#not to say they dont discuss morality
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
oh and another take that I feel the mxtx- specifically mdzs fandom needs to hear is that none and i mean none of the characters have any set morality. this applies to their mindset, actions, feelings- the entire point is that you see where all the characters come from and recognise their actions. none of them are completely 100% good or bad. the point of the entire novel isn't to see and judge their actions. it's to see where they come from, what mindset requires those terrible or honourable actions. is it okay to call out a character on their actions? yes. but please for the love of mo xiang tong xiu remember what caused those actions and whether your call out is necessary instead of making posts like "character A was just trying his best and character B came and ruined everything that's why I hate character C". no. almost all the characters are shitty to some extent albeit in different categories. recognise that and you will appreciate mdzs even more.
#mdzs#mdzs meta#mo dao zu shi#cql#the grandmaster of demonic cultivation#the founder of diabolism#chen qing ling#the untamed#i think this is something the other mxtx fandoms have down#the others dont have such scrutiny on morality as much as i they have on kindness and respect#not to say they dont discuss morality#they do but the characters themselves are better judges of it#and it helps the reader to identify them#unlike mdzs hwere the entire point of the novel is to learn about morality#now some of the main characters here for variety#wei wuxian#wei ying#yilling patriarch#yilling laozu#lan wangji#lan zhan#hanguang jun#jiang cheng#jiang wanyin#sandu shengshou#i give up after this
260 notes
·
View notes
Note
Wait is the middle picture from those three sketches that one scene from the wigmaker job?
yes! it's this specific passage where lucanis is just seething with rage and trying to keep a lid on it, and illario's a stablising, comforting presence. BROTHERS!!!!! <3 though i chose to draw his hand on his shoulder rather than his arm i guess. artistic liberty!
#in the future i want to discuss lucanis' anger in the short story + how spite would have made it worse#and how in my beautiful mind illario would have been the one to help him#no blood magic needed!!!!#like its a point of serious issues between the both of them and the relationship is like obviously fraught#and illario still gives his ambition pause because lucanis is losing himself to a demon and he drags him away from it#illario being a positive force despite his goals/lack of morality/etc is so interesting to me like. it doesnt matter what he's done#or the what's he's trying to do and all the usurping. lucanis is soothed just when his family is near#same applies to caterina to a . lesser extent. if they deserve this reaction from him is another thing#i also think. and important to note. that lucanis' internal narration never worries about illario's ability to finish the job#he sometimes giggles in his mind about illario not having the best balance or footing#but does not worry about the assassination being botched . and i also thought#the line 'i'm only here because of you' implies lucanis wants him to come on the job#considering he was the only one hired (the elf that greets them not recognising why he had someone with him)#so. i dont know why im saying all this actually. maybe just more on lucanis' dependancy on and care for illario + vice versa#lucanis dellamorte#illario dellamorte#answered#anonymous
98 notes
·
View notes
Text
it's so frustrating they don't take the necropolis as an opportunity to explore spirits with more depth in veilguard. or even Manfred's whole thing. Manfred being able to learn to speak implies that any wisp is capable of it with time. they have preferences and emotions and comprehend speech but you still shouldn't be concerned that they are used for slave labour in the necropolis. you're supposed to be horrified that Hezenkoss is abusing spirits but not at that. engaging with spirits as people introduces too much nuance to the situation and veilguard is absolutely incapable of dealing with it. otherwise they'd have to engage with why Solas wants to tear the veil down
#i love the line emmrich has where he says the dead venatori will be “put to work” or something.#it recognises the enslaving aspect and that he considers it punishment for the slaver's body but NOT the spirit. so interesting#“its okay when we do it because what we're enslaving arent REAL people” is compelling. unfortunately for DA that is always where it ends#every time they pull another “are these things people?” plot thread (often) they get scared and run away 😭#the tranquil. the mages. the darkspawn!!!!#that post i just reblogged. like yeah they DONT want you to consider the archive spirit as anything like a person. it all falls apart#dragon age spoilers#da4 spoilers#m#datv critical#tags from future me: i feel like that last line comes across wrong. spirits as people isn't what stops them talking about the veil.#it's the problem veilguard has with letting any moral complexity or greyness exist.#where inquisition tried to two-sides issues until it made no sense. veilguard ignores/dodges any potential issues with everything.#you might not want to help the crows if you acknowledge their sins. you might feel bad about tearing down the veil if you discuss it#so you cant. manfred likes the bubbles. its not that deep
45 notes
·
View notes
Text
many thoughts about vampires and how consuming their media with a strict, humanistic moral lens defeats the purpose
#before someone misreads this as me saying we shouldn’t apply morals to vampires - NO!#i’m not saying this#it’s just not the ‘gotcha!’ fandoms think it is#there’s also lots of cherry-picking in applying morality#we should be able to discuss morality from a nuanced perspective of character dissection#not for the sake of policing#i think a lot abt ppl who pick up vampire muses who have done some heinous things and then remove it#most notably damon salvatore#or it gets brushed under the rug : katherine pierce#and there’s two sides of it. ppl who romanticize or refuse to acknowledge vile acts or ppl who weaponize it just to#exert a sense of superiority#anyways all this to say#any villainous or villainous adjacent or muses who just do vile things - none of that is watered down here#and i dont want ppl to feel as tho they can’t criticize a character’s problematic behavior#u can#i do not care#bc i took up the muses knowing they’re shit ppl :p and want to dissect it#and bc i know im normal and wouldn’t romanticize it (i think ppl who’ve written w me for years could attest to it)#just block the tags for any of them if needed!!#putting this out there bc i have lenore on my list and im very aware of the polarizing takes on her
24 notes
·
View notes
Note
Future trio for character bingo (you knew this was coming lol)
hehe of course. ive marked "i have many headcanons" bc i guess by drawing them so much i am technically making headcanons, tho the word is pretty vague imo.

grovyle the guy ever. deservedly popular within fandom and people who vaguely remember playing eotd when rhey were 6. probably best character in the entire franchise. what could i even say. i cant believe people dislike him just bc hes well liked and arguably popular for pmd cast standards.

dusknoir, who should be tied with grovyle for my fav character, except he could be slightly more favoured bc i dont think ive ever felt so passionate about characterization until i saw certain popular headcanons for this guy. Still, i adore and have obsessed over every dialogue he has in the game, what else could i say that isnt patently clear in my fanart and ramblings. Def one of my fixations at the moment and top contender for the Best PMD character ranking. who doesn't love a well done twist villain/antagonist who will do whatever it takes to survive and perfectly contrasts our morally grey lizard hero.

celebi, the most girly girl that ever girled just so the writers could add romance. I cant believe she made me have a character arc where i first couldnt stand her and then ended up loving her thanks to cool fanon content and my belief in fighting the toxic misogynistic 2010s fujoshi that lives within all of us. it took a while for her to grow on me but now shes def part of the trio of all time. its a shame shes still vastly underdeveloped compared to the other two, so its a good thing they have each other to become more interesting through their interactions!
#ask#future trio#idk if it was in this fandom or another one but sometimes ive seen fans say they like a character. and then elaborate#that they only like the fanon version of that character and. im sorry but if thats the case then they DONT like the character#fanon is always gonna be very varied and different interpretations enrich a space and open discussions which are a net positive#but sometimes it reaches extremes that make it look like people are dismissing source material to insert fandom tropes#which isnt morally wrong its just not always my cup of tea. esp when they become too prevalent#this is universal to all fandoms btw its not just this one by any means#the good thing is that headcanons that clash with your own tend to leave you to analyze things more deeply which has happened to me here
13 notes
·
View notes
Text
i will cashapp $10 to the first person who can name 3 real life harmful things bob bryar did without accusing him of thought crime
#wordvomit#this isnt to say the things he said or thought are good or justifiable- just to point out that he never ACTED on them in any capacity#meanwhile he is being socially prosecuted to the extent as if he has. during such an awful time for his loved ones who are the only ones#who will be exposed to all this hate. possibly including the members of mcr#i understand thinking the things he said are sick and disliking him and being uncomfortable at the discussion but.#i dont understand how you can honestly morally justify half of the stuff people have been saying- like 'he deserved it' and whatnot#without contradicting the 'thoughtcrime isnt real' sentiment i see get thrown around so often ?#isnt the Overarching issue with conservatism as a whole not the idea of . moral purity and puritanism and#'everyone. everything and every idea ontologically different from mine and my communities-#they are objectively worse and i deserve power over them as retribution for what they've done'#ie colonialism. racism. yadda yadda#these are false comparatives bc discrimination based on unchangeable factors vs backlash to opinion is vry different but i still think#the core idea of 'no one who has not enacted harm deserves harm wished on them' kinda shines through it all#and there is a semantic debate to be had about the definition of harm but in this case i am using it to mean anything more Tangible#something that has a wider influence than 'the people who read/heard it were upset and uncomfortable' yea ?#im been waffling about this a lot and why it hasnt been sitting right with me as someone who is incredibly uncomfortable with a lot of his#final statements#it just reminds me so much of my dad and what ive watched him go through#as well as other people in my community during the pandemic#i cant disconnect myself from the humanity of that. especially while condemning him for lacking humanity
21 notes
·
View notes
Text
think its so funny that ppl are seeing my art aand realizing they might have ocd
#not that its like funny funny#but its like a . yeah i know how THAT goes#ive had ocd since i was around 10 or so and i actually realized i might have it when i was like 12#but i got wary and unsure and forgot abt it and later prioritized getting other dxes#(esp since theres an assumption that ocd is 'not as important' as other things. fsr)#only got dxed a couple yrs back and that was cus being on qelbree made it extremely obvious and impossible to ignore anymore#but its hard to realize bc it just feels Normal#and bc a lot of themes arent very well known#mine lean moral n existential nd other more obscure subjects so it wasnt smth i saw discussed or shown#(well and contamination but thats been more prominent in recent yrs than it was in the past for me)#but its prob why ragatha and pomni having ocd is particularly important to me bc i dont think either of them have it in a way thats like#associated w ocd all the time. i see moral ocd discussed more in recent yrs which is cool though#but pomni i def channeled my like. 'weird' obsessions into. i think pomni has the most esoteric obsessions+compulsions known to man#not to say everyone who relates to my ragatha posts 100% has ocd but like. i def get the experience of seeing a depiction of smth and going#oh. oh
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
Maybe I'm going to get some heat for this but people do realize brambleclaw isn't like.... a wife beater, right???....... Dudes an asshole but I swear people act like he's *the worst* character in the entire series. I see people get genuinely agressive over this man, to a degree i never see with other toxic characters in the series. It is kind of ridiculous imo. Like can I please mention his name without 500 people running up to me screaming "THE ABUSER!!!" Like can you fucking chill out. The way people talk about him you'd think he punches women in the face when he's just a pitiful overtly-controlling emotionally manipulate ass... I seriously feel like if I mentioned the fact that he actually has good character qualities I'd be crucified
And well.... sorry for getting heated lol... Only saying this because I've legit been approached aggressively just for mentioning his name in a conversation.... not even about bramble either like why are you yelling at me I'm talking about hollyleaf dawg
#warrior cats#wc#brambleclaw#bramblestar#i dont even care anymore tbh like this is my biggest peeve#do you know how awkward it is when im trying to have a normal ass conversations and i mention brambleclaws name#n people come up to me like “oh haha! bramble the abuser! i sure hope you never say 1 good thing about him! or you are defending an abuser!”#like when tf did WARRIOR CATS reach this point#i dont even like brambleclaw btw its just so unserious#i want to be able to have discussions about these characters without people projecting their morals on to me
68 notes
·
View notes
Text
some people hear 'character with strong moral code doesnt like authority' and immediately dismiss all prior knowledge of said character and instead decide to depict them as having some crazy badboy past. good GOD you people will say anything
#squinting at some of you#you dont think the dislike of authority comes from the fact that they ARE morally upstanding#when whatever authority figures dont align with their moral code obviously theyre going to dislike that#its a 'power is corrupt and i will do better' thing not a 'oh im so edgy even tho nothing about my character suggests that!'#begging you guys to have A SHRED of a characters personality consistent#bc you just hear one new thing abt them and immediately make that Their Trait#instead of seeing how it fits in beside their other traits#anyway🥰🥰#i wouldnt care so much for ooc headcanons if people didnt keep saying they were true and people who dont agree are mischaracterising#mfer im not convinced youve seen the character your discussing
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
Someone being extremely annoying in the replies of my flowey and clover gif and I'm running out of patience 😭
#'well I THINK theyd just kill everyone then never reset in neutral' 'WE decide who clover is at heart' can you not#like. this is a piece of fanart. did you really just reply to tell me you don't like my headcanons or what#like... at least mention the art of you're gonna go on a several reply stint of this...#and im sorry but mmmmh... bad takes. frisk is morally ambiguous and its impossible to know what they'd do without our influence at this tim#but its a. fucking HUGE plot point in yellow neutral that we know what clover does without influence. without us. without flowey.#they stay w toriel indefinitely...#there's wiggle room for why and that's interesting. but its very clear vengeance wouldnt normally be their driving force#and that in itself is interesting! do we make them give into their anger? warp their sense of justice?#are they just going through the motions of getting this done now that they've ended up on this path?#that's all way more interesting to discuss than what feels like just treating them as a nothing character to treat as an insert#they did say its bc they dont like considering vengeance canon but that stumps me even more#why do you think we mold them then????#and idk if the devs said anything about it being noncanon but i haven't heard so#(and the devs also said Clover's gender is 'up to interpretation' and that's stupid so i also just don't care I'm sorry)#I'd rather embrace all routes and consider what that can mean for the characters#vengeance being unrealistic for ut means nothing when NONE of uty is realistic for ut#it's just a cool what if kinda story
9 notes
·
View notes
Text
i wanted to make a post about a thing but the more i think about it the more i want to say and it's just going to end up being a big ramble essay, so instead i'll just give the thesis statement, thusly:
as the #1 Ratgrinders Apologist (self-appointed), of course they're the final boss fight to the death. i expected nothing less and the people trying to make discourse about it are ignoring the entire context of this being a Dungeons and Dragons game
#they're not playing 'discuss our traumas and and try to help strangers grow: the game'#they're playing 'murder people for getting in our way: the game'#which i know is now me being snubbing about D&D as a game but like. siobhan said it: theyve committed SO much murder#did the lunch lady in episode 2 deserve to be murdered? did the skater dwarves deserved to be murdered?#did the monsters the school sicced on the kids in their Last Stand deserve to be slaughtered like that??#its literally the name of the game!#the two things that are turning this into a bigger essay are 1) me being actually very disappointed in Burrow's End with how the players#just did not want at all to engage with the moral greyness aabria was trying to bring into the story#it was clear that was a direction she wanted to explore and i wanted to see it explored#but even OUT of characters the cast just would NOT engage or acknowledge the validity of that direction#and there was only so much aabria could do without being labeled a killjoy... because D&D often ISN'T a game for reckoning with#the justification of your character's actions! its a game for killing giant bears and saving the town from cultists!!#baked into the foundation of the game conceit is 'you are the hero and you are saving the day ergo your actions are Right and Just'#thing 2) i just listened to that WWW fireside the other day where brennan goes on about how combat does not get in the way#of story in dnd. that whole stove metaphor? and it rankled me so much lol because like aabria finally says after that:#yeah you bring your own food to the stove but when what you've got is a stove. the food you make is GOING to get cooked#combat and fighting and killing is baked into the system from its foundation. acting like D&D or even just d20 (the system)#is a resolution engine that also allows fighting and not a fighting engine that also allows other skills is. wishful thinking i think#and to bring this back to the POINT: of COURSE they're going to kill the rat grinders! because it's fun!#because thats how you resolve conflict in a combat game! straight up i honestly believe a lengthy conversation trying to win the kids over#would have been a weird energy to end the season on! it would have been a let down!#it would have been a huge tonal shift. because the tone you bring to a D&D game is 'killing this is fine actually'#and if you dont like that you /dont/ play D&D. its not a value judgment#i LOVE getting into moral implications and justifications and ive gotta tone it down when i run D&D games because it can kill the vibe#anyway. i said i wasnt going to write the whole essay and im not. but i did write most of the rant oops
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
Not to yuck anyone's yum here, but I don't see how someone can do meta if they don't even have basic reading comprehension, much less do surface level critical analysis that says anything of substance.
#truly is the piss on the poor website#it has nothing to do with his morality or the ethics of his actions btw it's irrelevant to actual point being discussed#which is ''you keep using that word. i dont think it means what you think it means''#just because someone on xitter with 25k followers said it doesn't make it true#you know what i should just fic it to illustrate the difference then link to anyone who says otherwise#I'm increasingly tired kinda hard to curate your experience when the whole damn fandom's gone crazy#cultural hegemony go brrr#feel like it's time to ramble on because i'd literally have to block everyone to stop seeing stupid takes#sometimes i wanna make a powerpoint about diegesis and make people take a test on it#but alas that's not how fandom works#and it's not like it's limited to this fandom either#i noped out of my fav character's tag with six new people on my block list when i decided to touch bases in a previous fandom#and in this one it's even more infuriating because it's literally just a ship war#if it's unethical towards her it's also unethical towards partner of choice#like the person that called ks healthy before the reveal#in what universe is attempting to kill each other healthy
4 notes
·
View notes
Note
You've listened to too much proganda. Israel has border control between the Palestinian enclave and Israel, the same as Egypt has border control between the Palestinian enclave and Egypt. They run humanitarian missions to the Palestinian enclave giving them access to water and electricity because Hamas doesn't care about maintaining Palestinian infrastructure. It helps Hamas's cause to leave most of Palestinians living in desperation. And Israel isn't trying to murder millions. They told people to evacuate because they wanted to avoid that and then waited two additional weeks when the first deadline wasn't possible. Finally, Israel is fighting a war not randomly deciding to kill civilians. They were invaded by 2,000 men who horrifically killed as many civilians as they could before being stopped. Rockets are still incoming. 350,000 Israelis are internally displaced and homeless from Hamas's ongoing attacks. What's happening in Palestine is horrible but Israel didn't wake up one day and decide "let's genocide Palestine". Hamas set them up with an impossible situation and you fell for it. Reactions like yours only makes future attacks from Hamas more likely. You're giving them what they want. And in the meanwhile, all the civilians suffer from it.
honey im from israel
#and also i dont feel like arguing with you#sorry i just literally have nothing to add to this discussion#if you dont have a moral issue with what israel is doing to gaza and has been doing to palestinians since 1948#then i just dont have anything to say to you#ask#anon#politics cw
14 notes
·
View notes
Text

beau is sooo messy i'm obsessed with him. him being happy to see felix seemingly flourishing and being more confident etc but also feeling weird and almost jealous at the fact that it used to be just him that got to see felix that way. that he used to be the only reason for it. and like he KNOWS that's a messy and kind of fucked up way to think about it but he also knows he's in a really weird spot emotionally and can't help it
#one question i am obsessed with at the moment is what makes a person/character 'toxic'#i don't think it's a simple yes or no a character either is or isn't#especially with grief and complicated emotions like...#i have had some UGLY thoughts about people. even about people i love and consider friends#and i have had times where i've had to question myself and wondered if i'm actually this spiteful and meanspirited person#but i realised all of those moments were happening in very difficult and dark times in my grief#which was making it harder for me to regulate emotions and being much more sensitive and quick to take something personally#even though i would know logically that i did not feel that way AS I FELT THAT WAY#it was a mind fuck and it took so long to figure out how to process and unpack all that...#anyway im obsessed with grieving characters having sensitivity and messy feelings and being easily triggered into them#and feeling them even though they know logically that's not how they actually feel under 'normal' circumstances#all this to say i dont think beau is a toxic person. but i do think he is grieving and his is the fleshiest/rawest character ive written in#a while LOL#hes competing with felix and dorothy. who imo were actually being toxic to each other in RR LOL#but then it's like. a character that is toxic at times is not necessarily a bad person to me!#im specifying character because i dont want to get into a discussion about irl morality. but like.#oughhh i love characters who are hypocritical and suck but are also full of love and a desire to be better but its hard to be
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
im so deranged rn about a song of love and loss. im so deranged about terry killing ibis.
When Ezran says, "Violence, loss, pain, violence, loss, pain. More violence. Stop! I just want to yell stop. But that's not enough. It won't work. "I think about a positive vision. A faith we can all share, that we might build a future together in hope. A future where we can be safe with each other. But it's not that easy, or simple.
"Because people are still hurting, and they are still angry. We can't ignore that, or pretend it will go away. Somehow, we have to hold it all in our hearts at the same time. We have to acknowledge the weight of the pain and loss, but open our eyes and allow ourselves to hope and maybe forgive and love again." Ezran's entire speech is about how it is impossible to just ignore all the suffering and pain humans and elves have gone through in favor of peace, and it's really interesting to me, especially in the context of my own OC. For context ig Aspen has a lot of conflicting emotions towards violence and death. He is aware that he can hurt people, he is aware that he's hurt people. His complicated feelings towards violence, murder, and death are directly from experience, from having committed those acts with his bare hands, fully aware of himself, and it is specifically him perpetuating the cycle of violence, loss, and pain Ezran speaks about.
It is him taking the role of Claudia but also at the same time, it results in him being unable to take the role of Ibis; being terrified to do anything that would hurt others, even if for the sake of his own protection.
And because of that in a way I think he sort of embodies Terry? Cause Terry, right after killing Ibis for Claudia's sake immediately breaks down, he is clearly guilty and upset, even if it was to proect Claudia, and IT'S SO FUCKING SOMETHING TO ME because Terry and Claudia have these incredibly different feelings and views on violence but they also can boil down to committing the worst atrocities if it is for the sake of those they love, but their feelings during the aftermath are so different. This where I start to think about Aspen, and how honestly for a long time he has viewed himself as a liability but after committing murder, and killing another person for the first time, it got so much worse. And as a result, he cannot bring himself to do violence on another person, to the extent that if somebody is not there to protect him, he will take any attack, no matter who is the perpetrator. In a way, this can also be seen as Aspen perpetuating the cycle of violence Ezran talks about, because he is aware that people other than himself have also been hurt, are also experiencing pain, and he just ignores his own in favor of this positive vision, of having this sort of ingenuine hope because he is so terrified of proving himself to be a liability, but even then, that doesn't really stop anything, does it? Because he isn't enacting diplomacy, he isn't actually trying to stop this violence, he is just sitting there and taking it, and it's really interesting to think about.
#aster talks#tdp season 4#tdp season 4 spoilers#tdp#talking about my ocs#not interested in discourse or anything abt this im okay with discussing and idrc if anybody disagrees with me on claudia ibis and terry#but like im not interested in moral arguments about myself#only saying this bc ive seen this kind of this happen on here so i wanna nip it in the bud#but i dont think this post will get big enough for that anyway wlkjdfslfjk#aspen reference?!
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
i rly rly rly want to get back into reading i read so much as a kid and i like rly liked it so i think that is definitively a thing i enjoy ... and whenever i do manage to make myself read again i have a lot of fun like i can sit and read for hours and enjoy it its judt sitting down to actually do it and having something To read . i struggle with
#i dont have motivation to do like basically anything ever which is the problem. This isnt a moral failing on my part i literally have lack#of motivation disease (self affirmation) butttt i rly rly rly do wanna get back into reading basically is the gist of it. bc i read um like#digital books sometimes but i hve much harder time getting likeee. immersed ig ? i need to go to the library more mein mamma takes annie to#the library once a week to meet with his teachers so maybe i could tag along...#i just never know whats like a doable amt of books to check out yk like as a kid i could check out like 5 books and id read all of them#within a week and obv speedreading isnt like . yk. but i wasnt speedreading or slimmingor anything i just rly rly liked reading and ive#always been a fast reader ... but anyways i say this to sayyyy ummm. ig i should just start with checking out A book#that way i dont get overwhelmed if i cant finish a book on time you know. much to discuss....#i also like . feel dumb bc most of the books i read back then were. kids books and like ya books and such . so i dont rly know what kind of#more grownup books i enjoy bc ive read a lot fewer... Not that theres anything wrong with reading or enjoying kids books OBVIOUSLY like i#reread asoue last year and it was a lotsies of fun. ^_^ but yes id like to branch out more and read more things but i have trouble like. idk#what i like or enjoy or am interested in basically. i have a little list of books though
1 note
·
View note