All the brothers...
I can't grasp it well yet, but I feel like Tolkien really loved writing a dynamins between two (exactly 2) brothers, especially twins, and making them a stark contrast.
Melkor and Manwe, of course. The good Vala and the bad Vala. Both into the same woman. One is the king, the other wants to be the king. Names start with the same letter, we'll see more of it later. Good / purity vs evil.
Do the lamps count? Do the trees count? Sun and moon? Generally: silver light and golden light.
(skipping Feanor, and two other Fs, because there were 3 brothers)
Another M-pair: Maedhros and Maglor. Fire and water. Not only in their final fates, but music is of water too. (and the third Silmaril ends up free in the air)
Curufin and Celegorm, Indoors and outdoors guy, but both pretty awful. (Caranthir doesn't count, he spent less time with them)
Amrod and Amras, and of course, on twin dies, the other lives (for now). Also, again one is tied to fire and fell fate.
Huor and Hurin, extended to their sons: Tuor and Turin. One did great deeds, one was doomed. Destiny at its best and its worst.
Dior's sons, surprisingly they probably both died? But at least they were twins, so maybe I should include them.
Elrond and Elros. Twins theme at its peak. Men and Elves. Immortality and death. Fading into background and short-lived, doomed glory. Also, they tie to M&M. also, Elros's heritage dies in water, which ties him even more to Maglor. And Elrond is, surprisingly, tied to the element of air, because of his Ring.
Elrond has twins again (+Arwen) but we aren't told their fates.
Isildur and Anarion?
I probably forgot some more pairs.
Well, after I wrote it down, it's not a lot, but I still feel like it's a strong theme in the Silm. Dualities. Mostly
silver / gold and Elves/Men, I would say those map on one another and maybe West / East is also similar. Silver-elves-West and gold-Men-East
also, the lines of Numenor kings and Andunie tie to the previous one partially
One lives (at least for some time) and weeps, the other dies quickly.
some subset of Fire/Air/Water
Maybe it's just me. I was always sad as a kid that I was the only one.
Thoughts?
40 notes
·
View notes