear your throat. “It felt so romantic that night and when we made love—I-I mean, when we had sex—”
“You made love,” she flatly corrects back, unamused and unenthusiastic. “You don’t have to censor the words, it’s not like I’m allergic to them. Besides, it was never just straight out fucking with you two. You’ve been making love—” she says the last two words like they leave a sour taste on her tongue, “—for God knows how long by now. You just kept on insisting that you were having casual sex when literally everyone else but you knew that it was never just casual sex.”
“Right.” There’s absolutely no way you can have this conversation without turning flustered every three seconds. “Are you done? I’m trying to tell a story here if you don’t mind.”
“Sorry. Your relationship just gives me headaches, that’s all.”
“Would you prefer if I stop?”
“Oh, no, please, this is better than Grey’s Anatomy.” She slurps up her strawberry juice. “Do continue.”
She barely has any emotions on her face but there’s not a hint of sarcasm on her voice either. “So we made love, yes. But it was so… So beautiful and intimate and it just felt right to say what we’d been wanting to say. So he told me he loved me and I told him I loved him too.”
“That’s it?”
“That’s it.”
“Huh… Well, that’s anti-climatic. I thought he’d kneel in front of you with a ring or something.”
“E-Eren wouldn’t do something like that!”
“He kinda gives me that vibe, though. That nausea-inducing kind of prince charming vibe.” With a shrug, she climbs back to her feet. “Before I get back to that, would you excuse me for a second, please?” Ignoring your frown, she takes as much air as she can into her lungs and screams until your ears begin to ring. With her hands cupped around her mouth, she shouts, “POKKO! POKKO, COME HERE!” She’s garnering people’s attention at once but she doesn’t care. Around eight or nine cubicles away from you, Porco stands up from his seat with his face flushed, mouthing, “Are you insane?! Shut up!” Pieck makes some questionable gestures and when she still can’t convince him to come over, her voice booms again. “IF YOU DON’T COME HERE IN TEN SECONDS, I’M GOING TO TELL EVERYONE THAT YOU HAVE A GIGANTIC MOLE ON YOUR—”
Porco has never run so fast in his twenty-six years of living.
“W-what’s up?” He asks, landing one hand on your desk to support himself as he tries to catch his breath.
Pieck chimes in. “Jaegerbomb confessed to her and she told him she loved him too.”
“Wait—” You shriek, panic and shame mixed into one. “Pieck!”
“Shit, for real?” The thought appalls him once but Porco doesn’t stay like that for long. On the next second, he clicks his tongue in vexation. “Damn it,” he grumbles under his breath, “Why couldn’t he wait for another week.” He turns to Pieck, rummaging his back pocket in search of his wallet. “So, how much do I owe you? I’m really running low on the money here, Pieck. Be gentle with me.”
“I’ve always been gentle with you, Pokko, you know that.” Her naughty wink paints more color to his cheek. “A hundred bucks.”
“Fuck. I thought it was more, like, fifty.”
“Nope. But if you let me peg you tonight, I’ll call it even.”
“Sorry, how much was it again?”
“Guys?!” You stand up from your seat, face in flames. “You’re making bets on me?!”
Pieck has the biggest pout on her face when she receives her money from Porco. Clearly, she wanted him to choose her other offer. “Honey, I’m sorry,” she says, smiling apologetically at you even though she just blatantly made profits off you. “We just find it frustrating that the two of you never had the balls to speak your feelings out in the open when literally everyone could see that you were both in love with each other. So we figured, we might as well enjoy the show.”
“By making bets on me?!” You drag your eyes to Porco. “Pieck I could understand, but you? I expected better of you, Galliard.”
“Sorry,” he winces. “I really needed the money.”
“You just handed her a hundred-dollar bill!”
“Which would’ve stayed perfectly still in my wallet and got me another hundred dollar bill if you just kept your confession to yourself for another week!”
“Pokko, if you let me peg you again, I’ll give you back your money and double it—”
“WILL YOU STOP WITH THE PEGGING, PLEASE?!”
“Oh my God, why am I even friends with you two.” You have your face buried in your hands, moaning in exasperation.
“So, what are you planning to do next?” Porco leans against your desk, while Pieck sinks back into her chair. “You guys officially dating now or what?”
“No,” you mutter weakly, mentally drained. “I told him that I was still not ready to be in a relationship with him and he said it was okay to stay where we were.”
“For how long, though? You can’t tell me that you want to keep this up forever, right?” Seeing how you grow silent as you can’t find the answer, his forehead creases. “What is it? Is it because you feel like you’re not good enough for him?”
Truth is, yes, you’re still afraid that your personality and behavior—how you tend to be possessive over your partner, how often you go jealous over the simplest things—might put your relationship into jeopardy but with Eren… You think you can try. “I feel like…” You wet your lip. “I feel like I don’t worry about that as much as I did before. The more I get to know him, the more convinced I am that no matter what I do—no matter what I become—Eren will still accept me for who I am. And now, after I found out what happened to him, I think he’s afraid of the same thing too. Of me leaving him because he’s not good enough for me.”
Pieck leans closer. “Why do you think that?”
“Because when I told him about Armin, he didn’t act like he was jealous. He seemed…” Your heart squeezes at the memory. “Sad.”
As you’re deep in thoughts, Porco and Pieck exchange stares. “Well,” the man says, “Seems to me, you two understand each other very well. I don’t see why you shouldn’t take this relationship a step further.”
You have both hands resting on your lap, fingers curling tightly into balls of fists. “I don’t know…”
“Honey,” Pieck chimes in. “Let me ask you something. Are you planning to see other people?”
That you can answer instantly. “No.”
“Why not?”
“‘Cause I’m in love with him.”
“And he’s not going to date anyone else either.”
Your tongue lays heavy in your mouth. “I… hope so.”
“So, you’re both in love with one another, don’t want nor allow each other to date anyone else, and want to spend literally every breathing moment with each other for the rest of your lives.”
Heat pools in your face. You haven’t thought about spending your forever with him, but now that she’s mentioned it, that’s the only thing you can think about. And honestly? It isn’t such a bad idea. “Y-yeah, probably.”
She pokes her tongue against the inside of her cheek, staring flatly at you. “You know that there’s literally no difference between you dating him and not dating him, right?”
“I know—oh God,” you’re groaning with your hands on your hair, tugging at the strands.
“Maybe it’s because of his fans,” Porco helps you out. “I mean, his fanbase is insane. Never seen so many horny teenagers gathering in one comment section in my life. They were, like, talking about licking chocolate off his abs—”
“I’ll lick chocolate off your abs,” Pieck flirts, batting her eyelashes. “As long as you let me peg—”
“Jesus, read the room, Pieck.”
“Sorry.” At his scold, she returns to you. “Babe, I know it’s gonna get hard. And the faster you get familiar with all those death threats coming your way, the better.” She jabs her fork through her zucchini. “But, you just gotta remember that by the end of the day, he belongs to you. The only one who can ride that monstrous dick of his is you and no one else.”
Her choice of words doesn’t really faze you anymore. “I know, but that’s not what I’m worried about.” At Porco’s frown, you elaborate further. “A week and a half ago, he punched a journalist for mentioning me in his interview. I don't want that to happen again. I don’t want him to put his image and career on the line because of me. Being a musician has always been his dream, Pieck. I don’t want him to throw that away for me.”
“Did you tell him about this?” Porco asks.
“Yeah.”
“And what did he say?”
“He promised he wouldn’t do it again.”
“Then, believe in him.” The sandy blonde hair man rests one hand on top of your head, smiling as a way to comfort you. “You wanna be with him, right?” You sheepishly nod. “Then be with him. You can worry about the rest later. Cross the bridge when you get there, that’s what I’ve been telling you.”
You sigh. You know overthinking wouldn’t do you any good. You’re already at this point anyway. Going back is no longer an option you can choose—nor an option you want to choose.
“And,” Pieck adds, taking your hand and squeezing it lightly. “If things don’t work out, you still have us. Don’t worry, we’ll never break up with you, baby.”
You can’t help but chuckle. “Thanks, guys.”
***
Today passes by in a blink. The conversation you had with Pieck and Porco puts you at ease but at the same time, it pushes you forward, forcing you to decide your relationship as soon as possible. There’s no reason why you should postpone this any longer. The more you wait, the harder it would be to start, and the bigger the chance he’s hurting because of you.
I need to tell him.
And if I see him today, I will.
You slide your card key with a restless heart, mind running a thousand miles per hour, thinking about the way to lay down the conversation on the table. Is it really as simple as saying, ‘Eren, I want to date you’? What’s going to change after that?
Finding no answer, you push your door open and step inside your apartment. You’re welcomed by the darkness of your living room but it’s fine. You’ve remembered every corner of your apartment like the back of your hand. What bothers you is the fact that Eren’s not here, since the lights are off. Reaching for the nearest switch, you turn it on and let your kitchen and living room be illuminated at once. You feel your heart drop a little bit lower when you see that he’s nowhere in sight. No pair of lips parting to form your name before they brush against your own. No large hands pulling you into a warm embrace nor a chest to lay your cheek on.
You sigh. Since when did I become so attached to him? You haven’t seen him in not more than a day, and there you are, yearning to see him as if seasons have changed without him. Settling your belongings on the kitchen counter, you figure that today will only get even longer.
After quickly washing your hands, you make your way to the fridge, desperate to grab a can of cold drink and some dessert to ease the tension. There are a few leftovers from yesterday’s takeouts, including the strawberry cheesecake Eren has brought you from the Italian cafe you once visited. Bending down to take a spoonful of it into your mouth, two strong arms find their way to your waist.
“Missed me?”
Eren’s husky voice resonates right beside your ear, causing you to jump on your feet. Dropping your spoon, you feel your body being spun around, the startled noise that escapes your lips muffled by a pair of warm, sweeter ones. Closing the fridge with one foot, Eren pushes you up against it, one hand framing your face, another one holding you firmly by the waist. Right now, your heart is palpitating from shock, but in the next second, it’s solely because of the way his tongue swirls around yours, tasting the flavor of your strawberry cheesecake. He spends a minute to pour his longing for your touch into that one kiss and you let him, whimpering quietly against his mouth.
He lets you go when he’s satisfied, leaving you a bit dazed. There’s a naughty twinkle in his eyes as he breaks away, wiping off the cream from his bottom lip with his thumb and licking every bit of it off his digit. “Welcome home, baby.” He accompanies his line with his signature smirk, making it seem much less innocent than it’s supposed to be.
“You scared me.” You land a light punch on his chest, causing him to chuckle deeply.
“Sorry.” He leans in again to brush his lips against the spot between your eyebrows. “I’m glad you’re back. I’ve missed you.”
The way he just so easily causes your heartrate to soar from the simplest line is unbelievable. You let him kiss you once more before you whisper back with a shy smile. “I’m… glad to be home. I, uhh… I’ve missed you too.”
“Yeah?” Eren smirks, brushing his thumb over your glistening lower lip. “Kiss me again and show me how much then.”
No matter how embarrassed you are, he doesn’t take no for an answer. And there’s nothing left to do but to slant your lips against his, letting him taste you a little better.
The passion in his kiss reminds you of the day when your friends-with-benefits relationship just started. The little teasing bite on your supple skin, the way he tugs your bottom lip before he suckles on it, everything feels fiery and exciting—a stark contrast from all those tender, affectionate touches you’ve been sharing recently.
Eren, without needing to be asked, reaches over the counter to grab your favorite mug. “Have a seat,” he says. “I’ll make you some coffee.”
“Oh—umm—you don’t have to—“
“I want to.” He pats your head, showcasing his beautiful smile. Joy trickles down from your heart to every inch of your body. Taking a seat on the dining table, Eren joins you a moment later with two cups of sizzling hot coffee. “Here you go, Milady.”
You take the cup from his hand, tossing a smile as a token of your gratitude. “Thank you.”
“You’re welcome.” Eren drags back a chair, taking a seat beside you.
You can tell he’s admiring you from the side, his eyes raking over your side profile. Feeling like the room has gotten ten degrees hotter, you clear your throat. “H-how was, uhh…” You bring your mug closer to your lips. “How was your day?”
“Horny.”
You nearly lose your grip and accidentally splash a few drops of hot coffee to your shirt and hand. You hiss, wincing at the pain and Eren promptly stand up from his seat and leads you to the sink. Taking your hand gently in his, he pours cold water over the scalding skin. “Sorry,” he says. “Should’ve phrased my line better.”
“It wasn’t even a line,” you grumble but there’s no anger in your voice. If anything, you feel your heart warmed at the way he’s taking care of you over the smallest of injuries. “What do you mean by that anyway? No, wait, on second thought, I don’t think I wanna know.”
“Well, I found the lingerie you wore that night.” He tells you with a devilish smirk you haven’t seen in what feels like months. “Any chance I might be seeing you in it again?” He’s getting a little bit of his old self back, and it’s a nice change. Refreshing, even.
But no matter how thrilled you are to have that naughty version of him back, you narrow your eyes suspiciously at him. “Eren, you’re supposed to be reflecting on your mistakes,” you reprimand him.
“I am reflecting on my mistakes,” Eren argues, amusement standing thick in his voice. “I shouldn’t have let you go to work this morning. Could’ve done so many things to you if you had stayed at home.”
“I meant, the incident you had with Levi.” You take a quick look at his face, observing the bruises that begin to fade—almost entirely—from his skin. It has been a week and a half since his fight with Levi occurred. As ordered, he’s been staying at home—your home—to let his bruises heal and to make up for his mistakes by answering letters and signing posters and CDs to be given to his fans during his next concert. It’s a tedious job and Eren grumbles all the time as he does it. Honestly speaking, if it wasn’t because of you and your consistent nagging about how he should take care of his image properly, he wouldn’t have done it. “Have you thought about what you’re going to say to your manager when you’re back at the studio again?”
“I’ll think about that later,” Eren answers as he turns off the water. “I kept thinking about you—I could barely concentrate.” He examines your hand, exhaling in relief when he notices there’s no swelling. “I wrote down your name instead of mine when I signed one of my albums today.”
You can’t help but smile, thinking how much you two are alike. “You’re embarrassing.”
Every time he manages to make you giggle, elation washes over him. He wants nothing more than to do that every day, every hour, and every second of his life. “So,” he takes a step forward, reaching to either side of you to grab the ledge, and properly traps you within his arms. “I was thinking that maybe…” He tilts his head to the side, his lips hovering close to your ear. You close your eyes, feeling ticklish from the way his breath fans your skin and that deep, alluring voice of his. “We could go somewhere nice tomorrow.”
Your breathing becomes labored when you feel the tip of his nose brushing lightly against the side of your neck. Eren intentionally maintains an inch's worth of space, making you feel him without actually feeling him on your skin. “Where..?” Your voice turns hoarse, your hand unconsciously moving up to feel the muscles he hides behind his thin shirt but he doesn’t let you. He laces your fingers together, bringing it down until he has yours pinned against the counter.
“To the beach,” he whispers, finally taking your earlobe between his teeth, moaning softly because he knows how much his sultry voice drives you insane. “I’ve always wanted to take you there.”
You catch your bottom lip between your teeth, head lulling back to give him more access to your throat. “So we can have sex there?” You tease him with the same joke he made on the night when you both were staying on different continents.
“Well, I was thinking more about swimming and building sandcastles with you, but sure okay.”
You laugh, but only for a second before it turns into a suppressed moan. “I don’t think…” You swallow, surrendering yourself to him. “We’re gonna get any sandcastles done.”
“Yeah,” he answers breathily, loving the way your skirt rides up your thighs when he settles his knee between your legs. “Probably not.”
He’s so sensual—every bit of him is. His tone, his gaze, his little touches that spark electricity on your skin. Unsatisfied and impatient with the pace he’s going, you grind your hips against him. “Eren—” His mouth finds yours, fingers framing your jaw to keep you under his control. You clamp your hand around his wrists, eyebrows furrowed at the intensity of his kiss. “I want you,” you gasp against his mouth.
“Me too,” he groans, lifting your body by the waist and settling you down on the counter. Your legs spread naturally for him and Eren wastes no second before he settles himself between them. You’re gasping against each other’s mouth when your hips make contact, his hand gripping tightly against your thigh. “Fuck, I want you so bad, baby girl.”
You shudder, your insides churning. “Then—”
You're both interrupted by the sound of your stomach grumbling. It’s so unexpected, so embarrassing that it takes you three seconds to convince yourself that no, this isn’t happening but that thought shortly morphs into fuck, okay, so that did happen, but hopefully he didn’t hear it?
But when your eyes meet again, your heart trembles in horror because Eren is trying his very best not to laugh at you. Your face feels like it's seconds away from exploding, hands shooting up to cover your expression. “Please don’t laugh at me—I—I didn’t know why—”
Eren, still chuckling softly, retrieves your hands away and fills the gap between your fingers with his. “You’re adorable,” he says, making you feel even more flustered. “You haven’t eaten anything on your way back?”
“No…” You pout, still feeling completely distraught by the sound of your grumbling stomach. “You?”
“Nope. I wanted us to eat together so I waited for you.” With his help, you land back on your feet. “Sorry, I should’ve asked you about it when you arrived. I got, uh... distracted.”
“It’s…” You’re having the hardest time meeting his gaze. “It’s okay.”
Eren presents you with a quick peck on the cheek before he walks deeper into the kitchen, stealing your apron from the top drawer and ties it around his waist. “Give me fifteen minutes, okay?” he says, unfastening his hair tie just so he can bind his hair up again. “I can’t make anything fancy but how do you feel about having some Pad Thais for dinner?”
It feels like a dream. This man—this beautiful, beautiful man—standing before you with his delicate smile intact and his emerald eyes gleaming like crystal, acting like the perfect husband you could never even begin to imagine. Instead of answering, you half-run toward him and wrap your arms tightly around his waist. You knock some air out of his lungs from how hard you’re embracing him but Eren chortles, tangling his arms around the curves of your body. “Baby, I love you but as much as I enjoy being hugged like this, I can’t really cook if—“
“Eren,” you stop him, and his eyes widen slightly at the firmness in your tone.
Seeing you nervous makes him nervous. “W-what?”
I need to tell him. I need to tell him now. “I want—”
Your phone rings.
The sound makes you both freeze in an instant, two pairs of eyes peering into each other. None of you wants to acknowledge it but it grows persistent. With your heart feeling like it’s being chained down to an anchor, you step away from him. “Sorry, can you give me a minute? It might be important.”
“Sure.” Eren’s eyes don’t give you the permission you need but his smile does, no matter how forged it seems.
You return to your purse, snatching your phone with one hand, and take a glance at the caller ID.
It’s Armin.
Your heart palpitates hard. Not sure if it’s because you’re thrilled to have him call you again after all this time staying in the dark, or because Eren is there and he’s close enough to hear the conversation you’re going to have with him. Pressing the phone against your chest, you move away to the living room before you answer it.
Eren raises a brow but that’s it. The rest of his expression is too guarded and you don’t have the time to decipher every bit of it yet. Without asking questions, he makes his way to the fridge, grabbing the ingredients he needs to make his special dinner for two.
You take a seat on the couch, inhaling deeply before you answer the call. “Armin, hi,” you speak so quietly you’re almost whispering to the phone.
“Hey…” His honeyed voice never changes, still so light and pleasing to listen to. “Bad timing?”
“No. It’s fine. I just, uh, I just got home. What’s up?”
There’s a pause that makes you wonder whether he’s staying mute because he’s hesitating on what to say or whether he can tell by how nervous you are that you’re not alone in your apartment. Either way, Armin doesn’t stay voiceless for long. “I’m sorry for not… seeing you in a while…”
Your heart jerks. You whirl your head to the side, catching a glimpse of Eren’s back as he chops down some green onions. He doesn’t seem to pay you any attention and you let out a breath, slightly relieved as you lean your back against the couch. “It’s okay…” You speak to the phone with your lips breaking into a delicate smile. “Is everything all right with you?”
“Yeah. Everything’s fine. I just—” You can hear him take a shaky breath. “I just really missed you.”
You’re treating Armin like a best friend you’ve always wished to have, but you know he’s not treating you the same way. It’s written clearly in his voice that he has missed you as something more than a friend he shares his favorite books with. The yearning, the aching he holds for you… Maybe it’s wise for you not to indulge him but you can’t lie to yourself. Even when it’s not the same as how you felt when Eren wasn’t around, you did miss him. You still miss him. And Armin deserves your honesty. “I’ve missed you too, Armin…”
There’s a quiver in the breath he releases. “I want to see you…”
“I want to see you too.”
“So… So badly…“ His voice breaks. “You don’t know how much I want to be there with you right now…”
There’s something different about him. Instead of the usual nervous, easily flustered, young boy Armin Arlert, what stands in his shoes right now is a man with a broken heart. He’s honest to his soul, tired of building walls around him to keep his emotions hidden from the world.
“Armin?” You sew your eyebrows together in concern. “Are you okay?”
He takes a moment to himself, desperate in trying to stay composed. When he returns to his phone, his voice sounds firmer. “I’d like to take you out tomorrow.”
“T-tomorrow?” It seems like the roles are reversed. You’re the one who’s easily surprised and nervous about everything. You take another look at Eren, stammering, “Oh, umm… I—”
“Please?” Armin begs. “I know it’s so sudden but… tomorrow is my birthday and I—“
“What?!” You gasp, your jaw turns slack. “I thought you said your birthday was on Christmas Eve!”
“Well, I—“ There’s guilt in his voice. “I lied. I didn’t want you to make a big deal out of it, so…”
“Armin…” You sigh. “You should’ve told me.”
“Please don’t be mad.”
“I’m not mad, I’m—” You catch yourself. “I just wish you told me. I haven’t bought you any gift.”
“You don’t have to get me anything.”
“No, but I want to. You’ve given me so much, I wanted to give you something special in return for your birthday. I thought it was still months away…”
Armin can sense the sadness and disappointment in your voice, you can tell. “Then just come with me tomorrow. Please…” His plea comes out in a whisper. “Even if it only just for a few hours, I… I really want to spend my birthday with you…”
Your heart breaks. Has he ever sounded this lonely before? Your eyes drift back to Eren once again, your mind running through multiple scenarios at once. If you decline his invitation, Armin is definitely going to distance himself away from you, even worse than he already is now and you don’t want to lose your best friend. If you say yes, you’ll make him happy. You can probably fix whatever it is that’s falling apart between you, but then…
How is Eren going to feel about that? You’ve stated many times before that you wouldn’t return Armin’s feelings for you, but if you were in his shoes, you would still worry about it, wouldn’t you?
“It’s…” Armin’s voice sounds like he’s speaking in a distance. “It’s okay if you say no…”
You must have taken too long to think about this. With a heavy heart, you decide to go with, “Can I call you again later? I need to—” You swallow hard. “I need to check on something first.”
“Huh? Oh... Okay…” The despondency lays thick in his voice, to the point that you almost hurriedly say yes to his offer.
“In a minute,” you promise him. “I’ll call you again in a minute.”
He stays mute for a few seconds before a weak, “Okay,” makes it to the other line.
“Okay… Bye.” You tap your thumb on your phone, ending the call, and watch his name disappear from the screen. You close your eyes, exhaling heavily.
What am I going to do?
Eren, noticing your footsteps closing in, stops his hands from slicing more bell peppers. He turns around to face you. “I’m hoping that wasn’t your boss?” He tries to lighten up the mood with a smile but your lips feel too heavy to mirror the action. “What?” His eyebrows are knitted in concern as he sees the way your face turns pensive. “Something wrong?”
“It was Armin.”
Silence strikes like a hurricane and you wonder if it was better to lie about it. No, it’s not. Telling lies would never solve a problem and Eren deserves better than to hear one.
“Oh…” is his only response. There’s sadness in his voice that may not sound too vivid to anyone else’s ears since he’s trying his best to cover it, but you notice it, causing your stomach to swirl uncomfortably.
“Yeah…” You fiddle with your fingers. “He’s having his birthday tomorrow and… Well, he asked me to go with him somewhere.”
“I see.” His shoulders slump slightly, attempting a smile even when he can barely meet your eyes. “Well, I think you should go.”
You look up at him from behind your bangs. “You—you do?”
“Yeah, sure.” He nonchalantly shrugs. “He wanted to spend his birthday with you, right?”
“Y-yeah…” You can’t say that his answer doesn’t surprise you. “But, Eren, if you don’t want me to go, I’ll—“
“You should go.” He doesn’t say I want you to go, you notice and that’s when you realize that he hates the thought of letting you go but he’s trying his best to be considerate—to not steal the options away from you.
The heaviness in his voice still makes you feel restless. “Will you come with me?” You know it’s out of the line to ask him without Armin’s permission, but you can’t stop yourself.
Eren goes stiff but only for a split second before he melts into another smile that seems so forced, it nearly makes you flinch. “I wasn’t invited, Sweetheart.”
“You’re his friend too. I don’t think Armin would mind—”
“I think he would.” His tone turns a little bit colder but not bitter. “It’s okay. Just go and have fun.”
You bite the inside of your cheek, your chest tightening in discomfort. “But you said you wanted to take me to the beach tomorrow.”
“It can wait. Unlike him, I can take you out anytime I want. Armin only gets to celebrate his birthday once a year.” He chuckles once, dedicating himself to act better to assure you. “Really, it’s okay. I’ll be here and wait until you get home. You know, just hang around, play some games. Maybe jack-off a little when I get too bored.” He throws you a flirty wink.
You deeply scrutinize his face, not convinced in the slightest. You want him to tell you how he truly feels about this but you’ve pushed hard enough and Eren is devoted to keeping his feelings concealed. And, well, Eren’s right. Armin only gets to celebrate his birthday once a year and he chose to celebrate it with you.
“Then…” you finally say with a timid smile. “I guess I’m gonna take his offer.”
Eren nods. “As you should.”
“I won’t stay out too long, I promise.”
“Good, ‘cause I don’t want to miss you too much,” he says with a boyish grin but it lacks the warmth it used to have. “Anyway, just realized we’re running out of sugar. I’ll head downstairs to buy some.”
You blink twice, caught off guard but when he’s starting to walk away, you quickly chase after him. “Wait, I’ll go with you.”
“No, it’s fine.” Eren casts a smile, dragging open the door with one hand. “I’ll be quick.”
“But Eren—“
You’re answered by the dull sound of a closing door. You have one hand stretched out, hanging in the air before it returns powerlessly to your side. Your head throbs, your heart aches and as you make your way back to the kitchen, you notice one thing.
You still have a full jar of sugar sitting on your counter.
***
Eren is out of your sight but he doesn’t leave right away. Instead, he enjoys the silence that the hallway of your building provides him as he leans his spine against your closed front door. He shuts his eyes, his skull making a dull thud as it knocks lightly against it.
What am I doing?
Honestly, he hates what he’s doing. But Armin is your best friend, and he knows how much you cherish him. Eren doesn’t want to be awful to you; doesn’t want to be too possessive over you that he wouldn’t allow you to meet another man just because you’re together with him. He’s not like that. He’s not going to be that guy.
He doesn’t have any reason to be jealous. He believed you when you said nothing was going on between you and Armin, he still does but… It doesn’t mean he can completely be fine handing you over to someone else to spend a special day together.
Someone who’s much better than him too.
Stop it, he states firmly in his head, curling his fingers into balls of fists. She said she loved you. She said she wouldn’t answer his feelings, so just keep a blind eye to it. This won’t change anything.
Eren sighs into the air.
I hope it won’t change anything.
***
“Eren…”
You lay a hand gently on his shoulder, cold fingers pressing against his warm skin. He’s still lying down on his stomach, bundled in a thick blanket. He’s wearing nothing but his lounge pants as he always finds it uncomfortable to wear shirts to bed. His long hair is untied, tousled from sleep. He looks younger like this, deep in serenity, far away from the fame and the traumatic past that puts a heavy weight on his shoulders. “Eren, wake up…” You shake him lightly, enough for his eyebrows to furrow before a pair of stunning jade green eyes come into view. “Hey…” You cast him a smile, carding your fingers gently through his hair. “Sorry, I had to wake you up.”
He mumbles incoherently, his words almost too slurry for you to catch on but you manage. “What time is it?” he questions.
“Eight-thirty. It’s still a bit early but I’m leaving in ten minutes.”
He pushes himself off the bed, weak and lazy. You fix his blanket to cover his body, worried that he might catch a cold. With eyes squinting to adjust to the morning sunlight, he takes a look at your appearance. “Why are you so pretty?”
You almost laugh. “I’m not.” He’s the one who looks so pretty, effortlessly so. Eren doesn’t wear makeup much even when he’s on stage since he already looks so handsome without it. They just need to style his hair and that’s it. He’s perfection from the start. “I’ve made you some pancakes and poached eggs,” you tell him. “Eat them before they get cold. There’s some orange juice in the fridge. You can have my pudding if you want to.”
His brain hasn’t functioned properly yet but as he rubs his eyes away from sleep, he mutters, “Okay…”
You nibble on your lower lip. Somehow, a huge part of you still doesn’t want to let him stay in your apartment by himself. But you have to go. You know you have to. So you lean in to place a soft kiss on his temple. “I promise I won’t be long.” You stroke his cheek. “I’ll be back home before you know it.”
Eren’s eyes are still a bit hazy but he nods. You give him a light kiss on the lips before you climb down the bed. He reaches out a hand to grab yours, stopping you on your tracks. “Eren?”
“Five minutes,” he says. “Give me five minutes to wash my face. I’ll drive you.”
“Huh? Oh, no, you don’t have to. Armin is picking me up with his car. He’s already on his way.”
“Then, I’ll walk you downstairs.”
��Eren—“
“Please.”
His eyes don’t plead, nor the tone of his voice, but they leave you speechless, nonetheless. With your heart feeling like it’s being squeezed tightly, you nod your head.
***
Your walk down to the lobby with Eren matching your steps from the side happens with a very little amount of words being exchanged and an endless excruciating silence. Eren’s hands are buried deep in the pockets of his grey hoodie, his eyes droopy but not bleary from sleep. He holds the elevator door open for you and you toss him a smile as a form of gratitude, one that he refuses to see. Keeping his eyes away from making contact with yours, Eren leans his head against the steel sheet, his eyes turn vacant as his face grows pensive. You’re in dire need to find a conversation that could ease the tension, but every time a word form insides your head, it never finds its way to your lips.
He’s upset.
He’s clearly not okay with this.
Maybe I shouldn’t go.
But I already promised Armin I’d see him.
God, why does this have to happen now? We were doing so well with each other.
“Hey,” Eren’s call yanks you back to reality. He has his index finger pressed against the button, holding the door open for you. “Aren’t you going to step out?”
Get a grip on yourself. “Yeah, sorry.” You walk past the frame with Eren following your steps soon after.
“You seem distracted,” he says, tucking his hands inside his pockets again as he walks next to you. He sneaks glances to observe your expression but he never lets his eyes linger long enough for you to notice. “Are you okay?”
You resist the urge to look at him. “I’m fine. Are you?”
“I’m fine.” His tone doesn’t give you a hint of his true feelings and it frustrates you. You’re on the verge of stopping on your tracks when you take a step outside your building, wanting to confront him about it—whether he’s okay with everything because you really don’t want to make him worry over something that he shouldn’t have worried about. Stepping off the stairs, you turn to face him. “Eren—”
A car—Armin’s car—drives close, stopping at the side of the road, just a few meters away from you’re standing. Eren looks up, face turning solemn but again, more guarded than ever. “He’s here,” he tells you, but you don’t turn around to greet the person you’ve been wanting to see in the last few weeks. You keep your eyes on the person that matters. Eren’s teal ones slowly drift back to yours as Armin turns off the engine. He weakly smiles. “You should go.”
Please don’t look at me like that, you want to say. Don’t look at me like I’m breaking your heart. “Eren,” there’s desperation in your voice and you know he’s aware of that too. “You don’t have to worry about this. Armin and I—” Your breath catches in your throat when Eren suddenly walks forward, moving past you. You can hear him greet Armin behind you, a little of his chuckles erupting in the air.
You clutch a hand against your heart, hoping it could tear away the invisible hand that’s been squashing it tightly.
You spin around to see Armin turning pale, his sapphire eyes growing wide in shock. “E-Eren…” He gapes. “W-why are you—I’m surprised to see you here.”
“Yeah…” The brunette rubs the back of his head. His smile is polite and a bit awkward, a perfect facade to lie his way through the conversation. “I wanted to pick her up for breakfast but she said she had plans with you.”
“Oh…” Armin drags his eyes to the side, finding their way to your face. “Y-yeah, we, umm… I was going to take her out for breakfast too.”
“Ah, right.” Eren’s smile doesn’t reach his eyes but Armin is too baffled to notice. “Well, she’s all yours since you already made plans with her first. I heard that it’s your birthday today?” The golden-haired man hasn’t found the proper words to speak when Eren congratulated him on it. “Have a blast today, man.”
You’ve been staying mute all the time, fully knowing that you’re going to make the situation a hundred times more awkward than it already is if you intervene. It’s when Eren steps back, gesturing you to come close with yet another smile that you brave yourself to greet him. “Hey, Armin. You’re right on time.” You step closer, avoiding making eye contact with Eren and focusing more on making your smile seem genuine to the other man.
Armin moves his eyes from you and Eren, silently scrutinizing. You can tell how he grows even more suspicious by the second, most likely wondering whether you two had spent the night together for Eren to be wandering this early around your neighborhood.
Wanting to divert his attention, you nudge your head toward the direction of his car. “Shall we go?” You don’t wait for his answer, already making your way forward.
“Huh? Oh—” He follows you as you barely give him any choice to stay. Armin whirls his head around to take a glance at the musician and Eren hides his hands inside the pockets of his hoodie again, hoping that it would be enough to conceal the way his nails are sinking deep into his palms.
“Take care of her for me, Arlert,” he says, maintaining his smile. Armin, no matter how restless and uncertain he is, answers timidly with a nod.
Eren keeps his eyes on you as you step inside the car, but you never look back. You’re too anxious, afraid that you’d witness the pain he tries to hide behind those eyes. Even when Armin steps one foot on the engine, you never do.
And Eren is standing there on the side of the road, leaning his back against the streetlamp’s pole. He watches as the car drives away and he keeps his lips pressed tightly until they turn white.
Seriously…
What the hell am I doing…?
***
Time seems to slow down. The universe stands still as Eren lets his eyes linger on the ceiling of your living room. It's funny how silence never seemed to strike as something unbearable, but an old friend that he grew to welcome ever since his mother walked away from his life. Silence gave him solitude. Silence gave him peace of mind. But right now… Right now, silence equals loneliness and loneliness… Well, nobody wants to be alone. Eren thought he was different, but ever since he knew how it felt like to spend every precious hour with you, he realized he wasn’t. Maybe he even dreads being alone now.
He hasn’t done much in the past few hours, his thoughts too clouded to function. It’s only his chest that’s making a constant motion, heaving up and down, slow and steady as he lies down on the couch; one hand draping over his stomach, his other one dangling around the edge. He only heeds to his surrounding once the sun starts stepping its way down the stairs, waiting for the moon to reclaim its throne. You’ve been gone since morning, and during those times, his thoughts constantly revolve around the questions he’s been trying to turn a blind eye to.
Where does he take you? What are you doing now?
Is he making you smile in the way I never did?
Making you feel in the way I never did?
When you come home to me later, will I still be the only one in your mind?
Eren trusts you. He trusts you with all his heart, more than anyone else in the world, and if you say you love him, he takes your words for it. It’s just… It’s not impossible to be in love with two people at once, he concedes with a sigh, closing his eyes. And Armin… Armin is the kind of person that can be loved easily. He can offer you a million reasons for you to love him, and a million reasons why he should love you. Unlike him.
It’s like another soul is residing within him, someone whose voice turns vehement when he’s sinking too deep in his past. And the more Eren listen to it, the more it makes sense.
What if I only get to be with her because I met her first?
What if I didn’t?
What if Armin was the one who stayed with you from the beginning, and I only just walked in now by coincidence?
Will you still love me? Will you even notice me?
Eren hates himself for not being able to find the answers. And he knows you’ll hate this part of him too if you know what’s been crossing his mind. But he can’t help it. The fear of being abandoned is always there, and it will never change. When he’s with you, he’s cured. He doesn’t give in to his other part. You’re his medication, an addicting drug but once you’re gone, he’ll fall back into relapse. And the more silence befriends him, the bigger his fear is taking shape in his head.
Maybe the reason why she isn’t brave enough to take a further step in our relationship is that she’s still unsure of her feelings. Unsure of her feelings for me.
Or maybe she’s in love with Armin too and she’s taking her time to sort her thoughts.
Then… Who will she choose?
Now that they’ve become close again, is it still gonna be me she’ll pick in the end?
Eren stands up from his seat, his jaw clenching hard. Shut up, you idiot. Just shut up and don’t think.
He moves toward the window, his silhouette painted by the sunset. He watches the brown leaves detach themselves from the trees, carried by the wind before it falls helplessly to the concrete pavements. As his eyes follow, he notices that Armin’s car has been parked on the side of the road. His heart jerks. They’re here, he thinks with a hammering heart, how long have they been standing there?
Eren takes a step closer, his palm pressing against the glass as he watches intently. Even from the third floor, he can see the way Armin smiles fondly at you. He’s in deep conversation with you, his hair seeming golden underneath the light. He laughs a little over something you say, a pair of shy, sapphire blue eyes peeking from behind his bangs as he’s too diffident to meet your gaze. He’s a boy with a heart too innocent for the world to ruin, and it’s pure the way he loves you, his gaze untainted.
Eren feels his chest tightening, his nails sinking into his palms. From where he’s standing, he can’t see your face, witnessing only the way your hair is half-tucked inside the collar of your coat. But when you press your palm gently on Armin’s cheek, Eren sees it. When you circle your arms around his neck, pull him closer until he envelopes you with all his warmth, Eren sees it.
And when Armin’s thin lips meet your softer ones, Eren sees it too.
***
Next Chapter
A/N:
Guys, I'm so sorry it's 24k long 😭 I was also rushing a little bit to meet my deadline so I'm so sorry if there are a lot of grammatical errors in this chapter 😭😭😭
Also, this chapter includes the angry sex scene that anon requested. congratulations for making the right guess about Mikasa. I hope you like the scene, anon! ❤️ I tried my best not to make him sound toxic, i hope it works 😭
SUPER HUGE thanks to @justasketch for being such a thorough reader. like man, the way you always managed to notice the smallest details I forgot to put in. I LOVE YOU BRO SERIOUSLY
Tagging: @tasteless @l6ffys @vivi-et @halparkebitch @fwess @littlemochi @thebeardedmoon @luvtaromilktea @didiyogo @xximthefoolxx-blog @coyloves @erenbean @tehehebri @infnteen @naiomiwinchester @spiderlingh @doyochii @ahornyenby @jeagersruletheworld @sakurashell @indiecursor @the-princess-button @resonancesoul @link-avalon thanks so much for reading, lovelies! Let me know what you think ❤️
798 notes
·
View notes