POTO adaptations analysis — Part 1 — The Phantom of the Opera (1925), by Rupert Julian, starring Lon Chaney and Mary Philbin
I will list the positive and negative points of which midia and give a score at the end (remember this is MY OPINION)
Positive points:
– this movie has a lot of different soundtracks, but my favorite is Gabriel Thibaudeau's. His Don Juan Triumphant piece is simply fantastic
– the casting couldn't be more perfect, even if Raoul and Christine were blonde in the original novel, the actors still give an amazing performance for their characters. Mary Philbin and Lon Chaney as the two main holes are the best thing of this movie
– it's extremely Leroux accurate. Sure, they needed to explain the events as fast as they could because it's a silent movie of less than 2 hours, but it still captures the atmosphere of the novel
– the scenarios are amazing and they were made specifically for this movie (no, they didn't go to the actual Opera Garnier, it was all built!), specially Erik's lair which is amazing
– can we apreciate more the unmasking scene? Aside from the acting and direction that are already great, the scene is both frightening and tragic, it makes you sympathize for both Christine and Erik in that situation
– the figurine of this movie is speechless. Although i miss Christine's black dominó, but it's still accurate to the characters and the 19th century
– aside from horror and romance, this movie also includes the comedy scenes that the original novel had
– the chandelier scene was pretty difficult to simulate back in 1925 yet they still managed to do it realistically 👌🏼
– Erik's hand gestures and expressions 🥹 it's a whole movie by himself
– THE RED DEATH OMG his red cape in a black-and-white scenario is just 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
– Erik's make-up is obviously the best thing about this movie. Lon Chaney made it all himself, his work is still the most accurate and realistic deformity
– they included the Grasshopper and Scorpion scene
– Erik's lion alarm is so cute (not sure of how it works but anyway)
– the scene where Erik enters the lake as the Siren is so fucking perfect, really it's weird and cute the same time (and seeing wet Erik honestly makes me wetter than the Count's corpse)
– the scene where Erik leads Christine to his lair for the first time is the sweetest scene ever, he is so sympathetic and trying his best to make her comfortable
– also; the Don Juan was written out of the love he had for Christine. She was his inspiration 🥹 he wrote it for her!!
– DAROGA IS HEREalthogh he is a white man and has no relationship with Erik butAND HIS NAME IS LEDOUX
Negative points:
– instead of the love triangle, Raoul and Christine are just lovers since the beginning of the movie and it obviously makes him more "sympathetic" (even if he's useless and has creepy behaviours such as hiding in her dressing room to spy on her)
– Erik directly and shamelessly threatens to kill Christine in the unmasking scene? No, why??
– Christine has little to no agency here, and the rooftop scene makes her much more unsympathetic, she wasn't so petty in the novel even in the Apollo's Lyre
– the ending. Obvious that nonsense angry mob that discovered Erik's lair out of a miracle was included after the original ending was changed. It's just nonsense and cruel and takes away the redemption that Erik needed, like if the original message didn't even exist
Movie score: 8/10 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
47 notes
·
View notes