#race changing discourse
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
yoko-suki ¡ 29 days ago
Text
My thoughts on the race changing discourse.
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
What made me inclined to making this post. Well it all started with my shifter friend sending me a post earlier from another shifter on shiftok. Now I don’t associate with shiftok for many reasons that most of the shifting community avoids it. However I just wanted to share a few pointers from this post and another perspective of this discussion. 
FROM THE ORIGINAL POSTER
you're not being expansive. you're just being harmful.
and these displays of hubris show up most in the way y'all behave when it comes to simple boundaries. the moment someone says
"hey, that's not okay," it's met with deflection, dismissal, or that tired ass excuse: "but in infinite realities, this reality's morals don't matter."
IDGAF! killing innocents is wrong! incest is wrong! race changing is wrong! pedophilia is wrong! fetishizing trauma is wrong! when you promote it, you're just showing your ass as someone who hasn't shifted because if you had? you'd have actually understood the fucking implications of coming online and ADMITTING that you, in real life, did any of these atrocities or agree with them KNOWING what it's like to live there! you'd know just how vile, insidious, and deeply unserious you sound.
and imma get into how this shit is wrong in another post, y'all gon my ass today
Something I wanted to unpack in this particular paragraph is the comparison between each category she mentioned. However both are morally wrong. Regardless of reality you partake in and the consequences. From my own understanding of this matter, it seems there’s shifters amongst the community aren’t in a unanimous agreement with this discussion. It’s either the opposing side of shifters like this person for example.
Or it’s the side actively participating in it. For their own reasons rather it’s inherently in a harmful matter. Or In secrecy which excludes them from receiving the backlash from the opposing side. Lastly you have middle ground that doesn’t necessarily agree with race changing but doesn’t particularly have that much of an issue with it.
Now what are my own personal thoughts? where do I fall in these categories. Well I fall in the category of bias. I don’t particularly have an issue with it. However I do understand and sympathize with poc shifters and knowledge their frustration on the issue and even betrayal they might harbor for shifters who actively participate in it. Especially if it’s poc shifters. However if the shifter doesn’t fetishize the cultural aspect of it or the specific group of the marginalized group.
They are willing to educate themselves. As well as validate poc shifters that find their actions deplorable and unacceptable. It’s only right to recognize it and accept they feel that way for their own personal reasons. Other poc shifters like myself won’t exactly penalize shifters for it. In fact we might look at it from nuance perspective with the “there’s infinite realities that exist and outweigh our limitations we are the universe” approach of the argument. That’s how I genuinely look at it from that perspective. Spreading awareness about the importance of educating other shifters is completely harmless.
There are ways to go about it without aggression, arrogance and moral superiority. Because there’s also the group of shifters that might not understand the harm it’s causing. Perhaps it’s a younger adolescent, would it truly be the right approach to bombard them with profanity and hatred because they weren’t fully educated on the subject? Would that cause them to be more inclined to to be open minded and consider the feelings of the shifter that’s against race changing? Or would they simple disregard their feelings and go about it in rebellious manner because of the tone of the message?
If you truly want to educate shifters TONE matters. If you want your discomfort and concerns to be addressed. Listen to your tone of your voice and your message. Frustration is valid, betray is valid but hatred, vindictiveness and hostility isn’t.
-FROM ORIGINALLY POSTER
fracism doesn't exist in your DR- great it's been long eradicated in
alrof mine. but you still brought yourself there. this version of you. the one raised in a world where race impacts safety, freedom, and dignity. so when you choose to "change races", what you're really doing is sidestepping the pain of our lived experiences while cherry-picking our features for your fantasy. and you may say "no, no it's not like that"-but it is. you just refuse to open your eyes to it. and no, it doesn't matter that "it doesn't impact us here* because you coming online promoting it does. your choices are not insular. your beliefs impact this community. and spewing around your poison will get somebody burned.
so when shifters of color tell you, "please don't wear my skin. please don't romanticize an identity you've never had to survive," and you respond with, "fuck off infinite realities exist!" or "but this poc doesn't mind." you're not just being dismissive.
you're being racist.
because what you're saying is "my desire outweighs your dignity". you're saying, "ÂĄ don't care what you've lived through-as long as I get to feel special" and if "anything is possible" why is harm the first thing you choose?
listen when i tell you this- you don't get to shift out of responsibility. you don't get to silence voices you've never taken the time to listen
because if you truly believed in the infinite nature of reality, and not just fulfilling your own fantasies, you'd have imagined a version of yourself who knew better now.
Unfortunately I’m one of the shifters that doesn’t hyper focus on what others do in their drs. Unless it doesn’t inherently have to do with murder, pedophilia, cheating on their s/o’s, backstabbing friends, committing crimes, being overall horrible people in their drs. The sad reality of it it, somebody is currently doing all the above in their drs.
There’s nothing I can do to stop them from their destructive nature and how they choose to use their abilities. I can spread awareness about it on how it’s morally wrong. As a shifter who’s been through countless of traumatic events and experiences in my dr. Including witnessing my s/o getting brutally murdered in another reality. I can’t stop shifters from scripting traumatic events in their drs. I can truly only worry about myself and my own shifting journey. As much I want to and have continued spreading awareness about it in separate shifting platforms. It’s up to that individual to take it into consideration, if they choose not to I’m not going to berate them for it.
Because that was their own decision with their own consequences as a result of it. My point is every single decision we make during our shifting journey is a learning lesson, none of us are perfect we all make mistakes. We don’t deserve to be penalized and perceived as such unless it’s truly deserves that kind of response. Everyone is on this journey like the original shifter of this post. There’s no harm in educating people who maybe uneducated, if you can’t educate the ones that refuse to be informed then don’t associate with them. Don’t waste your energy on them. Educate those who truly have that empathy and compassion for those who want their voice to be heard.
That’s all I wanted to say on the matter.
But I like to know anyone else’s thoughts on it rather you are anti race changing, race changer yourself or simply meet in the biased category of this discussion.
1 note ¡ View note
laeana ¡ 8 months ago
Text
I’ll just add this, but after pulling the story of underdogs as “we don’t have the fastest car” that Lando even reinforced recently in an interview, after trying to paint redbull as cheaters (which isn’t the case) to show themselves more legitimate (when the actual cheating was done by McLaren, or I guess “loophole”, but that still led to them having to change all of this rear wings, for those who still don’t know about it), now the discourse of the fia is biased toward Max and helping him! is coming out.
Of course that’s how any team can try to win the support of the public, but don’t come talking about dirty tactics when your team is using it.
53 notes ¡ View notes
youspeakshit ¡ 1 year ago
Text
re: lando norris, starbucks, F1 and boycotts
the first rule of Formula 1 is understanding these privileged men do not give a shit. they partake in the most elite sport there is, where only 20 people can do it at a time. it's a bubble of money and luxury they thrive whitin.
just don't put anyone on a pedestal or your hand on fire for any of them. not even the ones that seem like the good ones.
personally, I expect the bare minimum of no homophobia, no racism, no sexual misconduct or assault. but I do not expect them to care about world problems as strongly as we do. bc if all went to shits they will run to a safe mansion, and we'll be the ones left to survive.
embrace fandom and friendships, the fun of the races and the drama, sharing gifs and fics and edits, and put THAT above your favorite driver!
69 notes ¡ View notes
thefabelmans2022 ¡ 3 months ago
Text
how do i say this without getting jumped....... i do think the movies miss something in not emphasising the racial/ethnic divisions in district 12 but i also don't understand people who constantly claim that any description of "olive skin" means non-white person.
17 notes ¡ View notes
randomnameless ¡ 11 months ago
Note
Everytime I see your Pat lolcalization posts, I can't help but think if this is him overcompensating for voicing the character of n*zi germany in the first seasons of the hetalia anime.
I can't say and I'd rather not say anything about Pat's intent or own agenda or whatever -
But the interesting "lolcalisation changes" and direction give to VAs really seem to favour a certain reading of the events happening in FE16 and to this day, I still can't understand how that managed to be released without getting at least some flak.
Sure Fates' lolcalisation is a tough nut to beat and nothing comes quite close to what happened to Fates to FE16/Nopes, and yet I wish I am joking when I say nearly 80% of the lines involving Supreme Leader and/or Rhea/the CoS should be double checked, because "Dany expy bringing a revolution" has to fit in the story that is FE16, and that's talking about the washed down version of Dany some people have and not the one who uses violence for the greater good, until she starts to realise that the "greater good" is as solid as smoke and runs away from the - well-intentioned ! - mess she created.
Again, I don't think anything was malicious with the lolcalisation Fodlan got, is it just a case of misunderstanding the game and slapping archetypes and "trendy notions" to make this "strange" game sell like hotcakes in your home market?
Or is it another case of "think of the children Susan" where Susan sure as hell can't endorse a character presented as the heroine sprout disgusting things and advocate for imperialism 101 so the heroine is now rewritten?
Or is it the lolcalisation team - after looking at the jp script - try to make the general idea of "you must feel bad for this character" somehow work, because they thought no one would seriously want to walk with her and feel any sort of sad uwus for the "you have pointy ears, you cannot rule over humans" red emperor? So they modified the script and directed the VA accordingly ?
IDK, but I think if you've been long enough on this blog you know my stance on localisation and lolcalisation but this discrepency between the two versions (or at least two audios) really took me by surprise when the game was released in 2019 lol
7 notes ¡ View notes
tboyquackity ¡ 6 months ago
Text
i'm sorgy i'm still on it that stream was so embarrassing
2 notes ¡ View notes
batsplat ¡ 9 months ago
Note
u r sooo right about the red team blue team rivalry which is also what I thought about the aesthetics of some pictures of fabio q vs pecco in the last title fight races of 2021. pecco was so unsure back then and fabio had more natural talent and gumption and pecco seemed nervous and fabio seemed like he was having a good time and they made for good a narrative in their blue and red leathers.
we have only had four title fights this century between a blue team and a red team! and even that is me being generous by including 2007 - which imo counts because casey had to outscore valentino not dani at motegi to clinch the title and dani only nicked second in the championship off valentino at valencia. so yeah, four title fights: 2007, 2008, 2021, 2022. just isn't good enough
I will say by the END of 2021 pecco had mostly finished finding his feet and was winning a bunch of races, whereas fabio was less self-assured and more going 'yeah this title is nice but... uh...? guys we might be a bit fucked?' but. yeah. aesthetically their title fights were nice vibes! I was totally pro that rivalry conceptually! in practise, these aesthetics were let down somewhat by the absence of this little thing I like to call 'actually fighting on-track', which as a traditionally-minded viewer I do on occasion like to see in my title fights. like, valentino and casey's whole rivalry aesthetic was enhanced by how you have cool shots of them actually being, y'know, in the same shot
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
a selection from some of my favourite on-track battles of theirs during the time they were at ducati and yamaha respectively (minus assen 2007 + phillip island 2009 for obvious reasons). very nice distinct colour scheme, colours really popped, we know casey was paying attention to luminous yellow covering things and it's symbolically neat that one of 'valentino's colours' is on casey's bike (no, I do not care about what the australian flag looks like and indeed refuse to acknowledge the existence of 'australia'). also generally liked their helmets during that era, strong stuff all round
I've been thinking a fair bit lately about how this era compares to the other era this century that is generally associated with poor quality of racing, aka the alien era. the word that is commonly associated with those few years is 'processional', not unfairly... I think a refrain I see quite commonly is that some fans still have too much nostalgia for the alien era because they're only thinking of the laguna 2008's and catalunya 2009's of this world, not all the many many races of that era that weren't laguna 2008 or catalunya 2009. which is true! my general take is that the average race quality these last few years has been higher and there's often something interesting happening somewhere - you don't get the abysmal lows of the alien era quite so often. on the flip side, while the alien era certainly is associated with technical regulations that produced some poor racing... well, it did seem to at least be possible when all the stars aligned to have a duel that lasted for more than three corners. that used to be a thing even in the alien era. like it did happen
as much as I find the alien era deeply frustrating and agree with the general point that race quality these days doesn't plummet quite the same depths, I also think you need those highlights!! just to give people stuff to remember seasons by, stuff that lives on in years to come because it was just such a foundational cool memory. the current dearth isn't primarily the fault of the riders, but we have been pretty short on outright classics since end of 2019 - and the ones we have had tend to be more in the dogfight category of the typical phillip island mould than the race long duel. my sense is the current formula makes these even more impossible than 800cc did, which also weren't conducive to duels but at least didn't have this infernal tyre pressure crap week in week out that makes it impossible for riders to follow each other closely. also does feel like one of the real issues with increased homogeneity between the bikes... like casey/vale was kinda the motorcycling rivalry for babies because you knew that casey would have the edge in the straights and valentino would have the edge in the twisty bits. now a bike like the current ducati just has a way more balanced performance profile, and that's what everyone else is chasing. which. y'know. harder to be doing dramatic duels if you're all good in the same places
anyway, the point is that fabio and pecco had all the ingredients for a perfectly enjoyable rivalry... fabio as the more precocious one but also by 2021 a somewhat steadier performer, pecco cerebral but also volatile, self-critical to a fault. pecco's actually someone who I'd kill to see in a better version of this sport just for a bit, seeing as one of his biggest strengths as a rider is how excellent he is at defending - which would be nice to see tested more in races where that like... actually matters. they're both a little bit too nice and non-confrontational for my tastes, like you kinda worry any rivalry between them is destined to just be quite friendly, but there was still enough contrast in personalities and approaches to theoretically generate intrigue. plus, obviously, most importantly - they did have a red and blue colour scheme
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
while I'm generally a fan of dark colour schemes, I do feel like the white of the fiat yamaha era did allow the blue to pop a little more. and maybe it would've helped if the red had been a bit brighter to provide more contrast - I like both of these designs on their own, but together they do look a tad bleak. also my god have these bikes become massive
unfortunately, however, it comes back to the lack of memorable on-track battles. 2021 and 2022 were both kinda weird years, with pecco not really establishing himself as The Title Rival until quite late into 2021, and then 2022 being... y'know, a truly bizarre experience. they were never really good at the same time! didn't ever really hash it out for the win! even when they came close, like jerez/mugello 2022, it wasn't all that much of a fight... it's a shame - we know they're both theoretically capable of perfectly compelling on-track battles, they just never really did it with each other. pecco's had more good fights with jorge than with fabio, and that's also not exactly happening at the rate I'd like
in conclusion. it is time to bring back red vs blue sports contests. let us return to this
Tumblr media Tumblr media
and the only way to do that? well, that would be for the blue team to get its act together
2 notes ¡ View notes
tommyssupercoolblog ¡ 9 months ago
Text
My mom is also really REALLY chill about plurality, and she also sees me and SeĂĄn and everyone else as different people but all like, her family. I was sorta worried she'd love the core more than us but she loves all all equally!!!
Our core has finally been able to get herself into headspace instead of just being dormant when she's not fronting, which also means she can front more. I was really anxious about wether or not I'd still be able to do things in front now that the "original" is active, and mom told me that if we stopped fronting at all, like if the core kicked us out, she'd feel sad because she loves us too and would miss us and I'm like. YOOOOOO
(also our core said she would never do that and she wants us to be happy too. POG?!! She's very poggers)
Our mom is SO POGGERS she's like the best mom ever she's the BEST I love her
I wish people were more chill about plurality. My family has gotten to the point of “Antlerkitty has brain people, it’s disordered but that’s ok, they’re just chilling and the disorder is the unwelcome intrusions, not the people.”
I wish everyone could have that. Normalize plurality please.
Edit: If y’all keep reblogging with syscoyrse due to my “the future is plural” tag, I’m going to turn off reblogs. Of course I don’t want more kids to go through what we did. I believe in endogenic plurality too. “The future is plural” is not about forcing people to be plural, it’s about plural acceptance.
1K notes ¡ View notes
firstoccupier ¡ 4 months ago
Text
Scrutiny Surrounds New Executive Order on Education: Ending Radical Indoctrination in K-12 Schooling
In a bold move that has ignited controversy across the educational landscape, President [Name] has issued an Executive Order titled “Ending Radical Indoctrination in K-12 Schooling,” aiming to reshape the content taught in America’s classrooms. The order, announced on January 29, 2025, reflects a concerted effort to address growing concerns over educational practices that some argue undermine…
0 notes
ipoddymouth ¡ 1 year ago
Text
ttpd good when you don't have a bitch in ya ear tellin you its about matty healy
0 notes
foone ¡ 2 years ago
Text
Bad idea: Age gap discourse but in a fantasy land where there's multiple races who have vastly different lifespans and life styles.
Is it wrong for a 27 year old human to date a 140 year old stone elf, considering most stone elves don't get out of diapers till their 30s?
Is it wrong for a 80 year old dwarf to date a two year old fire wisp, when fire wisps only live up to 5 years (between the eruptions) and have memories of their past lives, so in a way they're "born" at age 400,000+? That octogenarian dwarf is way younger than the fire wisp that's only physically younger than some of the socks the dwarf has!
Is it wrong for a chronomancer who was never born to date, well, anyone? They are zero years old and infinity years old and negative one hundred and seventeen years old all at once. They look like an old human, sure, with the long white beard and the wrinkly skin, but as far as anyone can tell, they've always looked like that. We've seen the cave paintings.
Is it wrong for a 30 year old lizardman (that's old in lizardman years) to date a human who is 60 years old in biological years (because of aging spells), 26 years old in lived-experience years, but only 13 years old in calendar years? (ie, they were born 13 years ago, but spent some of that time in sideways timelines, so they've lived more years than have passed in their home timeline?)
Is it wrong for a 12,000 year old dragon date a pile of 400 kobolds when kobolds only live like 10 years on average, but reach full maturity in one year? And if you disagree, can you do anything about it? You do know what happened to the last policeman who tried to arrest a dragon, right? Their city is still smoldering, 50 years later.
Is it wrong for anyone to date the time worm? It's the same age, every year. So the age gap can only intensify. If you start dating the time worm when you're both the same age, when do you break it off because you've become too much older than them?
And most confusing of all... What about the fairies? They could be anything between a thousand and a day old, they would lie about their age either way, and they can look like whatever they want. There's fairies we know for a fact have been around since the founding of The City of Towers, who met the silent mother herself, and also look like they're at most ten years old. Is it wrong to date them, or just really uncomfortable for everyone who sees it? And on the other side there's fairies who are "born" (hatched? They come from plants, I'm not sure what the verb even would be. Seeded? Sprouted, maybe) this week who are already appearing like middle-aged men and dancing with widows in what looks like a scheme to run off with her fortune but they never take the money, because what would a fairy want with worthless metal discs? Maybe fairies have a hive mind or genetic memory or reincarnation with full memories, they'd never tell you or give you a straight (or consistent) answer anyway.
Stonefolk are really the only inter-race dating situation anyone can agree on. They're unthinking & unmoving solid rock during the day, so those hours don't count. Thus their "real age" is a nice even half of their true age. So if you meet a stonefolk who was dug out 30 years ago, watch out: that's a 15 year old, and if you're a 25 year human, that's too young for you, even though their dig-date is five years before your birth-date.
EDIT: 2024/01/12: Changed the name of the Stonefolk
18K notes ¡ View notes
harrysfolklore ¡ 1 month ago
Text
red - cs55
summary: carlos is dating a singer who's 9 years younger than him, and it's all good until it isn't
folkie radio: okay guys i know that summary is so bad but this is basically inspired by red by taylor and i hope you like it 😭
MASTERLIST | PATREON
Tumblr media
liked by gracieabrams, carlossainz55 and 2,937,499 others
yourinstagram��mi corazon ❤️ @/carlossainz55
view all comments
username1 HELLO??
username2 WHATS GOING ON
popbase BREAKING: Pop sensation YN (20) confirms relationship with Formula 1 driver Carlos Sainz (29)
carlossainz55 Mi vida 🤍 Finally sharing you with the world
oliviarodrigo this is so cute! happy for you lovie 🥺❤️
username3 the ferrari jacket while recording SHES INSANE FOR THAT
lando about time you two went public! was tired of pretending i didn't know 😂
username4 her new boyfriend is an F1 driver??? THE POWER THIS HOLDS
sabrinacarpenter the way you've been glowing lately makes so much sense now 😍
username5 Carlos Sainz and YN?? We're living in a simulation 😭
username6 age gap discussion incoming in 3...2...1...
charles_leclerc Finally! No more hiding in Monaco 😂
username7 nine year age gap... thoughts? 🤔
taylorswift This makes me so happy! ❤️ Can't wait for you both to come over again!
username8 isn’t he a bit old for her?
username9 young popstar dating an older guy? i think i’ve seen this film before
username10 I LOVE THIS
username11 THE THIRD PIC HAS SUCH AURA
username12 this could be the ultimate power couple or a complete mess
Tumblr media
liked by username1, username2 and 28,936 others
f1gossip🚨 Pop star YN supporting boyfriend Carlos Sainz at the Spanish GP! This marks her first public appearance in the paddock since confirming their relationship last week.
view all comments
username1 I LOVE THIS SO MUCH
username2 Carlos is literally 29 dating a 20 year old. I'm sorry but that's weird 🚩
username3 they look so happy! she fits right in with the ferrari family
username4 the way charles and alex have basically adopted her already
username4 not sure how I feel about this... she's barely out of her teens and he's almost 30?
username5 IM LIVING FOR THIS
username6 here's why this relationship is problematic: [thread]
username7 can we talk about how she's handling herself so professionally despite all the hate? queen behavior
username8 she's an adult who can make her own choices. stop infantilizing successful women.
username9 the paddock dynamics about to get interesting 👀
username10 BEST WAG ALREADY
username11 not trying to hate but 9 years is a big gap at that age...
username12 charles treating her like a little sister is everything
username13 age gap discourse aside, they actually look really good together
username14 anyone else notice how all the drivers seem to already know her? must've been dating longer than we thought
Tumblr media
liked by username1, username2 and 38,268 others
popbase 🎤 F1 driver Carlos Sainz supporting girlfriend YN at her sold-out Madrid concert! She even changed some lyrics to reference their relationship 👀
view all comments
username1 carlos in boyfriend era is everything we needed
username2 not charles and alex being the ultimate supportive friends 🥺
username3 the security had to stop fans from taking photos of Carlos instead of watching the show 💀
username4 LOOK AT HIM BEING SO PROUD OF HER
username5 YN’s "Spanish nights" lyric change already trending on TikTok
username6 still weird seeing a 20yo performing for her 29yo boyfriend but go off I guess
username7 first she comes to his races, now he's at her concerts. COUPLE OF THE CENTURY
username8 "And all my Spanish nights are better with you" HELLO??? THE LYRICS???
username9 he looks at her like she hung the moon and stars 😭
username10 the age gap comments getting real old. they're obviously happy together
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
liked by selenagomez, charles_leclerc and 1,879,022 others
yourinstagram 21 🤍 thank you for all the birthday wishes x
view all comments
username1 BIRTHDAY ICON
popbase YN celebrates 21st birthday with star-studded party in London. Notable absence: boyfriend Carlos Sainz.
username2 sometimes i forget that she’s still so young
alexandrasaintmleux You looked beautiful birthday girl ❤️ Love you x
username3 carlos was posting from madrid while yn celebrated in london... trouble in paradise?
username4 something's off... she usually writes longer captions
charles_leclerc Happy birthday pequeùa! You deserve the world
username5 he was having dinner with friends in Madrid instead of being at his girlfriend's birthday??? 🚩🚩🚩
oliviarodrigo ily birthday girl! your 21st year is gonna be amazing 🤍
madisonbeer HAPPY BIRTHDAY GORGEOUS 🥹
username6 please tell me they didn't break up
username7 maybe he had commitments in madrid? stop assuming things
username8 age gap strikes again? 👀
username9 no carlos, no "te quiero" caption, no couple photos... something definitely happened
username10 CARLOS WTF DID YOU DO
username11 we knew this relationship was not going to last tbh
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
TMZ EXCLUSIVE: F1 Star Carlos Sainz Missing from Girlfriend's 21st Birthday - Full Story
TROUBLE IN PARADISE? F1 STAR CARLOS SAINZ SKIPS GIRLFRIEND YN'S 21ST BIRTHDAY FOR BOYS' NIGHT
Pop sensation YN's star-studded 21st birthday celebration in London had everything - except her boyfriend. Formula 1 star Carlos Sainz (29) was noticeably absent from the festivities, instead posting Instagram stories of a dinner with friends in Madrid.
Multiple sources tell TMZ that Sainz COMPLETELY FORGOT about his girlfriend's birthday, leading to what insiders describe as a "major relationship crisis."
"He was posting stories and having fun in Madrid while YN was literally crying at her own party," reveals a source close to the singer. "Everyone was asking where he was, and she kept making excuses until she couldn't anymore."
The party, held at an exclusive London venue, was attended by music industry heavyweights and even several F1 drivers, including Sainz's teammate Charles Leclerc and his girlfriend Alexandra Saint Mleux, making the Ferrari driver's absence even more conspicuous.
Another source tells us that Sainz realized his mistake late in the evening when he saw social media posts about the party. "He immediately tried to damage control, but the damage was done. YN was devastated."
The 9-year age gap between the couple, which has been a topic of discussion since they went public with their relationship, is now being scrutinized again. "This is exactly what everyone was worried about," says our insider. "She's turning 21, and he's out there forgetting her birthday completely."
YN's team has not responded to our request for comment. A representative for Sainz said they "do not comment on personal matters."
Got a story or a tip for us? Email [email protected]
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
liked by yourinstagram, landonorris and 1,789,653 others
carlossainz55 Sometimes the biggest mistakes lead to the strongest promises. Te quiero más que nada en este mundo, mi vida. Forever making it up to you. ❤️
view all comments
username1 I CANT DO THIS
yourinstagram i love you more 🤍
username2 this is so..
alexandrasaintmleux My heart 🥺
lando back to being disgustingly cute I see
username3 THE WAY I CAN BREATHE AGAIN
username4 they're good y'all
username5 Carlos Sainz redemption arc starting strong
username6 not me crying over that caption
username7 well that was a quick resolution
username8 I'm still mad at him but this is cute
username9 NOT THE DAMAGE CONTROL POST OMFGGGGG
username10 this is gold
Tumblr media
liked by username1, username2 and 39,378 others
gossiphub🚨 DRAMA ALERT: YN and Carlos Sainz in heated argument outside Mayfair club. Sources say tension arose after Carlos "got too protective" over other guys approaching YN inside. 👀
view all comments
username1 the way she stormed off... this isn't just about tonight
username2 he looks jealous af... carlos baby what are you doing
username3 anyone else notice this is the same club where her ex was spotted earlier? 👀
paddockgossip YN seen arriving at her apartment alone. Carlos reportedly went to Charles' place
username4 this man rly thought he could control a 21yo in her party era 💀
username5 age gap issues showing... she wants to party, he's in his settled era
username6 y'all don't know the full story, stop assuming
username7 she's literally crying... carlos better have a good explanation
username8 not me remembering all those "controlling boyfriend" blind items...
username9 WHAT IS HAPPENING
username10 this is why drivers usually date within the F1 bubble tbh
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media Tumblr media
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
liked by theweeknd, carlossainz55 and 2,796,554 others
yourinstagram singapore lights hit different when they're shining on you @/carlossainz55 ❤️ so proud of you mi amor. p.s. champagne is not good for silk dresses but worth it x
view all comments
username1 MY HEART
carlossainz55 The best lucky charm. Te quiero mi vida ❤️
charles_leclerc Get a room you two 🙄
lando mate was more excited to see you than the trophy
username2 THEY MEAN SO MUCH TO ME
lewishamilton Beautiful moment you two ❤️
username3 remember when we thought they were breaking up after the club incident? now look at them 🥺
username4 The Valentino dress with Ferrari red heels >>>>>
tmz YN and Carlos Sainz silence breakup rumors with stunning Singapore display
username5 he way the whole team loves them together
username6 AND YALL THOUGHT THEY WERE OVER
username7 age gap will always be a red flag
username8 THE FERRARI QUEEN
username9 CARLOS REALLY DID THAT
username10 ahhh im so happy she was there for his win
Tumblr media
liked by landonorris, yourinstagram and 1,766,380 others
carlossainz55 Ending the year exactly where I want to be. Starting the new one exactly who I want to be with. 2024 ya estamos aquí mi vida @/yourintagram ❤️
view all comments
username1 I LOVE ONE COUPLE
yourinstagram forever mi amor ❤️
username2 YN choosing family dinner in Madrid over Hollywood NYE parties... we love this growth
username3 they could never make me hate them
scuderiaferarri 🤍
username4 carlos is turning 30 this wear which makes the age gap weirder
username5 YN3 is going to be full of love songs
username6 HES SO IN LOVE
landonorris My parents
username7 the way yn is literally younger than lando😭
username8 cuteee
username9 THEY'RE NOT BREAKING UP WE WON
username10 this is my family
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
replies:
username1 THE RELIEF I JUST FELT
username2 y'all really had us scared for a minute 😭
username3 deuxmoi being wrong again what's new
username4 but what about the suitcases? 👀
username5 she's moving in with him besties, those weren't breakup suitcases
username6 idk something feels off... remember how she denied the club fight?
username7 the way she always defends him... giving Stockholm syndrome
usernamd8 she's literally trauma bonded, we saw how he acts in public
username9 STOP projecting your issues onto them omg
username10 Carlos: *breathes*
Y'all: RED FLAG RED FLAG
username11 notice how she didn't deny the "trouble in paradise" part 🤔
username12 defending toxic behavior again... girl we're trying to help you
username13 some of y'all need therapy instead of projecting onto celebs fr
Tumblr media
liked by carlossainz55, oliviarodrigo and 2,011,289 others
yourinstagram some of my favorite memories will always be in red ❤️ but it's not the color i fell in love with, it's you @/carlossainz55. so proud of everything you've achieved and everything that's coming next. you'll always be my champion, no matter the suit 🤍 ps: i'm keeping the jacket.
view all comments
username1 IM CRYING
username2 i can’t believe carlos is leaving ferrari
carlossainz55 Mi vida, siempre ❤️ (and that's MY jacket 😤)
scuderiaferarri Once Ferrari Family, always Ferrari Family ❤️
alexandrasaintmleux the way I'm crying rn
username3 SOBBING. THE MEMORIES. THE JACKET. THE EVERYTHING.
username4 "not the color i fell in love with" STOP I'M CRYING
username5 CANT BELIEVE YN WONT BE A FERRARI WAG ANYMORE
username6 imagine yn in mercedes fits tho
username7 AND SOME OF YALL SAID THEY WERE BREAKING UP
username8 she’ll always be THEE ferrari girl
username9 this caption is so beautiful
username10 THIS COUPLE IS MY LIFE
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media Tumblr media
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
replies:
username1 the way he JUST posted about their anniversary two weeks ago???
username2 remember when he said "age is just a number when you find your soulmate" in that ferrari interview... aged like milk
username3 let's not jump to conclusions maybe-
username4 he fumbled THE BAG. she literally moved countries for him???
username5 imagine throwing away 2 years because you're having a midlife crisis
username6 I DONT BELIEVE THIS
username7 nah this is fake
username8 how many times people have said that they're over but turns out they're not tho
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
liked by username1, username2 and 17,027 others
tmz YN steps out for the first time since breakup with Carlos Sainz news broke
view all comments
username1 LEAVE HER ALONE
username2 disgusting how they chased her down just to get pics of her crying. she can't even process her breakup in peace
username3 if you're sharing those photos you're getting blocked. respect her privacy
username4 my heart breaks for her. these 'photographers' are vultures.
lando Proper shameful this. Let her be.
username1 OMFG LANDO
username5 maybe if carlos hadn't dumped her by TEXT she wouldn't be crying in parking lots
username6 she doesn't deserve this. no one does.
username7 To any media outlets - we will report and block any accounts sharing these photos.
username8 yall SUCK
username9 i hope you're ready for that lawsuit
Tumblr media
liked by oliviarodrigo, charles_leclerc and 2,836,944 others
yourinstagram healing sounds different for everyone. for me, it's always been putting pain into poetry and turning heartbreak into harmony. taking some time away to write my truth into existence. thank you for understanding 🤍
p.s. no, none of them are "nice" songs
[comments turned off]
Tumblr media
liked by username1, username2 and 38,927 others
dailymail SPOTTED: Carlos Sainz with Scottish model Rebecca Donaldson. Sources say they've been "quietly seeing each other" for a month. Apparently met through mutual friends... 👀
view all comments
username1 a MODEL?? this man really said "you're too young" to yn and then- i can't.
username2 respectfully deleting my carlos fan account. yn deserved better.
username3 "i need time to focus on racing" yeah focusing real hard i see
username4 the way he's trying to recreate his old relationship but with a "socially acceptable" age gap... embarrassing
username5 LEAVE HIM ALONE
username6 man poor yn
username7 he’s innocent idc
username8 OH CARLOS SAINZ GET READY FOR THOSE BREAKUP SONGS
username9 i always knew he was trash
username10 IM ON HIS SIDE IDC
Tumblr media
liked by harrystyles, arianagrande and 3,749,886 others
yourinstagram RED.
13 tracks of what happens when you love someone scarlet and they leave you burgundy.
october 22.
produced by @/jackantonoff
available for pre-save now.
view all comments
username1 OMFG
username2 SHES COMING
charles_leclerc track 9 🎹🖤
↳ username1 IF CHARLES PLAYS THE PIANO I’LL DIE
oliviarodrigo screaming crying throwing up this is gonna be INSANE
lewishamilton Already pre-saved 🙏🏾
username3 CURRENTLY SHAKING AND CRYING IN MY LIVING ROOM
username4 charles really said "let me help end this man's whole career" with track 9
username5 not me calculating that track 5 is 10 MINUTES LONG... carlos better move countries
username6 she’s coming for BLOOD
username7 RED??? FERRARI RED
username8 NOT EVEN CARLOS’ FRIENDS ARE ON HIS SIDE
username9 album of the year already
username10 red bc carlos is a red flag so true
username11 this cover EATS
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
───────── ౨ৎ ─────────
Tumblr media
liked by charles_leclerc, arianagrande and 2,947,922 others
yourinstagram RED. out now everywhere.
thank you for every tear that became a lyric, every memory that became a melody, and every heartbreak that became healing. special thanks to CL for the late night studio sessions, ASM for being the best friend ever and all of my collaborators for helping me bring this to life
and to the person who said i was too young to handle this life - watch me.
view all comments
username1 IM CRYNG
username2 CHARLES AND ALEX?
charles_leclerc proud of you piccolina ❤️ (track 9 was therapeutic)
alexandrasaintmleux i love you so much 💘
oliviarodrigo THE BRIDGE OF ALL TOO WELL???? actual perfection
username3 "you said if we had been closer in age maybe it would’ve been fine" ACTUAL CHILLS
username4 "i’ll get older but your lovers stay my age" SOMEBODY CHECK ON HIM
username5 charles playing piano while she sings about his best friend's betrayal... the LAYERS
spotify "All Too Well" breaks single-day streaming record
username6 THE SONG ABOUY HER 21ST BDAY HELLO??
georgerussell63 Amazing songs. You're incredible
username7 the way she ended a man's whole career while staying classy... queen behavior
username8 CHARLES PLAYING THE PIANO WAS BEAUTIFUL
username9 this is the album of the century
username10 BREAKUP ALBUM OF THE CENTURY CARLOS SAINZ YOU'RE SO OVER
Tumblr media
liked by username1, username2 and 13,928 others
f1updates Carlos Sainz addresses YN's album 'RED' for the first time:
"Look, everyone has their version of the truth. The album is her art, her perspective. But let me be clear - I never cheated, I was honest about needing space. The age gap was a real concern. Meeting Rebecca happened after. That's my truth."
view all comments
username1 WELL
username2 not him lying AGAIN when track 11 has literal timestamps 💀
username3 this is getting uglier by the second
username4 LEAVE HIM ALONE
username5 stream red
username6 don’t care we’re all on yn’s side
username7 GASLIGHTER
username8 does he ever shut up
username9 they should be asking him questions about RACING not his ex gf
username10 this is just ridiculous
Tumblr media
liked by oliviarodrigo, landonorris and 2,874,378 others
yourinstagram one month of RED. one month of healing. one month of turning heartbreak into history.
thank you for every scream-sing to track 5, every tweet decode, every dm sharing your own story🤍
p.s. someone asked if i regret being "too honest" in the lyrics. no. some people give you their truth in press conferences, i gave mine in verses.
view all comments
username1 IM CRYING
taylorswift Proud of you ❤️ welcome to the better off club
username2 IM SO PROUD OF HER
username3 "some people give you their truth in press conferences, i gave mine in verses" HELP WHY IS SHE SO ICONIC
username4 not a single skip on this album... even carlos' new gf had to private her spotify
sabrinacarpenter watching you heal has been the best part ❤️
charles_leclerc So proud of you !
username5 SHE KEEPS COMING FOR BLOOD
username6 are you ready to die carlos sainz
alexandrasaintmleux MY FAVORITE GIRL! couldn't be prouder
username7 i think about the lyric "said i was too young i was too soft can't take a joke can't get you off" every single day
username8 SO DAMN PROUD OF HER
georgerussell63 ❤️
username9 someday she'll be everything to somebody else why carlos ages horribly
username10 SHE MEANS SO MUCH TO ME
Tumblr media
liked by username1, username2 and 489,278 others
williamsracing We're excited to announce Carlos Sainz will be joining Williams Racing for the 2025 season onwards. Welcome to the team, @/carlossainz55 🤝
view all comments
username1 OH MY LORD
username2 THIS IS WILD
username3 WAIT. "losing him was blue like i'd never known" FROM RED... SHE KNEW
username4 going from ferrari red to williams blue... she wrote this in the album TWO MONTHS AGO
username5 remember when everyone thought the "blue" references were about sadness? Girlie was dropping CONTRACT INFO
username6 LEAVE CARLOS ALONE
username7 she really buried the contract news in a breakup album... queen behavior
username8 loving him was RED (ferrari) and losing him was BLUE (williams) i can’t do this
username9 YN YOU SICK HUMAN BEING.....
username10 none of this comments are congratulating him we're all dissecting lyrics LMAO
Tumblr media
liked by username1, username2 and 39,878 others
gossiphub SPOTTED: YN having dinner at Monaco's Hotel de Paris with mystery man. Sources say they spent 3 hours talking and left together in his car.
view all comments
username1 THE WAY HE'S HOLDING HER HAND UNDER THE TABLE I'M-
username2 MERCEDES BOY? 👀
username3 not me zooming in on the reflection in the window... that's definitely a british accent in the video snippet
username4 THIS IS GOOD KARMA
username5 carlos unfollowed [redacted] on insta... he knows something
username6 carlos sainz was found crying
username7 IS THAT SOMEONE FROM THE PADDOCK???
username8 streets say that's another driver...
username9 she's moving on already? wow
username10 THIS IS ABOUT TO GET INTERESTING
Tumblr media
liked by georgerussell63, sabrinacarpenter and 2,827,299
yourinstagram but on a wednesday in a cafe i watched it begin again🤍
[comments turned off]
2K notes ¡ View notes
tulassecondblog ¡ 3 months ago
Text
black reader discourse…
I am quite frankly, very tired of seeing posts complaining about ‘hood’ Y/Ns and all of you coming out of the woodwork to proclaim that you don’t act this way and it’s disgusting to act this way and you hate fics where the reader wears wigs or acrylics or says the N-word and how all of these are just an inaccurate representation of our community. this is just very coon like behavior and is giving pick me.
yall know very well that fics including black women didn’t even exist until very recently. i’m grateful for every fic written whether it’s bad or good. either way they are contributing to the growth of a very niche community and helping establishing our presence here on this app. i’ve been on this app for like 12 years and I remember in the very early days when fics first started including black mc’s. no matter how the black mc was represented there would still be people in the mentions/comments like ‘eww gross you n***** why did you write this?’ or ‘this fic is so good but why is she black?’. we were quite literally fighting for our right to exist on this app.
hood culture is, like it or not, a big part of the black community and it’s not all negative. it’s a cultural movement that spawned from us being barred from white spaces and seen as the ‘inferior’ race no matter how we presented ourselves. hood girls deserve to see themselves in fiction just like everyone else. they deserve love without the implication that they need to imitate others/change themselves to seem more ‘civilized’. they aren’t bad people just because you don’t share the same style, vocab, interests and hobbies as they do.
whenever you bring this up you are giving non black people a free pass to insert themselves and say ‘yes omg so ghetto’. there are enough people against us. i would never help facilitate a conversation which further criticizes our community. especially when it’s related to very real people whose experiences you are trying to devalue.
1K notes ¡ View notes
freshfrenchtoast ¡ 8 months ago
Text
Tumblr media
Kageyama's backstory only being revealed near the very end of the series is really interesting from a meta perspective.
For reference, his chapter is 387 out of 402. That's 96% of the way in.
To contrast, other characters like Tsukishima and Yamaguchi's backstories are shown in Chapters 87-88.
Now, we do get the explanation for his "King of the Court" title in Chapter 6, at the start of the series, but we don't see how he got to that point, or why he started playing volleyball in the first place like Tsukishima's and Yamaguchi's stories show.
It creates this situation where, despite being the deuteragonist, the character our protagonist, Hinata, is practically glued to the entire series, we barely know anything about him.
We don't even know he has a sister until that point whereas other characters' siblings like Natsu, Saeko, Akiteru, Alisa have all made appearances way before then. Even Oikawa's sister, though we don't see her, we at least know she exists because of Takeru.
He's both closed off to us (the audience) as well as the other characters in the series, and this results in them finding him rude or disliking his character in general (see: the "Kageyama is abusive" discourse that somehow keeps popping up even now).
Chapter 387 takes place in 2018 and was published in 2020 so it takes him 6 years of in-universe time and 8 years of irl time to really open up.
And the catalyst for all of this is Hinata fulfilling his promise of beating him.
You see, another thing to note is that, whenever Hinata thinks of Kageyama, he's always looking at him from behind.
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
His internal image of him is someone who's always up ahead, someone he needs to catch up to, meaning Hinata can only see one side of him, he cannot see all of Kageyama until he catches up and passes him.
Which he finally does here.
Tumblr media
In this shot Hinata is finally the one who's looking back at Kageyama. At this moment, Hinata (and by extension the audience) can see him for all he is, can see how he was just a lonely boy who's been waiting for someone to meet him where he is, to keep running alongside him and not quit the race.
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
Someone he doesn't have to go easy on. Someone who would actually tell him to hurry up instead of slow down for a change.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
His someone better.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
2K notes ¡ View notes
onlyangel4 ¡ 10 months ago
Text
never going back. ln4. glen powell. part one. smau.
cheater!lando norris x reader. glen powell x reader
when lando cheats on reader she makes a promise to herself, to never go back to him and by doing so she meets someone that treats her just how she deserves to be treated.
faceclaim: scarlett leithhold
part two
f1wags
Tumblr media
liked by user1, user2, user3 and 56,829 others
f1wags: some of you may forget but lando norris does actually have a girlfriend, y/n y/ln is an american based model and has been dating lando for a year and a half. lando never comments on their relationship saying that he likes to keep their personal lives private. y/n is in the paddock in australia to watch the race today for the first time in a little under a year.
view all 14,293 comments
user1: i always forget that they are dating
user2: hasn't he been getting really close to one of mclaren's influencer guests this week
user3: this is how i find out lando is actually taken
y/ninsta posted a story
Tumblr media
written: good luck my love
influencer posted a story
Tumblr media
written: been in australia all week watching these guys get ready, can't wait for race day.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
y/ninsta posted a story
Tumblr media Tumblr media
y/ninsta
Tumblr media Tumblr media
liked by lilymhe, alexalbon, logansargeant and 872,394 others
y/ninsta: so i was not going to say anything about what happened in australia but i have seen some discourse online blaming @.influencer for what happened and that is just wrong. she is the reason that i found out something was wrong. she had been lied to just as much as me. i don't know if i will ever talk about exactly what happened that day but please be kind. remember that you only get 5% of the full story online.
a little personal update: i am now back living in texas full time and boy is it nice to be home. i hope everyone is doing well, i love you all.
comments on this post have been disabled
lilymhe posted a story tagging y/ninsta
Tumblr media
written: my girl is visiting us in monaco and lets just say some questionable choices have been made
y/ninsta posted a story
Tumblr media
written: a change was needed
alexalbon posted a story tagging lilymhe and y/ninsta
Tumblr media
written: lily is now claiming that she will be quitting golf to become a hair stylist
Tumblr media
y/ninsta
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
liked by lilymhe, alexalbon, landonorris and 762,394 others
tagged: lilymhe and alexalbon
y/ninsta: monaco trip dump. a massive thank you to mom and dad for having me
view all 14,384 comments
user4: lando needs to get the fuck out of her likes
user5: you finally have your smile back y/n i am so happy for you
lilymhe: i miss you already
y/ninsta: i miss you too lils
alexalbon: the house actually feels empty without our child
y/ninsta: say the word and i will move in permanently
∘•···············•∘ʚ ♡ ɞ∘•················•∘
TAGLIST SIGN UP SHEET
taglist: @formulaal @formulaonebuff @danielshoe @noooway555 @dilflover44
@peterholland04
@sunshinedaisy21
@nikfigueiredo
@fall-bambi
@mel164
@lando-505
@charllleclerc
@paigem00
@heavy-vettel
@pseudoyo
@simple-soul-searcher
@lyannesworld
@wordesthatics
@toldyouitwasamelodrama
@sltwins
@aquamariene-me
@justarandomfamdomblog
@janeh22
@kol67-t
@gr3yhues
@luckyladycreator2
@nichmeddar
@multi-fandom5
@whatthefl1p
@stradlingmrstradlin
@notpeachybby
@kikiki04
@marknolee
@asparklysoul
@sleutherclaw
@stinging--nettle
@holybatflapexpert
@gothicwidowsworld
@pear-1206
@scorpiodiosa
@charlesgirl16
@marshmummy
@jess-wither
@callsignwidow
@jenxjar
@livbullyingjeongin
@rexit-mo
434 notes ¡ View notes
darnmand ¡ 3 months ago
Text
A Postcolonial analysis of Marius
(Disclaimer: This is not me trying to fight with anyone, this is just my own analysis of Marius. He’s an extremely complex and difficult character and so I have a lot of thoughts about him. I don’t 100% hate or like Marius. But more importantly, I don’t make moral judgements about how OTHER people feel about Marius because at the end of the day these are fictional characters.)
~
I think a big part of what I am going to call the Marius Problem (which I am not gonna take pains to describe here bc iykyk) is that Anne herself didn’t really seem to see a huge problem with him, and that affects his portrayal in the narrative.
There is of course the obvious way he treats Armand, and anyone who is familiar with Anne’s corpus of work knows that that relationship dynamic is something she revisits a lot and often in the context of erotica which is like a whole other bag of worms but…
The thing I feel like we don’t really talk about with Marius enough is his very Western Eurocentric view of the world. From a postcolonial perspective Marius’s philosophy is deeply unsettling. The way he polarizes the “east” and “west” and the modern and medieval, reason and superstition, are very insidious ways of defining things, as is his idolization of the Enlightenment, which was at its heart a positivist, Eurocentric, and deeply prejudiced school of thought which managed to convince the world that social constructions like race and gender were “scientific” in nature.
Marius is basically the embodiment of imperialism, not because he’s some malicious Big Brother twirling his moustache but because he is a very powerful, very privileged, and deeply misguided man who is takes his experience of the world as a universal truth, and who mistakes his own subjective feelings and desires for objective morality.
One of his greatest crimes against Armand that no one talks about is that he tries to force him to conform to a culture that goes against Armand’s own nature and history, and discounts Armand’s view of the world as fundamentally flawed and wrong just because it doesn’t align with his. In the book the conflict of ideologies is between classical humanism (Marius) and Eastern Orthodoxy and mysticism (Armand). In QotD, Marius even laments his failure to “perfect” Armand. Even as he showers them with gifts and affection, Marius treats Armand, Pandora, and even Akasha like dolls. Due to the changes made to Armand’s character in the show, I imagine the dissonance will be even more intense and the suppression of Armand’s selfhood will feel even more disturbing, because it will register on the level of race as well as other forms of identity.
But regardless, the most difficult part of this is that Marius is not doing this out of malice. Marius genuinely thinks he’s doing the right thing. He thinks he’s helping Armand. He thinks he is liberating the subaltern subject from the dark shadows of superstition and oppression. He thinks he is educating a being who must not know his own self and his own rights because he is fundamentally ignorant. He does not realize that what he is trying to do is efface the Other and absorb it into himself. And he eventually abandons Armand, in part, I think, because of his failure to succeed at this mission, and so facing Armand means facing the Other in himself which he wishes to repress to be the ideal enlightened western man. Marius is not even aware of his own need to dominate.
(But please please remember that Marius’s need to dominate is not likewise reflected by a need to be subjugated in Armand. Armand is equally able to move in spheres of dominance as well as submission because Armand does understand much of what Marius does not about the nature of power. Marius does not have this kind of mobility.)
This is at the heart of imperial discourse. This is what gives it momentum, what immortalizes it— the idea that we (the West) occupy some moral high ground from which we can liberate and speak for the subaltern subjects which we ourselves have locked into oppression and victimhood.
And sadly, I don’t think Anne wrote all this into the books consciously. She herself said in an interview that her own philosophy of the world aligns more with Marius’s than with Armand’s, and I think that is part of why Marius is a fundamentally sympathetic character. She made him that way. And I don’t necessarily blame her for it because these kinds of discourses are epistemological and extremely tricky to parse out. Power is that which we cannot name. So yeah, I don’t think Anne was intentional or malicious in it either.
And I don’t think all of us who look at Marius and probably feel somewhere deep down to be like him, to have his power, are doing it because of a fundamental flaw in their humanity or their politics. It’s a flaw in the epistemological system, and I don’t think it’s a flaw anyone can really see unless they’re the Armands in that equation, or they’ve been extensively trained to see it.
And before anyone gets defensive, this is not an attack on anyone or a criticism of any individual. It is a criticism of a system of knowledge and knowing which we likely cannot escape. And it is also a call for people to look at this story differently than they might have before. A call for lovers of Marius to try to begin to understand things from Armand’s perspective, and a call for lovers of Armand to remember that he is far more than just a victim, and that it would be very dangerous and reductive and harmful to his existence as an autonomous subject to understand him in that way. And if you feel the same as I do about these things, please talk about it, don’t get stuck in the surface level dynamics of the Armand/Marius relationship.
And if you’ve stayed with me for this long, I applaud your patience and thank you for your commitment.
168 notes ¡ View notes