Brodie and the role of determination in "Still Wakes the Deep"
From the start, Still Wakes the Deep depicts Brodie as one of the more clear-headed characters after the Beria D is, effectively, attacked by the entity. Granted, if you're working on an oil rig, you (probably) have to be a certain person to work under high-stress conditions. As the apparent diver on the Beria (and senior figure, after Roper, Innes, Trots, Finlay, and Rennick) Brodie is probably accustomed to working under pressure (literally and figuratively).
Brodie operates under the pretense of what my former supervisor called, "positive reinforcement". Highlight a person's strengths, and address their weaknesses as "areas for improvement". Hence why he gets annoyed with Caz when he heightens Rafferty's anxieties about going down in the diving bell with his own personal fears.
Folks like Douglas and Rafferty look to him to know what to do, so Brodie takes it as a personal failing when someone is harmed under his charge. When Gregor and Caz fall into the water, he's the one who goes in after them. And given the height both fell from, by the time he was prepared to dive, he shouldn't have been able to find either, but he gets lucky with Caz.
Of the survivors, Brodie is together enough to send Finlay down to restart the generators as they're cutting out and sends Caz to reach the surviving radios (initially). Even when preoccupied with another situation, Brodie was forward-thinking enough to consider mitigating the broader damage on the Rig.
When a panicky Caz, probably to his surprise, completes what he sent Finlay to do, he reorients Caz (by hyping him up a little) and asks him to help with tension wenches in the Pontoons. Whatever reservations he might have about Caz's anxieties, Brodie appreciates that he's willing to throw himself into certain danger to help.
Brodie's determination to save the Rig, perhaps to save themselves (because there was no way to physically leave the rig without transportation) was such a gripping story beat to watch play out between himself and Finlay.
Way before Caz gets himself out of the pontoons and encounters a mutated O'Connor, they're talking to (or at) each other in notes. Brodie operates like the situation is another high-stakes circumstance that he (as a diver) must be accustomed to. Process of elimination.
He is pushing to save the Rig, but only long enough for rescue. But his initial plans fail. The surviving radios don't work, so they can't reach the support ship. Most of the Rig is collapsing and flooding from the damage. Stabilizing the tension wenches leaves the Rig vulnerable to sinking. The tone of Finlay's notes suggests they should focus more on leaving the Rig altogether, instead of hailing the support ship. (Again, the issue with that being, of course, that there's nothing sea-worthy left on the Rig to even float on.)
And she's already speculating at the entity's intentions after seeing so many of their coworkers die, transform, or become gore on the walls. Brodie, however, isn't particularly curious about the entity beyond seeing it as an (environmental) obstacle. Stabilizing the flare stack prevents explosion, but he initially believes it was at the expense of Caz's life.
Brodie could be motivated by what happened to Raffs in the diving bell. I can't imagine seeing someone under your charge explode into a hostile lump of tentacles and inhumanity would leave you anything but determined to save as many people as you can, bad odds be damned.
And in that dynamic, the person delaying what's inevitable really can't stop the person who's decided about what they'll do. And, for me, that's interesting, as Brodie and Finlay were both kinda positioned in the story to be 'dependable' and 'pragmatic' in the face of terror.
Both of them try to sway Caz from going after Roy, but relent, knowing he won't be any good to them with his mind elsewhere except in the priority situation (the tension wenches).
(One of the last bits of advice he gives to Caz when they're face-to-face is to make his every move count, and not panic when he goes underwater.)
In most circumstances, I would've expected Finlay and Brodie's roles to be reversed. So, that Finlay was the one to just accept that they were all doomed after a certain point, was nice.
Brodie's willingness to venture into certain danger and death ultimately seals fates and is catalyst enough to push Finlay to do what she'd been thinking about since their exchanges. Caz is convinced of Brodie's own "jamminess", that he believes he can get out of the oil-flooded pontoon to return to them, and if he can't, he has him to rely on. Brodie knows otherwise, and, so, home (Isle of Skye) is the last thing he thinks of before imploring the others to escape.
I don't know if the Isle of Skye is considered a "harbor town", but Brodie's apparent comfort in and underwater struck me as a connection to his home. That he dies, drowning in oil, feels like a cruel irony of circumstances.
On a more personal level, given that Scottish / English / Irish narratives trend towards whiteness (and are often loaded with weird "racial purity" undertones), I wasn't expecting Still Wakes the Deep to have any significant characters of color in the game. That Brodie is the only Black character in the game with a major speaking and narrative role within the narrative (and voiced by a Black actor, thankfully) is a double-edged sword.
It's a) par for the course (and disappointing), but also b) nice to see a predominantly white narrative acknowledge Black Scotsmen exist. Sunil (Scottish) and Dobbie (Irish) are two other Black/Brown characters with lines, but they're minor characters (both killed by a mutated Muir on the Derrick).
Throughout the multiple playthroughs I've watched since SWTD was released, I've always found it extremely baffling that most (white) players assumed malice on Brodie's part when he's surprised to see Caz survive the collapse of the skywalk connecting to the stack.
He's clearly relieved to see his friend alive, but most were like, "Was he trying to kill Caz?" And it's like, how the hell did y'all come to that conclusion?
And if I were to speculate about the entity's intentions, it wouldn't be much interested in going anywhere except back down below. The potential threat that was the Rig, is no longer a danger to its existence. Hence why everything it pulled apart and invaded, was gradually sinking under the water.
26 notes
·
View notes
SWTD Plot Part 1
That insane moment where you decide to write a play by play plot list of the entirety of still wakes the deep for fanfics you may or may not even write....
Story notes
The Start
Starts with Suze sending him a letter talking about divorce on Christmas in the 3rd deck
Trots comes gets Caz and tells him Rennicks looking for him
Kelly and Douglas room
Caz finds Finlay down the hall she asks for a light before telling him he's in deep shit with Rennick because he got some letters from the mainland
She complains about Cadel and Rennick being cheap
Caz goes to get breakfast
Gibbo rooms with Dobbie
Addier signed up for double portions Roy caught him
Canteen (accommodation)
Conversation between trots, O’Connor and gibbo
Trots talking about unions, industrial actions and Cadel making cuts to get more rigs going
Gibbo thinks he's being ridiculous
O’Connor agrees with him stating they're down to a skeleton crew in the pontoons
Conversation between brodie and Raffs
Raffs going for his first solo dive
Brodie is looking out for him and chides Caz when he mentions he would never do a solo dive
Raffs is nervous
Addier is eating alone
He antagonizes Caz saying it'll be his last day and pokes fun at his lack of ‘good’ work
Caz bites back with how he couldn't hold a light when doing his job.
Cracks a joke and everyone laughs (you wouldnt know a spark plug from a fucking hairdryer)
Conversation with Roy
Rennick immediately buzzes the announcer calling Caz to his office
Caz tells Roy about Suze whose thinking about divorce
Roy tells him not to worry about it too much and to next time think before battering in Billy chamberlains head next time (not dead but certainly injured)
Apparently, he made some unclean comments criticizing Suze and Caz swung on him
Roy reassures that the lord loves Caz and so does Suze
Dobbie passes by the kitchen door and lets Roy know that trots left roys insulin in his cabin
Trots is Russian??? Maybe German
The Deck
Innes and Muir are bantering on the lower deck
Muir makes a comment about Innes's head being hard to miss
Innes chides him saying the Rennick is just itching to give someone a kicking
Banky is working on the stairs making Caz go around
Yellow sign says Cadel Beira D 2/23 (February 23rd?)
Rennick again announces to us questioning why were not in his office, this happens multiple times with different phrasing throughout this area.
Caz askes Innes and Muir if they need a hand
Muir lets them know that they're alright
To which Innes adds on that if he wants to transfer to the deck, he should give him less lip/backtalk
Muir buts in saying not to mind Innes he loves it
Another announcement, they assure Caz that he'll be alright and to try not to punch him
Conversation between Sunil and Alex
Sounds like they're trying to fit metal parts
Alex says they've got gaps to will Sunil comments that the drill crew will love that
Alex reply's that Rennick will love it even more and that Sunil's telling him
Sunil replies that he told him last time and its Alex's turn
Sunil is on top deck, Alex lower
Conversation with roper
Roper is usually in marine control but came down as the drill is acting up, has everybody scrambling to figure out the problem thought they can't.
He’s hoping they won't get behind schedule, most likely to avoid Rennicks outbursts
Roper and un-named are in the derrick
Conversation between McClurg and Bruce
Talking about shipments that won't be coming in for a few weeks
McClurg says he can patch it but might want to say some prayers
Bruce seems exasperated as they've been needing a lot of those lately
Dalgliesh warns Caz to stere clear of the lift as to not get crushed
Scooby startles Caz (calls him Mcleary)
Asks Caz to quickly fix the fuse box while he's down there and toss down a screwdriver
Scooby is on the upper deck
Administration
Rennick in installation manager office, above administration
Conversation with Rennick
He is pissed, really pissed. Rennick is upset about the letter he got from the police and yells at Caz about how he runs a tight ship and there is no excuse for how he's a liability.
Revealed that Caz was a pro boxer, however no matter how popular he is on shore on the rig Rennick is the ‘fucking king’.
Caz tries to explain how he can sort this with some time, but Renick cuts him off
Rennick gets a phone call from gibbo presumably telling him that the drill hit something, and he thinks they should stop and investigate before continuing.
Despite gibbo and roper advising against it Rennick orders them to continue drilling or he’ll come down there himself
The call ends and Caz makes a comment causing Rennick to tell him he's fired and to get off his rig.
Helipad
3 people on helipad, Gregor, archie and someone else
Something explodes causing Gregor to fall off the edge, Caz notices and runs after him while archie screams at him to get away from the edge
Gregor begs for Caz to help him, to not let him die
A second small explosion causes Gregor's hands to slip from the railing. Sending him plummeting into the sea
This is followed by a third, larger explosion the sends Caz over the edge after him
Caz falls into the ocean cutting his vision
Screen flashes with flesh like tones akin to an injurie matched with flashing distorted images and memories.
This is where the story will start
The true Beginning
There is a memory sequence with Roy, Caz and Suze
They're talking about Caz working on the rig, Suze is against the idea and goes back a fourth with Roy
It's brought up how Roy forgot their wedding cake on a bench
Roy promises to take care of Caz
Caz was going to be stationed for four months on the rig
The Dive Deck
Caz fades in and out of consciousness where we hear Douglus and Brodie pulling him out of the see
They both fuss over him with brodie focused on getting them to safety while Douglus panics if he's still alive, they both fuss over him while rushing to cover, most likely to avoid getting tossed off themselves
Caz passes out again after coughing up water and wakes up alone
Stepping outside brodie immediately, yells out for Caz to help him,
we can already see the rig falling apart with things popping off the sides and plummeting into the ocean
Caz asks if he was able to get Gregor out too, with brodie replying that he couldn't find him and that he's not the only on they lost
His attention is then grabbed by what we can assume to be raffs who's stuck in the bell.
Raffs is tossing inside the bell screaming his head off much to Brodies horror and confusion as ‘decompression shouldn't be this bad’
The current running theory is that the drill hit something, a gas leak or air pocket, that caused an explosion
Douglus went off to find out more about what happened and if the Beira’s even safe anymore
Brodie tries to comfort raffs saying he’ll get him out real soon, brodie regrets letting him go down there, stating he was supposed to take care of raffs
The under rig, Catwalks
On first observation the rig itself is falling apart, the catwalks are mangled and bent
When we pass the drill there's glowing blue light with an undertone of red that reflects onto the tin undercarriage of the rig like water.
In the center of it is a web of winding rope like pieces of perhaps flesh, if its pulsing and breathing has anything to say about it.
It looks to be coming from inside the drill, having probably winding up and around it before bursting out and latching onto the under carriage
It has a bubbling effect on one's vision, gathering on the part of the eye that is closest to it
Caz’s reaction to this is a mix of awe and horror, cause what the fuck
He starts to hear someone or something, almost like music that is until Douglas breaks his temporary fog by telling him to get the fuck away from that and come back inside before the Catwalk falls apart and dumps his ass back into the ocean.
He then tells Caz to meet up with him inside
There is a lock Caz breaks with the screwdriver that blocks the way
Balancing across a board mixed with some jumps and monkey bars Caz ends up around leg b before transitioning to leg c to get to engineering access
Leg C
Looking down over the railing the flesh from before seems to have penetrated Leg C
Using the walls to form and grow in spiral patterns and drape onto the surrounding walkways
Thankfully it seems to have only made it about halfway up the inside of the leg, rapid growth
Rennick comes on the announcement declaring that there has been a minor drill issue, and that work is suspended until it is fixed.
He continues to press that it is a ‘temporary issue’ much to Caz's exasperation and disbelief
Continuing down we notice that the inside of the leg is almost as twisted into scrap metal as the catwalks outside, roundabout jumping and walkways continue
The Beira shakes rumbles periodically, causing more pieces of metal to fall further into the leg and in turn the mass of flesh
Caz continues to make his way around to the entrance for engineering and finds a head lamp, thank God, shit was dark
Engineering
stepping inside the left and most direct path to engineering ops is closed off by rubble, making us take the right path that will lead us to gas separation
Once going down the stairs the path’s floor is covered in maybe 5 inches of water and gas (if the rainbow reflection tells much)
Entering an open room a pipe bursts, making a loud pop sound that is replied to by a even louder gargle/shriek much to Caz’s horror as he rushes up a set of stairs to the next room
There he finds a vent which he quickly pries open and climbs into
Coming out the other end however he is met with smeared blood and a white hardhat
The ominous noises continue mixed with what sounds like sobbing, snorting, and more gurgles
Finlay
Following the hall Caz opens the door and gets startled by Finlay who beckons him to come closer
Caz asks what's making that noise, commenting that Finlay looks like She’s seen a ghost.
He’s shocked when she’s says its gibbo making all that racket and says they should go find and help him
Though Finlay is against that idea, going on to say that he's not right in the head.
Apparently, the explosion caused an unknown substance that looked like oil to splatter all over him causing him to go crazy and lunge at Finlay
She tells Caz that Gibbo’s out there with him, much to his displeasure, and to be careful, really fucking careful
Caz asks if she’s seen anybody else to which she replies that she just got here. Most likely missing Douglas by a hair
Finlay continues and tells Caz that he needs to go through the water tanks to get to accommodation, she warns him to be quiet and to stay the fuck away from gibbo, has not right
Walking through gas separation Caz climbs a ladder and comes face to face with a scene right out of horror movie, taking place in Engineering OPS
This would be our first close look at Wisps (that's what I'll call the ropes and curtains of flesh from now on)
It looks to originate from the top panels, most likely growing and spreading through the crevices between the roof and ceiling.
It then would have shot down, probably enveloping the people closes to it and infecting them, causing rapid growth and likely death (perhaps they weren't infected with the right type of shape, therefor causing them to be used as energy rather than gatherers. Perhaps 2-3 people caught
Continuing through the room Caz goes up the ladder to level 2 jumping over a hole in the loft before entering the water tanks
A few water tanks seem to have burst, partially flooding the room up to Caz’s hip
Water tank section
Stepping down into the water immediately sets Gibbo off, we can hear him heaving as he bangs between water tanks, his voice echoing of the metal. This makes it hard to tell where he is
He seems partly conscious, pleading with Caz through strained breaths to not come any closer and to stay away.
Though conscious he’s hardly coherent, he mentions addier telling him to go down here, most likely with Finlay to do something with the drill
At times he’s comforting himself, saying he's a good lad
Caz makes his way through the water tank almost shitting his pants when he gets to a hatch
It's only a few steps down the hatch that what gibbo now is barrels overhead, slamming the hatch closed and sending Caz to the flooded ground, gibbo continues to stomp and bang on top of the tank,
Caz slip through a tight hallway connecting the tanks and to his horror finds Douglas hunched over the ladder,
It looks like he fell, probably the same way Caz did except he hit his head, hard. Though gibbo probably had a hand in that as he states.
As we go up the stairs gibbo screams apologies, he didn't want to hurt him, just stop him from looking, he keeps seeing his face, don't leave him alone down here, he's confused, what's happening, and tell his mom he’ll be home soon
If you hang around a bit longer, you'll hear sobbing, he'll say he’d never you'd know I'd never, what do I do, I don't know what to do
Take the exit to accommodation
Accommodation
Step in to the utility floor in accommodation and Caz will find a heater, thank God since he's fucking freezing. Caz tells himself not to think about it
Turn right and Caz finds a phone and answers it, on the other end is O’Connor
O’Connor has Bruce and Fergus with him, he asks Caz what the hell's going on
To which Caz replies that the drill hit something, and O’Connor needs to get the fuck out of there, and O’Connor doesn't disagree
O’Connor tells Caz that something is wrong in Engineering (I'm assuming his on level 3 since we just passed through 1 and 2) he says they’re
Going to go through the leg and come up the under rig, he swears that Rennick better set up evacuation and fast. Then he cuts off
Caz tries to tell him he must come up through accommodation, but the call has already ended by the time he gets too
Caz goes back into the hallway, the only way to move forward is to go up since the laundry room is blocked
Going up the stairs Caz notices the way to the cabin floor has been blocked, the way to the deck is covered by whisps and the canteen door is barricaded
Entering the crew lounge we hear trots struggling with something in what i think is the bathroom
Refracting blue light flashes the room leaving water like shadows on the floor and ceiling
Inside trots is screaming to get ‘it’ off him, repeating the phrase in a shrill panic as Caz tries to get inside asking him if he's ok and to let him in
Caz gets increasingly panicked as trots screams turn from panicked to pain filled, ending with a strained and gurgling scream before silence.
After a few more attempts to get the door open Caz is forced to give up in favor of finding Roy, taking the other exit to try and get into the canteen
Roy
Walking into the canteen it’s in complete disarray, the ceiling panels are falling off and chairs, tables and a trashcan was used to block the main entrance, that and the metal cover has been pulled down over the serving windows.
Opening the door Caz scares the shift to out Roy, before Roy Tells him to get the fuck in here
Roy seems panicked and out of breath as he asks Caz what the fuck is going on out there, Caz tells him that people are dying much to roys horror as he asks who and how.
Caz struggles to explain what's been happening saying he doesn't know what to believe
Roy agrees, stating he saw something outside and thought he doesn't know what it was it scared the shit out of him, he wants to barricade the door, but Caz disagrees, they must get off the rig, they can't just hide
And that's all I've got so far which is, granted, a fuckton...
24 notes
·
View notes