── PEREGRINE // FOUR
Series Synopsis: The ways that you and Seishiro Nagi fall together and fall apart over the years.
Chapter Synopsis: You and May go dress shopping before heading to her house for some bonding time. There, she pieces together the truth of your past with Nagi, prompting you to finally reveal everything.
Series Masterlist
Pairing(s): Nagi x Reader, Kira x Reader
Chapter Word Count: 4.8k
Content Warnings: unhealthy relationships, cheating, non-linear narrative, probably ooc, angst, nagi is endgame, kira sucks, alternate universe, original characters
A/N: i have written and rewritten this chapter so many times it’s illegal and also i still hate it LMFAOAO but at this point the story must go on!!
divider credits: @/benkeibear
“Can we please please please come now?” Reo whined through the phone. You could imagine the way his eyebrows would be drawn together, his eyes huge and shiny with desperation, his mouth twisted with raw sadness as he begged you, and it made you huff. You glanced over at May, who had finally, after hours of trying things on, decided on the dress she wanted to wear for her wedding. Sensing the opportunity to mess with Reo, who had been inundating you with phone calls almost the entire time the two of you had been dress shopping, you smirked.
“No, you can’t. Your future wife is as picky as you are impatient; I don’t know if she’ll even be able to pick a dress before the place closes for the day. Maybe we can plan on doing something tomorrow?” you said.
“What?” he shrieked. There was a thudding noise over the receiver, and you could only imagine that that meant he had dropped his phone on the ground.
“Hello?” you said. Your only response was a shuffling on the other end of the line, and then a soft breath as the phone was held to someone’s ear.
“Y/N, don’t bother Reo like that when I’m responsible for his emotional wellbeing. It’s so annoying.”
“Nagi,” you said, swallowing at just the sound of his sleepy voice. “Give Reo his phone back.”
“Mm, no can do,” Nagi said, his quiet irritation so strong you could feel its weight settling over your shoulders despite your distance. “He’s run off to call a taxi.”
“Call a — that idiot! Is he planning on coming even though I told him not to?” you said.
“Guess so,” he said. “Oh, man, he’s waving me over. Guess I better go…”
“Hold on a second!” you said.
“Hm?” he said. “Ah — Reo, what the hell? No, I’m not making things strange — stop it!”
You blinked, bemused, as Reo’s muffled voice scolded Nagi while he weakly protested. In the end, Reo must’ve won the spat, for he was the one to speak to you next.
“Y/N, I’m so sorry you had to talk to him. And after I promised you I wouldn’t leave the two of you alone!” Reo said.
“It’s okay, Reo, it was just a phone call. If I was uncomfortable, I would’ve hung up,” you said.
“If you say so. Anyways, we’re on our way,” he said.
“I told you not to come, stupid, not the other way around,” you said.
“And I almost believed you, but then I thought about it a little more, and I realized that there was a high chance that you were full of shit,”he said. “What wedding dress appointment takes this long?”
“You obviously haven’t watched enough reality TV,” you said. “There’s this one show that Ryosuke and I used to watch on the weekends where the brides have to choose their dresses live, and let me tell you, some of those sessions really did last an entire day.”
“Okay, but if a bride is crazy enough to be on a reality television show while picking out her wedding dress, then it’s not a surprise that she’d also be hard to please. May isn’t like that; she’s definitely picky, don’t get me wrong, but not in that way,” he explained.
He said it so familiarly: May isn’t like that. You were almost jealous of the way that he understood her so well, understood her to the point that he would catch a taxi to see her a little earlier because he knew she wasn’t the demanding type. You wanted to be understood like that. You wanted someone to be so comfortable with knowing you again.
“You got me,” you said. “I was just joking around. She finished up a few minutes before you called. If you hadn’t flipped out and dropped your phone before running away, I would’ve said that, as well.”
“You’re such a jerk. You’re a major jerk, did you know that?” Reo said.
“I’ve been told,” you said. He scoffed.
“True,” he said. “Okay, we’ll be there soon. Talk to you then!”
“I think May wants me to start trying dresses on myself now, so I’ll probably be getting changed when you guys get here. You can see me in my options and help me choose, though, if you’d like. Ryosuke is busy, so he can’t, which means you’re my next-best option,” you said.
“Ooh, sounds like a blast,” he said. “You know I’m always up for a fashion show!”
“I know,” you said. “Alright, they’re calling me over, so I should hang up. Bye!”
With that, you ended the call and trotted over to where May was talking with the willowy, long-haired designer who was in charge of constructing her dress — a glamorous man by the name of Jyubei Aryu.
“Are you the maid of honor?” Aryu said when you joined him and May, tucking your phone into your pocket as you did so that it did not distract you.
“I am,” you said.
“Wonderful. I’ve put a dress which I found suitable on the rack in the fitting room; please call for assistance if you need it,” he said.
“Thank you!” you said, going in the direction that he had indicated, ducking into the fitting room and admiring the dress he had provided you with.
It was a blush pink, in keeping with the theme of the wedding, and made of a pretty, expensive fabric that you definitely would not be able to afford if Reo had not insisted on paying for the entire wedding party’s outfits. When you slipped it on, it flowed against your skin like water, and it was just as light and comfortable, too. The intricate detailing on the bodice did not itch, and the skirt swished around your ankles as you took uncertain steps forward, acclimatizing yourself to the feel of the gown before daring to venture out in front of the others.
You knew without even asking their opinions that you wanted to get it. Perhaps Ryosuke would shame you for it — you were growing so terrible at being able to discern his will, so for all you knew, he’d hate the option, but it mattered little to you. You liked the dress. You found it beautiful.
Aryu had graciously left a pair of heels approximately your size by the dress, so that it did not drag on the floor when you walked. Fastening the buckle of the dainty ankle strap, you opened the door to the fitting room and crept out to the waiting area, where you knew May would eagerly be waiting to see what you were in.
“Oh, wow,” May said when you rounded the corner. “Y/N! You look so beautiful!”
“Thank you,” you said. “I really like this one. Do you think it’s appropriate for a maid of honor?”
Hers was the only negative you’d entertain. If she didn’t think that the dress was suitable for her wedding, then you’d let go of the idea, albeit begrudgingly. After all, it was her wedding, and whatever she said was what went.
“It’s perfect,” she said, pretending to wipe away a tear, as if you were the bride and she were your lovingly overbearing mother. “Say yes to the dress, Y/N! Although I’m afraid you’ll outshine me if you’re standing next to me in that.”
“Be real,” you said, rolling your eyes. “No one could ever outshine you, May.”
Just then, the bell on the door chimed, announcing someone’s arrival, though it needn’t have. Only seconds after he had stepped in, Reo was declaring his presence to the public with that same gaudy, business-like professionalism he oozed every time he was forced to engage in high society.
“Hello, hello,” he said, somehow managing to simultaneously nod at the secretary, shake hands with Aryu, and wink at you and May, all without looking harried or awkward. “My apologies for any inconvenience our late arrival might have caused. It seems my fiancée’s dearest maid of honor was finding some humor in giving Nagi and I the old run around.”
“It’s not a problem,” Aryu said. “Pleasure to make your acquaintance, Mr. Mikage.”
“The pleasure’s all mine,” Reo said. “This is Seishiro Nagi, by the way. My best man.”
“It’s good to meet you, too, Mr. Nagi. My wife was a big fan of yours back when you were playing soccer,” Aryu said, holding out his newly-freed hand to Nagi’s in greeting. But Nagi did not take it, far too distracted to even notice, although his phone was for once not in his hands. Reo, who would never let his perfect facade drop in public but obviously wanted to scowl and smack his friend for the rudeness, turned his head to see what could possibly be holding Nagi’s attention if not a screen, and then his eyes widened, because he realized that it was you.
Nagi was gazing over at you in that way only he ever had, that way only he ever could. The weight of his stare was hot and adoring, like there was nothing else in the entire world he could be troubled with, like he’d carry a thousand burdens if it meant that you’d let him collapse at your feet once he grew tired, like you were the one pain he’d willingly take and even seek out. That was the way that Seishiro Nagi gazed at you, and the only thing you could do was cross your arms, like that paltry gesture could ever be enough to ward him off, like you even wanted to ward him off in the first place.
“If you say so,” May sang under her breath, so only you could hear. You startled, having forgotten that she was still standing next to you.
“Ah, Nagi’s not played soccer in a bit,” Reo said, discreetly stepping on Nagi’s foot, breaking him out of his trance. “But I’m sure he appreciates the support. Right, Nagi?”
“Huh?” Nagi said, his eyelashes brushing against his cheeks as he blinked sleepily at Aryu. “Oh. Yeah, right. Does she want an autograph or something?”
“I’m sure she would be delighted!” Aryu said, producing a pad of paper and a pen for Nagi to scrawl his messy signature onto.
“You got your dress?” Reo said, his arm going around May’s waist as he pressed a kiss to her temple. She nodded and beamed up at him.
“It’s amazing,” she said. “The exact kind of dress that I imagined I’d get married in one day.”
“I can’t wait to see it,” he said.
“I wish my mom was here,” May said. “She was so sad that she couldn’t make it in time. I FaceTimed her and all, but it’s not the same, you know?”
“I told your parents not to worry about work or anything,” Reo said, rolling his eyes. “They should’ve just flown over with Y/N and Kira. If their bosses gave them any trouble, I’d have sent lawyers after them or something.”
“Neither of them are comfortable taking advantage of you,” May chided him. “You know that.”
They continued to converse, and you took a step back, feeling as if you were intruding on something private. Rubbing your arm, you stared at the ground, wondering what Ryosuke might be doing back at the hotel. Was he truly taking a nap, as he had claimed? Or was he with another girl again?
Well. Either way, you supposed he was most likely in bed. Snorting at the double entendre, you almost missed Nagi’s soft tap on your shoulder.
“Hi,” he said. You opened your mouth, and then you closed it again, not wanting to be too hasty, not wanting to say something you shouldn’t when Reo and May were right there beside you.
“Hi,” you said back.
“That’s the dress you’re getting for the wedding?” he said.
“Yeah,” you said, adjusting the straps.
“It’s nice,” he said. “You look nice.”
It was such a simple statement that it barely counted as a compliment, but you could not stop the corners of your mouth from twitching as they fought to curve into a smile. After all, hearing things like that from Nagi were so rare — he was never one to find much merit in praising just about anyone.
“Thanks,” you said. “Ryosuke wanted me to choose something pretty, so…”
You saw the way his face closed off at the mention of Ryosuke and immediately cringed, though no one else would even be able to discern the imperceptible shift of his expression. Still, you were quite certain when he shrugged his shoulders slightly in approval that there was distaste brewing in his blank irises, and you bit your tongue, cursing yourself for ruining his mood before pausing.
Why did you care? It was your right to bring up the man you were to marry, wasn’t it? In fact, it was the honorable thing to do, considering your history with Nagi. The reminder was a good thing. A boundary that needed to be set. Something along those lines. So why, then, did it feel wrong? Like you had further torn apart something you might’ve still had a chance at mending?
“He’ll be satisfied, then,” he said. “You’re pretty.”
“Isn’t she?” May said brightly, somehow manifesting at your side, though you had not noticed her walking over. “I told her as much! You should definitely get it, Y/N, if even Nagi can find it in his heart to say something sweet to you about it.”
“Speaking of getting things, Nagi, come on,” Reo said, also appearing from nowhere to tug on Nagi’s sleeve. “We have shopping to do for ourselves. Let’s leave the two of them alone.”
The notion of Reo leaving you alone was so foreign that you almost protested, but then he grinned at you over his shoulder and you recalled his promise, about how he would ensure you and Nagi were not stuck together at any point, as long as it was within his means to keep you both apart.
You didn’t want Nagi to go, though. You didn’t want Reo to keep the two of you apart, but how could you tell him that? Did the words even exist for you to explain any of it? You thought that they mustn’t.
“By the way, I convinced Reo to sleep at Nagi’s tonight,” May said.
“Why would you do that?” you said.
“He should bond with his best man a bit!” she said. “As for me, there’s a lot of bonding that I want to do with you, Miss Maid-of-Honor, and I don’t think you’ll answer my questions if Reo’s within earshot, so this was the perfect idea!”
“I think that I’m not going to like your questions and your bonding very much,” you said.
“Too bad!” she said. “I’m the bride, so you have to do what I say!”
“It’s not your wedding day yet, you know,” you pointed out. “Technically, that doesn’t hold.”
“What happened to you wanting to make my life easier and all of that nonsense?” she said. “I’m just asking you for this one favor, so you really ought to grant it!”
“Okay, okay,” you said. “Let me make sure Ryosuke is fine with me staying at your place again.”
You brought out your phone to call your fiancé, but May snatched it out of your hands the instant he picked up.
“Kira? This is May. Yes, May Ducat, how many Mays do you think Y/N knows and spends time with? She’s going to sleep over again tonight so that she can help me with some preparation stuff. No, you’re right, I’m not asking you, I’m telling you. Uh-huh. Oh my god, did you know my future husband could buy your entire life? Shut up and let me have my best friend for the night! You get her every single day back in America, so now it’s my turn!” she said, making a face.
“May!” you said. She handed you back the phone, showing you that Ryosuke had hung up, and then she gave you a double-thumbs-up.
“We’re set for the night!” she said. “I’m so excited!”
“I was literally at your house earlier today. You should’ve just asked me your questions then,” you said.
“Um, like I said, I doubted you would answer if Reo was around, and anyways, I just came up with some of them now,” she said.
“Whatever,” you said. “Okay. I’m excited, too.”
You were not, considering the types of questions you sensed she was going to ask, but when she tackled you in a hug and promised you that you would have so, so much fun, it was hard to say that aloud.
Luckily, all of your things were still at May and Reo’s, so after everything was bought and paid for, with shipping arranged via one of Reo’s assistants, you could go straight to their house instead of having to stop at the hotel again. Reo, who had taken a cab back to get his car before dropping you off, waved merrily as the two of you stepped into the driveway.
“Have a nice night, both of you!” he said.
“You, too. Try to finish that one zombie adventure thing you and Nagi started last month. I don’t want to hear about it on our honeymoon,” May said.
“Actually, we both got the new Pokémon games while we were waiting for you to finish choosing your dress, so we’re going to start those together tonight and see who can beat the Champion first,” Reo said.
“Make sure to choose the fire type starter, then,” she said seriously. “They’re always the best ones.”
“No, Nagi usually chooses water, so I have to pick grass, just in case he challenges me to a battle at some point,” Reo said.
“Only lame people choose grass,” May said. “I always go for fire. What about you, Y/N?”
“I’ve only played Pokémon once, and it wasn’t my game, so I didn’t even finish it,” you said. “And I picked the one I thought was the cutest. I do think it was the fire one, though.”
“That’s what I like to see!” May said, high-fiving you.
“And how many battles have either of you beaten Nagi in?” Reo said. “That’s right, zero. So I don’t want to hear it!”
“How many battles have you beaten Nagi in?” May said. Reo glared at her.
“See you tomorrow,” he said, rolling the window up and driving off without another word.
“If only the girls at my high school had known what a big baby Reo really is,” you said. “They wouldn’t have made a fan club for him.”
“He actually had a fan club?” May said. “He told me that that wasn’t real!”
“It was real,” you affirmed. “Believe me. The Reo Mikage Fan Club and I have a long and storied history, so you should trust me more than him on the topic.”
“Were you a member?” she said, unlocking the front door and ushering you in. You choked on your saliva at the mere prospect.
“No way!” you said, sitting down on a bar stool at the kitchen counter while May dug around in her cabinets.
“Found it!” she said, brandishing a box of grocery store mac and cheese. “Reo would have a fit if he knew this was in our house, so I’ve kept it hidden away for a special occasion, but what’s more special than this? Also, I was just kidding.”
“Remember when we made Reo eat those cups of mac and cheese that you make in the microwave and he almost threw up?” you said.
“Yup,” she said. “And then he started complaining about the chemicals and additives and whatnot! As if that’s not half of the fun and flavor.”
“That must’ve been before Chigiri had the fire department called on him for forgetting the water in his microwave noodles,” you said. “The RA banned their microwave after that, right?”
“Oh, jeez, I forgot that that happened! They used to have to come to our room to warm up their leftovers,” May said, shaking her head. “What a time.”
“Do you miss it?” you said.
“Being in college?” she said. “Yes and no. I miss being your roommate and seeing you all of the time, and I miss how carefree everything was back then, but at the same time, I’m really happy now. I wouldn’t trade those years for anything, but I don’t mind that they’re over. Whatever comes next, I’m sure it’ll be great in its own way, even if it’s different. Maybe especially because it’s different.”
“That’s a good way of looking at things,” you said.
“What about you?” she said.
“The same, I guess. I miss everyone being together,” you said. “I still have Ryosuke and Chigiri, but it’s not the same without you and Reo there. My life is much more stable now, so that’s a positive, but sometimes I do wish I could go back and change things.”
“What would you change?” May said.
“I’m not sure,” you said. “It’s just a thought. I wish I could know what my life would look like now if I had followed a different path at some point or another, you know?”
“You told me earlier that you weren’t happy,” she said, putting down a dish of macaroni in front of you, sitting down at your side with her own plate. “That you were satisfied, but not happy.”
“That’s right,” you said.
“Why can’t you be both?” she said. “Why can’t you be happy and satisfied with your life?”
“I just can’t,” you said.
“There is a reason,” she said. “Tell me. I can’t help you if I don’t know what’s wrong!”
“You can’t help me regardless,” you said bitterly, stabbing a clump of pasta with your fork. “I gave up my chance at happiness for the sake of my future, that’s all. I left it behind in search of the very life I have now. You’ve known since we met that I don’t have any particular dreams; if my existence is mundane and tired, then it’s okay. That’s my goal. Not everyone gets to be Cinderella like you, May.”
“Left it behind in search of the very life you have now…” May muttered, narrowing her eyes at you. Although psychology had not been her degree, it was suddenly so clear why she had chosen to minor in it — she was uncannily good at reading people. “It, or him?”
You dropped your fork. “What did you just say?”
“Correct once again!” she said triumphantly. “I’ve been suspecting it for a bit. There’s someone else, isn’t there? I was so sure it was Chigiri, but I could never find the final bit of proof for that theory, so I was forced to dismiss it. This led to a new puzzle, though: if not Chigiri, then who? You’ve always tended to avoid talking to guys, at least as long as we’ve been friends, so the list of options was pretty limited.”
“Why does everyone think Chigiri and I are secretly dating?” you said, throwing your hands up in the air. “You’re not the first person to accuse me of it, and for some reason, I feel like you won’t be the last.”
“Don’t distract me when I’m on a roll!” she said, pointing her fork at you. “Anyways, it was bothering me for a while, but after last night and today, I was finally able to put it together.”
“You didn’t put shit together,” you said frantically. “May, you didn’t put anything together. Don’t say it.”
“I’ve never seen Nagi look at anyone the way he looked at you in that dress,” she said. “That was the first clue. From there, it all began to make sense. Why else would he come to dinner when he never agrees to such outings on any other occasion? What other reason could there be for your awkward relationship? You said that you hated him for a complicated reason. Well, this is definitely complicated! For one, you’ve been lying to everyone about the true nature of your feelings — that is to say, you are, or at some point were, in love with Seishiro Nagi!”
“I don’t like this bonding activity anymore,” you said. “Let’s do something else. Wanna play cards?”
“Wait, I’m actually right? I mean, of course I am, I’m always right,” she said. “I can’t believe it, though. How does that even make sense? You guys are total opposites.”
“Obviously we are. Don’t you think that there’s a reason it didn’t work out between the two of us?” you said. “You are right, as usual. When we were in high school, Nagi and I were together. The break up was mutually agreed upon and for both of our benefits. It was a long time ago, and in the grand scheme of things, largely inconsequential. Happy now?”
“If you were telling the truth, I would be,” she said. “Let me guess which part you were lying about…hm. I think that that relationship wasn’t inconsequential in the slightest.”
“When you’re in high school, every relationship feels earth-shattering and all-consuming. That doesn’t mean it is,” you said. “At the time, he was important to me.”
“And now he’s not?” she said.
“Now he can’t be,” you said. “I’m engaged. I’ve moved on, and so has he. He was the one to do so first, actually. I didn’t start dating Ryosuke until I realized that there was no point in looking backwards, not when the rest of the world will leave you behind if you get stuck like that.”
“What the fuck,” May said, holding her head in her hands as you continued to eat your dinner. You didn’t blame her for the dramatics; her entire view of your history had just been shifted, and not necessarily for the better. “Y/N. What the fuck. Kira was your second choice? I thought you were totally crazy about him!”
“First choice, second choice, does it matter?” you said. “He’s the one I’ll wed.”
“Do you wish it was Nagi instead?” she said.
“No,” you said. “He deserves better. He always has. Even back then, he deserved someone better than me. I’m glad I’m not marrying him.”
“Woah, woah, woah. That’s just about the opposite thing I was expecting you to say. He deserves better? He’s probably too lazy to even shower properly! If anyone deserves better, it’s you,” she said.
You took a sip of water to clear the thick feeling from your tongue. “It might seem that way, but to be frank, I’m a very hard person to love. Just ask my parents and Ryosuke if you don’t believe me. Nagi should be with someone who isn’t a pain, and though he never said so, I know I was always a hassle for him.”
“Why would you say something like that about yourself? You’re not hard to love,” she said. You exhaled, pushing your now-empty plate away and resting your chin in your hands.
“When I was a child, my parents only cared about one thing,” you said. “Whether I’d grow up to be beautiful enough to seduce the son of a rich man. Not whether he’d love me — love doesn’t matter, you see. People can fall in and out of love quite easily. Financial obligations, duty, the law…those are things you can rely on. Would I be beautiful enough to stand by a wealthy man’s side? To be worthy of bearing his children and binding him to me forever? They were obsessed with that question and its answer, and that obsession had its consequences.”
May was quiet for a moment as she took your words in. “I didn’t know that.”
“Don’t blame yourself. I didn’t tell you. I’ve only ever managed to tell one other person all of this,” you said.
“Reo?” she guessed. You laughed sadly.
“Reo? No, not him. I wish that I could, but he’s not the sort of person I can talk to about these types of issues. He has his own, more pressing problems,” you said. Understanding dawned on her face.
“Nagi,” she said. “You told Nagi.”
“I did,” you said. “He knows more about me than anyone in the entire world. The truth, since you’re so determined to figure it out, is that I loved him back then, May, though I should have known better. Love is never enough. You can’t save someone just by loving them, and neither can you change who they really are.”
May cocked her head. “Huh? Y/N, what do you mean by that? What…what really happened between the two of you? Because obviously, Reo had no clue what was going on, and I’ve only ever heard about your high school years from him.”
“What happened between the two of us? It was a series of mistakes, the biggest of which were allowing him to fall for me and falling for him in return,” you said. “It’s really hard to live a life without love once you’ve known it. I keep searching for it in places that it won’t ever exist, but deep in my heart, I’m aware that I’ll never be able to find it again, not in any way that lasts. Not in any way that resembles what I had during my last year in Japan, in those few months I spent with Seishiro Nagi.”
taglist (comment/send an ask to be added): @mariyumemi @naatggeo @prettyarsxnist @noble-17 @rinitoshisgirl @stuckindreamland06 @little-miss-chaoss
34 notes
·
View notes
The Tickle Mobster (Piofiore)
Did I love Nicola's route? Meh. Does this man radiate Ler energy without trying? Absolutely.
Heyo everyone! Today I bring you Nicola Francesca of Piofiore for a fic because this man just NEEDS one! Just- look at him! I don't really have much to say for this beyond thank you for letting me be self indulgent with these fics akjrkjearjke I hope you enjoy!
Summary: Nicola decides to mess with Lili. That's it- that's the fic.
Nicola poked his head around the corner of the salon, eyes finding his dear beloved sitting by with a book. She was a picture of calm, blond hair tossed in a loose braid over her shoulder and cheeks flushed with happiness. The characters in her story must be endearing to have such attention.
Anyone else would likely feel bad for distracting her from such a sight.
Alas, he was a criminal, and criminals rarely feel bad for disturbing the peace.
Creeping over to her, he raised his arms, fingers wiggling with devious intent as he went to surprise her. Oh, how he couldn’t wait to hear her squeals-
“Hello, Nicola.”
He froze, just inches from her now. “Oh, hello Lili. How’d you know I was here?”
“You’re getting predictable, dear.” She didn’t look at him, but he could see her smile growing. “You always come by to play tricks on me whenever I’m at the salon. What was it last time- an ice cube down my dress? And the time before that- you were sneaking flowers in my hair without me knowing.”
“Those were good tricks!” He argued, fighting off a laugh at the shriek she let out at his chilly prank. “And your hair looked stunning with the flowers in it.”
“Hm.” She merely shrugged one of her delicate shoulders, flipping a page in her book. Oh that does it!
“Why you- come here!” He wrapped her up in his arms from behind, making her yelp and drop her book. “I’ll show you what happens when you dismiss me so!”
“What are you-ah! Aheahhahhaa, nohohohohoho! Nihihihihcolahhahhaha!” Lili let out a squeal of mirth as his hands attacked her sides, dancing along her ribs. “Whahahahait it tihihiihihckles!”
“Does it now? I never would have guessed.” Feeling extra bold, he leaned in- gently nibbling on her earlobe. That earned him a proper squeal. “What, does it tickle too much? Hmm? Is my adorable Lili too ticklish for her own good?”
“Nihihihihcola! Aheahahhaha- whoahahaha!” She yelped when he released her, sending her tumbling onto her side. Second later he vaulted over the couch, properly pinning her beneath him as he carried on scratching at her stomach and ribs. “Aheahhahaha, nohohohoho fahahhahahair! Nohohohohoo fahhhahahair!”
“Yes fair! I just wanna hear you laugh, is that so much to ask?” He cooed in her neck, continuing his gentle bites and nuzzles as his hands danced across the various tickle spots along her torso. Lili could only thrash and cackle, her hands slapping at his shoulders as she kicked her feet against the cushions. “Such a pretty sound~”
“Aheahhahahhha! Iiihihihf you lihihihihke lauhuhuhuhughing soohohoho muhuhuhuch, thahahahake thihihihihs!” She cried, switching gears from defending to fighting back. With a burst of strength, she shot her hands out to his sides, grabbing and squeezing.
Unfortunately...
“Sorry, love. I’m not ticklish.” Nicola winked at her, much to her shock.
“Wahahahit wahahahit tihihime ohoho-OHOOHOHOHUT!” She cried when he went back to tickling her, focusing his efforts onto the bad spots along her hips. “TIIHIHME OHOHOHUT PLEHAHAHAHSE!”
“Hmm..okay.” Nicola paused, watching her gasp for air beneath him. “Lemme know when you’re ready.”
“Eh..ehehehe..heeh…” She ran a hand over her messy hair, pushing it out of her flushed face as she glared weakly up at him. “Thehehere’s no whahhay you’re not ticklish! Everyone is!”
“Sorry, but I’m afraid I’m the exception.” He leaned into his fist with a boyish grin, his other hand coming up to trace her cheek. “You can ask anyone here and they’ll tell you it’s true.”
“I bet Dante knows the truth.”
“Oh he wishes. It’d probably make him feel better given how many times I’ve tickled him.” He laughed softly, something nostalgic in his voice. Lili felt her heart melt at the thought of them so close.
Alas, she needed to focus! “Can I check?”
“With him? No way. You're all mine.” He winked at her, making her flush.
“No, can I tickle you! I want to see for myself if you’re seriously not ticklish!” She puffed, determined. Nicola’s eyes widened some before he chuckled, warmth in his expression.
“So stubborn. Alright- but just know; for every tickle you give me, I’m gonna give you back tenfold.” He climbed off of her, laying back on the sofa as she switched their positions. “It really is a wasted effort, Lili. Don’t cry if you can’t make me laugh.”
“Hush, I won’t.” She waved him off, getting comfortable as she debated where to even begin. Nicola was a picture of serene, arms tucked behind his head and ankles crossed. He was looking at her so lovingly she nearly forgot what she was doing.
“Stop, you’re distracting me!” She blushed, looking away.
“Nah, I love seeing you blush. It’s beautiful.” He teased, making said act darken.
“You’re so mean! Fine, take this!” Anticipation was useless here. She reached out and prodded at his armpits. Then she tapped into his upper ribs. Then swept a few fingers into his neck and chin.
Nothing. Nicola just laid there. The chin scritches did make him arch some with a purr, but she was sure it was just him enjoying them more than anything. She dropped her hands lower, squeezing his lower ribs and sides with little success. She then prodded at his belly, but the event led to nothing. At some point, she started jabbing at his chest.
“Whoa, careful now. You might just get me excited.” He grinned up at her, watching her squeak and pull her hands back flustered. “Just kidding! Hehehe.”
“Hmmmph!” With a huff, she nearly gave up. She dared a little lower, squeezing along his hips with no success. “You really aren’t ticklish, huh?”
“Nope.” He pulled her down soon after, trapping her against his chest as he got ready to tickle her once more. “Now, where were we-”
Footsteps came, followed by a small yelp and someone clearing their throat. “S-Scusi.” A flustered Dante apologized, cheeks on fire as he turned towards the door. “I’ll have this in my office-”
“Dante!” Lili quickly sat up, pushing her mortification at the misunderstanding aside for this golden opportunity. “Dante, hang on- where is Nicola ticklish?”
“I told her already, I’m not ticklish.” The underboss was quick to interject. In that moment, Lili was sure she heard a hint of nervousness in his voice. “Enjoy your cafe latte, Dante!”
“Don’t go! Tell me!”
“Really, we’re fine over here.”
“Hush!”
“How cruel!”
Dante sighed, holding his brow as he turned to look at the pair. “As Nicola said, he’s not ticklish. Best to believe him.”
Lili felt her heart sink, disappointment slumping her shoulders. Nicola patted her hand gently as Dante began to leave once more.
Only then did he pause, looking back into the room. “His back and knees were bad when we were kids though.” He gave a rare cheeky grin before scurrying away, Nicola’s curses following him out.
“Dante you son of a- I’ll get you back!” Nicola called after him in betrayal, arching some when Lili slipped her hands beneath him, curling her fingers.
“Your back, huh? What luck- I’m in the perfect spot to reach it.” With a sweet little kiss to his cheek, she rapidly began curling her fingers against the spot, delighted as he began to crumble in mirth. ‘Now, let me show you how it feels to be tricked!”
Thanks for reading!
20 notes
·
View notes